← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/48780/2022dismissed

Sangeeta Kumar v. State Of Punjab

2023-03-20Mr. Justice Ashok Kumar Verma14 pages



  

   !"!#!

$!!! !#!

  

     

  

  

 !"

    #$

% & '

  (   ) )

   * &+,+

    #$

% & '

  (   )--

   !

!

.

&     #$

% & '

  (   )-/

   + +.

&     #$

% & '

  ( 

!%  &"'%

( !( )) %!

* %!



0 1 "2

+3  1 4 +  & +( 31    " + 31 % +(     22 +(   

 .

( 2  +531 1 3 & '

% +(  



( 31 % +"(2

!( )) %!

* %!

4 / 7+422(% + '"  (     + "+    % +"" 89 7+  (     +   %2  +  (  (     

   % + %" 23/- % %

( :'

2  +"  89;

)  

        / ,% +9   23/ < 2

 ;

, 30  2""  .

+ 7+ ' 894    +'

%4  "(2   "'% +"" %23. + ':

"(2 

+2  5:

2  22   +  +    (    %  $  !

.

9   2  +%" 2  $ 2 1'  : '

=  !

!

.

&3+ "

3 + +.

&3

 0 3 

 !"

30   * &+,+

30 %$ *"

 >     9    ?   *>9?  +  +  (       +"(2 @%"   +  +%" 2  "

%     %  1         %  +  ((  +:     "

 2   "

%   +"

 23 +:4   9   2 2 '

 1% (+   + 4"

 2 +:422 "

= +( :"   + (   +    

 ': +"3 +"(2 @%"((2 4"

 2  + %"

9   22:3%    % % +"(2 3 +:"

= ( :"   "  + %  +:  (+   4"

 2 2 '

   =( % 3 +:4   " ="

( :"  (" ( : +"

   "  % 4  A+ +  2 "      ++       )33/ )$3  + "(2 = +" 2  +   +  + 2 '2 :3 +: +B%%%    = + "(2  +  +  +B      %  ( :"    + (    +'

=' 4+  + +B4(   +'

= + "4 +  7+ % 3 +"(2

= +"( 2: 2  + 4++ +(        +   +"(2

 ?   2% +(   +   +  + (   + ' % 22:"(2   +(   122 + (      4+20 $

 0 $>"(2:% +%"$*>9?

   

 !"

 + +.

& 4  2 :  (       (     2 :$2B  (      

  !"

  4   4 2: "     0     +  89     !

!

 .

&  +      %"  + "( :  / 3+43' % +%+ +.

&&3

0 3+4     : , =1 %$*>9?   %  "        4   +      +3     * &+  ,+

 4       

    +    %

(     / 1%  " 3+4 %%  2 :

 $*>9?   + 2  %4   (  +"3 ++"2%2+2 "'%;?702+ 7+ ' 3

 3    + 2%%% 2?B  7+ (   +  2 (        % +"( :

7+  (     +       :  %  +  +B      + "(2 C%"

, %   - 4      ' 4  +(   7+( :" 4"

':$*>9?%" "  "  +"(2 @%"

*43  "  +%  3 +'  "

%      %$*>9?

%% 22 (% 2%'   'B   " 2" 

) ?   2% +(   + % +'"  +  2 :( 4 2   

  $*>9?'% ;?73;402+'%   % +( 89  ) 

/( ':;?73;402+3 22 +0 % + "( :4(   + (  % +"( :4

=    ':    #=   5( 3  4+  4   ((     9 "

2   %   "    (     /  %  + 9 2 :    , =( :  3  /<  4   224    ('2

 " 4  2"

 22 ( %  2 %$ *>9? '"  +2 " # / )

/3?B    ((     %+  " "        )  %  + 9 2 : , =( :3 /<""  9   %%2

2 "3 +"(2    9( 

  $*>9?

'%;?73+  +4++4 4 +4':+" 

) 

 7+  "(2  +   2  %2       '  ; ;17$)<$ / ;17$

/$ /    / % + ;  '29  " 1 3/

/'% +( 894++  (  '% +"(    .

