Mohinder Singh & ORS v. State Of Punjab
!! "#
$
$ $%& &&'
('
)*
+ # # ,& -&#'
!! % ,! '
- ('
$#/0 1 - &#'
+ !
3&#.&
+ #.
! !
- ,#.'
& '
# - 456
7'
'
&. 1
# &0! # -
578 8 689898 8
8 5:
;$'
'
# -
8 6
+
& +%
'
# '
8 !!
'
&#.& .
1
!
!
,#.
+ #
# 0
+ +
1!!
0#
&
<
+
4+
#
- + ; #!
*+
! "#$ ;$ .# + +
*
;$ .# + +
!
8 =# .# + +
< + & 5:
.# + +
!
8 =# .# + +
< + & ;$ .# + +
& *
8 =# .# + +
+ & 8 5:
;$ .# + +
& *
8 =# .# + +
+ & ;$ .# + +
< + & 9 ;$ .# + +
* %&$ "#$
;$ .# + +
*
;$ .# + +
!
8 =# .# + +
< + & 5:
.# + +
!
8 =# .# + +
< + & ;$ .# + +
& *
8 =# .# + +
+ & 8 5:
;$ .# + +
& *
8 =# .# + +
+ & ;$ .# + +
< + & 9 ;$ .# + +
* %!
"#$
;$ .# + +
*
;$ .# + +
!
8 =# .# + +
< + & 5:
.# + +
!
8 =# .# + +
< + & ;$ .# + +
& *
8 =# .# + +
+ & 8 5:
;$ .# + +
& *
8 =# .# + +
+ &
4+
#
- + ; #!
*+
;$ .# + +
< + & 9 ;$ .# + +
* '$ !!
"#$( )%
;$ .# + +
*
;$ .# + +
!
8 =# .# + +
< + & 5:
.# + +
!
8 =# .# + +
< + & ;$ .# + +
& *
8 =# .# + +
+ & 8 5:
;$ .# + +
& *
8 =# .# + +
+ & ;$ .# + +
< + & 9 ;$ .# + +
* +
.# + +
1 *
8 .# + +
+ &
+
.# + +
& *
8 .# + +
+ & *$ "&+
"#$
;$ .# + +
*
;$ .# + +
!
8 =# .# + +
< + & 5:
.# + +
!
8 =# .# + +
< + & ;$ .# + +
& *
8 =# .# + +
+ & 8 5:
;$ .# + +
& *
8 =# .# + +
+ & ;$ .# + +
< + & 9 ;$ .# + +
* %,$&+- "#$
;$ .# + +
*
4+
#
- + ; #!
*+
;$ .# + +
!
8 =# .# + +
< + & 5:
.# + +
!
8 =# .# + +
< + & ;$ .# + +
& *
8 =# .# + +
+ & 8 5:
;$ .# + +
& *
8 =# .# + +
+ & ;$ .# + +
< + & 9 ;$ .# + +
*
;$ .# + +
* .,
"
"#$ (
/ " "#$ (
"
( $
" !
"#$
;$ .# + +
!
8 =# .# + +
< + & 5:
.# + +
!
8 =# .# + +
< + & ;$ .# + +
& *
8 =# .# + +
+ & 8 5:
;$ .# + +
& *
8 =# .# + +
+ & ;$ .# + +
< + & 9 ;$ .# + +
*
;$ .# + +
* 0&+- "#$ .*"*1 ,
"#$
;$ .# + +
!
8 =# .# + +
< + & 5:
.# + +
!
8 =# .# + +
< + & ;$ .# + +
& *
8 =# .# + +
+ &
4+
#
- + ; #!
*+
8 5:
;$ .# + +
& *
8 =# .# + +
+ & ;$ .# + +
< + & 9 ;$ .# + +
*
;$ .# + +
* 0&+- "#$ .*" *1 0 2 "#$
;$ .# + +
!
8 =# .# + +
< + & 5:
.# + +
!
