High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/140/2013dismissed

Om Parkash Singla v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2023-04-12Mr. Justice B.S. Walia7 pages

!"#"$%&%'

() *++",, '! -".&/& * "&+'#"'!& 0 1)

."&"'!0

. '3%4/+! 5#4$ !".!6" ++",, '!

. !%&6%'7, 55 .8 ' .."&+'#"'!&!

&&6%! "7%5#4$ !". . 9%! /! 95#4$ !". ."&+'#"'! ::: ;< '&! '! "7/, . "$'# ++" , 6 & =""' %,"# 7 %'&! !6" 3/#79"'! '# #"$."" # !"# > + &&"# =8 !6" ," '"# ##%!%' , %&!.%$! /#7"5 %.& %' %4%, ++" , ?@ /+6,#%'7 !6" 3/#79"'! '# #"$."" # !"# AB + &&"# =8 !6" ," .'"# %4%, /#7"

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

;< ,,!!"# +,!/'#".!6"&$6"9" ,'7D%!6 $@"9+,8""5=/! $!/ ,,856" D & ,,!!"#6 ,+,!&%G"9" &/.%'7A1HFI1D6%,"!6"!6".6 ,+,! D & ,,!!"# ! 6%& $@"9+,8"" %"

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

8%'7 . #"$."" 9 '# !.8 %'3/'$!%' . #%."$!%'7 !6" #""'# '!&E."&+'#"'!& ! ,,! '" +,! ! 6%9 %' /'%$%+ , /'$%, ,'85"7/ #5%.& .%' '8!6".$,'8!6"99%!!""%',%"/ 6%&."9 %'%'7&6 ."!6"+,! '#!6 '#4".!6"+&&"&&%'!6"& 9" !6%9 ;< ' ."&+'&"5 #""'# '!E."&+'#"'! K /'%$%+ , /'$%,5 %.& %,"# D.%!!"' &! "9"'! D6%," #""'# '!&E."&+'#"'! & ! #+!"#!6"& 9"""'# '!E."&+'#"'!%'%!&D.%!!"'&! "9"'!!C /+ !6" &! '# !6 ! !6" +, %'!%E ++",, '! 6 # ."%."# .9 &".4%$" ' B '##/.%'7&".4%$"56"D & ,,!!"# +,!%' /'%$%+ ,/'$%, ,'85 %& . #5 %.& D6"." & '" +,! #3%'%'7 !6" +,! !6" +, %'!%E ++",, '! D & ,,!!"# ! 6%& $@"9+,8"" ' 9",8 95 .%4".

'#% '8!6".+,!6 #=""' ,,!!"#! 95.%4".!6"'!

;< & 9" 9/&! 6 4" =""' ,,!!"# & +". ./,"& '# !". !6" & '$!%' !6" 4".'9"'! '# % !6" +, %'!%E ++",, '! 6 # '8 7.%"4 '$" !6"' 6" D & ."J/%."# ! . %&" =3"$!%' ! !6" .","4 '! !%9" ="." !6" $9+"!"'! /!6.%!%"& ," !6" +, %'!%E ++",, '! !6 ! !6" #""'# '!&E."&+'#"'!& 6 # 7%4"' &&/. '$" ! ,,! '!6". +,! ! 6%9 D & #"'%"# '# %! D & /.!6".$'!"'#"#!6 !!6"+, %'!%E ++",, '!6 # $$"+!"#!6" ,,!9"'! !6" +,! %'%!% ,,8 ,,!!"# ! 6%9 D%!6/! '8 ."&".4 !%'5 !6 ! %' !6" 8" . A??5 !6" /'%$%+ , /'$%,5 %.& 6 # ,,!!"# +,!& ! "9+,8""&

/'%$%+ ,/'$%,5%.& %' /'%$%+ ,,'8%.& &+"../,"&=/!!%,, # !"& '$!%'.!6"& 9"6 #'!=""' $$.#"#=8!6"4".'9"'! '# !6"." D & ' J/"&!%' !6" #""'# '!&E."&+'#"'!& $!%'7 %' #%&$.%9%' !.8 9 ''". "&! !6" 4".9"'!& 9 #" %' !6" +, %'! D"." #"'%"# '#+. 8".D &9 #".#%&9%&& ,!6"$%4%,&/%! ;< ' !6" +," #%'7& !6" + .!%"&5 !6" ,,D%'7 %&&/"& D"." . 9"#0@

" # ;B< '!6"= &%&!6"+," #%'7& '#"4%#"'$"&,"#=8!6"+ .!%"&5 !6"," .'"#!.% ,/.!#%&9%&&"#!6"$%4%,&/%!D%!6$&!&D6%,"!6" ++" , %,"#=8!6"+, %'!%E ++",, '!9"!D%!6!6"& 9" !"

