High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/1221/2012allowed

Hem Lata v. Balwant Singh

2019-03-01Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath7 pages

!"!

#$%&%' () %%*%%

+ , +"-" ./# 0!#12 *%%

$ 5) % 0 00))

$ +%)%0%2#1-647

+% +%"2/+).647

2..

#1 !# # 3

# !"

4 %&% 3""

4 0-8 !7!"!

#. -4! !.1!"

:3-+6/2 89#33.! #!.

+3 +(!

!#12

39 #4 4!" 2+1

.!8!.!

96 /" 4!"(!""

4% ) +!.

+ 2 +!#1 3+ " #4 2+ -12 :-41( " +

89 -#"

+7 -#4!#1

#&<

!8.

+-( " + "2 = 56 ##

4/!

- >2!.

!""-!#1 #

(

#6 ?%@%3""

/!#1 +$ A) -#"

+6 !#

+.!6

#4"

33.!

+ 2" 8

# 4!"(!""

4 !# 7!

+ :-41( !# B #4-"

" ) 4%

+","%(+..,"%-(#!#4#

+!(!#.<6/2 ":-41( !# "

( 4+ 0% +82- ,"%09 4 8.. %6 +!(!#. <?6 !" 33.! 8.

!# "

+ "

+ /" + 49

(C 39( ( !#4!"3-

(

+D%E%% #/2!.

+!. !" 4!+

-+# #4 4

1!7 #89 2!" %F 2

+6 /2 (

+ ( -3 + 2 +!#1

2!" #D%<%6 2!" /2!.

4(!

# 3

#6 24 "

4!#1" 8

+!. 6"-8:

+5"4 "!

2!#

GH/!

2!#3 /

C"8

+!. %0-8"

+6-#4 +"3""

2!" 63+ 3

#/"

.!"

+2 +!#1 E%@%<% ) -#"

. 3

+6/!

- 4!"3-

.!8!.!

+ -#4 + 0

# &< "-8(!

!# (3.!# /!

4 D%<%

+ 2" .+ 49 4 "!

4 # "%6?6I !% % ( .

#1 /!

GH68

+!. % 2"+

4 D%<%E "-8(!

4 "-8 !7!"!

#.-4! !.1!"

60(#!# 2!"+ 1+4% !"6 2-"6 3+9 " ( .

#1 /!

2 !#

6 " 4!+

2!" 6"

#4"3!46#

2!#1"-+7!7 "!#

#% !" 9

-+ + "-8(!

#&< 6"

6/!

39(

!+ 4- >2!.

++!#1

:-41( 3 J !# I"

+" #4 #"

+-( % ) 4% #4

+ ,"% B# 2# 6 E 0 @?'@6 !

#&< 6 #8

-#4 # !# 8"

% # "!4 :-41( 3 J /2!.

4!" -""!#1 !

+.!

+ :-41( " !# ( 4+ 0% +82- "-3+ #4 B #4-"

" "-36 2" 2 .4 /2 !"3!489

4!#1"% 2 7# J " + :-41( / -.4+ 4"-#4 +$ A<% 8 4!" -""!

/!#1"3

+1 $ ! -#4 + 0

# &< !" 3+!(+!.9 !7!. /+ #1% -+4

!" # -"

4 !# 7!

3+ "-(3 # -#4 + 0

# &' 8- #4+4 "- 23+

!"K3+ +# 88!.!

"K%2 "( 2"

+(..9 4"-((+!.9"3 +3+ "-((+9 +!.-#4 +% %%82"- 27+! " (9 8 33+ 3+!

4!#1" -#4 + 23

L, % 2-" + 46 3+!# !3.

# ?< +% %% /!.. 33.9 #4 # .

4!#1" #4 4!" 2+1 -"

# " !"

( /!

2 ""

" #4 !#

!"3!4#4! !"#

4/!

3-#!

!7 "3

!! 2

3+ 3+!(+!.9

+96 3-#!

!7 !#1 (!#.9 /!

+ !#1

-#4!#1 !#!

!. "

-+1 8- !"#

4 8++ 4 .

"-8:

33+ 3+!

#"(98 -#4 8.

@ !!! 2 -12 -#4!#1 + ;-!+

3+ "6 #!#8"

"- 2 6!#

:-"

# 8 !#1 " !"!

2" 8

# 4-.9

46 # !# !

4!" +

# .

4!#1" #4 4!" 2+1 -"

4% !7

4-+ +!. "

"-#4 +23

+L,

2"# +(..9

"-((+9%2 4!" +

1!"

#43+ 7!"

#@&6

.4 !

/"-#4 "!+8.

"-((+!.9 " "

( 2# 9 + (9 27

46!"

J + !"

#"!4 +!#1 -+ 3+ + "

!(3+!"

#( 2" :-+!"4!

# -#4 + 0

# &?E& +% %%

/+4 "-!

# /!

2 4 -.

-#4 + 0

# D@ % %% #4 /!

2 -+ + 3 +"

+9-#4

#@&+% %%>!

2!"33+ 26 3+!"

# "

( 2# 9 + (9 #

;-!+ 4!#.. "

"% 7 0!# 7!4 (3.!# #8 1!7 !47!

6 "-8:

"-(( #!#1 +"

1!7!#1 !47!

#4 J(!#!#12!( #4 8#CM" ".!3 !#13+!( !

7!4 4!"2 -+ !"-##

""+9 1!"

+4#9-+ 3+ .!(!#+9 7!4 % 0- 2 !47!

7!4 # 8 4 " 7!4 .. "

+!.

4!#1"% 2 (## J(!# +"

1!7!#1 !47!

# 8 " 3 + 0

# D@ +% %% 2 " 2 !"

/ "-((+9 3+

4-+ J /2

J + !"