8 =# .# + +
< + & ;$ .# + +
& *
8 =# .# + +
+ & 8 5:
;$ .# + +
& *
8 =# .# + +
+ & ;$ .# + +
< + & 9 ;$ .# + +
* % ! "#$
;$ .# + +
* 5:
.# + +
!
8 =# .# + +
< + & ;$ .# + +
& *
8 =# .# + +
+ & 8 5:
;$ .# + +
& *
8 =# .# + +
+ & ;$ .# + +
< + & 9 ;$ .# + +
* 0 1
#
# !* )1'
# *
# .
. '
'
!
'
1
+
-
5 7
$'
0 +
+ +
'
&#.&
# '
!
!
,#.
'
>#
!
.
# (#
,.
&.
!* 1 .
&+
# &0! # -
578 8 689898 8
8 5:
;$ # -
8 6
+
)1'
& + !
#..
..
'
& * !
.
>#
!'
0 >#
# 3& '
0
>#
!
>#
!# 0 .
5 !!
# + ..
0
'
0 + ..
>#
&1
# '
+ + #
&+'
&#
&* !
#
&.
!
#
& #
.
#
+0
=;
1& ?<$@ 68 .'
& '
6
! &
!!
1
!
) !'
& . .
0
) A0& +
/# ! - .&'
-#0&& &'
, ! ,
)0
& ! 3&# '
;
-) !
) !'
& !.
+ !
! 3& -#%&
+ !
+
& + +
" !!. , $# @!
+ ) # ! - %&
& # & B % !!
!
!!. (& &.
*
+ .'
!.
& # ! -#%& 1!!
!
(#/
- .&'
)0
4 - .&'
)
-& - .&'
" !!. , $# @! '
-#0&&
-& A!
$ + 4.'
& '
A0&
C - .&'
!/ 4.'
& ,
C& - .&'
" !!. 0!# 1 !#.& .
!
&
1
3&
0#
+'
# +/
& - .&'
!!. (& &.
+
& &
!!* !.
#
4
- .&'
#
, - .&'
&
, - .&'
,%
#!! - .&'
-#/
, - .&'
-#%&
, - .&'
!
)%+ - .&'
!
!
- .&'
" !!. (& &.
7
#
1& ! + !* 1 !# .
('
3%#'
-1'
(& A & ;++ !* & .
4
A!% <& .
!
- %&
!#.& .
& ! 3& !!
# 0 .
++0
+ !
*
&
1
# # /#
&+ +/
#& ) # &
#
+ !
! & +!
0*
! & .
4+
&
#
# 0
!!
++0
+ !
* 1
1& !
.
&* !!
& 3&* !
& .#
) A0&
.# & 3&* 1
1*
!.
&
1
&
!!* 3&
+ !
+ #
1
++0
+ !
* 1
-#%& - .&'
! - .&'
-#0&& &'
,
)0 1 #!* /#
& !. + & 0 0% ) A0& 1
!
& +#!
! /# 3&
+ !
&
!!
& !!. +
!! 1 !
-& !#0
+0#!
+0#!
/# 1
&
!
) !'
&
+ !
!.
(#/
-
" !!. , $# @! #
) A0&
1* /# 1 +
& !
#
++
+#
) A0&
# .
/#
&+ !
# /#
- %& - .&'
! - .&'
-#0&& &'
,
)0
++
& +# 0&
&
#
# & 0 .
- %& # !
+ !
.
! # &
&+ ) '
% .
# 3 9 3& 0 . +
+ !
1
-) +
&
#>
!
&#.& /
.
+!
=; # -
8 68 89898 5:
;$ ;>#
A0& ) 1 + + <+
& 0 1 .
#
/# 1 ! #
+% +
3& -)
#.& ! +
+ ! ?
3
!.
#!
#
1
1
% !
6
7'
/# 1 . ! #
+% +
6
0 .
+
- %& 1 - +
/# 1 ! !
! &
/# 1
% !
56
7'
# & - .&'
#& - .&'
-#/
-#%& - .&'
96
# # - .&'
+/
1 76
# 4
! 0# 1 76
7'
+
1 . .
)0 - .&'
1& 1 +
& ! 3& -;
,.
