← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/825/2012dismissed

Manoj Kumar v. State Of Haryana

2022-09-22Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice N.S. Shekhawat14 pages

        



!"#$% &%  '( ")*"#"+#, - #($.% &%    



       $ / 0%11123 / 0%1%1%132        

     !

"   #    $$$$$ 

% 

  & '(')*'+*    +,')*'+* - .       /& 0 - 

0 &        ,1, ,213*434 ,'* ,15 6 .3  76.840  0 &  9 :    ,1,6.

 &              &  0       5'';9  6                    &  

&           ,213*4346.

   &0    + ''';96        &

&        

  

 ,'*6.

   &0    + ''';96        &

&        

   ,156.

 &              &  0       5'';9 6             &  

&           %      <    0

    

       -

  -    &   -   =      & <  <   >      

- ?

 @6   0& -   =9*  

    6;:   & =9+*- 

  A<9*

       

     0    -  -       %

;0 !0  -*9, &  - 1''  ,''B*''(

   ! 

  &  7 83 0 

  0      **)9  6.  0 0 0  &  C-   .  1('( ")3'#'(4'5 %+((''6'7

 %%% 9%

: &-( % ! 0 -    =9, 

 ! &0

&  7 8% 

      

  & 

-6     & '+'5*''(          !0        - &  7 80 &        0  

:

    - &       &         -     -0 &   

3 40  & -   &  : - 

  @6A<=1;?0 &    .

0  ,1, ,213*4 ,'*6.&  

      0    6;:   & =9+*   

   &   A<=9+*;?      0   +1+.

.&  

    &    6> A<=);. % 

      -  0      #      0  

 &    <  %

0

 -     ')'5*''(      A<=++;

 0

   !  -&        

  ! -   0  0

0    

             &   =9+*      &  6;:

   +2,.

. 0   



 &   > -       <   -  7 8&( 0 -  =9)  "

             -        ?    '+'5*''( %     0< - A<=);? 6> 0< - A<=);. %  ?           -

8

-09 -                       

    

 ! 

 "   #   $   

% 

     



"  

 -    



& -    ' (  



" &    - )   *  + $        " 

   -   (  !

 "

" & ,   " " &   " - - * *  $      - )      

    "

    -      

 .

  "

&

- )    

 " " . 

/

" 0        "

         

"   "  - ! " "  

1

   ?     0

< 0 &

 &0

  -     & 0-0  -  

 <    @D AE9B     -   @D  -0



A<95@D -   0  0   7 8 " &                   <   +* 0 

 %

0< - 

    ,+,.

. !  0

 

 &  

&   &   F     ! 

 ;

   - &  &     0   %  

<  0  0      "=9+       "=9*  

    

       

-  =     & 

       -  0  %  

      - &      -    

0 =9, 

-  -  0 & &- &   % 0  0  =9B   

 

   @

   -    

        ! & 

 -    @

 -  &  - 

& <  00  "=9+  "=9*

 0 &  

&   F   6

    

& AE"

0 %  

 

0  -  -  0       

.     

 % -   - 



-  

- 0  

&       0      

  &  

   -

  0 -       &  -    D 

        -   0 -   -     &    A   =9*     0         

 ;7  =9,  3 0 40 - 

       --  &  -   0   0  =     -     &  -        =9*  =9,   %   0    =9*       - 1''  ,''B*''(  &      

 !0  7 8 -   0  &  %      



! &  7 8  0 !   ! &  

      ! 0  0

    

0 

> - &  7 8:    - 

   

   0      &  -!

; 0-

%    - 

&     0 &        0  &  0

   &  7 8     & -),' '+'5*''(  <   0   -   %    

      @6  0  &    -         0     -   &   & &  

%    0< =9*-   0-  

9<   0     6 

 =9*        & 



      D    & ,''B*''( 0  - ! &0 &  -

          &'+'5*''(

0   A 0 &

&  =9*               -              

         .              <   =9,  

&-++  

! &0   ;  7 8 -     &,''B*''(A 

0!0

-

 - &

   0  0 !A   0       0    & 

A  &  9<    &  - !-   00  -  D 

  -

0  =9* =9,  0   0 

   0              7 8  - &      - 

   =     -        00  -  &   0    7 86 =9,  0   0 

0!0 A  0 -       

0   

  0- 9<    00   &  0   

     &

  90 

   0    - && -   0  =9* =9,  A    

 ,+,.

.

  <  0 

&  &       6 =9,   

! &0  7 8 - 

     = =9* 0    & 

 0  &           &  6 - - 8-  .            



 !"

#$% &'& #'

()%

!$*H  9 23-   

4   

5     

      4"   ,

6

  & "                "         

                 

&         

   "       -      

    "   8 2-                   

     "

"

  "          "    9    

         "     "         "  9    &   

 "                     "  

      

  

                 

 "       "  "      1  1<''!  =!<=,<'#!  1<''!

=!<=,<'#!1'!' %1('( ")'<''

<('7

&88 1

.1'!' %1('( ")'<''

<('7

&88 1

.>'- !!?'6

<4<'##' !!? %1('( ") #!<''- !!?'6

<4<'##' !!? %1('( ") #!<'  '!

<7  

.

    =-=#'9  8.  $



.

1 ;'!

<7

.

 =-=#'9 8.$ 

.

1 ;>=-+4<'"(=3=4'# % 1('( ")'<''

<('7 

.=-+4<'"(=3=4'# %1('( ")'<''

<('7 

.

