Jyoti Manchanda v. State Of Haryana And ANR
$
$
$
$
%"$ ' %"$ ' %"$ ' %"$ '#$9 $:8$&.
#$9 $:8$&.
#$9 $:8$&.
#$9 $:8$&.-
E0$
$& & =$&(,(
!$&
$% & E0$(9 "$ '
'
'
' &$($ '
&$($ '
&$($ '
&$($ ' 5)0#
# 5)0#
# 5)0#
# 5)0#
# ) ) ) ) &0(!
(!
+-"=
$%&
39&$($ $:
&+$" !&,*!= "$ 9&$($ $:
&+$" !&,*!= "$ 9&$($ $:
&+$" !&,*!= "$ 9&$($ $:
&+$" !&,*!= "$
$& %$&$ %$&$ %$&$ %$&$ *60 &0
&, ** &> 7-""
7 &
0
$%&&$(9 "$ 0 0 ?????
?????
?????
????? ) ) ) )-03)6 03)6 03)6 03)6 # # # # &$($ 9$
!
( 8$$ % 7$ $" , "$& #$
< 2 % !$ !
+ #,& +(!
#
.- ($$+ * /, (!
* %
0 "
$"10 0 .-, "$&#$
@%
$ 7"$- 2 3%& (!
!& 4 56- &$*
7
#$ &2-
7( 77(,8($ $/,$ 9& $$"
!$&$% %&: !$:
:97
($ 8$ 0
; <1;
2"
0 0
2
(4 F"$$9# *!=(0
5 7&$ "(
"("
(:
(($"
(>
> = "$&"$&"
$"
0.0 .
3 $A,&$ .6 % 7$" , "$&
.2 % $*
87$
&,:$ - 22 3%&(!& 4
560
:9,* $" 3 ( ($ ,
!$ 9$
!
"6 &$ "(
!,(' B
' .... 2 #
C#
(!&$#!0)#
-"=
& 7
((,$"
2
#
'
; <1;
2 $ 0 &$($ '
(!
$%& :97
0 ,($" 8($ ,($" &$ $ =$" 8 + ",7 ($&=$"
9,87 (!$" 8 > % 9,87
( &$/, &$" , "$& #$
2 &000
&9$& "% "
(!
7(8$$ $A9 &$" (9$&&$9& "
10 0
(($9
$(
$:$ %$A$ ,
* (
87$> 7(&$ &"$" 9&$= ,("
$%!$ *0$ &"- !$ ,& ((
(%
9&$($ $%
,($" ,7"G 8$($ ,&$"8&"
&:$ (0 &"
*7- ,($"
-> %$%#!0#!
+
-&$( %,($ 0 2- - "- (!$&$8"$ 7 &$" (9& 7
:$"9$&( 0
((
*$7$ 9&$7
&$= "$ $8$&$ ($= "$ $, "$&#$
11 &000 ( :97
" >
%,& !$&7$ $= "$ $, "$&
11&000 !$&$%&$-( (!$&$8 7($"8 ,& &"$&0
>
9% (&"$&8$($ !$# $& $" "
%%>
"
&$* $& ($$&($
@
+$ $ $(( & 7$*
, "$& ",$
( ,& & 8$%&$10 0 .0 ,& !$& !$ $& $" # ( "
( $&
9&9$& "$
7( % !$ 9& 7
:$" 9$&( &"$& && , 9& $$"
( 9$& #$
2.0 &00 1@.- !$ $& $" #
=$(
!$ 9&$($ :
$& 8
+
, !$ " ,:$ ( %& &$(
79&%$ '(,8:
$"8 !$9& 7
:$"9$&( >!
7$9$
, >
!$ $& $" 8 + % >!
! !$/,$ /,$(
9&$($ ($ > ((,$"0 ) % 9&9$& ( >$77 $&
=$ 8 +
, % ,($" 9&= "$" 8 !$ :97
0 ( "$&
%&$(
"%
!$ 79
7$% >
( ,&
!$$A
+ , % ,($" (9$& !$/,$ /,$(
-"$
7(%>!
