(O&M) Oriental Insurance Company Limited v. Parminder Kaur And Others
-1-
FAO-3 XOBJ 3140-2012 (O&M) & JC-98-CII-2012
+ * 7
! "# '( %
*+%'
# $%& / 0 %) "%&%1&2 3 &(
'$ $%& 4 0
)/0 !+1 ! 2
)'3 !+1 !
/4
2$0 5$0 /,-8
& 22
, -. # $ 6 .
$ ) +
#$ !
!
! " #$ %& ' (( ( ) * + ! ,--! .
!
9
-2-
. $ ! 6 $ 5 /6
#
2$0
$ $
$0 /4
&6 .
' (( ) * +
! ,-- $ # #$ !
! 6
2$0
,!!9 2 6. @(A
:63
'6 ; ' $
$0 $
2$0
6 .
$ #$ ! !
5 /6
1 0 6 < 4 -! :
:6 3 '6 =
= = )
+ 6 6 : 6!
! )
!
! . 6
6.
=3 (<44+$ <4)!:63 91 >$ '6
= +
=?
$! + =6! .
= #
1
$ ).
!
!
= !.
.
. $61$ /
6 6 6# 12
-3- $
= (- .6 6
= .
=1$:63 +
!:63 1
0
. = )3'
!7 !.
#
.
6 616 2
=$ $ 19 B 7/(4 -
,9;<+ . 6 )=!? 7 4 C ! ( B 6 ! .6
. $
#$ 2
!
" #
$
% %&&' ( (
) * + #) ( , ) # # -,$$-.'//!
0*1 %
*1
0 *1 "
"
*,42 $ !
4 *,42
-4- .
, 5 7.
After taking into consideration the pleadings and the evidence e on record, th he learned Tribunal has awarde ed compensation to the tune of f ,!!9 2 6. @(A
'6 and the appellant-Insura :63
ance Company was held liable to o pay the comp pensation. Hence, the Insurance e Company filed the present ap- - peal.
- 2
1 61 . 61 1 16
#$
2
$ $
9 / 4 ! ! $ . , ! / 49
$0
$ #$ . 1 $
#$ 6 2
$ 9 / 4 # !
2$0 $ . $ 2
$
$ .
.
-5-
1
.
3 6 !. $
1 .2 60 3
, 2
4
0"
7 2
8 ,0
,7 ! 8 "
1
2."
+
1 $ #$ !
! / /( 1. 61 & . 6 6 D!1 4 # !$
. ! / ( $61.. 6 6 D!1 -, ; +
6.
.
#$ 6
8
6 $ 16$
# #$
ED7! 1 .
$
1 61 .
61 -6- 116
'62 ! 7# #. D!.
$
1 .
61 16 <
. $
!
!
6 1. 61 16 !
$
$ 1$
6 $ 1 # $
6 >
)
! .
6 1 ! $2
1
$ 4
! 8
2
$
6 $ $ 1 6 6 1 61
2 ! 6 $ #$ 6 $
8
$
6 1 ; > ! 6 . . 2 6 $ #$ # !
! $61 !
6
5 /6
( +16 .
2$0 $
2$0 =6
-7- +
6. 1 .
$< <
# 6 . ! # $ 6
6 < $ 6 6
)=3& 6 4 - +
6 . 1 .
$16 .
=. $6 6 4!92 .1!
.
$ # ! # #$ 6 . 6 $
= $ 0$ 6
7 -92 , +
. 1 #$
6 .
# ! . ! 78
$
+
. 1 #$
6 9;.
D
$ 9< . B ! 6 6
D2 F 6. 6.
# ! .2 > 6
-8- 9
%$ '
:,
/.
.01*" 3 %1"('! !
;!
! .
.
1 2 G 7 ! "
8 !
7 # 9 )
-
!: 9 9) " " " "
) "
8 ) ! 4 ;
<2="!
! %2)4;
<3=" !
! 3.) 4 ;
<$="!
!8 "
!
) "
0 !
)
) ) $&>
8 ) !
!
" "
)
!
) " !
;= !
# !
? )! ) # " "
!
"
! 0 ! ) ! "
!
-9- ) ! "
! ) )! % 7 !
!
