← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/4333/2019dismissed

Ganga Ram And Another v. State Of Haryana And Others

2022-12-20Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal15 pages

   !"# $# %& '(  " '

!  

 )* +,

,

,  ' --*

,

,

!./ ,,0011 23 4 5 ,,0 "* 6&7 ,%#4

" 

784 $7  

   

    

 

784 $79%1 

  

     !  

# $  %  & #$&'



   () ) %  &

(&'

    "  %    *  !'

+ 

  

   

 - .

/ ,  

%  &

&'

!!

 

/ ,  $

 %  & /$&'



#$   ! 

 

     2!

 "   

" 

!! 

  

  "

2   4 

 56 57 35 



    

) 5.

! 

  

) .

!

    !

 9

    "

0234  3 35 4 

 .

   35 51 35 (   57 /$  

) 5.

! 

   

    

50

) 5.

!

   

# -055555:2   

 

" 56 5 #$ 

 

) 5.

!



 

;

# 0557-..:2 

0 58 35 #$ 

    !    # 0557-..:2   

    

  



4  !  

/$  





     





    #$   !

   "

 9  !!     

 !

!  

/$  

 !

!

:

  

 <     !

 (  <  ="

 +  $! > !     

 

 0

 "

 !" 

  $!

)



 

   

 

?



2$ @  !> / !> 4   /

 

   !

 "

 !

 

  # 355555:2 ,



   $ # 

  

(  !

  !

/$   "

,  ! 

  

    

@  

   

>! 

  %#A2-888235 1'2 

   3    8 B    4! 4+ C #

-   ! #  $ ) 6  

#! 4   ) D /   / 3 3 @  !

 

  !   

  "

 !     - 3 *  !2 ?> -: /     ?> -:

/     ?> .:

#

  50 35 ?> .:7 /    

 3 8 C  





(  !

>! # 2    /$ B" ?

 !

3 - @  !

 

  !

   

(  !2 ?> #- )2* 3 6 @ "

 

    

  ! %#A2-888235 1'2 ?> 

?> -   ?> 6 $

*  !  /     ! <  

   ?> .

?>    ?>  := 

<!" 3 .

@  

   

>! 

 %#A2 8.123535'2  :    3: D / 3 7 @  !

 

  !   

  "

 !     - 3 *  !2 ?>  :     ?> 3:     ?> .:    #!

3 0

(  !

  

  !

   "

 !     - 3 *  !2

+ ?> #- +   

,

      

&



   

#$   !

$      80 %?>  :$'   



   

"

"  

#$      ?> 3:= 

"

"   "   





  



(  !

 >

   





+ #$   #$&   ?> 

 !  

# $  

 !  ;

1E  !

  



!   

 56 57 35 ;

# 07 57 -..:2 

@  

  #$     

 "  

   !"





+ #$  

    ?> 6  

 

#$   

  

*  !



  !  "# $%&' () *'% $%&'"' ('!

'" ('+(''%)%&'+ (%'

+ "  

     

    "

   ")   ,   " " 

: - 3      

"    !    

 2  4  

  ?>"    4 +    #   # (

  4103;51< ?> 6:

?> .:8

5 56 51 35

-D2

 3703.076:2 6855555:2    ?> 6:3

1.1 51 5 8 31D2 - 70087655:2 3 386.15:2    ?> 6:8

175 51 5 8 31D2 - 70087655:2 3 386.15:2    ?> 6:-

160 51 5 D2 1 831 555:2

865 680:2    ?> 6:6

161 51 5 D2 1 831 555:2

865 680:2    .

?> 6:.

1.3 51 5 8 8D2 0 .60 655:2

86556 8:2    ?> 6:7 3530 33 5 D2 1 831 555:2

865 680:2    ?> 6:0

53 35 8 8 D2  7 058 36:2 0655555:2    ?> 6:1

53 35 8 36D2 . 61..3655:2 0655555:2   

?> 6:

53 35 8 87D2 7 07630 36:2 0655555:2    ?> 6:

-6 3 53 35 8 8 D2  7 058 36:2 0655555:2   

?> 6:

53 56 35 3 CD26

 

555555:2 833....7:2  

?> 6:

53 56 35 3 5D26 6

.6 , F

 

355555:2 86355555:2 

?> 6:

33 56 35 3 5D27 3585555:2 -.-55555:2 

?> 6:

-15

6 5. 35 3 5D28 6  0.3655:2 81-3067:2 

.

