Shrinivas Sakharam Dudhgaonkar v. Union Of India And Others
!"#$#%
"&$ '(
$!)#)'* ++
,-.)*)/"# ,"0-"."1
23-4"'*0".
5$&)&)'*$.
6$.#2#
*)'* '( *3)"
"*3 &-$.#
5$#7'*3$*&#
)&-
,-.)*)/"# ,"0-"."1
23-4"'*0".
5$&)&)'*$.
6$.#2#
*)'* '( *3)"
"*3 &-$.#
5$#7'*3$*&#
8
9 : 8+ , 8
, :
! " #
" $ % &&& 8
, :;
+ ."<%
#
'( )) * * + * * )
$
, $$-.$$/ !
01 $0$% 34 $05 *( * ) $0$% 34 $#5 *( *
%
, * (
6 ) $2 #$ $0$# 34 #5 ) * 7 )) "
! 7 3 8)*#&)&2&$95
% # , ) 0% 0% $0$$ 34 $5
) * ) 7 ) 6 )( ! 7 )) 7 ,4 : 7 , * ) 7 37
)5 ( ;#$ 3/<<00$02$005
% $ , ) 01 $0$$ 34 15 ! )
)
* ( * ( ( ) * ( * ( * )
% % , ) 0- $0$$ ) )
) , 6 02 $0$$ ,
( ( 3= , ( * ) ) * ) , ) ) >( ) *( (
, >( )
)( ) ) * ) >( *6 )9 )9 (
% ?
, ) )
) ) ) ) ( ,)
* (
?
;
)
( + "
! 7 ) * 3 8).#& ,&"&2&$95 ) * "
!
@
%0 + ))* ) * 3$5 %0 )( ) ( * )( 4 ( 4 * ) ) ( , )
) ) * 3$5 3*5 %0
)
) ) * 3$53 5 %0
=
, (* () , ) ) * 4 .) * " $ ?
#$ ) ( ( * , * )
( >(
A * ) , ) * *( ) , * ) *( 7
) * *( ) B , %$ +
= )) ))
*( )
( , ) = )) , *) 0?
0< $0$% ) 0# 0/ $0$$ %0 0- $0$% , ) ) * 6 6
" $ ? *) %0 + ) )
) * * , ( 35 4 (
* (
35 4 ( , )( 4 ( ) ) ( *
.) * ) * ( ) , ) * 3$5 %0 + ! ) $3*5 %0
* ,
( * 4 B ( ) * .) * )( * ) ( ) ( ( ( * , ( + ) * C ! ) "
! 7 A (
$0$% 3 8
,&"&2&$95 , $0$% )
0?
$0$% * %0 $0$% ))* %# ) ) ! $0$% 8 ) )( ) ) )9 * * "
)( ) )(
) * 4 ( , ( ) ( * 4 ( ( ( * , )( ) * (
(
,
*
> ) ) ) >( ) *( %## !
! )
( ) ( * ) ( ) )9 )9 ( !
)
( ) * ( * * ( , ( ) ) )
( 6 , ) 6
) ) , ) ) (
) *
) ) ,
A
) ) , ) > *
> )
) ,
) ) )
,
* ) )
D ) >(
*) #$ )
>( , ) (
* ( , ) ) *
)
)
) 7
) , * ) )
) ! 4) 6
* >( ( * ) ) ! ) .) ) ) )( )( >( )
-
! ) *
/
+) ) * > !
D ) ) ( %03$5 + "
! 7 ) * E !!
D ) )
)E !!!
D ) >( 6 *E <
, > ) *
>+ '+ +
-$&-$.
&$.1# "*3 !'*3)&)'*# '( &-$ "3/$.&)#$1$*& ".$
!'*&.".?
&'
<"2#$ % '( ).#& ,&"&2&$ '( &-$ "&)'*"< *#&)&2&$ '(
$#)4*;
-1"3"@"3A
< # ' ( * %0 + %0 %# $0$% , 4 %0 + %0 : %# $0$% <"2#$ '( ).#& ,&"&2&$
!
"
" # $ %
"& '&
'
& ( '
# $'
& ( '
# $' )
& ( ' )
# $'& ( '# $ " " "" $ "*"
$ +*
( ! $
"
( "
'
" "
" $
(
$ ,,,, ,,,, ,,,, -.)
* ( "
$ %
(%$(
" .( $(
* $ "% /
.
0" " $ -0 " " "". $ "% / . 0" " "$*" $
+*
(
<"2#$ '( ,&"&2&$
- . !
