← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/27812/2019disposed of

Gram Panchayat Village Mansa Khurd v. State Of Punjab And Others

2024-03-12Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Lalit Batra11 pages

    

          



 ! "# $%&'()( "%&%*&+ $%&')(    

 

   

   !"

 '  ,-

 . .

. /

  ,-

 . --  # "$%& '(')'#*"+,' -.! '"#.** )'$  '/)#.".

*"+,'0. .'"'#.*"+,' -!"122 .

. /

 0   2

.'0!","'#'.4'(#- ""'"567157289:

;5<0.$%.44*

'"(+* '"(* )'$4'"".  ., +/!4',.'%' --,*''",".,'4 5   '!!/,'  "  ,  6  -  .   )'$  //'# 44'"9# /'<,*28=29.'--.,'//"' .>,-28=2><0'-/"$%.'4',.'%'*''. "

'#'.!". .!9 !'<,/'4". "-'+",-+,'#'.!".

   1

. #.'"4'".*217?572?9:  ;2<*.//,4'"'+",-+,./+' . '##+"  .-4  !-"  '  '!!'/  .'#'  $-  . 44* '"(+* '"(*0.. #.:

;

5*4'"'"-4'"-.  .,+/!4 ',.'%' --,*''*",".,'4$%-//0#. !,!/-' '/) ,'"$%-//0#.", "$%. >$/ #. ,'@;A7=7;577?*@;82A5;2881'"

@;5B?;288B B

./'", /-.!'0//'./'" , /'!!'#-!"122''""4.' .!!//') ",'$,'4:,"$%.44*

'"(  +*  '"(  0'  '  '!  :,#  -  '!!//' ) ",*'4-:

;1*.'!!//') ",0' $:,"$%.44*',.'%'/'"*.'$%. 44* '"(+* '"(C /%*."- 4'"',/".4!

#""9:

;5<C "

$C '."'"'"$ !,+-",9<$,4# !'"$%. @;A7=7;577?*@;82A5;2881'"@;

5B?;288B* '.'"",9<' !, '4:

;1 ,,"#/%*:

;5C '."'"'" ? .''4'%*.'##+"-4:

;2*4'% , ''!!'/.'#'$ 4-:

;1*.

$-.44',.'%''" =

-.'"'!!'/4$'"*. !*.'!!//' 4'%,/'4.$--,2B-.4',$,4# "0".4

)   6  #!",%-.'0!$-.  *,.!',.'%'.'' 4"!-."!

"

/'"*.$%. #.''!!/,'$'#;617;@;575B ,' ",2BB-.*.'!!/,';!"1 22,/'4.4'(#-'"$%. -. - !.4-."!

"/'" A -  !,"#    '") ",'  !  .  '!!/,' 9 !'<*,'%#. #.-', '/$',("!-.,' 8

.,/"'!,"#(!/',.4.'/ ,,".%'28?B;?? .'$'+".'.'!!/,' 0/"#'''!..'D/4 -.$',.' /'"    !  -  .  --*  .%  -'/"    #  .  #. +",'"'" /4'/%.%-/"'! ",B5-. ' )'$ /"#/"'9+'" '#4'< ,*28BA9.'--.,'//"'.>,-28BA>< .'"

!0'"!"-+"""'"757?28AA'".4' 0'4'""$',(./"' --,0..",.' .. /".'.!'*:'4.,"'".'!!/,'. /"

$,,/%.0' "''$') ".'4/'.!,- .'$+'"'' 27

.  /"'  --,*  . #.  '  "  4'"   587628AA9:

;1D5<.4'""  ',,!".'" !    .  $'  -  .  '"  "*  4 '    2=82  0' ',"-'+ -!"122*0..%0 ,""'0!-./'"C  22 ##+" '#' .'$+'""*. !; '4',.'%'-/"@5?27;28A8 0+*.'"!

(   0'"4"$%. +"""'"567528A8 25 +  .  '4  ',.'%'  ,.'//#"  .  "  "'" 587628AA  !'"  $%  .  /"'  --,  $-  .  . ""'/  ,  0+*  .  '"  '!!'/  -/"  $%  .  '4 ',.'%'0'"4"+"""'"7?7B28879: ;

1D=< 21  $C /%*  '!!/,'D!"    1    22  # 0''-! "-4./"' --,:,# .!0-'//, '"'".!0' #"/+".4.4.-'%*28A8'",.. '!!/,'D!"    1    22  '    !',- /  , /+'# !-./'""!

 2B

.''$ 1?!.+//'#'/-/"@;88BA; 28A8  ,.'//##  .  "  "'"  587628AA  9:   ;1D5< 0+*.'"!$,'4"4"$%. +"" "'"2B7528829:

;1D?<+#/$%.! '!!',..,/"''

.-.! "/- 2?