?> 6:

.

.-1 51 57 35 3 5D2 1  38.5555:2

1078.0-:2 

?> .:3

3 50 35

-D2- 6376555:2

55-7.

1:2   

?> .:-

5 56 35 3 -D20 0 666-555:2

5557357:2   

?> .:6 3-.

5 56 35 3 -D2 6

653 61-7655:2 1116710:2

   ?> .:.

36 51 35 3 1D2-

3.65555:2  555555:2   

?> 

3. 56 355.

30D2 8 8-53 076:2 1655555:2

   ?> 3 .

3. 56 355.

6D2 .

07.3655:2 1655555:2

   ?> 8 .73 50 5. 355.

3D2 . 6 886-755:2 1655586:2

  

= 3- ?> - 6631 56 355.

36D20 85 .3655:2 1655555:2

   ?> .

3 5 0D25 65555555:2 65555555:2  3.

?> 7

3. 56 355.

0D28 1.70 36:2 1655555:2

   ?> 0 66.

31 56 355.

-D2- -107655:2 1655555:2

   ?> 1

5-6 3 57 355.

-5D25 -1655555:2 11555555:2    ?> 

3..8 50 5 13D27

. . 3655:

-555555:2   

4103;54 ?> #

5 35

1D27 3-55555:2 3568-7.:2

   83 ?> #3 8563 31 58 35 3 -555555:2 3555555:2

   88 ?> #8 3516 3

-5D2-

5565555:2 3555555:2

   4103;51<   ?>"        #   # (

 --5555:2 6-0 83-.:2   ?>  :$ 50 5- 35 :

D2 8    

?> 3:= 6.

0 53 35 8 3D2328 5555555 8771687-:2  

4103;54 ?> #26

..1 3 35

D2 1 6176555:2 -555555:2   - 8 C  

  



"!  , "% )& ! %&'( %#A  1'

  $   

  ;

# 3 88 835:2 



 "  ! ! 

- - C  

   

(  !

 #$    

(  !&    





   #$&   

 

     ?> .:3 %"  -'

 " >

  

>  

!   





- 6 + $   

9  !

       "

   ,       !  #$  !!  

  

 



  >

2  *

% $

*+' %  - (!'!.#

(% %% .'"

-'( %&   %&'  *

%  - (!'!  .#  %&' 

""'

% ( 

 

            

       

    

 

        

  

 

 



 - .

C 

       ":" )                

  !  

/$

+  

      *  !   " & !,  $! ! %&'(/011234

562 - 7 #$   !!   >

   

     

!    !







- 0  

         !  

$  >   

"  

  ! "  , 

    

@   !  !

  

  "   "   > " !



  !  !

 

 





 > "

!



    

   

 , 

 

 "

>    !!      "



"

 ! 

  

  "  

 ! !

#$  

 

  4 2< 

 

C 

 

*  !   "% )&7 '/ +( 3  

  

  4 2 < 

 

 "

  !!  - 1 C 



 .

  

   ! #  3-670

. 

 

 

! #  38 @  

 



   () )  !

/ %  &

(/'

  

  

C 

"

 !      ?> 6:3 6:

.:.

 

 

 



  56 57 35

 ?> 6:

3 6:

8 6:

- 6:

6 6::

.

   

!



  ?> :.

%"  366



3 5 3'

 



  ?> 

?> - ?> :7 ?> 

    >!

.

 " 56 57 35

 #$  

      !  , !

C 



 .



   ?> #:-   

    ?> #3  "  8563 % 31 58 35 3'

?> #8  "  3516 %

'

  

"



 

 ! 

 

! #  6

 ?> #:3 ?> #:8   ! 

! #  6

C

   ?> #    

       ?> #:3 ?> #:8  

"



  ?> 6:

%"  015'

 



! #  88   

! 

  ?> .:3 %"  -'

 

! #  87   ?> .:8 %"  5' 

    #  88 ! 

 ?> .:- %"  363'

  

 # 

8  ?> .:6 %"  3-.'

 

! #    "* ! 

C 

?> #:-

    

 

   

  ?> #:3 ?> #:8  

"



  !"



  ! 

  8563 % 31 58 35 3'

%?> #:3'

8G

! "  





   ?> #:3 ?> #:8 # 3555555:2 

 / ,  $

  

 # -055555:2

   

"

@

 

! #  38

@ !  

 



 &# &   ! 

