← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/47378/2022allowed

Shubham Alias Shubham Saini v. State Of Haryana

2022-11-29Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary14 pages

         



 



!

"#

$

$

 %&!

!

"#

'$

$

( )( ( (

* +&+&"#

,

-

(   

*

."#!

#+



/) $ (  

#+  



        

 

    $

$

  

   ! 



"    #$ "%"  &

 

' ( 

'  )* +,,-   ./#/, '

     ,$$  *%"  %

   "

  0

     1  (  

' 

 





 -/, 

'

'   /#/$/,  %

      .#/,    

 !

"

"

13   4   5  "

5 !!     1

 &

 

  

  1   

  1  '   

    

 

'    '

  " ,. %

 " (          1

1   &



'  '(  



'   6 

 3      &     1 

  

 (     &

 





    &

&

*1     78/%           

(

' 9      "

 

     & 

1     '

')*

( 

'&    

 -#/, 2 

 '

    

      ,7 "%" 1   

     -/, 1       "   

'  /#$/,

((((

$

0          

 '  1

  18         9    1   

'      :

; <6

       '

' )*   (   *3   

'!&

  '& 1

      

 5  /   

    1

 1 

  7-/ 3 '

 

 

     /#/$/ 1   1 1

&     =  $./   (  1   &    1    

          

   

    

    )*

(      

 1      1    '

 %  =

      1   &   ,/,//    

6%-*  & 



 1

  

 &     '&     &   !&

  &!     

 

    

1

 1   " ,. 

   2 

  '

          -#/,  

&    '  

'  

 #    

    1  

  

 1    

 1

         

  '1

' *  

)*

(  

1   &1 -8//%98//   

'

'  1  &   "   ,///       1        1    (     1  !   ,9/./

  1   ! ,9// 

   

' 

>         )*     

'   ,$$*%"   

 

     

)*  1

        '        

            

  ?' 

 "=@*2,. &  '

' 

   &

      

    -/#/,   

 '

   

1 

  

   1       ,.9:,;"%" 

'

    

'  ,7,$$*%"  & 1 

  & &

    1

1   

 



*          )* 1  ' 1

 

    /-/,  ,7"%"1  

3  

'&

     1  &



   

      ,7 "%"   /-/, 1   

"  '1    

 /./7/,& 2 

 '

  

'

/-)*'



      '

    

   &  '

  /./7/,



  +9 1

&          &  &  

   %

   +#9- $/-/,



)*     '  &

 1    &  

   

' 

   )     -

&   & 2 

 '

 

&

'     (     ,.9:,; "%"  -/ 2   '   //91       '

     ,$$    *

 %  "   2   '    '



 *   6   &  '

 &  2 

  '

           1  &

'  &

   &   

1

 1    

        (    ,.9:,;"%"     

  &

' /./7/,      

'   /-/,         



 '  1

'

 &  1



'     

     /-)* & 



   '

   '



'



& 1    & 

 '

 

  

  '

     

 %

 $/-/,1

'

   1

'   1      

   

'  /-/,  

   2 

  '

    /./7/,           &(  

      

' 

 1  6

 '       " 

 

 

 1

 

' 

' '

          /#/$/,:

6%#;&    

  

           1     

        ,$$ *%" 1    '

 

 1



'   

     ,.9 :,;    1   

    

  2 

 '

 =  )*

   & '  &

 &     " 

    (      

   &    &     1

  '

    

'

1  

!



3&

&   

 &

 !'  

$ -#&3..3#

3#!

"+4

, $ (+3+

"5 36&7 3!-

( 2:&;3# <-63

$

:

(+3+

"5 -#=3> 3#!

"+4

 //$ "" = 

 ##, (;

+3  +3+

 +$

)+!$

$ (+3+

"5 3?3#3 3#!

"+4

/,9 "" = 

 -9$/

3#3#!436 3#!

"+4

, $ (+3+

3#!

3#"+4  /,$ "" = 

,-.$ "43# <-@

=3 , $ (+3+  :

+"32; /,. "" = 

 )

(4;

3#!

"+4

, $ (+3+

"5 3433 4+3//"" 

.9. 9 0    &  

  

3#3#!436

3#!

"+4

: ;     

 "    )*

 & '

    ,$$     

'

' 1

&   ,.9:,;"%" -

 & 

!'  2

"

"43# <-@

=3 : ; 1   

    ,.9:,; " %"     

 &     



  :; "%"1   



 1 &   

    ,.9:,; "%"           :;  " %"     

'

  '1

'   & 

       

  ,.9:,;"%" *

 &  

! 

' )*   

'   ,7"%"

  



       ,$$ *%"     '

      ! 

  '

  3  



'

    &   7

 !'   &

"

 ) (4;

3#!

"+4

: ;1

 1 '

  

 

   ,.9:,;"%"

$ =

            &  1           2  

   %

   1

 &       2 )





& 

   1 

         "=@*2,. ' 

  & 

 '

  1

    1

      -8//%98//* &   &    )*   ./#/,  &  '

  1

  &   

' '

 

     &  &    '

   /#/$/,3     91 

 & 6

 *

 &          '1  

 1  

' 



( & 

 '



     3 )*

& '  &  

   .       