& >#
.
+ + <+
#
& 0* @ #
++
1
#
6
7'
0
+
- %&
# -
;$ # -
8 6
+
1 ! !
!
0!
! & .# 1
=
- A0 *'
& .&
&
=-A
. .
0! !
0!
! & 1
. .
<+
+ *
+ .
#
! !
! .
&
&#
--$'
&
# ++
#
-$ '
&
&! .
># * ) '
. .
+ .
# &!!
;># * ++
- +
+ .
1
+ !
. '
!
.
# 1
!
#
6 -
1 < !# !*
0!
#
- '
&#
++
!
6
! ,# !
. ;
!'
& '
++
#
!
#
-
7 # <+ +*
'
#0># !*'
#0!
#
!
#
!#
#
'
!
!
,#. 1 . # -
$'
1& '
# ! '
'
! +
! + !
; '
!
#!
<+
45 : !
#!
!! '
& .# #0+
& #
=;
+
&
+ +
#
!0!'
+ '
&# #0+
& 1 *
#
. .
'
# .
#
. '
&
#
!
'
# .
& '
+ .
+
+
) #0+
!
1
#
# .
#
. 0 .
=;'
& '
.#
'
1 +'
#
#
'
$@98'
$@6'
'
$@:'
1 !.!!*
!
'
1&
. '
.#
+ #.
#
.
. +
.+
&. 3&#'
.#
+ #.
>#&
& #
!*'
! -
#!
& .#
&!!.
& #
1!!
+ '
'
1
+ .
&'
& #
3 3
6 789 7: 7;
$@98 & <+ &
&
#! '
" !!. , $# @!
+ )
#
&
# ! - %&
& # & B % !!
!
!!. (& &.
*
+ .'
!.
& # ! -#%& 1!!
!
(#/
- .&'
)0
4 - .&'
)
-& - .&'
" !!. , $# @! '
-#0&&
-& A!
$ + 4.'
& '
A0&
C - .&'
!/ 4.'
& ,
C& - .&'
" !!. 0!#'
1 !#.& .
!
&
1
3&
0#
+'
# +!* +/
& - .&'
!!. (& &.
+
& &
!!* !.
#
4
- .&'
#
, - .&'
&
, - .&'
,%
#!! - .&'
-#/
, - .&'
-#%&
, - .&'
!
)%+ - .&'
!
!
- .&'
" !!. (& &.
7
#
1& ! + !* 1 !# .
('
3%#'
-1'
(& A & ;++ !* & .
4
& .
!
- %&
!#.& .
& ! 3& !!
# 0 .
++0
+ !
*'
&
1 !
# # /#
&+ +/
#& ) # &
#
'
+ !
- %&
! & +!
0*
! & .
4+
#
&'
1&
&* %
!
+ '
.
#!
& #
#+0
& /#
) !
# .
#
#!
#
&
.#
) A0&
&
.# & 1&
&* !.1
&
#!
1 !
+
&
!!* 3&
+ !
+ #
1
++0
+ !
* 1
-#%& - .&'
! - .&'
-#0&& &'
,
)0 1 #!* /#'
'
& !. + & 0 0% ) A0& 1
!
& +#!
! /# 3&
+ !
&
!!
& !!. +
!! 1 !
-& !#0
+0#!
+0#!
/# 1 &
!
) !'
&
+ !
!.
(#/
-
" !!. , $# @! '
0#
) A0&
1* /# 1 +
& !
#
++
+#
) A0&
# .
/#
&+ !
# /#
- %& - .&'
! - .&'
-#0&& &'
,
)0
++
& +#
$@6'
#!
# '
& <+ & 1 #0/
<
.
<+ )1'
$@6 #
#!!* &
.
. !! .
<+ 3& '
# +
*
.
% . $@6 & <+ &
+ $@6'
*
* . + + +0!! &+
& #!* +
1 .
#
*
#
&
# .
*
% . & + & <+ & '
&
<+ 3& '
! # +
.
'
+
.
$@6
1 #!
# $@98 - %& $@:
,
- .&'
1& ! &
+
0
+ $@98 3&
!