) "
" ! !
) $&> " !
8 !
$&> !
-")"
!
) " "
" ! 4 ! ) 8
! 4 !
"
! # "4 & & & & & & '%
! !
9 ;3= ! ! ;
!
7 @) 7 # 9 9 =) " "
' ; $%& % %$ $ =)!
) +4 / %.2& )+4 .2 2$ )+4 $2.3&
)+4 33 3$ ) +4 23.$& ) !
"
) )+4
$
$$ )+4A$..& &
)+4/.
.$ +4$../&
%$ '
( )* !" #! $ :,
4. 006 ; . ' ((!(;2+(- )* + !,-- ! .
.6 2
-10- +& ?
16D F 3& ' 66 F & +6 $ 6 F ?& 7 $ 6 1 ! !
!
D ! .
F E&
6 6 . 0$F 2 D
# 1 0 6
2 G+% 1 *, , ) " "
" 8 , B 0 , %$)&&& "
8 ), )&&)&&&"
"
,
)&&)&&& "
7 8 7 7,
C ) " 7
)
) ! !
! " !
! D # )
! : 1 : ! 7 !
8) !
#
)
! 7
!
7 7 ! ! "
) "
!8 !
-11-
)"
!
# # : " )
!
! # ! 7)" # 8 ! 0 ! ) ) ) 8 ! ,
$)&&&) , 3&)&&& ,
$)&&& &
7
!
! 4 : 4
# " !
! " : ! !
!
&>
! "
!
E E E E +- ) $&> >
"
) " ! "
! " 3& ) !
7 !2 2&>) "
!" 3& $& 0 "
!" $&.
.& ) !
$> 1
!
+- '
0 "
4 ;=
8
) 3&> !
! "
" "
! " 3& 1 %$>"
-12- "
!" 3&$& &> > " "
!" $& .& &
! 7 !
8
+- + ?
) 8 ) !
! !
2&2%
F " "
! +- . 7
! 7 !
F G "
3% +- / 7 ! !
+- 0 , ! ) ) ) 8 ! , $)&&&) , 3&)&&& , $)&&& &
7
!
&>
5
;
%$ '
'@3' & "'+ + &!1"'&2 %3*'&< =3=( $ >! '&1
'3 '+='! ?1?"1 '3 - - (? "! :
6, 6. ; 6 '"+' > "3',!1*"'.
"'&'< (?
?=,1*"'. . 66 7 1
2 6% 19 9 *
B "
"
! "
0
)H H
-13- "
"
H
H)
H)
H
H 7 "
) ) ) ) )
)"
) " 8
"
%
) *)
!
4"
"
" H
) ) ) )
H %
% # *)
) H
)
) ) )
)
H %
*)
1 #
7
9 ) )
%% 9
! "
+ " 4 I 8 "
+
-14-
! "
7 "
) )
)
% 7 + F 1 !
)
0 "
) )
!
! "
*
"
"
"
1 1"- 9
"
-") "
"
" ! "
%'
7 ! "
"
! !
"
H H
" *
0 )"
"
) , ,3&)&&&
<
1. . .$ %$ '
$1 0 6 ! $
$=!3=!! $ $$61 !.
2$0 $
2$0 0 9 / 4 '++%A $ # . 17.02.2012
6 #
2$0 9 /
4 -15-
2 2
(
4 ) -92
@ 4A 92 4A -& ; ?
D
. 9< 492 59<& < #
492 8 4& 4 ) 4 ( +
? ;!4!92 45 54&
E 4!92 - ED 4!92 ,
'
B
7 <D !!92 7 <D 7 7 <D %('+ +%3* &!'(=%&
! 76
C 3%1 "=B1 1&(A'"$ $B<(? 1&'+
!/4
C &?'
'&2 $'3%1&( ,
!0
C
! 76
/4
.
4 '
! $ %$ '
12 3 ! 1
/
40
() , . 7 1*" 3 %1"( '! !
4
2$0 9
6 @,A 6
H
( -16- # 2
. #$ . .
0 6# #$
$
6.
2$0 9 / 4 .#
$0 9
/4
$=
#$
6 &! !
0 I 1+ J J , . =692 =6' $ K =6 9/