High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/126/2013dismissed

Sunehri Devi And ORS. v. Samadh Baba Daulat Giri And ORS

2015-07-07Mr. Justice Rajiv Narain Raina13 pages

!"# $"%!&' () * $ +,+

-.."%!/ * 0,, ,

&&1/ $"%!!' () *, 0,, ,

*, (- 23( 0

, *-

! " ##

$% !%

&' ! " # 44444 (

) " #* + , - # *

0 5 (

% #"%## $ (+."

+/(0 $ 0012"+/((3"% "

## "&" $ (+."+/(0" ! #% " ## +

# ## ##4 #4 4 5#"4 ""##4 "" ##4 4 "

! " %"4 "

"" !%" %67 + 8 !

* 98+ 8

*8: 6(7819:0.. % ""%"4 " #! %" 4 , ""4 4; 3 #!

4! %"4 "!

"# 4% ! 4"

# <<" "# % &" "

! 4 " ) #% " "

##4" ": % %% ##4 &%45#"4

6 8+ *+ 8

*8 !

* + *8,:

6(70= ../ 4 ## :

% #%" ##4 &"" ##44"! 4 6"4

#! # !

4"" " ## % # >

$ ! ! +. 4 +//0 +1 4 (7=0 % # " ! $ +82 +1 4 (7=0 % " " #" "" %! "#% 4"

> $ ? "

% 4$ " "$(@4 +/// #""$ ( % 4% (2

@4 +/// %&" #%4" $ 6%# %4 # % > % ""# % 4 "!" " "# "0/ 4 488><##% #! " !"! ) %

! "

$!% &

) *!

+*!, -

) , . , -

) ,

, !

0 1 ## 2

( /

(

-!!

%! %

! "

0 ( !

( !

(

*! 3

4 /

522

(

522 0 /

522 6 /

527 /

527 3 /

27 8 /

5 9 /

(

527 # /

527 /

+*,

0 5

527 0 :

. "" % "4

" " ##"%

4%3 #!4% 4 " " 4 ! % % " 4 "

##4"

4%# " #4%% ! # %#% "

5" (7=0 , :

A "4%" - "4 % "4##5#"

&# # % # # % " & #4 ! #!" %!"

! % 3 4 "4" !##-"4"" " " #! %"4 % ! % " #"" %

? 3" % % 4 27" & # 4(7=0% % 4+//0 4 $ % 4 #"" %4 ## 4+/// #""<+% 4 4 " ## %

% " %

# <- "4# !" ##"" "&% % #4 % "! " #"" " " 4 ""4 % 4

6 ## " " % ##" (= +/(+ " @ (/

$% ##" # !4! " ## 4 " @ " $ +=0/"

+/(/ +0 +/(( ## % +2 4 (7=0" 5 " # "0/4 %# % " #! 4 ##4"

###

6## 5 ""

##4 #" % A%" " 5#" # " @ % " 4"

! " (*8, !

*8,: 6(7+7 8(.% 4 "

B& C "

D5#"4 ""

6 "" " - ##

#""+ #%# 5 4 +2 4 (7=0 4%4""

:%! ## ! 4 #!4 # ((

#43 5 !% % " "" 4 % 4 % !

&"! #" " #% %# 4 # ##" 4 " %%% -" 4" %5 " 4 (+

? 3" @

4 # 6% 27 7." % %## 5# # #!"7. ! # " ! ! ##4 # %% " 4#!"! " " % % (+4" " !" " ## 4 % " %% ! 6 # % 4

5#" # @ ## " 4+8 !

(87+ *8,:

+//((8( !% % " % % 44

! 4 #

# "" "

%% (0

" " % " !4 ## "

! " # " 5# ? 5#4" " ; # #

? # @ "" " " - =

? +//7"% ## B#C

- # B#C%## @ % # " ##4

###! " " B#C!! 4 % "" # (2

##" ## #%" - B#C (.

$% # # "!- " " !% ! " % #4# B#C +8 !

(87+

*8,5 +//((8(E ;!

8 3 *8,5

6(70= 8(.E 3 8 9*

+8+3 +

9+ !

+<*8+=,+98< +

<7,+9

*85 6(70.!4(80E *><0? *8, !

8**+0 9

*8,5 6(7...+7E@+*88!

< 5 6(7+7 8(=E 67 + 8 !

* 98+ 8

*85 6(7819:0.. <+ 8

*8!

+ 5(78( @207% # !%# ## "!"

)# ! ! # " ! 4 "# ; # #% # )

% " "4 <,8; !

8 8 *8,5 (78(!% #1.1 4 <3!

,8 3 *8,5+//8 (0.( " ! ! ##4" 5#" 4 ! # #!"

- 4" ) (720% #" 7 (1< " @

#"" % 4%""5 " #" 5#4# "

4 "-%# #!"

- )4 (88= 6 " 4"" #!7" (720 ? " B#C %

; 4"5#4" # ! 4" "! # (8

D!%

6! &

" " ##" " % " #"" #!" - 4" ) (720 :# #4" %"% 6" -& 4 # " " ## %" ! # - $ ! "" ##45## #" 5- 4!%!% ## - (7

6% 4 4#"" "# % # " 4 4 "!"

# %! 5# % " % # % ! 4%!

44 ## 4#!

%! :%! 4#!4 %! " ! # #" #4 %! # -"%!" 4 4 " # 2@ 8+ *8 + 7 8 ,8; = 8+ 8

8 ,8 , 6 (7.1 (0//< %! 3 "&% !4 -- %! "!- % D!" - #! %! 5% &F? 6#"F (( D # 0=2 ((7/86 02 .( =+ +B(81(C7 % 18= G 5% < !"

4#! - # D!4 %! %! !"% 4" " #" !

#! #4 % 4 # %

% "4# # #4 F F%F . D # +.7 G # 4 % # # ! - " ## 4 % #4" 4 "" # ! # !! % # #44%! % "" - " F +/

# %# " " ##

###%" 3"%" H " ##" %

&&1/ $"%!!

H " ## % - " +2 +//8 ## # 4

@ (+ # +//7!$ )<0.7 "+//0 "" % '

0 ) >.5"%!/