*
* . + + +0!! &+ 0 .
&
!* # + 1 . '
&
&
!!
# 3& '
#
0
'
'
+ $@6'
$@98 $@:'
>#
* 1 &'
! & '
& &#.&
# & #
0! & .
&. 1 .
#
3
37
5
1&!+ .
$@98'
$@6 $@:'
# !
!!
&
&
<+ & &
# '
1&
& '
+ * !
+ !
* !!
& $@ 1 #
!
.#
<+ '
0#
# .
#
& #.. + #
!!'
!
#!'
& #..
& .'
# .
&
<+ &
+ ! !*
! +
#
!!
'
#
# '
!!
& $@'
# #!
'
'
! 0 #!*
/
. .
'
&
#
* !
0! .
'
&
*
< 3
# .
#
# !
.
# 4 &&
0#'
. # !# +
+ ?<$@ 58'
1&
+ <
&
!"#$#"%
!& '!( )
!& '!( * + )
* ) + ) ,#-
#.
# /
0
12 !3%45## 2 67.!%'"5## 2 8 + *5&%#$#"%, .
0 <
. # !# +
# 4 &&
0#'
!
&
&
!*
& .# !
0#
& ! !
#
# .
*
0 ! ?<$@ 58'
. .
'
!
& & .'
'
! .
+ 0 .
< !# !* %1
& + - ##
&
&#.& * ++ ?<$@
58'
#
*
0 ! 3&# * .
.
0 ++'
&
0 0!
0!* * & . #
# ?<$@ 58'
& 0 0!
! '
& !
0 0!
0 .
. 0!
#..
3&#'
*
*
.
0 1 ++ #!
!*'
0
& &#.& >#
0! #!
#
+
$@98'
$@6 $@:
9 # .
#
# !
.
# & '
#
#.!
. .
# # #
& '
# -#/
# '
# -#%&
-#%& # +!!
<'
# +/
# +0 ! & +% 4%
4 :96'
& 1 7
8'
& '
+% ,
&#
#+0 ! '
!.1
!!*
# # #
& +0 ! &
4% !
. .
0
#
#
. .
+ # &!!.'
&#.&
#
<+ 0 .
+'
#
. .
'
# * +. !
&
>#
&
!!
!
8 #
+ *
+'
+ !
!*
# 0#
!
& #
#
++
&.
'
! ! +
. !* 0! & ##!* ! 1&
+ & 0 # #..
8 #
'
!
3& '
0
&#.&
0 #
8
!
#!
1 '
'
+ *
+'
+!*
0
# #!
#
>#
#
#!
#
34
5
6
+ + #
0*
)0 1
#
9 6
$@ $@
&
& '
# & .
?<$'
!
# * #
0*
)0 - .&
7 '
&
#
)0 - .&'
1 1 .
&+&.'
& %
+
#
/# '
1&
+ + #'
1&
#
#
*
#
# !
+ + /#
$@
0*
<
&
9: ;
< #0# 5
7# #
# 9: !"*
)
# 9: % *
) # 9+: ;
# 9+:
% 3 *
) # 9+:
!& * *
)
+)#,
:
+ + #
0*
) 1
#
6
$@ $@ &
& '
# & .
?<$='
!
# * #
0*
) - .&
'
&
#
) - .&'
1 1 .
&+&.
& %
#
/# '
1&
+ + #'
1&
#
#
*
#
# !
+ + /#
$@
0*
<
&
9:
!&3* * + )
*
#-
# 9:
!&3*
!2'# 9:
7 ='*
!2'
#
9+:
7 &"#&(*
!2'# 9+:
!#("#&(*
# 9+:
7 3&*
<
#-
< *
#,
+ + #
0*
A0& 1 !
#
6
$@ $@ &
& '
# & .
?<$C'
!
# * #
0*
A0& - .&
'
&
#
A0& - .&'
1 1 .
&+&.