+0-.'-"*.'"+//'#-/"! 1=1D8?$-.""'/,*/"' . #.' "  4'"  .*    7?25288?*  .  ""'/  ,* /"'  0."0  !'  -  4  /'"  -4  .  .'  -  . '!!/,'D!"122'"#'+.'4.'" +//'# 2= ##+"  '#'  .  "  "'"  7?25288?* '!!/,'D!"122-/"@;2?6=;288=$-.  0.,.0'"!"-+"""'"577?288A9:  ;1DA<

1   26

.'!!/,'D!"122'/-/"',+/ -!4') ,*0.*.%!,-,'//%!/'"".' .% .'" $,4. 0- ./'" "!  '" .'4 ',.'%'$'"-4-#.! .'4 ',.'%'-'/""-".,''"0'!,""'#':;!'

.,+/ -/"$%.'!!/,'D!"1220' ","257228829:

;1D8<*0.*0'./".'. '!!/,'D!"122'0!-./'" "!

'".'4',.'%'.'"#.*/. '" /'" 2A

  .'  $  - .  '+"  .'  .'-  .  '4 ',.'%'" .'!!/,'D!"122-4 ./'""!

-/"'! ",B-. )'$ $/, 4  '"  9+,  '"    ,+%<  ,*  2861*  0./ ,,'/#.4''/-',''"'$+ 28

. #.'"4'".*217?572?9:  ;2<*  .  /'"  //,;, 4; *  ''  '//0"  .  '"

),4'!!/,'-.!;'4',.'%' 57  .'##+".-4'!!/,'D!"1 22!-"''!!'/.'#'$-.44* '"( +*  '"(*  0.  . #.  :

  ;5*  4'"  '  "  - 4'"  -  .    .  ,  +/!4  ',.'%'  --,* ''*",".,'4 52

.!;'4',.'%'.'",.'//#".'- "  9:

  ;5<  $-  .     $% -/#  .  '  0 ! 55

    - .  '+"  .'  "!  .  -',  .'

2   '!!/,'D!"122'0!-./'" C *.'4',.'%'" .'!!/,'!'"

/ "'"217=572?C #.  0''- ! .'!-."!

"/'"0''($%. '4  ',.'%'    2?7=572?  '"  .'      .  '$,  - '!!/,'D!"122 0+*,"".'. '"!,"#.'+$"!'!'"!0'+ $'(-4.!'!!/,'D!"122 51

.'51275751*.!'4',.'%'.'" .'+".4'E,!' "2A(''//'" -.'//'"- ??2A'"-,- //%(.!-."!

"/'" 5B

,"".'.4' $;) ",$-.  '".!;'4',.'%'0.'//4+* ". #'$-'%"*#'"$%. .'"'(!'-./'"

$/##.!'!!/,'D!"122*"!. -',.'.'!!/,'D!"122'.'.', '/ !.%,'/, /+'#!-./'"C *0.,.'/ "!,"-4.+ ," 5?

.!;'4',.'%'0//#'//%.0#.' .'.%.'+'(.!2?7=572?$ .#'"

.%.+ ," 5= C /%*      ,""  .'  .  4'  - ' 4!  -  !  +  .  "!

"  /'"  $%  .  '4 ',.'%',4!//% /'0- /'".$%.'!!/,'-/"

",2BB-.$'//0" 56

./'", /-.'!!/,';!"1   22   $4*  .'  .  +,  "  9:   ;2<  $,'4

   ,.'//#"  $-  .  44*  '"(  +*  '"(* 0.$%./'',,!".'"'!!'/'"4'"".. //,  ,,"  -  ","#  .  '4    4  /'/%* .$% /'$"#*'"*,,/ +",$,'4,""* .'!!+,!$%.'

.,,"*.$%*. /'"  //,  ,,"  0'    C "    $  -,#  . +",-+,!'"'#'.'!!/,'D!"1 22*'.0'(- ,,- /:, *$#4'"-.4!

#"

0''-!*.$%,'.'!!/,';!" 122 ,,"*./+'+,!*.$%*%$+'$/ /!/,%-/#'*'.4'%'-4. ,,- /!'%*$  $,4#/"('-!-.',C "/'"* -4.",;./",,"*0.4 ,.!$,4 "/+"*!

 ',.4'(#- ,,- /:, -. 0''-! 5A '", /-.'!!/,'*.''/4'"/',*

!.!+,'" /52-.  . )'$ //'# 44'"9# /'< /*28=B 9.'--"' F. /-28=BG<*!+0.-$,4:',".'-  

  



        

     

              

   



            !          "  #

    

  

 

 

     

    ! 

   

"   $   %        



      

  

        

  !        $   

 

         & 58 .''4!""'0.!"'-.  *.!+4$"" $; /2'"5- /52- . /-28=B*0.,.$ 4'(, 4$* !*./'"

//,,,"*-.$,4'-"*.'!  ','

",*-+,$#!'"*.$%.'"+",C " $  -,"*  . #.  .  '

.E"  ,, !'  -  .  ! !!%*$#","$4+".-4 /'/%*4 -.'" $ /9 !'<*./'"//,,,"*.