1. 

1 . >  5 #4'(

'#  %  1('(  ")  '-=9  '!+7  

 : #4'(

'#  %  1('(  ") '-=9  '!+7 

 :  

=-=#'9 .:$ 

18 . =-=#'9 .:$ 

18 .>1'#6'?3+-''=#1'#6'?

3+-'  '=#  %  1('(  ")   9<=7  

  

=-=#'9;

$ 



 %1('( ") 9<=7

  =-=#'9;

$ 



1;::1;::> '!<+ %1('( ")3 '9'7

 '!<+ % 1('( ")3 '9'7

  =-=#'9  $ 





 1:&& =-=#'9  $ 

1:&&>+##'

3+-'  +##'  3+-'  *'!<?'?'  @  +##' *'!<?'?' %1('( ")#!<'*'!<?'?'@+##'

*'!<?'?' %1('( ")#!<''!

<7 

.1

;8'!

<7 

.1 ;8>5= 43'9' %1('(

")5= 43'9' %1('( ")'6'

(<'#7

:



=-=#'9 & $

:

 , #('6'

(<'#7

:

   =-=#'9  &  $  

:

   , #(  * +!B- #(  %%%8 $ 

8 18:& * +!B- #(  %%%8 $ 

8 18:&%C * :

     

   "   

"     "



        



           "    

        " 



                "     -     "  " " 8 2-  

  

    



 

 "

        

  

     "     "                    "  



  5  "" 

  

      

                         "    

 5    "  



   

      

      

 "     1 1

 "!<  '6  @  "!<'  %  1('(  ") '--+'#!3'

<-=7 

18  "!<' %1('(

")'--+'#!3'

<-=7 

18 >'

D'#(



 =  %  1('(  ")  +#6'E7  

.

    =-=#'9 '

D'#(  =  %  1('(  ")  +#6'E7  

.

  

=-=#'9 $ 

 18: $ 

  18:>=**''-'E<'4' %1('( ")=**''- 'E<'4' %1('( ")#!<''!

<7



=-=#'9 ;8$ 

& :#!<''!

<7

  =-=#'9 ;8$ 

& :1 :81 :8> = <='9 %1('( ")((''4<'#!7 

: 1 = <='9 %1('( ")((''4<'#!7 

: 1 > 3= <#'#  %  1('(  ")  '-=9  '!+7  

8   , #( 3= <#'#  %  1('(  ")  '-=9  '!+7  

8   , #( * A+!B- #(  %%%8 8$ 

8 1;& * A+!B- #(  %%%8 8$ 

8 1;&> 3==(=  '9  %  1('(  ")  2

( 

#B'97  

.

  

=-=#'9.

;$'9 %1('( ")2

(

#B'97

.

   =-=#'9  .

;  $  

.

   , #(  * +!B- #(  %%% 8$ 





.

 , #( * A+!B- #(  %%% 8$ 



1 ; 1 ;>1('( ")3'#'('4' %<'#! '

<'7

81('( ")3'#'('4' %<'#! '

<'7

8   =-=#'9  ;

  $  

   , #(  * +!B- #(  %%% =-=#'9;

$

 , #( * A +!B- #(  %%%:. $ 

. 1

:.  $  

.   1 

>  '-E'4 <  %  1('(  ") '-E'4 < %1('( ")<<'((= B'<7

.

:

=-=#'9::

$

.

:<<'((= B'<7

.

:

=-=#'9  ::

 $  

.

:   , #(  * A  +!B- #(

%%%  .   $  

.    1     , #(  * +!B- #(  %%%. $ 

. 1 >#6'# 3+-'  1<'-'  %  1('(  ")  

'-7  

;

:   #6'#  3+-'  1<'-'  % 1('(  ")  

'-7  

;

:   =-=#'9  :.  $  

;

:   , #(  * +!B- #(  %%% =-=#'9:.$

;

: , #( * A+!B- #(  %%% $

; .10 .% $

; .10 .%C

  %  9-    0 0      -  00          & 

      0  

0 

- -    6   ;

 7 0&- ( 0- !  -0-    - -  

        -

     30

  -    - 4  A   

 < =9)"

           0

< 

 &A 

@D  -@D  - A<5   0   0   7 0  &-(   6      & 0-=9+* 6;:   &

 0  

        ! -&      

  ! -  0 

0     6      

      -   0  6                      



  

0   

 &  

&   F

  %-   &  < "=9+  "=9* 

   0    0 ,''B*''(   

& 

0  ! 

&

 :

      &

 "     &

 3F4   ,''B*''(  ','5*''(  

& 0< - A<"

 0

 

9<   "=9+       

& 

0     

    !

- &  0      0    

& -  &  

 -  -    

&

0  ! &   

& - 

&

0   0

0!        A "=9*

     

0 -

 -   %    -   &   -      00   --

 &   &   -

 ! & -

0

   !   

   0

 

&  -       &        

 -- %    0   <

  &       <

 % - &  -  - - -

 6  &    -&  

    - &   & -     &      & 



-    %      - &   -- .   &6    -   >     .   &  

 8    %          8 6   &       -

     <     -    <     -%   >   

 - 0   %    &0   0&    &          0    & 

 0 -  - --

0              0   -<  &  

0   &   & 0     & -  (    0

  -    -        -  &   -&  0 &    0 

&&   - .       /& 0

   %

   &    &

           & .    -0 

  <

   %     --!   1123    %1%132 .% &%    

  =   ! &;

 I =  - I