Shanti Devi v. Kartar Singh And ORS












 

 



 

!"#

#$%&%'(
#)*+!*,
-
 .

/"0!'"%
#1% 22#33!'"

4#*&+& 5!*"!*
%'60

"0#*&  #&2'7#'"& 
 !

"#$%&
'( )* & *)
+%,'(-.&

*#&#'"( * *!&0!'"
!*6-
71$!"#
*
*&0%&0
!7!1-
71$!"#- *
"0#
!22#33!'" '#
*
"0#
*#&2'7#'"& 88888







































 *)
+%,' 0#
!22#33!'"923!%'"%
%&
%'
#6+3!*
#$'7
22#!3
!6!%'&"
"0# 7%&/%&&!3

"0#
&+%" #*#
!71#*"%'6
"
"0#
!*6+/#'"&

"0#
3#!*'#7
$+'&#3
*
"0# !22#33!'"923!%'"%-
%"
:+37
)#
!2"
"
6%1#
)*%#
2*#!$#

"0#
!$"& 22#33!'"923!%'"%
%'&"%"+"#7
"0#
&+%"
$3!%/%'6
7#$3!*!"%'
" "0#
##$"
"0!"
"0#
23!%'"%
!'7
7##'7!'"&
-
;
!'7
.
:#*#
"0#
:'#*&

 !'$#&"*!3
!6*%$+3"+*!3
3!'7
/#!&+*%'6
;<
=!'!3&

/!*3!&-
&%"+!"#7
:%"0%' "0#
*#1#'+#
#&"!"#

4%33!6#
+73!-
#0&%3
!**+=0'!6!*-
%&"*%$"
+*6!'

!'7
7##'7!'"
&
!'7

!*#
"0#
&'&

7##'7!'"


##'7!'"
 $!/#
)!$=
"
4%33!6#

00!:3!-
#:
#30%
%'
"0#
0+&#

"0#
23!%'"%
%' +3,-



!'7
*#>+#&"#7
*
2!*"%"%'

"0#
&+%"
2*2#*",
!'7
$3!%/#7
"0# &0!*#
3!%'"%
)#3%#1%'6
+2'
0%&
)*"0#*-
$!/#
"
1%33!6#
+73!
!3'6 :%"0

0#*
)*"0#*
!'7
6"
0#*
"0+/)
%/2*#&&%'
'
&/#
)3!'=
!&
:#33
!&

 ",2#7
2!2#*&
0#
23!%'"%
*#!3%&#7
"0!"-
%'
!$"-
7##'7!'"

/%&+&#7
"0# &!%7
2!2#*&
'
:0%$0
0#*
"0+/)
%/2*#&&%'&
:#*#
)"!%'#7
!'7
$'1#*"#7 "0#
&!/#
%'"
&!3#
7##7
%'
0%&
!1+*
1%7#
4!&%=!
;.
7!"#7
;


%'

*#&2#$"

3!'7
/#!&+*%'6

=!'!3&

/!*3!&
%'
!1+*

7##'7!'"
& "
-
:0
!*#
0%&
&'&
!'7
6*!'7
&'&
0#
23!%'"%-
)#%'6
!'
%33%"#*!"#- &%/23#"'
!'7
%''$#'"
1%33!6#*
7%7
'"
=':
"0#
%'"*%$!$%#&

"0#
3#6!3 %/23%$!"%'&
0#
1%&%"#7
"0#
%$#

"0#
!":!*%
!'7
%"
:!&
!22*%&#7
"
0#* "0!"
*#3#!&#
7##7
1%7#
4!&%=!
;<
7!"#7
;



0#*
&0!*#
0!7
)##'

6"
2*#2!*#7
!3'6
:%"0
"0#
&!3#
7##7-



%'
!1+*

?%"
%'609 7##'7!'"
<-
:0%$0
:#*#
2*#2!*#7
'
"0#
%'&"*+$"%'&

7##'7!'"
 0#
$0!33#'6#
:!&
3!%7
'
"0#
2*#/%&#
"0!"
7##'7!'"

23!,#7
!
*!+7 +2'
"0#
23!%'"%
##'7!'"
&-
-
;
!'7
.
7%7
'"
"+*'
+2
7#&2%"#
&#*1%$#
!'7 :#*#
2*$##7#7
!6!%'&"
 
0#
&+%"
:!&
$'"#&"#7
),
7##'7!'"
& "

!'7
<
'
"0#
:*%""#'
&"!"#/#'"
%3#7
'
"0#%*
)#0!3-
$#*"!%'
2*#3%/%'!*, )?#$"%'&
:#*#
"!=#'
!'7
%"
:!&
&"!"#7
"0!"
"0#
*#3#!&#
7##7
#@#$+"#7
),
"0# 23!%'"%
:!&
0#*
:'
13%"%'
!'7
*##
:%33
!'7
'
*!+7
0!7
)##'
23!,#7
 *#6%&"#*#7
7$+/#'"
$!**%#&
2*#&+/2"%'

"*+"0
+'3#&&
!'7
+'"%3
"0#
*!+7 %&
2*1#7
##'7!'"
<
!3&
%3#7
!
&#2!*!"#
:*%""#'
&"!"#/#'"
!'7
&"!"#7 "0!"
"0#
23!%'"%
:!