& %
#
/# '
1&
+ + #'
1&
#
#
*
#
# !
+ + /#
$@
0*
<
&
9:
$"#'("#(*
*< *(*
*
*
) *
< *
*
3(
# 9:
'!*>) *<
<*
#-
* ) # 9:
&"#(*!* < ) #&*>) *
# -
) #
9+:
&"#&(*>) (
< )#&* #7
#-
) # 9+:
!#("#&(* *<
< )#3# 9+:
!"#(* * (*
<*
#-
) # 9+:
;
&!* #7
#, &' + !
<+
0*
/# ! 1
6
$@ $@ &
& '
# & .
?<$@8'
!
/# #
0*
/# ! - .& !
/#
$@
0*
<
&
9:
&!#(*
!2'
# 9:
? &!#(* !2'#@
# 9:
#, 5 + !
<+
0*
/# ( ,
1
6
$@ $@ &
& '
# & .
?<$@ 8'
!
/# #
0*
/# ( ,
- .& !
/#
$@
0*
<
&
9: ? ''* < +
# 9:
? $$*
#
9:
? ("#'"*
&2' #@
# 9+:
? '"#&(* !2'#@
# 9+:
&"#'*
# 9+:
!"#&#-
!2'#, + !
<+
0*
/# -#0&& & 1
6
$@ $@ &
& '
# & .
?<$@ 8'
!
/# #
0*
/# -#0&& & !
/#
$@
0*
<
&
9: !(%#-
# 9:
3&#- '* < )#!# 9: !"'*
# 9+:
&&*
!2'# 9+:
'!* # 9+:
# 9+:
# 9+: 7 !2' * "#("#(*
!2'# 9:
$'*
!2' # 9: $&*
# 9:
!"(*
# 9:
#/
#, 9 + !
<+
0*
/# - %& 1
6
$@ $@ &
& '
# & .
?<$@8?'
!
/# #
0*
/# - %& - .& !
/#
$@
0*
<
&
9:
&!*
# 9:
!!*
# 9:
&!*
* $*
# 9+:
'"#(
( *
# @
<
#,
A 1
/# '
0 !# + 0 '
>#
&1 '
.
&
0 '
0
/# *1
# '
!
& ># * .
&'
.
& .
#!
/#
&
'
&#.& #
!* + * 1
'
#
3&#'
!
/# #
'
+ + 1
#!
#
>#
# '
&* /#
&* ! +* *1 0#
1&
# '
&
!*
# 3&#
* &
+ #
& + & 3& '
!*
& ! +
+ ! !* 1 '
1& /# * 1#!'
#!
. !*
!0!'
+ '
&
# #!
#
!
+
6 3&#.& 47
78=-A8$08-8?<+'
6 7
&#.& 4 78=-A8=!!8?<+'
9
7'
+ *
+81
+
&#.& !1
4755
=-A
'
<+
& 0 .
?<
#!
#!
<+
=-A'
0 A 87 0!
!'
&#.& +%
& .& !*
!'
+ & 0 #'
0#
0!!
<
&
+% .
*
+ '
0#
+ .
0#!! 8 !! 0 .
& +
!!
?<
?<$E !
#!
<
&
!# / !&
#34('% A A
#6 + *
# &# / #'!(,2%.. #?
"( ($3% A7A +
#6 + *
# '#
#!&
72!72&9 A?A + :* !&
#34('%
+ #, 6
7 3&#'
0!!
< &
. .
+ 0#
+ 1&
!
+ 1 #'
!
+
+
# & .
+ )1'
0 1
!!
#
!!
?<
0#
#
0 A .# 4 5:7'
'
#
! 4 657 ##!* ! 1&
. # !# +
'
& 0
# '
!#
+ ! !* ! '
0 1&
+ !
+ !*
&!
># * 1 &'
&#'
!
#
!
1& 0#
>#!
& #!
!*'
&
!
! ! '
0# +0*
0
+ * '
!!* 1&
+
3& '
0!!
<
+% .
* & .
?<$E'
+
#
+ 1
*
#+
#
!
+
'
+
#!!* 0! &'
0! #!
#
>#
+ ;
'
# >#!
&
& >#
+%
.
0
.