.'// '/!,",'

',!%-."-+,*$#'--:" . "-.',.'%'.'*'"*'4.,!,  !/',-.'*0.,../'".44+'$/!!%  '"

.4* $; /5- /52-. /-28=B*$  4'(,/'!'(#*.',''%! - -'/ ,4!/%0.."-+,*.

0..%"'%-."'- !

$/,'*.

.//,,,"*'%.--," /% '

.E"$%.4*.$.'/-*4'%+,.'!-4*'"*!  .',.'%'!-./'".44+'$/!!% '"4'%-.'!

!*  ,.-,'4'%$,'% 4. '$+:'," /*./'", /-.'!!/,' $4* .'$',.-.4'"'9 !'<*'.4'"*'-. !+#'-".*.'+$,4!/"0.'.',- .",;./",,"*'.',-./'"//, ,,"

    .

 .. .      -   . 

.-   - 

.-

   

  17

./'", /-.!'0//'./'" ' /+# /%'# $-. *.',. !/'"#  4'"    .  '  '!!/,'*  /'#    $',.  $# ,'

".!+- $; /5- /52-. /-28=B

.-*  .   $4  .'  -  0'  -  !/'"#    .  ' '!!/,'*!,-./+'' %-',*!,0.- $',.*,/'4"$%./'", /-.'!!/,'D!" 122 .-*. $4*.'.'$+'# 44'"$% ./'", /*-.'!!/,';!"122/'# $',.$#,'

".!+- $; /2'"5- /52 -. /-28=B'.'-+/ /%'"'# 4*'"D* -4/%4$"""./+'-', '/'' -.. .

 .. . - 

.-

 . 12

.     .'  ,+/%  4'"  '  !- "

,4!/'9<* !.'# 49 !'<*'$,'4!,+/% '"""$-. $%./'", /-.'!!/,';

!"1;22*$%./'", /-.!;'4 ',.'%''"$%./'"', / 15

'!!'.'.0''-!$,'4 "$% .//,,,"*/%'-:

;2$#!'" 11

.'$'#".'-*!,+- .!/'"#9 !'<*$#4'"$%.//,!,-$',. $#".!+4$"" $ /2'"5- /52 -F. /-28=BG '"!,+.'. .'"'/

   ,,/ "".'.'# 4!,.-*.

 ""/ 0+*.0'%'4!'+,%-:,," -.,'*'"-'-',4-. /9 !'<*.

$,4#"'0$%.//, 0+*.'"" ," .$%. #.. ',-0''-!0.  .'""-'-',$#4'"$%.//,,,"* ""4'(.'" ',9<$":, -.0''- !'.$+'" 0+*,.  '4#. ,#  /#'  .'    -'//%  4'"*  '  .     '- '.#:

;5*.'/#'".'!!/,'D!"1   22    4'(  '  '!!'/  '#'  :   ;2*  $-  . 44',.'%''" 1B C /%*-. '//0.'!!/,''"-

/4'/%.'

.%9 !'<*"4.,/'4.' % '!!'/*'$,4'"$%.'!!/,';!"122* .$%*.0 /"$4 /!/,%-/#'*'.$%. '4',.'%',,"0 /"$/"-/'!-(#  -!C '-."!

"/'"*'$,4.'""

+    .  '!!/,';!"    1    22*  . #.  '  " $,4#4'"$%.  1?

.-*. -'-4'//0#.'!!/,' ;617;@;575B'"',,"#/%"4*$ /'+/$% .'!!/,';!"122,'.% ,,". ' %'!!'/*.,/'4'- ./-.'.!-. "!

"  /'"*  $  "    .4*  $   . #.  .  '!!/,';

!"    1    22  -/#  '  :,   !  $-  . //,,,"

   1= !. @;5A177;5751/"'>'4"

 4''" .  '- )'$'" .>","" 52255751*4'(#.'$+''/%*%'!!'.'.", 9 !'<.'$,4!/"0. .--,-.,4!/', -+",9 !'<*.'.$%"!- .' %4" $#',,$/$%.'##+"-4.+",-+,!'" $%.//,,,"*%.+",9<-+,*. + 0. '0'#-. ,4-'!!'/+.'#' $-.' %'

.*'.$,4#!4!/%-,"  /'/%  .$%  .    $+ /%  '  //  C /  -  $+'$/ /!/,%  -  /#'  '#  '4#  .  ,#  /#'* '4 ,.'*. ,,- //#'- .'!!//'+'/   0  !,"#  $,4#  /+'#"    (  '  - !  -  .  "!

"  /'"    .4  $%  .  '/  ", ./"D/#',," 16

,C ,*.#%-. "," ,, /'',!%-.+",'//.,//,.' - )'$-.- .0'"'4*.

!,+/% .//,:,#) ", ".>,-28=2>'">.  /-28=B>'" '/.!!//' .%9<:,# !!//') ", ".'",*.'*.'-. ,,'- !-.$+'$///,C ,9 !'<  .

. /

    --  )(    ('+#. @..!'(#D'"

&

D @..!'$/ &

D