 

C 

  

     "  80 ?>  :$   



   

    

 ?> 3:= "  3 6.

 

! #  6. 

  #  38

  "  3 6.

%?> 3:='

 !"

(  !

    "  ..1 %?> #:6'

 

D



    

 

   # -555555:2 

C 

   

    #$   

 ?>  :$ #$&   "% )&,% %' $ (#  8 

3 35 + *  !  !

    !





 

8 56 35

@ !

"    ,  "% )&   !"# $% % &'

   $    

     !





 

8 56 35 ;

# 3 88835:2 

  

  

 

4 2<  #

+ !) 



  !

 

8 56 35 57 57 35

@ 

>! ?> #:-

H/I 

  



"

   

 

4 2<   A!

 



  

 "       

,  !  

/ ,  $

 ,     

@ "   !

  

 "



 

$, 

 #$&    56 5

0 58 35  

  

(/:

  



 





 ! 6 3

 !

       

'/;9



784 $7  %#'!

( ) *+   ,+# (   ,+# 4,

, " ,  4

, 



 # 4 C+ ?# (: ++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?# #A2 5023535 D#+# @

4 C+ ?# (: ++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?# #A2 8-23535 : BD $#A+ /+4 + #CB

@+ 4@#?$+C# (: ++?

CA

#F 4 C# #A2 6682353

++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?# (: C  @

4 C# #A2 6752353

++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?# (: #??+ @

4 C+ ?# .

#A2 6052353

++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?# (: D@  // 4 C+ ?# #A2 60-2353

++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?# (: #=@/

C?/ 4 C+ ?# #A2 6132353

++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?# (: B#< DB# ;

#<B 4 C+ ?# #A2 .552353

++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?# (:  @ DB# <@ 4 C+ ?#

#A28.123535  @ DB# <@ (: ++?

CA

#F 4 C# #A281 23535 =/ # 4 C+ ?# (: ++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?#

#A281323535

#@ # 4 C+ ?# (: ++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?#

#A281823535 #C +

(: ++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?#

#A2-5823535 < =@# 4 C+ ?# (: ++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?#



#A2-5-23535

#@ # 4 C+ ?# (: ++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?#

.

#A2-5.23535 BD =@# 4 C+ ?# (: ++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?#

#A2-8723535 D# @

4 C+ ?# (: ++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?#

#A2-8023535 #++@ # 4 C+ ?# (: ++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?#

#A2--523535 B @/ 4 C+ ?# (: ++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?# #A208.23533 ++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?# (:

F@ # 4 C+ ?#

#A208723533 ++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?# (: C  @

4 C+ ?# #A208023533 ++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?# (:

#@ # 4 C+ ?# #A208123533 ++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?# (: : 

/C++?# (+ /+4 4 C+ ?# 3- #A20-523533 ++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?# (: + B @/ 4 C+ ?# #A2023533 ++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?# (:

#@ # 4 C+ ?# 3.

#A20-323533 ++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?# (: < =@# 4 C+ ?# #A20-823533 ++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?# (:  @( D#@  D@# /C @+@$ (+ /+4 4 #

#A20--23533 ++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?# (: #C +

@

4 C+ ?# #A20-623533 ++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?# (: BD =@# 4 C# #A20-.23533 ++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?# (: + ??/@ ;

??/ 4 C+ ?#

#A20-723533 ++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?# (: #++@ # 4 C+ ?# #A20-023533 ++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?# (: =/ # 4 C+ ?# #A20-123533 ++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?# (: D# @

4 C+ ?# 8- #A206523533 ++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?# (: D#+# @

4 C+ ?#

+ #A206 23533 ++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?# (:

 # 4 C+ ?# 8.

#A206323533 ++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?# (:  CC/+@ 4 C+ ?# #A206823533 ++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?# (: : BD $#A+ /+4 + # @+ 4@#?$+C# 4 C+ ?# #A2 -57235 #??+ @

(: ++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?# #A2 -50235 B#< DB# ;

#<B (: ++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?# -5 #A2 .3.235 D@  // (: ++?

CA

#F 4 C+ ?#

#A285

 @( D#@  D@# /C @+@$ (+ /+4 + # @+ B+ C#@?4 #?#??++@(?

(: ++?

CA

#F 4 C# -3 #A28563235 #=@/

C?/ (: ++?

CA

#F 4 C# -8 #A28..8235 + ??/@ ;

??/ 4 # (: ++?

CA

#F 4 C# 

784 $7  %#'!