Sujan Singh And ORS v. Superintendent Engineer And ORS
!!" ##$$ % &!
#"' "!" # !"# $%&'( )*+,-( !.(*/,$0!'
("
)"!"($&*+%+ )", "%+% " )"
"" !$$+%+ "!$*" )""
-*$+# .%,"$+/".
!.(*/,$0!'1 &!""*$$# + 0+12+121+ 3
3
+!4" 445 &!$*""6 !4 4# "
!5 "$ -" $.+! !"!%
+ !5 2 "!"+ 7! 8+ /". ! 5 "$ %$$ 96!$+/:1+&!$";!$+ ""
;"4" "4<
0
2=* $$*:.
20
" 1 ! &! 5 $$" " !"+ 8! $$"8 % *" 0
4# " $ > +
?<#"" *!!*" !$$"+!$*" $: @" " 2 !+!$" ":$*% *"1
+!4# "$> +
?<#"" 4 !$*"*"$!$$
?<#"" :
" !"$=!*" *!!!:4# : "! ":.!$*"!#" ##$
" $ "!$*" :4!!$" ":$*!*" $.!4# "$ =!*"4#6# %*!$#$ %$ !$&!%$ !$*$! $#"" /
"!" :4!!,%"4! #$ "44 4 "*" 4# "$! "4 *!!4#!:*"6# %*! ! *"/#".!!*"!#"*
3+!4#:*"!$*""4
#$." $1
3 @!!"!+$" $ "! :4! !$$"!*" "4#/*%"+!$" ":$*!*" $."!4# "$ &!$*"!%#" .$< ##" !"$4 =* :4!%$ !$!"*4 !! :$4:.!$*"/*%"+!# ! ! ! /".! A44 4" "5 $!
%#$ 2
+1
3
/"$" $ "!#"#"
!##"< :6 !#" "5 $*
" "
;" 4" &! ! ! $*"!%$44#: "!$" ":$*>
+
?<#""+:
!.!%#" .$<".!"
%!*!#"$4+A#"$4&!.!% "$ #!#$ :.!,%"4 "444 4$.+!,%"4 /".! #$ 2
+1
3
A 44 4" !$ ! /".&!#$. 2
+#"%!$$! $*"*!!*" !$$"*#" "
0
""#% !+!$$ :$44 44#>+
?<#"" &! "#$. 2
:.!,%"4
0 *"%1
3+" !44 4"! A !."
&!"$%A" #$.+1
3+ "
<
:
A $"" $ "
# :$# "#! /".
&!#"4)4
<<<
? 2
C!#"4)4 "" "+ 44 4 $"" "5 " $ "# :$# "#
"%" #"4*$$!" *" A:.!/".,%"4 $$*
)4 4 $"" " "::$" , "
$#"" )4 4 $" " " " ! /".
:< $ (!6 $ " ! "!
#"#!".!/". $#"" )4 4 $"" "!" ! /".
$#"" &! $" " $ ! $ 4 " #.:$ " ! #"% ! 5 2
*!::"%!*!!#
44"6" !$!%" :$$. &!" "+ /". ,%"4 ! "<" ! 4"!"< A! $"" $$*
)4 4 $"" " "::$" , "
$#"" )4 4 $" " " " ! /".
:< $ (!6 $ " ! "!
#"#!".!/". 1
$#"" )4 4 $"" "!" ! /". 2
$#"" 0 &! $""$ !$ 4 " #.:$ " ! #"% ! 5 2 &!"%"*$$:##$:$$$! 5 *!"*"!%: " "
3 ""#% ! "
!5 2 B &!#$.1
3+!*!!44 4 $""
"!" !/". *""%2+
?<#"" "4 +
?<#""!""##$:$$$!5 *!"*":.!$$"!%: " "
""#% ! =!#"+!*"* :.!$$"
3!#$.1
3+! ##$:$.$
3&! "#$.$"+4.#+:" # %!* !%$ !$&6 ! " +!*"!#"* :.! $$"
3+!$*"!#""%: "4#>2+
?<#"" " ! " 4 :%+ ! #" ##$ " $$*&!*" $" ":$*4 $.!A
%$ !5 "$&!4>2+
?<#"" 4 4 *" %" #!$ &! $*"!$$$:$$$! ".: %$:$ !4 "!
!.(*/,$0!'
2* )03(