High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1210/2022allowed

Makhan Lal Saini v. State Of Haryana And Others

2024-05-20Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia,Ms. Justice Lapita Banerji8 pages

(105)

!"# $"%& " ' & " "'(&" '( )&()"

" * %)&& &(+" )$"% ,,,,

# -" ".& ") & %/&% 0 &&1 && & !!# # &" " "&" && & 2% "& 0 3#&0 &.0 45/6 0"#& .

%" && 7& " "& .

%) "8 .20& 8 8"

&&## .

%&) "")# &2 700"&&2 8# " "".# 0. #" '# %) "&" && 9 7#" & 0 8 "(

8" ":;80( . ( &% 1 "&0 3#&08 8%&2% "

" 8" &2% 8" "8& & (02 "&&) "") 8" "# &. 4#"0

-2- 0 ". "( &

00 "&" "<0 " " && 6/ =( .

%") 8 0 (8

8" "> &) & &&& 7& "&"":;$8(") ."(&%> "% ".;:; &2 & : ? & #&

8" " # 8 &/ 7#" ) #0 #" %"2 & "&# " " "& %" 4 ' ';)@ && "%4 #A . "#" " "(&& 8 % 0 ""0.

"0# "&&". $"% 4..8.&( 2 " 8 7 "

8 "B#"& " %) ".#" # 8 & ". ' ;)@ ' :)@ /9 7#":

!&..#&&; 7#" )

8" "> " 8 7&& " " 7 . #"0 &% " ) "(8"& &8 ; 2% 0. "&" # 7#" #"# " " #2.& 2% 4.. #& 2% '0 0") $"% & ( . 4" " .&) C.") D#"# " 1 &"&""&#&"

!" "

# # # $ % & # ' &

&() *

"! ," "

-3-

8" " 08 " .

%) . %)'<(D#.")8 8. "

%#&) " & 4#"2% 08 "8" 45//6&45; " ( %

00 "&"& 08 ""(1 & 8" 8" & & (0 2 "& (& "&" && 6/ & 2% " 0 * #&" 0 " %0( "&% "02% # " 4" "

"&"80.# &) "") % " " 8 "(& . 8# & 2 "& & &&&2% 0 " " 0"&"1 " ( ""& #&"

-4-

"# $% "$"&

' ( " " 8 .(& 6/ 0 " <0 "(& %0 "%" "(0 "& ?&"%0 "

""""# ) 00"")$"% &( .4" ".&)

# #" ". #&& #2% 0

80"&"9 . /&012 13424561" "

7!,4!8 0 94 " :" "

&# ' &

&1 &(&

1 ; . "<6

= $ 0

># / &?94

% " 8" "

? %

% /&0

," "

-5- / % ! "! ," "

," "

- ; "# 2( "&" 8# &) #) 0 8 & <# .

% " (0 "# .

% & %0 . "%" (&% 2 ". ") ".( # 8 # #"% "". " " "(& ". '0 0" & ..0 # & 8 # (

&0%B#"%)8) #)0. ""& " %) .8(( " #" <#)8 " " 8 "" " " #2.& 2% 4.. '0

8" " 8 " 2 " &#0 & & "8 & 1 "# .

% # .% ( % "0 #) 2# &2() "(# & (2& &8 & %( &% " #" 7 " ? 0" . "

% #& ""

""%0 ""( / ?# "#.) 4"&* &&"& : . ' 2 &

8" " "( & 2 ".& 8 2% 0 0. "&"1 # "# .

% 8 &"&"5" &"&

8" " 2"(0"." #"%" 2" "(8"& &8 8 # &0B#"%& "&" & 0. 8 (") "&" # 8# & 2 #2 ? 2 2"#0 #" ..& "&&:6 7#" 8 #&

-68" " 2% '0 0" " %" 96 " &0 ..&2 8"

& 8"

8#&2"% " " && 7#" ; $8(") 0 (8

8" " "# .

%)8 " &"& " 20 #2 "( 2 0"& 0 $8(") ." 8 "&0

(2&#&0

8" ")" 8 2&B# %. & 9 D 0(8 .## 8 820&"82% .

% E ' :)@) 8 &" . 2 & 8

0.& 8 &&82% 74#"

?' 6/;

4999 &

! " 6/6 44;)8 " ."".2% " 8("& 2% $0 4#" &" " &.0 &%0 " " .# 8"# .

%. 6 74#"# $ %

&' ( ) 69/ 44 & 0"&&.0# " "%"> "%&

82 & " "( .". 7 4#" $ "

)* + 9 9 44;7.& # &". . & 2 & .

% 8

0.& B#"% &2&'# %)8 & 0"""(2%8% "". "

-7- "( 8# &2 " " ".&% &&.0 8# &2 "0 ".&% 5 " %0 # " <#&0. & " ) 74#"#"& #. '# %) 8 & " 8"&0&B#. ". 2 80 " 0 .& 00"(0 & .00 "#. 8# &) #) ( 2 2"(& & .# 2 . %) " 2F '# %) "&" $0 4#") 8 "2% . &28"&&B#( (%" "% 2 %&

8&"88.&& 0.& .

% & # & ". &# # 1 2 ' 8) #) 0( .

% & '9 "1 & " 2 .&" & " ?# "#.)8" &"& &0# ""&&2% "&0 3#&0# &2#2 7 &&82% 74#" ) "&""0. " #" <# (2 ( & *% ("# ". ")

8" "> "0 # .

%. 8 " 2< "&F&.# 2 & ". " 8 8"

7 " % " ( .

%" =( #0 8 "# .

%.)8 " & &B#"%& . &&0$(0&& 2 2

8" " "

. .) 8 " &"& . 8# & " % ( 2 8"&& 1 .# #

-8- "&"&2% 4"&* "

"' #" &"& 8# &2&B#. "( "&"& 2%

8" " ". .2") / .# ".#" 2 & ". ';)@':)@ '# %) "

8& : " &"&"& % &.#' 8 "&8. ". " "& %1 "&" &&9B# &.

" "& 08 "( # "0"&0 "2#&

8" "

" .

%. 8 " "0 7 " ##$#% Amodh Sharma Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No Whether reportable Yes/No