Chand Singh v. Gurcharan Singh And ORS
!"
#$ $ % &' ( )* * !"
$ $ +, & !"
$ $ -
$$$$$$++,,&!'
.
$
-
-$ $$$$$$ + ! !'
/"
01 /-$ - -
-/
!"# $$$$ -
-/ $ % & ' ( )% *+ )*), "
%-- . %/00 1 2%/00 34 # !" & 1 2 & 34 " " ' 5" 6 ))/),05 '
( /8 "
# 5" !
' " *- *0 )*)% ) " :
"
" ( # & :
; ; #
-/ -- - 1 -1- -
& 5" " ( # & ( & # ( " ( 5" ( ,
!"# ( "# '
( " " # & '# ' 5"
& # " +
( ( -1 12
/ - - <3
" ! ( ''
' " ( #
& = !
&3 456&
.
$ 3&7 456&
&!
! '8
:
-5+ 6 5 '
&
! " # $" "! %#"& ! !'" & !
#$ !(!
( (! "! " (! & ! # !
'" #
"#" !
(#$& !%"! ! &" & "( $" " ! #& !'" # & # ! & $"&#" "! "" $"&
#
! #& ! " #&$& "! $&!#" $" ! #& " "! "!
!
)* + )"# ,&
+" " - ,.
/0)" *"1/2.
4 ( ! *,!
5!
)**
!6 7"( #&/0*82/
!"! !! $"& (9 :% ( ; ! " (! ! "%!" 5 ( ! ( $"! "!
! ! #$"! (9 5 (!"( ! < # 5"" ( " ! #& ="" ! % ->" & !
( ? ( 3 ( "( ! "
'" $" 5 !@ (
5% ( (&
," $"& # !!& "! ! !
,&" $"&
! !# ( ! #( !"! &
! # ! ("" ( " ! #&"" ! %
!@ ( ! % %%% %%% %%% %%%
! $" ! # ( $" ! " ( &
( ! #&
#!& # "
!# ( ( & "!& ( ( & ( ! #&% #" # !"! ( ( & ( ! #&
! ! $"!> % !
"#'"& % ! #& (!&( ! % ! #&
( & ( # !#& #" !&
! #& & " ! ( ( & ! !!(" "" $# ( !" !
"#$
%
%%
&
%
% '
()( 9
$"! (!10& !
(. 1000@> ! 3 ! ! #& # '" $"& 20A ! '" ! #& '" ! 10A
( &
!#& #" A # ! # " "! & #" ( ! * " # 9 " # !9. 12000@> # 5"" ( "
A " 9 . 800@> " # (9/ !
5"" (9 800%/ 9 . 00@> '
(*(9
$"! ! (!10& (.
1000@>
4 ! " ! ! ! #& ! 20A 4 ! $# "!(! 4 (( & & # ! ( &$# & &#
#" ! "" ( & / * " # 9
" !9. 12000@> # 5"" ( "
/ A " 9. B/000@> " # (9/ !
5"" (9B/000%/ 9. 8 000@> '
(+( 9
$"! B & ! & :(("! " ! ( ! " ! ! !
! # ! /0A $"! !"" ! '"! "( " "" ( & ! /0A
" # 9
"
" "!
( !# &! :( 9. 20000@> # 5"" ( "
/0A %! " 9. 8B000@> " #B & 9 !
5"" (98B000% 9. / 2000@> C- 9
(" !! " ! 6
&
("," * # ! " !!+"
"
%
> <3
" !
, ' + - .
/0 ;9 <:
- = > (
%-- %- %-0 . %/00 ('
14
'
= " "
?
1@4
"
'
' ?
1!4 ' #'
"
?
6 '
"# "
= ( ?
1A4 ' ' ( " ?
"# = #
& '"
&% #"
, " #(" ! & "
!" % "!#. 000. 80000 !. 000&
( ! ! # 6" "! # > '" "
> 7 "!#!(
" '" ! "! # ! (# & & ! "!# 0A & 7 !! !# " #(& ! <3
" !
1 .
1&
$+- "#"#)+2"34
F/
'"!#% !#&"9
% %(5(
%(6(<
! ""( # ( B1& &( $"!( - ," * &5 ! &) !G B0/*H B/00)*
, 82 !$"!( *"6 & ! " !#"! ! # ) ) !G 3
* ! B00*HB)* , ( (" >B & " # ( ( %! #&
! &!"!#& !" !) * ! "
" " # ! # ! /
-
%
%
%78 , ! !
!# !" H (! IG B0*H0)* !) ! + "$ "3 !I B0/*H/)*
7% # " H (! " 9 J , ( & # !
!## !
" &! #& !#& ! ! !
! " ( ( 9
"( ! "
"( !< 5 "!("" <
#& ! ( <
! %"!( &# '"!"! ""< !
5% J C "!D
! # ;! $"!( ) !+ "$ " (
" ! ( &"! !( & # ! '" & " ! ! #&"! ! , " " % ! #& !
@ ; ""
#! &K& "(" B0H " &B01
"$" !#" "!9 J, % 9
"! " "
"
"# #
"! "# #(
"1!8 I ( !
"# "( "
" "
"# #( 7 "! ( %! ( " & "( !#& !" !) * ! "
6 & !
