High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/571/2012dismissed

Khazan Singh And ORS. v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2020-07-08Mrs. Justice Rekha Mittal14 pages

! " #$ # %%&& '#( )#* # % +#

#+,*&-#./ $. -.

# %%&& #0##- &,-)#* #$1 &-.

##% 2

+#*# %%& # 4%& " &"& #%# . #5$6 ! " %%&& ./ .#4 4 %%& (%%#8*

. ' & 9 ( #* #"(4 . - %%& &&/ ' &9 ( #*&&/88#(" ##$

! " %%&& -(8::(;% -

# %(#% %# & &* 4 44 %#1 ##

% # "&* "#$"%& 9 && " %# %%& 8 # " :("4 %8* 9(#/ #8*( &8* %%&& # &# <( &#& %#4 :( /4 8* #&9(#-## " " &* (=%# " :(# 9.&9(# %%& &" :("4 #& 9(#/48* &#>("-,(#" / #8* %%&&9(#

#4 " #&9(# (= ? - 8# -# & & %# %& / ## 8 <(# . @@ ( # = $ <( #A A

( # B /%(8& = @@ ? %%&&

& 8: ( # 7 .## %%#( * # "/"# %%&& " 8:

&8* 4C& """#.- * & #/#% 8# "

= 8 # )" 9(#? )" 9(## %%&& 41 /# #%#

4 ##-)D+ 1(&/ #

# ". %#%# # " # #%# # 41 " % % ? %%&& # #. * #4 9

4 ##- )D- + 1(& # %%#( * # " /

# % #%#<(? *#.&# B @

2 #: " ##%# ? %* ## B @

/ (%%& 4? * & # #/#% 8# "B= B

2& "( /## ( )D

? )"

9(#- . ## @ 2

= #&" % # # # #*.&#4- .? %%&& & ( %#4#&* &&" #( % &-#4 / ; 4( %## ( # = /( %#%&* )#* ,.# 4 -& / #( / ; %## ( # =

8<(#7 (# #%& ; " #( 8 4& "

/ ( %%&& ? * .(" #& & <( /&& #( &8&8#&%#".# 4 %&*? *& (" <( &#& :( ? #% E & #/# 4 ? * #%#&4 #*8: 9.&9(# :(# (8 #4: # : # %#F %%&& .

%%# 9(#/ & F * . &( & ( # %& %%&7/# %##( ( # = - # 9&&# # 8: % % /& (? (& / 4%&&*. 4? & /<(#./#

= ? #&9(# #4 &&/ "( ##4

G # #( &8(& "- &

- &# # &%#%# %&

/# & #( /#

; 4( %##( ( #

= 4& #(

/ ( %&

/ ( " /# #%# 4 8* %&

9 4 ##-)D&&"H++

G # #( & / #( /; "/#&8&8#& %#,.# 4 %&*&&"H++ 27 ( #%#.-/ # %&

# & # #& %#4 : " %#* #H++ = G # .& 9(# :(# # #* %# (&&"H+ G # ( %&

8 #4: # : # #*%#&&"H+ BG # %&

. &( & %# (-&&"H+ G # %&

#%% #4 & " %# ( 8* # / ( &&"H+

G # ( %&

%#%#&* .&( # %(#% 9(# :(# &&"H+ @G # ( %&

%&&*4 8## 4 8&&&"H+

G # ( %&

8 #

&4 #( 4#& &&"H+

& ? %#/#&&/(. (%%#

##%. ? #&9(#1(%(= # 8* #&* "(% :("4 ) A8& (%#49(#'"'& #(")*% (#)&$+)",-") ../012

. "3-#("$+"$+'(&)%*% )"- "$4("5"'")")#""$+)% ..

062

7 & .& 9(# :(# %# 4#- -( 4 8&7 ./ " (=- 9(# ## * " ( 2

/ 8#.

" #(

8". .&9(#&1 :(# %# %( 8 # 8 #- 9(# %%&

#4 " #&9(# (= . (&&*4 %%&/ 9( & # %%&& & " ##8* 9(#8*# " /(84 7#"( 8 #.& #8* %#- #&9(# #4 4 *

( ##4 %#4 %#( . (%%# ##%.&47. 4 &*#"( #&9(# .#% ### "(=%#&4 #* (- # #- #&9(##(&*##8*1 "(%(= # % " (/ ( " #(

B #% / # %# . &#* ( . C# %(#%-# # 8 4 %#. ## =(& 9 9.&+#(# #A9+9A& &8

%& (% :("4 ) A8& (%#49(# )&%()& 8&)"'#9&,%#$:4#&'5'+*% )"9&&$&%"#0+&"+2'())%"$+ )%";$:<#'(4$$&4'&+4"%&% !