+ -#4 + "

#4 3+ 7!"

# @&

" #

""+96 /2

9 + (9 27

/+4 4 #4 # -#4 + 0

&?E& !" #"!4 4 !#4 ;-

6 27!#1 + 1+4

!## !. 3 !

9 #4

#4- -"

+#9

+ !+ -("

"% '% # 7!

8 6 / .4 /2 2!#

#4 """

!"3!4 89 "3 !!

4 4

4!#1"!# J + !"

"3 +"-#4

#@& 4/!

#?<+% %%".+ 49 8"

+7 46# +(. +-.

+!. "

"-#4 +23

+L,

"-((+93+

4-+ #4"-(( +!.3+

4-+ #8

4/2 "

4!#1 9 +(98

""+9

C!#1!#

#-#4

&?E&+% %%/!

"" 2# 9 +/!..#

4 ;-

627!#1+ 1+4

#4-

4#4

+ !+ -("

"% %# (3.!#

#&< (98 "!+8.

1!7 "2!"8#C #-(8 #4 ! 3 ""!8.

(!. -"

4% (!. !" 7!.8.

#C /2 -"

4 2" # "- 2#C6 #8 !#1+ ;-!+ 46"2 -.4-+#!"2"- 2 (!.

% # +9 "-(( #"6!""-

46!

(98 !#4!

! -"

44 "!

4 ( 6 /2! 2 "2 -.4 8 ""

27!#1 + 1+4

( #4 !#

I 6 89 !!

4 4

4 #

33 + -#.

"" + ;-!+ #43+

4!#1"(98 4"-8:

#97.!4 8:

% -"

(3.!

"/!

2"- 2"-(( #4 !# +(" #4 89 (!.6 # "

!# 8:

#6 ! #96 #4 .

4!#1" -#.

"" !

" #

""+9

4 /!

% # "- 2 "!

- #6 -"

4M" 3+ # 8 ;-!+ 46 -#.

"" !"

+/!"

4 "-8:

"- 2 #4!

#" " (9 8 #"!4 33+ 3+!

%2 -"

46/2 /#

6(-"

;-!+

4!" .

"3 !! 4

+"- 2

"C"3 !! ;-

%# "

+!.!"

46!

/!..8

J3.

""!8!.!

% /!.. ."

#"!4 3.

8+1!#!#1% 0-8:

2!"6 +!. # 8 # 49

49 8"!" #4

7 -+(-"

# .-4 !

2!#"!J( 2"%2 1-!.

9 (-"

3-#!"2 4 +.!

"3 +./#4 /2

9" ./ #

4 #

.4 -3 !# 3+

4!#1" + .

#1 -##

""+!.9%F

+6 7!4

4 @%E%E6 "C

(3.!# +4

4D%<% % 2 -4! !. 1!"

4""-#4 +$ A !" +

-..9 "-8(!

-#4 +"!1# 4 2" C

2+1 #%?%E6#43 +-". !.

"2 /" ( ) 6 3

+6 24 4 "!

D .

#1/!

2 !#

"%6?6?I 7!4 % < 4

4D%<%6!# (3.!# +4

4D%<%3""

!# 8 #

4 "

6 89 !12 2#4!1+2% 2 39

!3 2..#6 !" # .

2%2 3

+4 "!

2!#3

C"8

+!. !"-+ +"-8(!

4 "!

#1/!

2!#

!% % "%6?6?I24.+ 498

#42!" -#"

.6/2!.

3""!#1

4D%%89 +!. #.

0(3 6"-#4 +$ $ -#"

.% -"

#8!./!

-#"

.% % 49 "

/" !J + 4

7!4 % 2 -#"

. -"

49 3+ 4-

39 + 3""

4 89 !12 4

4D%<%/2

4!#1 2!" "

9 4#4 "%6?6?I2" .+ 49 8

# 4 "!

4 " 3 4!+

!12 % !" 4:

-+#

%% + /!

!#1 -+

+" !12 %F

!" .

+ 3

+2" (3.!

+!( +3""

2!" #D%<%#4 "( !"."

!# C# /.

./# 0!#12%

+ 2 +!#1 -#"

. 3+ " #4 27!#11 2+ -12 !(3-1# +#4-+ C!#1!#

#"!4 :-41( 3 J !# B# 2# 5" "

"-3+6 ( #"!4 3!#!

+2"4 "!

!+ .

#1 /!

2 !#

G H " 4!+

7!4 4

4 D%<%6 # 3-+3 / -.4 8 +7 4 89 C

3!#1 (

+3 #4!#1%7 -12 I 2"

E "2 /#2!"+ "!"

1!#"

( 7!

7 8:

4!#1"-#4 6!"

39(

#4 #

!# + ++ +" "6 "!(3.9 I 4

" #

1!7 2!"

%2 8:

!"3+!(+!.9

+963-#!

!7 !#1 (!#.9 /!

+ !#1

6"(98 -#4 8.

3+ % (98

/2 !(3-1# +/" .

+!. (

+/" 7 +9!#!

!. % 7 # # /6 " / -.4 33 + + !#

+!( +" 2!" + !(

!( +#"3!+ 2 4/9!#

4!#1"%2-"6!# ## +-.!#1 3 J !# B# 2# 5" "

"-3+6 !+ "

#4"3!46 2!" !"

4!#1"% #7!

8 #3

#!" ..

4% 2 !(3-1#

4 %&% 3""

0-8!7!"!

#.-4! !.1!"

:3-+6!""

"!4 #4

+!. !"4!+

4 !4 (3.!# "3 ./.!4 /# 89 0-3+ !# B# 2# 5" "

"-3+6 J3 4!

-".9% %&%' 4" >2

+03 C!#1I

4$ "I >2

$ "I