+%
'
A .# 4 5:7'
#
! %
#
#!
&
+% 4 &!'
1&
#+
#
!
1
'
#
! 0!
.'
0 A .# 4 5:7'
1
#!
1 '
1&
0#!! 8 . 1
'
.
#+
#
.#
# '
+ .
& ?<$E 3&# '
#+
0
. +%
'
0 .
+
A .# 45:7 & + .
+*
* +*
+ 1 ?
#+ .!* '
*
% + *
#+'
!*
?<$E >#
.
# .
0 A .# 45:7 -
& 0#!! 8 . 0 #!*
0#!! 1&
&*
3& '
!
#
0
.
%
A .# 45:7'
&* #+ .!*
+0!
0 A .# 45:7 4 &!'
+*
!!
#
.
#
0#!! + .
!*
.#
# : '
+ *
+ !
!!.
0!'
!
FF'
!
!!.
+
!
FF'
!
!!.
0!'
!
FF'
!
!!.
+
!
FF'
!
!!.
0!'
!
F?F'
!
!!.
+
!
F=F'
!
!!.
0!'
!
F(F'
!
!!.
+
!
F)F'
!
!!.
0!'
!
F;F'
!
!!.
+
!
F,F'
#0 +% ?<C C+G +% ?<C '
+% ?<C
! +% ?< C5'
!
FCF'
C# +% A $*/+ +% ?<A '
!
FAF'
C+G !!.
0!'
!
FF'
C# +% ?< 4 $*/+ +% ?<4 '
!
F4F'
0 C+G !!.
0!'
!
FF'
! +
=-A
'
<+
& 0 .
?<
#!
<+ #
0 + *
+ <
&
/ ?*7*B*8* *C**.* - #
**@*6D#,
#!
#!
<+ #
0
+
-!.
'
+ ! !* #..
#+
+
#
% .
!
+ ;
'
& !
0 >#
0! *
#
#!
# 0
0
& +'
! ># ># #
#!
1
#
=
3& #
#!
#
&* '
+# '
& ! .
/#
&
+ *
&* ># * .'
#! #.
&1 #.. '
A 1
/# *
!
#'
8 +*
!
& .
+
!
+'
+ '
! !* !# +
'
0
>#
&1 ! !*
!!
+ *
+'
1& +
# + !
! !
=-A
'
&
<+ '
'
#!
>#
# 0!
! & +
0 .
0! 3&#'
0 . & .
0!
&'
=-A'
'
+
&
+ !*
#!
#
>#
#
&
+
0
; '
&
+
=-A
'
0#
#
#!
1 '
0#
& !
&
.
'
+ .
#!
1 )1'
1#!
. * !.
'
& # + &
0! 0#
#
+ 1 '
+
=-A 3&#'
1#! +
!
#
.
#
+ 1 '
+
#
'
1&+ ! 1 +'
'
! 1&
0! #!
#
#
+ #
.# !
#
)1'
!*
!# +
'
>#
&1 !* ! !* + '
.
#!
1
+
!!
. .
'
0#
*
!!
?<
'
+ * 1
'
+
=-A
'
+ ! !* # & 0 .
& + 3& '
#+
+ .
& .
.
0#!! 8 .
#!
1 '
!!* 1& #
0!
#
+
#
'
+ ! !* #..
+
&
+
;
+ .
0
!# '
& #
.
/#.+
)F0! < #
! F
1& ! " #$$ %& '
.'
1& + ! < #!
!1
#
;
># '
+ #.
'
'
!
>#
&1
'
+
!* '
'
+ '
#
!
!
,#.
'
#
* . *'
0# *
. + '
'
;
># '
& +
!'
'
+ + ;
# 0 !'
&#
'
+ #
&+ #
< #
!
!
,#.
'
&#.& &
&1 1 .
++
!
1 >#
&+ *
* !
!1'
0#
!*
< *
! +
! .
!
1
&1 & 4
>?>>@>> 4 5 !$0+.$ $+!$+ .2+ , "#9 + .*"+&7 +.9* $+!$+ +2* !
)0+ +.9*