High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1252/2012dismissed

New India Assurance Company Ltd. v. Gulab Devi And Others

2019-10-15Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan7 pages

!"#$%&' %%(( )"! *!(+ , " -% ."

"-/ 0!$"1 "$2, " %%((

4" " "$ %%(2 $ (((&&(5 %%(

6"(& 2 " %"7($1$*!(+ ,1 1!(15 8$ "2 6((!8+" "1!$$"!5 "1!(15 8" 0%(2!"!,$" +"!5 ($ % !" 1 99 " ) ( 5 "% 0!$" 8 ","!$" !"#$%&'!""/%+"5"5" 4-

:: "" """ 5 , ( 2 ($5 $% !-(;

" %" ," %"7($< +!$2 0%(55"$+!6( 0( "!(15 "2 (",((5 5 , (=+5",+&"% 8 0!$" " 5(5$","& 5 %= %5"",((5 /% ; 0!$"8"% ", ((&"!($"+! %&& = /% " "4$%!"2"!;55 "

"!( = "% "," 5 /% " ,"; "!;+! $$"""((&$"$ %%= 0!$" "% ;+"!%!" , /% 5 """((&2 %"20%((( "$ /%"$5 """((&= !""+(5",!/!" %"2 %",( %= +&0!(% "%"= +&0%(;*"(4%(2

"!( " %$"$ >$ != "$( -

<:<" !"1?<: .#"5"5"% 8 0!$" .( 11"2 "!( "5 ($2 0%( ", ,"(1(,("+5!1(,( ;& %(&"= "5-27%"$ +&5,5 5

< ("= (( %" " % !% $ 2+ "%%%"(%" "$5 ($% "$ !+$ +& "% 8 ","!$" 5 , (2 (( " ($%5 ! ;%( /%,(,& ((5"5 $2("$( +5 "5"+& ($5 $((! %( 4,"2"5 $ /%@!!(&!"

"% 8!"$%& "(,$-!5 "$5,"$ ($%2! "%%"&"

$( ($% "$(+&"% !" $%&2 (;!%,"!%"($"&+/

"%$+(&!+"5 ($ % ;,"!!"&!" "5 %" ," -2 5 , ( ,"(

%5"0%( 55 !"+& /% "!;2 55 /% !(& %%(+";$( "2"% %%(& $"5&+";"", ! 5"% 0%(5( $((("$ /%+&$5 "((&2 $5 "$ %% 2 "!((&2 ",/!"= "," /%

(5&,(",5( $$ "5"5 5, "5"%+& !"=!" " /%@!+5%(,( "$ !" %(& (( 5 %", ") (2 ""2"%8!" $%&(+(%&&$%1! "%( %"&"$( ($% !$"""$ %""" @!%%"!(, " "5 "5!$2 " #($

"+!(2 "!( """"" "+!( % ($%,"9:"$% -2A927 " "B%"!$"$ (( "(C $!+%%"$5(( "($ @!((&2 %&+( +& + "%/(& ,"((&

"( !"$%&55", %%" #!"+&&(5 %"%%(%"&5 $+%2 $%!5"+ %%((8 !"$%&++(,(+(&%&$% ($

%%(5,"%+! " "%" "+ ( , "("!(" %%((+55 "!5 ""

"+!( + ,!+& %""5 "!$ $ (! "% ! " +& " 5(5",5 5/%

!5 + ( "%2%( +" %" -2 55! /% $(5(5+! "+!( " %&.D.%%!

0!$"2 (",((5 5, ((5 2 ("(& $2 5 "" 5, ( "% ;+"!%!""", /%! 2 +!((!+! $$2 $ $5"((&! (( !"5",!7(/!" %"2"!((& %

"+!( "5 (&! ,"5,+&.D.%%!

0!$"+"" &1! ,"+&">$ +5,%""," -

-!+, %,(&%!"% "$($ "& $ -(5 !""&$& $! %"(

-+5"5"+& %"2 $&+& $ (&!"5 ,5 %($;+! !(%" "$(2 $$ "$

""2! "5!$,+&("!("

!"$%& ,$! +"5

"+!( (( %/%%", , (!"! +!""&5%5"(!5 5 +52 !"$%&(+(

"+!( %" : ( %("/5 +",5 ,5"!!%5"",((5%",, ( !((( $5 "%"&!(+,"+& !"&%(&!"1:? 2"""5/!5$

!""#

$% & &

('& &

" ) "*+& #!"

""2 &"5" "+!( %

""2 ("!(" !"$%&"/ '" !( " !" $%& !" "

; $%!5" "5"@!!$$% 5 $%" 5 "4,"2 &$" (

"+!("5 $$!$5%",(514"&"!;((";" "$""!+& %!&#$$"2 "!(?2 $ + -:27 %" $

+,"&5%"$ +"5 !!"

""2 $+; 5 "

"+!( !7<" $"%"((,5 >% 1 + ("2 ! !( ,+B6! "+!( & $!"!!"%"%2 ;%5, 5

? !( ,+ >:B

""2 $;&"

$!"!",( -27!"(>%-27!( (("%"((2-27!"(>% -27"(+5"

"+!( "5 (& %%( $!(%(" A

$% (!( -2A927"(& 5 "(("& "!1 ($ ,(&"%%("" +/2 %"%"5"! + $+! "(& "5"!""! "$!

%%($"5(& !"

6"/ #$%&$%''%()*+%,-).%(/0+1 %)-* #$%&$%''%.*'&(23% %)-*