&
'
3'6#*
:'#*
%'
2&&#&&%'

"0#
&+%"
2*2#*",
!& &0#
0!7
&37

=!'3&

3!'7

%'
!1+*

7##'7!'"
<
%'$#
"0#
2!*"%#&
:#*#
!"
1!*%!'$#-
"0#
"*%!3
+*"
*!/#7
&#1#' %&&+#&-
%'$3+7%'6
"0#
%&&+#

3$+&9&"!'7% '
&+22*"

0#*
$!&#-
23!%'"%
#@!/%'#7
0?
!?-
3#*=
 +)
#6%&"*!*-
!**+=0'!6!*
!&
A9
!'7
0#*&#3
!22#!*#7
!&
A9
!'

 

    



    



   
   ! """#



   
   ! """#



   
   ! """#



$   
   ! """#% '
"0#
$'"*!*,-
"0#
7##'7!'"&
#@!/%'#7
!&
/!',
!&
%1# :%"'#&&#&
!'7
2*7+$#7
'
*#$*7
"0#
33:%'6
7$+/#'"&(9  &    

 & '!    

 & (
)* +*+ ,-

) % "0
"0#
+*"&
)#3:
7%&/%&&#7
"0#
&+%" * *!&0!'"
!*6
71$!"#
*
*&0%&0
!7!1-
3#!*'#7 $+'&#3
*
"0#
!22#33!'"923!%'"%
&+)/%""#7
"0!"

)"0
"0#
+*"&
)#3: 0!1#
!)7%$!"#7
!'7
$//%""#7
2#*1#*&%",
%'
'"
'"%$%'6
"0#
!$"
"0!"
!
*!+7 0!7
)##'
23!,#7
+2'
"0#
!22#33!'"923!%'"%
),
7##'7!'"

%'
6#""%'6 "0#
":
7$+/#'"&-
%#-
&!3#
7##7
!'7
*#3#!&#
7##7
%'
!1+*

"0# *#&2#$"%1#
)#'#%$%!*%#&
0#
&+%"
:!&
%3#7
:%"0
2*/2"%"+7#-
%#-
' 


"0
"0#
+*"&
)#3:
1#*3=#7
!'7
%6'*#7
"0#
!$"
"0!"
"0# !33#6#7
&!3#
7##7
!'7
*#3#!&#
7##7
0!7
)##'
)"!%'#7
),
"!=%'6
+'7+# !71!'"!6#

*#3!"%'&0%2
#
!3&
&+)/%""#7
"0!"
%"
0!7
)##'
2*1#7
"0!"
"0# !22#33!'"923!%'"%
%&
!'
%33%"#*!"#
!'7

!*7!'!&0##'
C!7,
!'7
'+&
"
2*1# "0#
#@#$+"%'

"0#
!6*##/#'"
:!&
!3:!,&
+2'
"0#
2!*",
),
:0&#1#*
%" 0!7
)##'
#@#$+"#7
0#
&%6'!"+*#&
:#*#
6%1#'
),
"0#
23!%'"%
'
"0#
2*#"#@" 
2!*"%"%'-
)+"
7%7
'"
=':
"0!"
"0#
7##'7!'"&
$'1#*"#7
"0#
&!/#
%'" ":
7$+/#'"&
"
:!&
'
!$$+'"

3+&"

/'#,
!'7
+*6#7
"0%&
+*"
* &#""%'69!&%7#
"0#
$'$+**#'"
%'7%'6&
),
*/+3!"%'6
"0#
&+)&"!'"%!3 >+#&"%'&

3!:
!&
7*!:'
%'
"0#
6*+'7&

!22#!3

 
0!1#
0#!*7
"0#
3#!*'#7
$+'&#3
*
"0#
!22#33!'"923!%'"%- !22*!%&#7
"0#
2!2#*
)=
!'7

"0#
1%#:
"0!"
"0#*#
%&
'
*$#
!'7
/#*%"
%' "0#
!*#/#'"%'#7
&+)/%&&%'&

"0#
3#!*'#7
$+'&#3
*
"0#
!22#33!'"9 23!%'"% 
2#*&'-
:0
!22*!$0#&
"0#
+*"
*
&#""%'69!&%7#

! *#6%&"#*#7
7$+/#'"
'
"0#
23#!