" " .# $ %
"& '
& ( -.'
& ( -) .' )
& ( -)
.'
!
'
!
'& ( -# $.'
& (
" " "" $ " *" $ +*
( ,,,, ,,,, ,,,,
"
-. ! '
"
"
$"
' $
' $ "
-
"
(
.' $
' $ $
$
"
" $
(
$ -.)
( "(
" - .!
("
( $(
* $ " % "
# " -1. !
0" " $-0 " %$' $$ . $ " % "
# " " " "
*" $ +*
( "
"
(
, " $ ?
#$
) , *
2 !
%
$
% $ " 3
(' 0 " "
$ " 4 $$ * % '
% "
$ ( (
'
"' (
"
$
$ 4
$
' $ % ""
" ,,,, ,,,, ,,,, 1 )
$ 0"
' $ %
" %
(
. 5*
. * (5* .6$5* ".
$5*7
$5* . "
8
" " "
$ . " 9:"
)% (.
)% .) $
" "" $
)
$ ,,,, ,,,, ,,,, !
3 $$ * %$ ' "
" %
(
( $ ' %
$
$
)
'
& ( '$ ( %
9
" $ ' 3
$ "
' "
( $
;
#0
, ) ) ) , 4 ) * 2+
! "
" $
( !
(7< !
(
& 8
%
$ " %
"
$ % $ 0"
4 $$ * % '
% "
$7 ( (
(
" ,,,, ,,,, ,,,,
"
" $
( !
(7< !
(
& 8
"
= $
"
! " "
(
6%*'
"
"
" " "
%
* 1 )
(
& 8
%
""(
*
"
"
'$ " $
"
" > ! ( " 0"
$ "%
(
$ " %
$ *" " < ! * "
$ (* "
" < & * -
77%%%
"
7
." " $< &6$ "
( ""
; ##
+) 6
) ) ) * ( )
) ) ) ( ) )
( ) , > * )
) ( (
+) %0 + %# $0$% ) ( )
) * * ! ) * *
+ $0$% ) * ) ( * ) 4)) ( , (
+ * 4 ) $0$% * 4 ) ( ( * 4
+) $0$% *) ( ) ) *
) 4)) ( +) * (* ) () ) * F )( , ) ) * * ! )
6 )( ( * !
) ) * * , $0$% ) ) %#3?5 $0$% )( ) ( * ) 4))
( , * ) )( * ,
) F )( *
* ) 4)) ( , * ( ) (* () * *( ; ) ( * *( )
) * ) , ) (* () ( ) ) .) )( * )( )(
, ) ) ) * *
!
* ) ) ) ) )( *
F ) ( %0 + %# $0$% ! + * ) * * ) ) $0$%
>+ '+
-$&-$.
&-$ 7$&)&)'*$.
"(&$.
"77')*&1$*& '* &-$ "3/$.&)#$3
7'#& !'2<3 3)#72&$ &$.1# "*3 !'*3)&)'*# '( &-$ "3/$.&)#$1$*&A
'
> 6 *
=
#$
G ' 4
( ) ) * , * * ) )
) 6 *
*
!
/+
;
!" !! #
6 )
) ) ) * ) * , 4 6 ) 21
* %
" "%
* " 3 "(
'
" $ *
(
?
%
?
%"(
%
( " " + 8 ' "
"% *" ( @
"*
"($ " " $ ="?
(
" "
(A "( " & * = 6 (
"(* $
( ( * " $ "
; !
$ /+ % ;
!&" '& 4 6 ) ) *
*6
! ( ) /+ *+
&",! 4 ( > )
, 4 -
/+ .
/
$ ;
," 0!# ( 4
4 " '
G ' ) (1 /+ !&0 (
, 4 . *
) !##'!,, *
#%
!
A
) ) , ( (
( , )
)*9 $0$$ )*9 $0$% *
) ).
= )
* ) ) ) !
) )
#?
, 6 ) A9* ) 2 3
*+4 4 5-*6*%*7 8 ( 3
!"!!!0*, 4 6 ) 2
$ *
*$
"*
'
"
" $ :0
* '
"
"$'( "
%%"
$
"
*
$ ?
(
*
"
$
' $
@ (
(
%?"
$ "
(
" "
$%
% * " % $ ( "
' "
%
"
*
$ ) ,,,, ,,,, ,,,, !
"
%
"
" (
"*
" $ "
$ 1 " C " (
( ( ( (
'
$ "
%
"
' %
"
"
(
"$
"
) ' ?
