Reliance General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Charanjit Kaur And ORS
!"#$% &' ( ) *&
"+%#"""
+ , #" -./0%-%$"
1.."++$ 2"
, 3 !%$4, $3"
" .
"$ 5* 605 )
5
" "#"- 8"
$3
,93:% "
# ("
"#%9;
! ! "" $%
$ &$ '( ! )( *( # )(" * + ,)*"( "" + -' ./,0% ( # ( ! 1 &,2&$$$3. " # 4 56 ! ! " ! 7 8 " !
$2 &$ 5 """" &
! " " (( # (!
# 9 "" ! # ( +
$%.
&$ 2 ""#! ! ("# % : " " ! ( ( ;+ '&&2&$ ' " ! ( " ((
"! &
& &$&$ " (
< = """" (+ , ( > # ( # < ! ! ( /
# .
( < !! ,
= " ! ( #" )?9 @%3 * # " ! ( ( ( " @%A "# ! # " #=" ( ! " 1
,$$$3. ! 9 ?9 @%3?9 @%3 ?9 @%38 &$ /.
, &$ ,.
5 &$ 5.
' 9 (! #!
(( !"
" 1
,$$$3.! ! (!
#" %$6 /$ " ! # # # ( - >B( 9 $% +
, #" -./0%-%$"
2"
,
/)"$3% $3"
&,6 ( # # (# " " /$.,$ > ( " '
> " #" ! 1
$$$$$3.# 1 &,$$$3. 9# ! ->B(9 + C D & ! (1 '$$$$3.
C < ! 06 !#" #
) :"
, +-,
%& %$"
% , #" -./ 2"
, % ,< 8% .. 2"
, 4 $8 "-"$ %."
#$
/= ) + 2"
- 2 /
>/ ? 3 4 % 3 $3"
2 8,+@ $3"
A# 56 !#
"
(56 06 !
; # " ( .
( 3 ! #" ( = 1
,$$$3. 1 &$$$$3. ! # 4 &,6 ) 1 ,$$$3.* ( !
!
=" 3/! / ( =" 1 % ,$$$$3. 1 &/,'$$$3. ( 1 2017(4) RCR (Civil) 1009 22017 ACJ 2700 32009(3) SCC-473 42009(3) SCC-705 52004(2) PLR-210 6Civil Appeal No. 5256 of 2008 decided on 29.01.2014 7Civil Appeal No. 9858 of 2013 arising out of SLP(C) No.1056 of 2008 decided on 31.10.2013
$ "! 1 &$$$$3. 1 &,$$$3. 91 /$$$$3. +
! # 1 /$$$$3. + & / ! =" ! ( 1 &$,$$$3.# # #59-""
+ , #" -./ 2"
, , - B 3, , - 1
&,$$$3.
(
! ( "! &
& &$&$;+ '&&23&$ ')E *1 A ! C! 1
" ! " = """ " (
!
+ , ! # ( #"
< !!
& C ! "8
"# ( / !!# 1 ,$$$3. %$6 ! 3/ ! 9 ! / ! 1
= ! 1 &,$$$3. 9
! ! ("1 &,2&$$$3.
% C ( 3 (! " !@ ( # "1 &$$$$3. ! #"" !#!" !! 1 ,$$$3.F #" ! ! ! < 8SC2018(4) R.C.R.(Civil) 333 : 2018(9) JT 195
/ ; 3 ! !! !( 1 ,$$$3. ! " !F 9! ! 9
,
# (! ! 9 ! 8 " ( ( ( " ! # !" ! ! 1 ,$$$3. > ?9@%3 ( ! ! " ( ! "
" #!8 " ( 9F ! 9 &$ /.
, &$ ,.
5 $ 5.
' ?9 @%3?9@%3 ?9@%381 "!! # ! # 1 ,$$/2,3. /%025'3. 1 5'5$'
3. ! 9 # #" # ( ! !8 " ! 1 ,$$$3.F # 8 " # @"!
( ! #! 9 # ( !# G " B# ( ! #"!
F @.%A "# ! !# ?
F ( 9 # ?9@.%3 ( ! ( (!
( !" !8 " 1 ,$$$3.!
! "! !8 " 1 ,$$$3.!
'
! ! ." !
!" ( B!! 1 &$$$$3. ".#" ( ! (! ( !
"#!!8 "# 1 ,$$$3.
! ( " ! 9 ( ( #" !
! ( " ! ! 8 " # 1 ,$$$3.
?9 @.% @ A " # ( 3 1" > ?" # "
?9@.%3 ( !
! < ! " = ! ! #=3( ;( # ( !! #"!
#=3( ! !
# ( "
! ( ( ! #! 9 # ( !# G " B !! #= < ! #=" . ! ( ! ! "9 !
#9!!! 9 ( ! !! !8 " #" !
! 1 ,$$$3.
8 ( !!# ?
( 9# # !
" ! ( (
C "8 " ! # ( / ! /" ) + 2"
-:"+3% .
$
.
$% 7&;
7%:%+; " ( ! ! &$ " "8 " ! #
( / ! ! # ( -
/)"$3% $3"
&,6 ! (!
%$6!
( &
C 3/! 9 (< ( " 7 ! " ! ! "# =( &&
$% + , #" -./ 0%-%$"
:
/ )"$3%
$3"
,.
A $%$,$% "#3 ($3" 6 +"),.
"-" , $3"+ , "
* H999 99999 5 )*1 (" ! ! 9 (1 ,$$$3.
1 /$$$$3. 1 ,$$$3. ! ( $6 I &% 1" ! (>B(9 59- ""
+ , #" -./ : , - B 3, , -
! 1 ,$$$$3. ) 1 $$$$$3.* # . ! . !
&/ ; ! " # $6 !1 /$$$$3. % !
/)"$3% $3"
! 3( ! ##1 !
( ! " : ! " ! 8 " " 1 //$$$3. 1
'5$$$3. !
! !C
" ! 1 $$$$$3. ! &,
!
#" !
" ! 1 &,$$$3. 9
#" ! ! #( -
/ )"$3% $3"
,.
!1 5,$$3. 1 &,$$$3. 9 1 5,$$3. "( &5
# "
( ! ! #=
!
+ >
)* ?
" 1 ,$$$3.! )* ?
" # &,6 1 ,$$$3.J%',$3.K 2',$3. )* : 3/ 9
3/ 2',$3.K /522 1 /50$3.K /$5$3. )* ! # ! /
/$5$9 &9 /K&%5&$2$3. )* C ! 4 1 //$$$3. 1
'5$$$3. )* 9 1 5,$$3. )* C 1 5,$$3. )*
! L)*J )*J)*J)*M &%5&$2$3.J1
'5$$$3.J 1 5,$$3.J1 5,$$3. K1 &,'
$2$3.
&'
, 3/:)$$"C.
" .
$
.
$% 0$ A%:%+ .."+ ' ( &'
$'
&$&$ >B( ! ! 4 06 ! ! 456 !
! ! ! " ! ! # #!! (406 !! 7 # " !
! 56 ! !! &2 9! ! 1 &,'
$2$3. 1 &,2&$$$3. ( " &0 " 5 #3A 7
5 ; 8 D3"$3"
."8%9E " "
* " E D3"$3"
".
$ +"* " E