*!+7
!'7
/%&*#2*#&#'"!"%'
*
$#*$%'- 0!&
"
3#!7
#1%7#'$#
%'
"+'#
:%"0
:0!"
0!&
)##'
&"!"#7
%'
"0#
23!%'"
*7#*
<

+3#


"0#
%1%3
*$#7+*#
7#
&2#$%%$!33,
2*1%7#&
"0!"
:0#*#
%'
!33 $!&#&
%'
:0%$0
"0#
23#!7%'6
*#3%#&
'
!',
/%&*#2*#&#'"!"%'-
*!+7-
)*#!$0
 "*+&"-
:%33+3
7#!+3"-
*
+'7+#
%'3+#'$#-
2!*"%$+3!*&
0!1#
"
)#
'#$#&&!*, :#1#*-
'
6%'6
"0*+60
"0#
%'7%'6&
*#'7#*#7
),
"0#
+*"&
)#3:-
%"
%& #&"!)3%&0#7
"0!"
"0#
!22#33!'"923!%'"%
0!&
/%&#*!)3,
!%3#7
"
2*1#
"0# *!+7


!"
!33-
!',
*!+7
0!7
)##'
23!,#7
+2'
"0#
23!%'"%-
'"0%'6 2*#1#'"#7
0#*
"
3!+'$0
$*%/%'!3
2*$##7%'6&
!6!%'&"
7##'7!'"


*#6%&"#*#7
7$+/#'"
$!**%#&
2*#&+/2"%'

"*+"0
0#
&!3# 7##7
2*#&$*%)#&
"0#
2!,/#'"

$'&%7#*!"%'
"
0!&
'"
)##'
2*1#7
' *#$*7
"0!"
"0#
$'&%7#*!"%'

0!7
'"
)##'
*#$#%1#7
),
"0#
23!%'"%
" '3,
"0%&-
#1#'
23!%'"%-
:0#'
!22#!*#7
*
$*&&9#@!/%'!"%'-
$!'7%73, !7/%""#7
"0!"
&0#
0!7
!

22#'7#7
0#*
"0+/)
%/2*#&&%'&
'
"0#
&!3#
7##7
!'7 7%7
'"
7#',
0#*
20"6*!20
&
!*
!&
"0#
&!3#
7##7
%&
$'$#*'#7-
%"
0!&
)##'
&2#$%%$!33, $/#
%'
#1%7#'$#
"0!"
7##'7!'"
<
:%"07*#:
"0#
!/+'"
*/
"0#
)!'=- "0#*#*#-
%"
$!''"
)#
&!%7
"0!"
"0#
&!3#
7##7
:!&
:%"0+"
!',
$'&%7#*!"%' @
%&
"0#
)!'=
&"!"#/#'"
:%"0
*#6!*7
"
"0#
:%"07*!:!3

"0#
!/+'" &
!*
!&
"0#
*#3#!&#
7##7
%&
$'$#*'#7-
"0#*#
%&
'
#1%7#'$# "0!"
"0#
23!%'"%
!'7
7##'7!'"
&
!'7

!*#
"0#
$3&#
*#3!"%'
"
#!

 "0#*

'
1%#:

"0#
!7/%&&%'

"0#
!22#33!'"923!%'"%
:%"0
*#6!*7
"
0#* "0+/)
%/2*#&&%'&
!'7
20"6*!20
!'7
%'
"0#
!)&#'$#

!',
%'6*#7%#'"&
 *!+7
!'7
/%&*#2*#&#'"!"%'-
"0#
+*"&
)#3:
7%7
'"
0!1#
!',
$$!&%' )+"
"
7*!:
!'
!71#*&#
%'#*#'$#
!6!%'&"
"0#
!22#33!'"923!%'"%
0# !22#33!'"923!%'"%
0!&
'"
)##'
!)3#
"
)*%'6
+"
!
7%#*#'"
$!&#
:0#"0#*
"0# %'7%'6&
!33
:%"0%'
"0#
*#!3/

%33#6!3%",
*
2#*1#*&%",
#'!)3%'6
"0%&
+*" "
*!/#
&+)&"!'"%!3
>+#&"%'&

3!:
!&
:!&
+*6#7 '
/,
1%#:-
"0#
!22#33!'"923!%'"%
0!&
/%&#*!)3,
!%3#7
"
2*1# "0#
%'6*#7%#'"&

"0#
*!+7
!'7-
"0#*#*#-
'
6*+'7
*
%'"#*#*#'$#
%'
"0# $'$+**#'"
%'7%'6&
%&
/!7#
+"

&+)&"!'"%!3
>+#&"%'
!*%&#&
* 7#"#*/%'!"%'
),
"0%&
+*"
#&+3"!'"3,-
"0#
!22#!3
%&
7%&/%&&#7
/01,2    *)
+%

345 '(-.& +565478 94

 :49

+565
 60!

:49