,/ 

         ,$$*%" ,.9"%"1

  8 B,$$2 &   ' & &

 C4   1

 &

  ' &  &

  1  1  '  

       &

   



  

1 



  

'   & 

     

  &     

 &

 

!      &



! 

  1    & 

 1          1

6    1 

1

6 1 1 & D  

  &        ' 



                 & 

 1             1

 6    6 1 

1

6    1 &  <6 C*      

      

 &     * 

 1   1

  &   

  &        E ( %+&"#

'2 &# 4

"!

5 &6&#37 "% !-

'

,.9 %        1     &

   '

&

!

   

'   '



  :,;+"   '

 : ;:

; 

   

&     ,7  ,$$ :&

 ;    *

 %  " :#9  ,$-/; :

;

 &         

  :

;

 

 

  6 

1

' &



   &

 1  

   &

D :&;:

; 

   

&  

   1

'  *

% ":#9,$-/;

    ,.  ,.- :&

 ; ,..// /9,,:&

 ; $1 

 ' & 



  



" :

;

  &

 #-

&  #7, #79 #7-  " 1  

   '   &



      '





 

" :

;

 

   

  &  

 

&

 :

;&  :

;6 

1

'    "       "  1

" &

 :;4  

&  &  &

   : ;& :,;

   1

 

    &

     1   

       

 "D   & "    

'   &    

8 %  

 1  &   

" 

 & 

:;*   :&;  &   :,;    F "F  "

  "

"

   &   &   "  %

        &     &  "   

  :#;)   :&;& :,;  " & &&

 "

  

       &       

   " 

   "

 " 1     

      

  " 

' 

 



  ! 

 1

 1    ! 

 

 "

  "

  8%   : ;1        

   "   "

 ! 

 & " 1



" & &&

D :&;1        "

        "

" & &&

 "

  "



' 





 ' & E ,, %      

   '

  

  1  F F   ,$$   *

 %  "  1 &          &

       

 1

' &  ! 

 '

  , *   ) (4;

3#!

"+4

-.39    &

"& B

 1     

&  

 '

  

  ,$$ *

% "&   1  & & %

*1   & B'

   )*    ,$$ *

% "  

 1 

 %

E ,



(;

+3  +3+

 +$ )+!$

$ (+3+

"5

3?3#3 3#!

"+4

/,9""= 

-9$/& 

'  ,$$*%"

  &

  

1

'&

&

  & 

 &      ,7 " ,#

""

 ' 

.- 3 4&?3

$ (+3+

"5 43++& A344 % :";+,///   8 B >&

"  

 '

  )*          ,$$  *

 %  "      1& @  &

    '

      ,.9  "

 %  "   1  3  "   &     &        ,$$    *

 %  "

'

A &    A 



 '

)*&  '

  )*1

    

 &    

     ,7:$;    " 1



 & &  ,.9:,;: ; 1   :;    " 3  

 

E

 :; "    

  

  

E ,9 *   &  ,.9"%" 1 1B+"E    6& 

" 

'

       6 

   &

 ,- %

  &  6

     &      ,$$*%" '

A & 

    '

 )*       

 &    

      ,7:$;    "  &  &    ,.9:,;: ;   1 

  B

E  

   :;    " 

 

 

 ,7 

'

'&  '

 '

  

 1 1 & >&3  "

#&7

<-63 $ $<$ &?3..3:/,;,/""7/9

' 3@ -!

(3&?

!

$ (+3+

"5 -=33+ 3#!

"+4

://$;9""--$1

& & B  



&  '

  & 

$         '  '

      

 

  

1 

&

E ,$ *

    &!'  

 

'

   )*1    &&'

 



 1  

3

 2 

 '

    &(  

    

   1 

  '    



& 

/-)*1

1  &   

    

 1         

   %

   1       &(     

             1     &    '

  

   &   

'   

'            &  '   '

  1  

       1   1     & 1

  

'

&  '

       



 ,. 

'  " ,.

&  &

'  

  





 

  

    &     



 '&

 '    1  '

'

1 

  &  

  

 

       '    

 

' & &

 1

 1             

'    '        

    ( &6

    (       1 1  /*   1 

  &      '  ,.9"%"

 & *   



''

 )*     ,$$*%"&

'6



&      

'  &



,

>& 3    "  *

  (+3+

"5

<3#3+3@3

$ )$ -#& ;36?

3#!

"+4

* ,.77 " ,#$.   8 BG #$ +1"1

  9-, ",$.$  8F+

" & 

 

1

" 

  &

  '

 

 

"   &  

" 1         !

F *  6

  

 1

"  (    

     1



'

1&  &    " D !

( 





''

&(  3  

'

"H

 1 &

 

   

    &



   

''

&  '  

1         *  

      &!  &

           

              1 !

"

( 



!

3  !

 



     1  '

 !

 '  &





' 1 & '

   

  

& 

   1            &!  

 

1

"!

&1  

&!  1&  & 

         ! 

E     ,.9:,;   "     

 ' 

   1 & 

 

'

 &

&      E  3

" 

   '  

  &  &

'         



  

' '

  1  



 &  1

 &  &

'  

 3 

   !

 )* ( 

'  &&(    *  1     

       1

 &

"   1        )* ./#/,

&(  

' 

'     &  (   (    

"

6>

'0

8 

  ?'  

   ? 

'8 I?+   &8 I?+