&$
87$ ($&$ &" 0$0 , 8$ * 0 .@<2<>
!8 +
:$7#
$ +% + $& "
9,&-
7> "- &
!>+- " 0 9% (&"$&8$($
*$&% $& $"8 +-(
!$8 + , % ,($" "% 7$ :97
$ &$9& >- :$ ,9 10 0 . %& >
* 00 ,& !$& :97
( "
% 7$ 7 % := ::= 9&9$& % ,($" "
$% A$"%&
+ *%,& !$&
(9$&7 >0
%&"$&'.0 0
(!#3
&, !
,"!
&6,"
7
$ 7 (( 0 10 "
7 $ #
' "
$ &"$& %&: !$ ,& % #
&, !
,"!
&- > &$ $ =$" 8 9( - >!
$& &$*
% &$* &"
* %% $- 9 $( &$ 8$ * 9&$9 &$" %&: :9, $& " 8$ * ($ $& $" %%
7( !&,*! 9( 0 9 % (
$:$ 7* >
! >
!97 $ % 7$ 8$ * ($ ; # @ !&,*! 9( %& %,& !$& 9& $$"
*(0
$',$ % ;#@
#- > &$* % # C D !$ 9&$($ $ % # #,&$ "$&0 $'
# > ( 9&$9 &$" >
! "$7 ",$ ($&=$& "> 0H .0 )$ & $" , ($7 %& !$ 9$
$& !
( (,8:
:9,* $" - !
( *$ $( (- &
7 :97
%
9$
$&3!$&$ 6, "$&#$
9& $$"
*(>!$&$%
$&> ("$ 7 &$" 9& 7
:$"9$&( I!$ $ :9,* $" 8$* &$*
$&0)$ & $" , ($7%& 9$
$& !
&*,$"
!$ &"$& 7( !$ 9& $$"
*( "$ 7 9$
$& 9& 7
:$" 9$&( &$ :
%$( 7 77$*
&9&= (%7 >0
(8$$ %,& !$&
$&
!$ &
. :97
, "$&#$
-!
7&$ "8$$ >
> 7 9
$( !
" $
($
7$:$ " !$ $ ,($%,7 9,&9($ >,7"8$($&=$"8
% !$9& $$"
*(/, :9,* $" 0
8,
&$(( (9$ %!
&*,:$ -7$ & $" , ($7%&
$&!
&$7 $" ,9 !$ &"$& "
$" 0.0 . 9 (($" 8 !$ $& $" ,"
$>!
!&$ "( !,(' B 7$
+$ ,9 "
(,:: ($ % 7$ %&:&$ &"&: "($$+ *9$&:
(( >
!$( (:=$" 8 !$ :97
!&,*! , ($70 #,:: $"&$ &"&$ $ =$"0
8$&$( &$"
(&
79(
0 ( (
*$ :97
(,%%$&$" ($9
$ (
$:$
!$ !
:9&:
($" >
,($" ( 9$& "$$" % :9&:
($ " !$ !
&$ $ =$" !$ !$/,$ :, >!$"$( >
9,&(,$%,& !$&>
!$ 9&$($ :97
!$&$%&$- !$ >
!$ 9$($ :97
$:$ &$ &"$"0:97
(",7
$"8!
( , ($70 9 % :9&:
($"$$"97 $" ($% 7$0 $ &"0 = $>% !$(
$:$ (:
"$8 !$ :97
-9&$($ :97
( "
(:
(($" ( >
> 0 7$ 8$ ( * $" !$ &$ &"(
$&",$ :97
$0H !$ ( &$ * ! % 8=$ &*,:$ (- 7$ & $" , ($7 %& 9$
$&!
(9&$(($"%&*&
%9$
"0 0 =$&($7- 7$ & $" #
$ , ($7 !
( (,8:
:9,* $" &"$& > ( 9 (($" (7$7 !$ *&, " % 8($ $ % 9$
$&0 $ !
( &
($" (,8:
((
"$: >
!$ &$97 "
@020 < 8 > % %%
%
$(! D,:
&- #- ((
::
(( $&% 7 $- 8* &! "- % ,& "
0 $- !>$=$&-"$( "
(9, !$%
!$9
$(!
=$
87&$(7=$"
!$:
$& !$:
:97
(
"("
(:
(($" (>
> 0 <0
$ 99$ &( 8$!