( (
"
" $
"
-. "%
-1. ) ' "
( "
" " D ) '
(
$ "
(
% *
* )
1
"
) 'E " ) ,,,, ,,,, ,,,, 1 ! " "
* " " "
"
"*3
"
$
"
$ " "
% @ " *
(%
$
( $ %$
"
(
"
$ "
$
!$%
*
( " "$
" "
$
!
? 3 "
$ ?
@
( " "
$
' % " 73
! (
( % * " %
$
" $ %
"
"
" $
$
( '
$ ( "
(
$%
$ @
" % " " @
( (%
" (( *";
#?
# , 6 ) ) * ) ) ( ) * * ) ) ) , * ) ) ( )
,
H " ! ) ) ( + $0$% , ) (
) * > ) ) *
)
) ) ( ) * )
>2$#&)'* '+
-$&-$.
3)#1)##"< '( &-$ 7$&)&)'*$.
B)&-'2& )*C2).?
)#
D2#&;
(").
"*3 .$"#'*"@<$A
#1
A9* ) 6 ) 1 63 +* 37
17) . 4 4 45 "!'5 72**6*%*6 5%44 45 0" 0#5 9 % $4 4 * 9 % $5 !##0" ' 5 3 1$ * -* $22 2" . 8 1*
* 22 3 2 "05 -
*+ 13
!"!!'! ( ) >( > * * ) *( ) ) )
#1 # ,
*( A9* ) * (
! * "<$ D9- 5 A9* ) ) )
) ) ) )
$# F 4 3 "
$ **" "
%
"
*
%
%-. @ $- .
(
**
(
" " % -.
"
"
( (
"
*
*
" *$ $
('
"F ! %!9- . )(
* ( 7 )()
) * ) ) )
)) A *
>( *( #- 0# #22/ )
) ( ! ) * ) ) ) ( *
)
!D" $G- .'A9* ) * )( )() ) , )( ) 6 ( ) ) ,
#2 2
*
"
(
$
"' " $ *" $
$ "
$
*$
" ($
?
"
3
'$ % $ 2*";
% 3 "
"
*
(
2
(
;* $
$
(
@
$ ?
5 &
(*B
"
H 5&
(*B
"
') 8>E
CI '
=
" -) 8 1' E. 2E J
'
* "" ( %
(
* ' '
" %
* @ " )
" = * +*
' $
" ' (
$
%
(
( ( "
"
(
"
* "
?' +*
$' * '
*
"
* ( "" " ' ( ( '
$
"
@
'
" @
)
"%
; #-
, ) * *( 7 ) ) * *(
) B
B )
+)
)
* 7 ) , *( 7 * )) ) B )
*( ) B 7 ,
( ) *( 7 )
*( ) * +)
7
) * ) ) * )
, ( *) ) ( )
)
(
#/
, > *) 0?
0< $0$% 0# 0/ $0$$ %0 0- $0$%
)) )
)) ) )
, $0$%
+ ) * , $0$% )
0?
$0$% ,
)) $0$% , *) 0?
0< $0$% $0$%
*( + ) * ,
$0$% *
))
))
) ) )) , )
( *( ) (
#<
G ' ) 1 9 * 8
" # !' > ) )( * ! )(
* 6 ( #$ ## #2<2
* 7 *
( ) , )( ) ( , )( * ,
( * A ) * > )
, ) ))
)( (
*( (
* #$ $# 6 * , )(
*(
)
* (
* ( )
, 4 * 6 )
5 :;< 9 * -3 !## 1=-!00 6 ) 1 9 * % 9
" !! & 5
. * (*1* -
2
!#,& 22" &# ( > *
) ) %## ! > * !
>( ) *6 ( ) )( ) * B >(
) ) ) *( )(
6* ) * ) ) , 4 )
)
) ) *( *
#2
! ) ) ) *( ( ) ) * ) *6 ) ( ( ) (
* ( : * ) ) *> *6 ! )
=
) *>
" , ( )
) , )
) ) ) * ) *( ) ( *
$0
' * )
H " ! )
) * * ( (
* 4 * ) . , 6
02 $0$$
) )) 01 $0$% , * ( )) ) ( ,
) ( *
(
) ) ( ,
) ) ( (
* ) (* )
$#
!
* * ) > *
, ( ) (*
) )( , )
) ) *
,
(
) )
) A )
) )
,
.* ) >( ) *( %## !
$$
7 * )
8
, :%
++
K ?
(7 " L7< L7<