← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaVATAP/39/2012allowed

M/S Dlf Ltd. v. State Of Haryana And ANR

2023-02-20Mr. Justice Tejinder Singh Dhindsa,Mr. Justice Sanjiv Berry6 pages

     

  !" "#" $"!%&



 !"  %'%("!%&

)# **+,+-"!

.."//0%- $" #'# 1"2-0-" 0 30%00%!0%-1"

"#.%!"%-# &4 * 2  2  2 4 * 22   555 

         

 

  

555   2  26    

$% *&+,#  -" .// !!  "

/      "    #        /  #    !

 # 

  /  ./  %0(1  // ,  ! / 2 345 3 

343 ,  '& $( '$$1  ,  #  5 3 , !

!   #  !

  ,  ,# 346

3 

 %001  /  7 / ,   2 345 3 !  !/" ,

 

! 7  %008*%000 * / ,

!   " 

 "   !  9 %$:108;'$2*  <                  /    9 &&%%1('02*,   /  / 

7 / ! 2 345 3 < 

/    "9 (':&&0$2*,  !,   ! /# /  #!  !  ! ! #!   %008*00 =   " ##

    , #   

, !/

#"    !

    >

!/". 

        ,

#  " ## , !/ "  ! !   ! * /     " /  7 /, !/

#"    !

  /

%% '$$:)"

*%+= ,!,* ?   

 !"#  

$ %&!



#'

 



              &  #  #  

  # !

   #

!&

('

  () *

!

  +

 $   & 

"

&

    

 

 #$  

!  #  ( ) *

! #  # 

*

 

$  , 

  ! #

! 

 ! #

&

 

 !" #   $ %&!



#'



 ##!!'

 * )  #'

 - . "

./012   3  4 ! 5  # 

  

!!

#,

!

# &

              (  '

     

  () *

!* 

   4 ! #6&, $ $" 

 ( !$" 



  , 

     



# !"  ## * #   , !

 3 4 !!

 &!

 !



  * &  

!

"!



! #



& 7



 "

$

*

! #

 "!&

  &() *

!

  !!&

&

#, 

       $ %&!



 !&!

  &     "*

 !"#  * 

!8

,

 

$5 ,!

! * # 

# 

$5 ,##

 #

!8 ,



#  3 4 !  # $" 



!  #!

  ! #

&

 

 !"#   $ %&!



#'

 ##!'

  !

 !

 !



&  

!

"!

 #

  !"     *

      #   $ %&!



&  

!8

, $5 ,7  ##

  &# #   # ! #



& "

 &!

9    9 (';1(0$2*,   # ! 

9 :1



"9 

, ;:  " !9 %$ =   #   #  .//  !  #! ,  .//        .//       

 %'

$8 '$$:

)"

  *'+                 #  

$0 '$$;    /   ,   /      -"   .//   

, ,   !         .//  ,       

%0 $% '$$( )"

 *(+    ,                     

,   !/ !

$% *&+ =! , -"

  .//   ,   >      !    

  ,    # !  > /  @         

!

@      

,.//

>   9 :1 

 "9 

, ;:



 "> !/

/ / #! 

@      #!   . )#091:0  0##';0, 10%!$# 2-0-"  0 30%00%! -1" #<

7

8 !"(+!"!  %  = 8

 )"

  *8+  

     ,    , ,!

 



"  /     !

#  "! ,  ! !

 9 :1

 "9      #   ! <            

/A B, =,  /    , !   !

/! 7 , 7

      #  ,,!/* ?



*

  !



!! 

  &!  ##

 "



#

"  

#









# *

  ! *   ##



  

# 



  



 

#

  * # 

/:  ;

:0 ! ! # 

 !

   



 & (8

!&!

&   9 6 !  >

!/     .  091:0  0##',0% 10%! #'. 0 

>

/ #C#

/.   3 # 

, /

@/   >

!/.   0+ 10 0-',0%!1",+(0/#*-!$#2-0-" 0 30%00%!-1" # 

 ?27 , /,,  ,!

  >

!/ 091:0  0##';0,10%!

#'. 0 6, # ,!  / , 091:0  0##';0,10%!2'. 0 , / !    #

$% *&+     7 , #   ! /

%% '$$:)"

 *%+ ! / %008*00

 ,   /

  2  2

 2  

 ": '0 3

6

#'%+-0 @9   =!D @9 # D