High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1128/2013allowed

Jagmal Singh And ORS. v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2015-10-29Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal13 pages

!"#$!%&'&"()**+ , ***--!..( '

/ *** !'-"($!( '

0 1,

*

23

!" #

$"

"

% '

( )* # + ( " , # $ # "#

# !" " % ) - # % "

"

% "

+.,

%

% "

" /"

0 # "! 1"

+2

3 , )45& #

% #

23 0 # "# ( " # # $ # # 6"

)45* " # "

%

# $ #

"

0 ( " "

% ) 7 $ # . " "

# " .

"

# ""8 "

0 # "# ( # " /" # "#

" # "#

" #

23 9# "

#

$" ) 0

% # # $ # "# !#

" :

1 - 0 # !" ) - #

% &:

1

0 " !"

":

1 0 " ":

1 0 "

":

1 ;

0 " ":

1 < 0 "

#:

1 '

3

.

$" # "

( ( #

(

" $" ( !#

)47;7< +6= <<, !#

)45-5& +6= '>, 8 "( " "# " "

>.

$" # " "

"

#

"! 1"

+2

3 , )45&

2+3

? $"

# "# " ""8 " " $ #

"# . #

? $"

" #

"

@.A? ?% .0B A # "

A "

/" #

# "

#

A

9" . !" # $"

!!

"#"$

# /"

#

##

)** $$ # " /"

/" # " $"

## " " " " +, +,

)** +), $$

%

/" " /"

#

#

"

"

" " " /"

?# "

"

#=# %&'(&)&* 23

> #" /"

" +, 0 $"

A" % ) - <

" :

+, 0 $"

> ""8 " " #

)4)<)'

>

+" , .:

+, 0 . ""8 " #

"

"# . ? . ! C#:

+, 0 >

. " # >

"

"! 1"

+2

3 , )45-:

+,0 > # > "

"

."# "/ +2

3 , -*)*:

+, 0 $" ## !"

# > ## ( # >

."# "/ +2

3 , -*)*

"/" :

+, 0 $"

" >

."# "/ +2

3 , -*)*:

23 . #( " #

@ ."# "/ +2

3 , -*)*

-

/"

!% &"(0 +, @ # ."# "/ #

#

# ."# "/ ###

"

F +, @$D # $

."# "/ " "

( $ 9

#

# # " $ F +, @$##D # $## "! ? 3" )''< +"! )< )''<,F +, @ ."# "/D #

" " F +,

@9 $##D # 9 $## "! ? 3" )''< +"! )< )''<,F +,

@?D #

"

."# "/ #

"

" " "" F + , @? D #

# ."# "/ " "F +, @ #D # #

# #

!% &"(0 %

"# " # # +, " 8

"# " #

= " ."# "/

#

# 8

" # "#

F +,

!% &"(4 +),

= "

#

# #

$ # #

#

."# "/

$ #

=

#

" " # #

+-, 1

" +), $ " "

#( /" #

#( # 9 " "

."# "/

+&, 0

"

# $ " $ # # #" #

+7, 0 # # # $ #

#( # #

/" #

+5,

."# "/

# "# "#

+;, A ."# "/ #

# "

$

+<, A "! # # # # ."# "/ ""#

# " #

#

+', A $ "!

#

#

"

#

+4, A $ "!

# #" # /" "

# "

2)3

- @

/"

" # -*

"

#

"

8

"# " = "

"

+,

= "

&

"

$ #

" #

"

23 . " " #( # " # -*

-*

# ###

" -*

23 A

= ### ? $" "

> 1 ;

3" )< $$

# -*)*

6 " > "

+.,

$" #

##

$" # " $" /"

" "

" !" #

#

"

" " !"

$" #

1 ;

3" )< $$

23 "# #

."# "/ +2

3 , -*)*

@ # ."# "/ -*

#

-*

#

&+, " 8

"# " #

= " .

# 1 8

"

&

$ # = " # ### " -*

#

# . # -*

+, -*)*

23

#

# ? $" # " # $

# #" $ #

( # = "# $

#

" -*)*

243

/" "

"

- #

= " =

= " #

$ #

.

#

? $"

2+3

$"#"

-

" " " " .

# -*

# ### -*)*

6

# =

253 A

" @-*)*D

=

( ? $" #

23 A " /"

#"

G" " "

A # -*)* " (

"#

= " "! #

#

.>

!" # $"

# " #

G"

#" )-

+, +, +, +, +,

"

!" # 1 ;

3" )< $$ G" %

+,

G" %

+, # #

? $"

>

."# "/ +2

3 , H -*)*

23 A

A#"

!" # $"

"

" "

% "6!7)8+