7% % &$(9 "$ 0 "$(9
$ ($&= &$9& 8$$%%$ $",9 !
:0 0
!
=$ !$ &" 7$ & $" , ($7 %& !$ & 7 9
$( " !
=$ 9$&,($" !$9 9$&8+0
@0
!$($:
7/,$(
($(%& ( "$&
!$9&$($ 9$
>!$ !$& :9,* $" 3 7( 9& $$"
!$&$%&:6, "$&#$
@% "$($&=$( 8$/, (!$"
7:
A% !$9&$($ ($0 20 ( F, ,&$J
>,7" 8$ 99(
&$%$& !$&$ F,"*:$ % (,& 9 (($" < < 1 1 1 1 1
1
1
1
(!
::
!
::
!
::
!
::
%
=(0#
$% &
%
=(0#
$% &
%
=(0#
$% &
%
=(0#
$% &
-"$ "$" 0@0 .
"$" 0@0 .
"$" 0@0 .
"$" 0@0 .J&$7$=
>!$&$% "( (, "$&' B.0 = $> !$%
$& !$9&
97$9& $$"
>!
$& > ("$ 7 &$"& 7
:$"%%$ "$&(
" 7,"$"- !$/,$(
>,7" ($
('K>!$ !$& !$* =$ & ,:(
$(-9& $$"
*(, "$&#$
@%
9,&(,
0 < "
$" @ ! % =$:8$&- @ 8$
77>$"
,$0 0 !$ /,$(
%& :$" ( :&$ &$(
$*& 7&$ " (
"(
(>$&$"8&"
$$ !% (,& .2 . 2
(G 7"$=!
" 7=0#
$% &
!$&G= "$&"$&"
10 0 1->!
!!$7" (, "$&' B& $& ( 9$
( %& /, (!
* % 0 "
<0 @ % 7$" , "$& #$
@ %
$ 7 "$ &$*
7 $ #
#$ &<- !+,7 77 !$& (,8($/,$ 9& $$"
!$&$% ( >$77 ( &"$& "
0 0 9 (($"8
7,& = "$>!
"
>
((,$" &$* $& %&$(
" 0G LL LLL LLLL )$ & $" , ($7 %& !$ 9$
$& !
( &$7 $" ,9 !$ "$ ( &$ "$&$"8 (,& GC + (#!
&:
=0,&9&$$ # *!D!7
!$& 3(,9& 6- @- 3.6 )000<2- &/, $ ! )
" !$&( =0 #
$ % &
!$&- < 3.
6 3&
76 @1 " G F $$(! D!
=0 #
$ % &
!$&G @ 3.6 )000 <<< >!$&$
& ,:(
$- (,& (!$7"
( !$:
9$
% , "$& #$
.2 % !$ (
"( >
> = $> %
87$($
7$:$ 8$ >$$ !$9
$(- !$&$%&$-
% 9& $$"
*( , "$& #$
@ % (!
77 8$ * 8,
8,($% !$9& $((%7 >0 LL LLL LLLL
= $> % !$ ( :$- % " :$&
!$ 9&$($ 9$
&"
*7- 9&$($ 9$
77>$" :9,* $" &"$&
0 0 9 (($" 8 ,"
7
$- ( 7 ((- !+,7 (>$77 ( 0"
$" <0 @&$* $&$", "$&
@%
$ 7"$
7 $#
#$ &<- !+,7 77 !$&(,8($/,$ 9& $$"
!$&$%- &$ !$&$8/, (!$"0G <0# !$= $>% !$&&"
$$ ! !$G(!+
=0
$ % &
!$&G &$9& 36 3&
76 2@- >!$&$
(8$$ !$7"
' ",8 !$7$ & $" , ($7%& !$&$(9 "$ (=$!$:$ 7
&*,$"
!$%%$ $, "$&#$
@ 000 "$9$ "$ % !$:
($- !$&$%&$-:$&$78$ ,($ !$:
($!
(8$$ (:
(($"%&>
%9&($ ,
- !$9&$($ 9$
8$
77>$"- !>$=$&- +$$9 = $> !$ %
!$ 9&$($ > (&$* $&$" 7 , % 8($ $%&: !$9& $$"
!$ :
($ >!