"$" % =" #! 1) !+ "$ "
&( " ! ""
<
! ! # ! 7 ""'" &
! !
( !"" " # !
( ! #& 1 A
'" # $"!( - ," * 5!
" & 2 !( ( "!# 0A " & $
"8 , ! !
! !"( " (A $"! " "!( H (! L "
G ( " !" !#& !" ! !A !#& *"
+0,+-9'0,
" ! &( !
" #& " & "! # !! 9 :
) 5 ( . 828%B%1 @00 . /@> ="" 0 !!
. 80@> ! % "!( ( "
. 8228@> 5 .
00000@> 5
! (& . 0000@> !"( . B00000@>
. 821@>
"! "#! . 821@> ! ( A "
! ! &
=
/ ( 5" ( -) #
" < ( ( '
# "
< ( '# '
6 )****5 " 6 % "
# "
<( "# ( " " '
(;
( ! " #
""
"
('
" '
""
"
(' ""
"
(' ( 6 %%*>-5 " " 6 4##;< %* ( & ( " ( "
' ( :
%% " # # # " ' # "
:
" "
# # '
" " '
"; '# " # ' ' ; # # "
" "
< "
*- *0 )*)% */ *0 )*)% "
D @ E F G < "
)> *0 )*)% *) */ )*)% ( ' '
1 " 4 ( & # " " # ' '
" # # A= !, (
#
( " # " )*8 :
( # & # " "" " '# :
%) & <3 = ! 2=> ?
@
"#"A ',+ 66B '' ' '
:
'
& "
C
+( #>!$"!( $" "! M ! "( "! ! >( " ! #& !" > ! 3 !"! # !
'" > #$"! ! " ! . 00000@> "! ! M !
"( "&" & > #& "
. 000000@> ! #$" ! # " !!
%
& ( '" " ! " ' " 8 ,&?8
'
%, ( 5" ' # ";'
"
# ;# "# "
# ""
& ! ( " )= 2
4
C)0,73B<
"##54 6#""#"3 & "
D)$$1,),$+:)?1
) ! (! 4L#% *"=.
2
+
4"#"#"?+?+ "54
! $"! ! (! #"B& !! ! 0 B00/ ! #!#& 4 #% *"
4>
. ( - BB !B !$"!( "!9 JBB
! ( # !!#& 4( *" . B 00 88& " . 1B0000 N" & & &
"& "!# " "
!!"
"
" ! 7 !"
"
" & ! "&
"& "!# !&! ( " #" ! ( ! (
& (;!#& *"?# !)5!
.
+
" >2
*H / )*
"& & # "
"
! (& ! "" "
G" " ! " !
#(;! ! # !
,"#$"# ! "" !$" (
B1
%%%%% B8
%%%%%
4 ( ! & #
" ! ( ! (& " ! 7 " # (& "( ( ! #!&" (" !
( ! # # ! !
) '" ! " &B8 " ! & ) '" ! "( &# ! & !#" " # # !( ! #!!! ) "!
'" ! "!" !" #!
!#" ) 4 & & B00 ( ! #". 882
7 ! .
000 ! '" ! ". 0000@> . B0000@> "
!"( " ". B20000 ! (
" &!
(
1/
, # 3 #&* 00A ! '""> ! "!# !! ! ( !(& 00A ! #& "!'"! & !( ! ( #& ! "!#'"!
=" 00A! #& > "!'" ! ! "!
!("( !% ="
"
" ! "!! !. 0000@>
) ! '"!00A! #& "!# "
". 0000@> ! "(. B0000@> !
1
, "# ! ! # ( $"! > "! 00A! #& # :% >8 G B0 & ! 1
B00 $"! !
( ( !( =" ! & $"!" # &" ! & !!&
1
&( !! =E ! > '" "" ! B8 " ! & ,=E 4L#)" *" ;! " & "# !! ! ( ( " " (& ! "
*" ( ( ! !!" ! #'"!! ! ! & ! & !" !" " #!
%+ ( '" '
' # # 5" ' $@
@
A$ %- ( "' " ' # &
" = " & ( :
' !
?1-'1C %> ( ( ( )% *+ )*), " '# ( ( # <3
" ! " " " " ( - $
$ &
6+!
&'* !
B& % " 6 %%%**5 ) " 6 %
)**5 16 %%%**5 I %)4 F '
)*8 #
6 )--,*5 16 %
)**5 5 I )*84 + > 6 %0-,0*5 16 )--,*5 I >4 - A= 6 % /),05 > '
6 *****5 !' 6 +****5 / & !' 6 ****5 %* F " 6 +****5 %%
6 >****5 %)
#
%
'&, ) 6+!
&'* !
&B& " $=@%@< =A %, 5)'* !" " ( # & $ @ #@ =A %+ !8&!) &6 5!'
( ) 6+!
&'* !
$@@=
A 9=@%@< = @ #@ =:
%0
# <3
" !
F *.
. "#)+275B ?. 0
.$ , $ + "#""3 + + #5
" # /8 "
"
'
"
D
%/ 6
!"# " '
( ( & ( ( " "
# '" & & " " '
( " )* '
14 # 9-
-/:
$ $ J K ;'5 ;'
;'
K
L