+   +3 +( 89 '%(%2 4   %'2&( :  " 22 4% "%%  7+(     : 422   &  +      +  2     B +     9  ((  %  +  '" 3  2     2  %  + (   + (2 2 (  +&" ( ':* @'2

("   



   

! ""#

$ %&#$% "

  ''(  ) *  +,+  ), # %*  - '   .   "  )    

* /""0 1 "

/"



2"!"  "

 '

3)4*+,+), # %*

' # "56#

"5



 "

  7-(

&. %$%   "

  85"#   "

    3734''7 &%

+"1+

 %

!

+ "

 '33)3*+,+), # %*7'

<   32  

 2+ (( +( (     "%(2:%2': +

 '"  +  + (   + ""  % 4 + +"(2 % +

" % )33/ )$ 8 ++    % + 



%:% " 3 +  2   % +(     :

7+%3 +( (   "

:'" ?     2  %  +  "(2  '"   +  + (   + "" +  4 + +"(2 @%"

2    +     +  "(2

    !

!

 .

&    +  :% ++B%  ;43+  2 " + +    :"

  4 + +"( : + 2  +0  % +"( :

 +89  +"2 %% +  2 :

'  

   !

!

.

& + +.

&  <"(2   3  '

2 '24  %  + ' 

   +"

0  +(  :% +(     / % +;

1 3(     <  % +9 '2  + 9 (( %+ " 32   2% + "(2 + (2 2 (  +&" %* @'2 ("  (  

9 :"

9" 

%



8

 "

$+ '3 , ?   2% +"(2 % +'"  +

+" "(    +:  /4+  +%%  2   +(0"'3 /- 0"'3 7+%3 + (     2 " :+ %" +" "

9 (( % + " 32   2% +"(2 + (2 2  (  +&" %* @'2 (" (  :"8  "

:;

""< "

$/1  ) '

3* ,,

7= 

<! 

+#! " '37)3(*,, -



- 9  +   +   2     2 %  +  (       ++ +2  / 1( +(  3   22:3 (   !

!

.

&3 + "

3  + +  .

&3  

   0 3 

  !"

3 0  * &+,+

30 %$*>9?   + %  % +"(2 @%"':( :  +%" "  " A+ +  2 "      ++       )33/ )$3  + "(2 = +" 2  +   +  + 2 '2 :3 +(   +  +B%%%  

 = +"(2  +  ++B %( :"  +(   '

=' 4+  + +B4(   +'

= + "4 +  A+  +"(2 @%"

%2  "(2          /  %  +  ;

 1 

   + (   3 +(   %"  +"(2  +  +:+2

=  +  "(2    '

=    +:  422  "

=  +  ( :"   <

 +: "+B  +"(2 4++4 2   +     +  (     +  '

=  A+  + "(2 = +(   ( 2: "

= +( :" 3 + (       +   +"(2

7+ % 3 + "(2  "

 "(2   '% +""  % 23 .

+ 4++4  B ':1 "" %2 0  3""  .

+    +'

% B:

(  +(  %0 ? 24  =   +  +( 89  

   +(    0  +    3  

,

    /% +  4   +(    &  B:'  +(     &  + B: > 23   

  !"

    * &+  ,+

 +   %2  (     '  ;  //

   /<

3  ( 2:3  % B + % +894++4"': + 7+  %" %   4"

 24 + )33/ ) $  "

= +( :" 4 +    + %  +"(2 @%"

//

%   + " "

':2   2% + (      +( 89 '%(%2 4   %'2&( : " 22 4% "%%    3* @'2 ("     

9  :"

9" 

%>  

 ) .*3  4+2   2   4 +  +  B   4+ + (  %%%     / % +;91  %%      <3 %9 '  "2 2:

 

  " %%  3'    

 

 

  



   

      

     !    " # $               %&'(%& )   

% *$        

       

     

     +  

+     ")      *$          

 ,

   

   %& *$   

 

 

     

     

#      +



   # # 

 

      



   ))  +  +      

    *$        

            !

