High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/105/2013allowed

Delhi Punjab Goods Carrier Pvt v. National Insurance Company Ltd And ORS

2019-02-13Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan9 pages

!"#$%&&& '

((

)&! * +!&%,(-. &

( &

& !/ 0&'1

* "0' &((

& '&&&0' &&(

3& -0&( !"#$%&&& ' . &!4 44&&5 $!&(4 !4* +!&% .

6 7' 4&/ &74&'&- 0809 ,! #- !&'-&

85 :080;< 9&=:>(&!,&, 8

5 <0 90!,4! ( ! &!41( 9 98!4!08#+!&%'&** < ;< 8!#-* 0( 0( ( !# $%&&&4#!#74 4(!# &(&4,&,( &?

( ,(-41 & &. "

"@&(&0!&?9 98!4!080&1& !& $!"&01!,44 -4 41( !&A 0 089? ,!1(-# #-( &('(&? 7411!

-!&1* & 009&(!&(& '( - * < ;< 8?( ((&,!,

0<9 8( -1' &,8 8

?,(-((!&'-& @ 01!,! :080;< 9&,&(& 801'& ,(-&(! ,( ,(- # &(& !#, #- " $!(0 %&& !' & ;

&4( !

,(-

4 0 (&' #4!(( 041&!

-! 41( 4',( &('(&?( &B!!& ,(-, ,'& ,#!0!0 ( #&!4!B!

0 ((& 1& ,4!&4(& ,&-#" !1#&"&&-(& , ( 1' ,&0 #

B! ! ((& !# 1 &4& & 4!? 1& & '4 &!4 '4&?! ,0#

,* 0:

1&(&'#-( 0!&#(&!, 7 #4!? & 4' &(& '4&&4&4#

#47'#(!#- ( ?* 1 #& & &(! ,0 &4

# ( -?&(&!&'-& @ # #'!'! ?&(&'4&1 &'#-* 11,!,#& 4&94A

(&!

&1& 7?&( -< !#,#-( 1

8 ,'?(&!&@&'&-%,,C 4! 0 ,-&(,# !,0

# !& !& ( - & &1A -##- + 1( ,(-,,( &(' (& !4 &,4 &0 (&-&, !

@ ( &( &'&4

41&,1&&&4'&, (

( 4(&0

14!1& &, D&( &'&-!,! (&-&E

D&!,# (&&,E

D& ,( ' & 1!

D& ! ( #&"& &-(&E

3(& '&(& ,

!&4!&'0( A, @ D0

3"" D $!&(40

44&& D

&0A, 6(

' )&,0 4& D " $!(0 !&'-& .&D

&&4 &! &(&0&

%!&!* '!&( 4 0!* 4'!& ( 0!* 84'!& ( !

-!( 1&&&'&- 08091&=>(&!,&, , #-!&'-& 8

&!!&&=;>(&!,&,&

! & F& ,!#! @ 1#-& %!&'"!4,& ;

1&44&'#-"!4, &- (( #&%!&& /!40/ &01'"!4, &: :

(((

*11!&( 44&' 77&%!&#-1- 4(& &4!

&(( 011!&(0 1((&&!4!

+'& &! &(&#44

; &!4&&

.&! &((

&4!& !&'-&((#-, '' 41( 0&&!(' &(& !,4! :080;< 901'&1!- &"!0((&!&'-&0 11&4&#&&-,&&(&,#

1&&411!&( -7#- ( !

#&(!&! 7& +!((& !0&&&!&-

" 1& 1 #&'!4!&&(&#&,((4& &!&'-&&&, 01'&0((4 !&'-&&&4 &,&(& !&& ,(&,# ? !&& ((!&'-&,&!&,!(- 4 &- & & (4 &(& & !&'-& (( !&'-& !&& &,& !4'#7 &#4&!&!& ,(-(( &!&'-&&!4&!&'- +1!&&#&' !4((&(&(&!&'-&

< 1!&&01'&0&(&(&(&401 !(( ,#-&&&&

,'0 !&,(-&"&(&!&'-& %!&&&&!,&' -&"&#&&- #(# &

&0 &! &&( ,1,& 0(& (&!&4! 0!&'-&1((01 B!&,&4!#

! '& !#

1&7&4&!

4&(! ( -0!0G&((

%!&&4 -, !( #-(4(( 41&4"!4, (#-& %!&

&&4&' 0+&1 "! & !& ,(- & &(& !#, #- & !&'-& (( #- @ !, ( '47!&( -(! @& !&'-& @ ' 41 ( ,(-& &. " !

"@&(&0!&!

4! :080;< 9! 0 1,41&&,4#! @& 4&&1!!&'-&'1 ( ,(-!#, &(& *41

: #&!4&&1,#74 !&'-&&

4 -!#,41&4&(& G 1&'4&411&4( 1& &0'&( ,!#!&

#!#-&0&1(# -, 4#4&#-!&&-&(& # ,,(#! 4410&!

, #- !& "! 4 ,( , 4 - ! 7 -1&1& &1 & ', !&4 - @ !&'-&(( (&&,4!#

'1 4,##71( &&& @& ,-#,&,4& (&4&#!!

(# -&,4&!&&(! ,(

@&1&# '&(&&!&'-& (4&(&!&'-&4( &! @"!4,(#-& %!&1

& #!((&(&((& ((&'&& &(& 1 D& "!4, ( #- & &/!40/ &!(4"!4,&( #- & %!& 7 ! &40 && 14 (( "! , @"!4,&(#-

&&/!40/ &&!# ,&

01&"!4,&(#-& %!&& &&#-1-((( 1

3&"

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#