/0 2 0#9#;211 "-&%( &%"#"$+)%*%#8#$*"+#;";&('""$+)% !!70 2 0#9#;2 .

-:("4 9(# ,$=">#:#'";$+%5%'&-'+(";# *% )&%#+#$: #4&)">,),)' "'#";" !!10 2 0#9#;26/7 4)8#% $'&)$"'#$"; *% ?% ")" :&$4#&% '+ !!

0@2

0#9#;26.7-:("4 048*)" 9(#("%A")")"A,&(%#;+") *%"$:")"-,8"+,&(%#;+") !!

012 0#9#;266 C(&& 0 )4 &+# )" 9(# )#'(9# "=(#$:'""$+ "$)*%8";#$:("$+"$) !!60@2 0#9#;21!6 ?& " 9(# <( :(#

9.&9(#-. 4 &*#"( ( (" # # # (( # = B 8( %%&& . && ".&*#&"&* - ( -:("4 ) A8& (%#49(# (#)&$+)",-")% 4"%&0%,8)"2 "3-#("$+"$+'(&)%%4"%&0%,8)"2 " # 7 #"( 9(# / ( %%# " #& #.#*8#(" # ( & %%&& &8&8 #& #4<( #( & # #4/

; %##( ( # = - 44#( #### #%#.#*8*#4 " (= " %%&& E%&

7 -#"( %%&& &&* &/#% = 8 # )" 9(# 4/# / # # 9 4 ##- )D? #%# 48* %%&& /#:.## B @

8( / ("# " 4%%#( * # "

4%& / # )" 9(# $#- * & /# % 8# "B= B

28( 4/#%

/ 8#. %& "#.&&#" (48# %( <( %%&& /##&" ## #*.& #47#"( ". #- #/ % / %%&& ;% &.&( ###& #"#. 9( &/(&

#4 && # %%&& .#. 4% #% %(& 8 #.#8* #% G #"# &4 %%&& 1#&

#& #4<( ( #( 8 "; " #- #&(% :("4 9(# )% "'()&*%'"'& ")5"$" ..@0 2

6. 9( & #%# " #% - ##*- (%%# :("4 4%("

/ (84 #&9(# #" &* #& (% :("4 ) A8& (%#4 9(#

(#)&$+)",-")%4"%&0%,8)"2 "3-#("$+"$+'(&)%%4"%& 0%,8)"2(% &%& #% E .&9(#

.:(# %(#8* %%&& 7 #"( &( "& %#= %& - 8

.## #( %%&& / ; %##

( # = 4(& 8&"&&* <(# &8& 8 #& " #8*- %%&& && "<( #& 8*/* (( # = B 7 (# ##"( / &% " /# % B= B

2 %%&& % # # /# #&" ## #*.&#48(/ & *

&.&(8 # 9(# . "###&:(# .# & <( # "( &-/ # %%&& 1&& && " ##%8* )" 9(# */# / # #&" " 4# #*.&#48( 4

8 #(

#:(# (% .&9(#/ # ;7 48# - 8 #"( :(# (% .& 9(#

##/ %##8*# "%&

/.# %# E#% C# %(#%-# # 8 4:("4 ) A8& (%#49(# "="%'("$'"'&

"+)"$%8)')8)"'#$B"$)*%";,A,$+"#)<" !!.012 ../ # 8 & /&&&%# %& &/ (#

#:(# / # # #

@ %#

#:(# (% 9(#8* 7 9(# 4#/ (:(# #" &*8 % ( "="%'("$ '"'& "+)"$%8)')8)"'#$B )%*%C"A#),%%"#$ !!/062 116 ./ . >("0 9(# $',;"5*% "5"A .770 2 !

- 4/(&8 (&&* - (- # %#%..##(& " && %%&* ( G #"#.&9(#&1 ":(# -( &

(# # #& (% :("4 ) A8& (%#4 9(# '"'&

,$="> *% -")=#' #$:( !

0#9#;2 !6 / # . 0 #& (% :("4 (#)&$+)" ,-")% 4"%& 0%,8)"2 "3-#("$+"$+'(&)%%4"%&0%,8)"2 G #"# #8* %%&& 8*#&* "

(% %#. ## =(& 9+9 :("4 (-#"( 9.&9(#&1:(# #.#*#8* %%&& # *( (&%(#%/(& . 8 #.8*## " " #(;%

41 " :("4 & " * # "## #( 8 *&"& <( / 9(### "( "&1 # :(# 4#7 (# ##"(

:("4 #&(% 8*( & # %%&& - 9(# . .# %#. ##

(&9+9 4%/# 9(### "(% * #4# ((

(- # #- #&9(# #" &* &* ( :(# -%(#&*<( &/- # C# %(#%- # # 8 4 :("4 9(# )"-

"$4("5"'*#;;":&#)"$'";"$*%"$'A(#$:("$+)% // !