    

#

 



,    +  

     *$,      

  

  #   ")  

   *$        ,      #   

   #     

    ,  +       

       - /

8" + % 

2:%2 4  +'& 3 2 + %%     / % +;91      %9

   %" + +'   % + 4%%   %%  A+2     (         /  %  ;9  1 3 % 2 +       + "% %+B   '('   (       %93+       "(      '  '2+  8  ( %%     / %;91 3 +  ' '2+ +  + +B  +   '    ':  +      +    2 22:

 % '2' 2 '2 :  + "+ ' + %  %% :%%   ( ( %  :  % "

3 + + % 2 ( : + " %+B4 +  +  (2  " 9  2:4+  % 2 "

= +( :" 4 +  + (2  "( ( %  %"

 +  + %%     / %;91 "

 

    9 + %(  % ++      %93 +      '(': +(  *43 +  ' (':(   +  +: (    + "%



 % ++B': + 3++  +     7+3%%      %9"

   + "%  % ++B 2%4++   + 4 +%%  

  / %;91 7+%3 + 4%%     %"

+ +  +( (2%'2&( :2% ((2  " (2 :

/ %   + " "

':2   2% + (      2 :(  2 :   

  +"( :4++D  + +2 " 22 '2 :% + (     3* @'2 ("  :"8> 

) .*4+2 2 4 + + "B  '    %    .  

    )

#    



   %/ 0/0

      #      .      # )   )      

           #       



    

        

   

  !  #  

   )#   2 

  2  )               

  

                      

#  

      

  )    

 #     

     

 #   

) )  

)

           .

/ 0 





             .   3$4#  

1    

  

)       

 

    #   1     

 % 5 

   .  

#



 ,       ./ 0 2  )     #   







                    

)  

  )   

   

        -          .  / 0 

 

   

    # #  

6-,   

     

     $*$   

   # # 

         

     ##     

2   



##    ./ 0  

  

-    ./ 0) 

           /0 $*$ )   ## )   )

!

    ./ 0)    

    # 

   ) 

1  7 

   ./ 0    

        



     

  



  

  

  

       

         8

  



 #) 

  ) 

         )       )#   #   !  # 

      + 

   %

6 1    -         ./ 0      

 #

.



 #            

    # # 

     + .   

 #  





        

( %    # 

   #  

   !

     %/ 0 3$#

    !

     .)  ) )       

 #  

     #

 

          

     ) #     111 111 %9   

  )    # 

    , 

 #       



#    # :    )  



 )    

 ) 

          

   

 )       

    2              

)

  )  

  )     

   

,

;1     

2  

       

 

#

 

  



,    

  )

 )        

,  

)    

  )   

  +      

        

## 

      +

  

   ) )   

                       +     )   

   ) <   #   #         

          

)   +



  2   #   

    #   

 ) 

  +    #   )      2

    )   9        # 2 # 

   !

 

       )#  

        

  - / 9  4  %  '3      2   +   (  %  + 9 2 :    , =( :    '

  +       %  + 2$" 2(    

   +( '   0  %% 2 ,: +" " 2: +( '    +"( :(    (   

  2 " 22 '2 :  2 '2  +  : +( 4+ + ""  " 2 7+ $    ( %" +( 22 '2 :    / % +;91 ':  2  % +"( :

A+ 23 2: +"( :3  +( 2( 22 '2 :% +     //%



+;91 /) 8 +"3     22    +(  8 ++    % +  %:%+

" 3  2   % +(     :

9   2((  %2 4 + (4D '2     % +  "4+ D   : +     ' D D(  2  7+* C'2 ("  

 $ %"#)3--(*(,,37(+2    '  =                 $3  

    

#  +



 .



 +   #  ) )

 ) 

    %

 $         

#  

     #    

 #  

  

  ) )  



   

# ) 

  

 

    2)        )

 



  

  .     #    

#

> 

 

#    )      , # 

    

#  # )  # 

  #!



   . #







 

 #    

  

    , $        

    ) 



        

       



)  2  

 #  ) 

 

  - /< 7+%   " % +&" 2( ':2   2% +(    B   + '2%" + %  % +(  ' : +  4 (2 %  

"  7+%3 ' % % + "34+ 3



'   +(    / *     +  2 :%%   " % +  %"  3 % " B +  3 % "



   +(   3(24 + +%   + +

" %" : 2  + ' 4 + ""  ( +" % + 39  %   %  % % ( :

'

2  +(    /

1 2:3 22 +(    +':" /-  1((2  (    22(   3% :3+  (%  2:

   -!( )) %!

* %!/ 2

  # A+ +( = $  

E$; A+ +( '2

E$;