! !
" 8$$ (,8($/,$ 7 &$*,7 ($" 8 ,& >!
7$ *&
* 8
!$ 9$
$&- !$ "$% ,7 ( " " $"0 (, ! & ,:(
$(-
% 9& $$"
, "$&#$
@)00(!
778$ 8,($% !$9& $((% ,& 0 @0 &"
*7-
77>$"0 0"
020 @-&$* $&$", "$&#$
@ 00
7 $#
D > -
"- (>$77 ( ($/,$
79& $$"
(!
77(
"/, (!$"0H 20 0 &$&$ $ 7- !$ 587$#,9&$:$,& F,"*:$
( 7F
# *!=(0#
$% &
" !$& 7F
# *!=(0#
$% &
" !$& 7F
# *!=(0#
$% &
" !$& 7F
# *!=(0#
$% &
" !$&-&
799$ 0.<1 % "$ "$" 0 0 <J!
(!$7"
' B@0. >- >!
!
99$ ( % !$ (
,( , "$&#$
2 &000 ,77 0$0- !$ 9$&( (,8F$ (, ! 9& 7
- 8 = ,$ % (,8($/,$ "$=$79:$ ( 7 *$&&$/, &$" 8$9&$($ $"8$%&$ ,& %7 >0 !$ - !$9&($ ,
(
779& $$"
(, ! 9$&( %&!
* 99$ &$"8$%&$ ,& ",&
!$9& $(( > $%%$ (>$& %% &:
=$0M$( (%& !$%77> ( (' 6
!$7 *, *$%#$
@- ( (B>!$=$&%
7(
99$ &
!$(9$ $"97 !$(9$
(&$/, &$"8 9& 7
EH0 :97 $(
!$ =$&
>!
9$&( ("
99$ &- "!$"$( "(- (#$
:$(
97 J 3
6 M!
%,& !$&%7>(%&: !$7 *, *$$:97$"
$% 99$ $8$ :$( %&
% !$#$
-
!$&$%&$- 9&($ ,
!$&$%& >,7" 8$ "$9$ "$ %#$
2 -&0008$ $%%$ J
6 #- >!
7$ 9& $$"
*( , "$&#$
@ 8$
"$9$ "$ %#$
2 - &000- 0$0- 7 8$
$"9( ((, $%9& 7
- !$
,$ %
"9& 7
( 7 *$& $%%$ =6M$%
!$$7!
*!,&
+$ (= $>- 0$0-
#$
@- (
" 7 $%%$ $ ,+$(!!
,+$(!!
,+$(!!
,+$(!!
=0#
$3 %$7!
6
# ) $$7 .J =0#
$3 %$7!
6
# ) $$7 .J =0#
$3 %$7!
6
# ) $$7 .J =0#
$3 %$7!
6
# ) $$7 .J = C$&:
= C$&:
= C$&:
= C$&:
=0 #
=0 #
=0 #
=0 #
. # ) $ $7 1J . # ) $ $7 1J . # ) $ $7 1J . # ) $ $7 1J# :$$ I &0 =0 #
:$$ I &0 =0 #
:$$ I &0 =0 #
:$$ I &0 =0 #
% $7!
I &0 &70 00 0 @ % -
$" @ % $7!
I &0 &70 00 0 @ % -
$" @ % $7!
I &0 &70 00 0 @ % -
$" @ % $7!
I &0 &70 00 0 @ % -
$" @
-
-
-
-
& !$&$ ( ( %&$(
$"->$ *&$$>
!$% "$ !$($ F,"*:$ (;&"$&(0 !$ (
:$-
(
"(
>$!
=$ ::$ $" !$:$&
(% ($(0 3=6 &
!$ %%$ $ 9&$( & 8$" #$
@
"$$"(
" 7 $-* =$
($(, % &
7%%$ $ $
>
! >!