! 0 B2 +&4#+&+$ 6!

%(<") "% *% "4((-"$"%% ...012 0#9#;21 / 7 . #( & # %#-%#( %%#81 ## 0 # .# " (84 4 8* ( & # %# (A/ # #&9(#/#<(###

" && (#(&% <( :(#

.&9(# # A-%# ( & # %%&& /(& #&* 4# 8 8#("

%%&8 # 9(#- <( #4 #&9(#/(&# &* " #&9(#-

%%&- <( :(# .&9(###.#? 8 "- #8*( & # %%&& 8*# ## " %#. ## =(& 9+9 :("4 #&(% ;/(&&#&. "

? %#- #" &* 8 #"(8*( & # #% :("4 #&(% 8*%%&& ( ### =(& 9+9- ## # %#. ##

(&9+9 #&. ;# #4##

(&9+9-# (

I9(# (I ( / ( .8 #4- 9(# && "# -/ # # #-(% %#(-( & "

(% * #4# ((

# ( %& 8(# (&# " #;#&. 4

# (8 4 & (- 9(# 4% ## " * #4# ((

# (-4 " #8* 9(#4* ## "

# && ( #4 ( % ( 8*## " " #4# (? #<(#4 ##(& ### " "(% #4# ((

# (- (4(8# %#&4 #*(# 9(##<(###%### ( /(&8% 8*## " " #4#( #&9(### "/ #"#:(# 9(#" %%&& -/ 8&" 9(### " #(7 ./ 4#- # #8* ( & # %%&& &1(8 # "&*#: ? 8# " 9(#4# <(

:(# 9.&9(# ) A8& (%#49(# "3-#("$+"$+'(&)%% 4"%&0%,8)"2 & %#2 :("4 -<( (

7/(& (8&# 4 4%& & #8* :(# .& (#1"

! # "( # -8* #*4%& -8##? .& (# #8*. :(# ".&#

.&* %#(# 4%&( # ? &*#" ""#.%# %%# ( &(#-.!- )" 9(# (%#49(#( # #%& #*%/#( # #&

B 2B #%.&* / & 4% ## # ;# ;## #* %/# 0## " # - # %/# .&9(# (#)&$+)",-")%4"%&0%,8)"2#&. ;# #4 %#2 :("4 -# &&/ ? (-(&8 4%&

& 4 #.%(8&%(#%G#- # #- & 1-%# &*.- 8*

#*4%& %/# .&9(# 1"

! ( # @ 9+9 ;&(- .&(# :(# " <( .&*#&"&*

( # = &# ( # B-;%8* )" 9(# %# "

( ##&

B 9 ( - .&( & / 4 8&G ( ( - " #&9(# #%#4 #8&(( ( 8&#.#-% / &#*1 .#)( "0#- ## :( // (:(#

2 - %%&& &/#% 8# "

= - % 8* )" 9(# . ##

? *" %%# )" 9(#8* & "/#% B= B

2 48% .##

@ 2

=#&" " % # ## #*.&#4? # ( "##8* )" 9(# # %%#%# #4*/ %%&& &.&(#:(# # "

<( <( # & % ; &&" #( # -&/ .&9(#7/ # %%&& .&9(# .:(# <( .&* # &"&* <( 4 8* ## " %#(#%##8 -4%& & -/ #4* * (&.& */# / ##

@ 2

=%8* )" 9(#? 4# )" 9(# #&" 4 ## #*.&#4 (

# :(# (% .& 9(# / # ; 7

"="%'("$'"'& "+)"$%8)')8)"'#$B"$'(&)%4"%&0%,8)"2 8 & 9(#

#:(# / # # %(8&*- #%# 4 8* %%&& -

%(#( # (8* )" 9(# /#%

= /#:.## B @

? %%&& . && "&"&*#.&* ##8*/* %# (7 ./ 4#-7 4*& ( 8&8%#(/ (84

= 48*( & # %%&& 9(# .44 ### 4( &%#.#*8* /# "(=" %%&&

.(# #% #(&- " (=#

#4 ./ / 8 ( # 8 #- " 4#- %%& & # "&*4&. " %# 8# #/

G ##%#8&