! 9& $$"
*( , "$&#$
2 &000
!$(
"%%$ $ ,($"(
"(-(,8($/,$ 7-
/,
$"-
>,7"8$9$&:
(( 7 >%& !$,& ($ N$"%
7, "$&(, !%%$ $-
+$ $%(, ! "$=$79:$
!$ ( *&, " "& !$ 9& $$"
7($- (!,7"(, ! 9& $&8$:
"$ & ,:(
$(% ($( > &&
20
7,( ->$!7"
#$
@ "$9$ "$ (,8(
=$ %%$ $-
,$ $=$ % !$ 9& 7
, "$&#$
2 - &000 ( $A
*, (!$"0
(
" 7 $ %%$ $0 AAAAAAAAAH
>$=$&- !$ 587$ #,9&$:$ ,& /, (!$" :9,* $" 3 !$&$ 6, "$&#$
@% ( $-
$&
!$&
%%$ $ !$%&:% &
7 :97
, "$&#$
- 22
!$(
($!
"8$$ ($
">
> 8 !$& 79
$(0 10
( %& !$ *! ,& - >!
7$ $A$&
$ 97$ & 9>$&( , "$& #$
< 2 % ##- .; 2 % &000- 1@.-
(!,7" 997 !$ 7 ,( $&$-
"$:
$A
$ !
7 :
$&- >
!, ( "$&
( 9&
:97
(0
!$) ( :$&$7 ($ %9&*& ::$"-
7$" !$*&, "&,7$(- 8$ $">
!, $A
:,( 8$$ %& $"->!
7$8$ :
"-
(9,&9($ $ (,&$(,8(
=$F,(
$8$ >$$ !$9
$(0 !$(
& 9&= % #$
@ % - >!$ 9$&,($" !$ 7 *!
% &
"$ "
% !$F,"*:$ % !$ 587$#,9&$:$,& 7F
# *!5( 7F
# *!5( 7F
# *!5( 7F
# *!5(
($3(,9& 6-, $/, = 77(!>(
, "$&#$
@%
"$( 9&9& = *&$8$ :$7
8$/, (!$"- ($ !$&
$(!
=$$
:9&:
($ "(, ! &
7 :97
; !
8$$ :9&:
($" " /, (!$";>
> &"
*70 >$=$&-
:$- !$ %
,: % !$ &
7 :97
; 3 %,& !$& $ % 9& $$"
*( >!$&$%6 !
* 8$$ :9&:
($";($
7$"- ",8
87- &$7$=
%
& 8$ ( "$&$">!
7$"$ *>
97$ %&/, (!
*% 3 7(9& $$"
*($:
!$&$%&:6, "$&#$
@% 0
( %
((,:$( *&$
$& (
$ ( "$&
9& $$"
*( 9$&
$A 7,( =$7 9&
$ &
7 :97
, "$&
- 22 ->!
!$7$* (7
,&$!
($A9&$((7 7 ((
:9, "
87$%%$ $0 #, ! 7
- $(9$
77 !$ 8 +"&9 % &
7%%$ $!
*8$$ :9&:
($"> 77!
=$ "=$&($ :9
@
!$ =$&8,&"$ $" ,& " +$ (0 77> * (, ! 9&($ ,
- >!$
:97
(8$$ ($
7$";>
> >,7", "$&:
!$7$* (7
=$
""
& !$&$:$"
,&$%#$
% 22 0
>,7"
:, =$ !$ 9&
97$( % %
& $((- 9&9&
- F,(
&
79& $$"
*(07
$&
$&9&$
:
(:$
:$(7$
, F,( , :$(
7(
!$ 7 >5( , "$&7 $" 9,&9($0
!$&$%&$- !$ *!,& , "$&
!$&$ F,& ("
:,( 8 7$
$& % ) > >
( (9
- $ (,& * %
& " $/,
87$ &$(,7 (0
99& ! , "$&( &$( ) >5( &7$
,( %& %( $& * (
&: ""&$(( !$ &$ 7>&7" :97$A
$(- $%%
,(7 7( $%%$
=$7-&
!$& :$&$7
$& 7;
$ !
7 :97
$0 0
!$&$ F,& ("
, "$& #$
< 2 ##- .;
2 &000- 1@. (9& 7
:$"
9&$=$
8,($%F,"
9& $(( " ($ ,& !$ $ "( % F,(
$0 !,(- >!$ !$ "
(9, $(($
779$&(
,&$ *$ , $ :9&:
($!
(8$$ &$ !$"-
!$ *! ,& :
$&=$ $ /, (! !$ &
7 9& $$"
*(- &$ * N !$
!$&$%>,7"8$ 9&",
=$ ", F,(
!$* =$ & ,:(
$(0 !$&$ 9>$&(% *!,& &$9>$&( >!
&$
7 &$97$ $ 9>$&(- >!
% "
" ( $A !$ ,& >,7"8$87 *$" (
(
77 "!$797$((7($$ !$9& $((%7 ",& 8$ 8,($"%& !$9,&9($(% F,(
$0 !$&>&"(J(, !9>$&3(6
*! ,&
( =$& 7 %$87"-
( =$& $(($ $-
::
8, $0M
!, (, !9>$&3(6- *!,& >,7"!
=$%&: 8, 7 + !$(,8(
$0 !$($9>$&(% *!,& !$ $"$($&=$ 8$ ( &,$">
!$> "$( 9(( :97
,"$0 !$($ !$&$ 9>$&( &$ ( $>
,&$% *!,& >!
!,*!
8$- "!
2
8$$ - =$( $" >
! 9>$&3(6 :
!&
9&$=$ 9& $(( % 7 >;,& ( 8$ * 8( &, $" & 8,($"0
$ 9(
( % F,& (9&,"$ $
!,*!7 >(
$:9 "$ 7>
77 ($(
:
($-
$ = % & ,:(
$( >!
! (!
9$ $=$
:9$&%$
( % 7 *, *$ :
+$
:9(( 7 "> 9&= (
87$%*=$& *$=$& ($->!
%
($(0 *!,& >!
$A ( %& !$ %,& !$& $ % F,(
"$%
87$ :
$&- (!,7"
!$&$%&$-!
=$, %$
$&$"9>$&3(6 "$ 7>
!(
(>!
!- !,*! $A9&$((79&= "$"%&8 !$7 >- $$" 8$"$ >
!- 9&$=$ F,(
& 8,($% !$9& $((%7 ",& (0 !$F,&
78 (% !$($ 97$ &9>$&3(6 !&
J %
!$($:
7", "&$(9 (
% *!,& J ,9!7"- 9& %,7% 77 !$F,"
7%,
%
":
$& * F,(
$- &"
$ >
! 7 >- &$*,7 &- &"$&7 $%%$
=$ :
$&0 !$& >&"(J #$
< 2 % ##- . &$%7$ 9$$&7$((9>$&(->!
*!,& :
"& >,9 ( $ $(( &>!$ $=$&
(F,( "$/,
"(- 9
,7 & $ (,&$ !$8($&= $% ",$ 9& $(( % 7 >- 9&$=$ =$A
& 99&$(( - " F,(
(,8(
7F,(
$8$ >$$ !$9
$( ($ ,&$ !$$ "(%F,(
$0 D$$9 = $> !$ $
%
$ "
* %
& ,:(
$(% ($ "J$(9$
77 !$&
7%%$ $8$ %%$ $ , "$& #$
.2 % $*
&,:$ ( % 22 - &
7%%$ $ 77$*$" !
=$8$$ ::
!$$ & 2- !$(,8F$
$& % !$ &
7 %%$ $ !
* 8$$ ($
87 8$ >$$
$( !$ &
7 :97
, "$&#$
8$$ >
> !$ 8 ( % (, ! ($
7$:$ ; :9&:
($J ( ,&
1 "$$:(
99&9&
:9,* $" 7( 77 9& $$"
$:
!$&$%&:"$($&=$ 8$/, (!$"0
(-!$ $-"
(, "$&' 6
9$
77>$"J
6
!$ 0 "
$" 10 0 .- , "$& #$
@ %
-&$*
7 $#
#$ &2- 7( 77(,8($/,$ 9& $$"
!$&$%&:(
"/, (!$"J
6 779$ "
3(6- % -(
"("
(9($"%0 3# )6 3# )6 3# )6 3# )6 #$9 $:8$&.
#$9 $:8$&.
#$9 $:8$&.
#$9 $:8$&.- & M!$ !$&(9$ + *;&$ ( $"' $(;
M!$ !$&&$9&
87$' $(;