;< ;>< )" .'"# $/'&", . !6" +, %'!%E ++",, '! $'!"'#"# !6 ! !6" +, %'!%E ++",, '! D & "'!%!,"# ! ,,!9"'! +,! ! + . D%!6!6" !6". "9+,8""%" 95.%4". '#'$" ,,!9"'!D &9 #"%' 4/. !6"!6"."9+,8""5!6"+, %'!%E ++",, '!D & ,&"'!%!,"#!!6" ,,!9"'! +,! D%!6/! '8 #%&$.%9%' !%' "4"' !6/76 & '$!%' 6 # '! =""' $$.#"#E ++.4"#=8!6"4".'9"'!. ,,!9"'!+,!&%' /'%$%+ , /'$%, ,'8 %.& 5 %' .#". ! 9 %'! %' /'%.9%!8 '# +, %'!%1&E ++",, '!1& $, %9 $/,# '! =" #"'%"# ',8 ' 7./'# ,%9%! !%' ;F<

". $'!. 5 ," .'"# ++" .%'7 ' ="6 , ."&+'#"'! &! '# &&6%! "7%5#4$ !" ++" .%'7. . 9%! /! 95 #4$ !" . ."&+'#"'! 4"6"9"'!,8 ++&"# !6" $, %9 !6" +, %'!%E ++",, '! '#$'!"'#"#!6 !=!6!6"/.!&=",D6 #+ &&"# 4".8D",,." &'"#.#". !".! C%'7%'! $$/'! ,, &+"$!&!6"9 !!". '#!6 !%'!6"$%.$/9&! '$"&5!6"& 9"#%#'!D .. '! '8%'!"."."'$" ;?< 6 4"$'&%#"."#!6"&/=9%&&%'&," .'"#$/'&", ;A< #9%!!"#,85 !6" +, %'!%E ++",, '! D & ' "9+,8"" !6"

/'%$%+ , /'$%,5 %.& '# ."!%."# .9 &".4%$" ' !! %'%'7 !6" 7" &/+". ''/ !%''BD6%,"D.C%'7 &$$/'! '!%'!6"%$"

/'%$%+ ,/'$%,5%.& 26%,"!6"+, %'!%E ++",, '!D &&".4%'7/'#". #""'# '!E."&+'#"'! 5 4".'9"'! .8 ' $ .4"# /! +,!& %'

/'%$%+ ,/'$%,,'85%& . #5%.& . ,,!9"'!!6"& 9"! "9+,8""& /'%$%+ , /'$%,5 %.& %' !6" 8" . AF 6" +, %'!%E ++",, '!D & ,,!!"# +,!/'#".!6"&$6"9" ,'7D%!66%&$@ "9+,8""=/!7.%"4 '$"!6"+, %'!%E ++",, '!%&!6 !6"D &7%4"'',8 6 ,+,!9" &/.%'7A1HFI1D6%,"!6"."9 %'%'76 ,+,!D &7%4"'! '!6"."9+,8""' 9",8 9 '#6" $$"+!"#!6"+,! & ,,!!"#!

;B< 6%9 ' !6" &&/. '$" !6 ! 6" D/,# =" 7%4"' '!6". +,! &/=&"J/"'!,8 #9%!!"#,854! /'%$%+ ,/'$%,5%.& $ .4"#/! '!6".$,'8. ,,!9"'! +,!& ! "9+,8""& !6" /'%$%+ , /'$%,5 %.& ! "7/

#5 %.& %' D6%$6 95 !6" $@"9+,8"" %& &! !"# ! 6 4" =""' ,,!!"# +,! F ,,"7"#,8 %' ,%"/ 6 , +,! ,,!!"# ! 6%9 %'

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

7. '!"# =8 !6" 4".'9"'! !%,, # !" " !6 ! & %! 9 85 '$" !6" +, %'!%E ++",, '!6 # $$"+!"#!6"+,! &D & ,,!!"#!6%9%'!6"8" . AFD%!6/! '8#"9/..+.!"&! ,,"7"#,8'!6"= &%& &&/. '$"6",# /!=8!6"#""'# '!&E."&+'#"'!&!6%9 &D",, &!6%&$@"9+,8""

9 '#&/=&"J/"'!,85%'!6"8" .A?? +,!D & ,,!!"#! 95 $@"9+,8""!6"+, %'!%E ++",, '! '#'!!!6"+, %'!%E ++",, '!5!6"' !6" 7.%"4 '$" %' ."&+"$! !6"."! /76! ! 6 4" =""' 7%! !"# =8 !6" +, %'!%E ++",, '! ="." /.! , D D%!6%' +".%# ,%9%! !%' ' J/".85," .'"#$/'&",.!6"+, %'!%E ++",, '!$'$"#"&!6 !'7.%"4 '$" %'."&+"$!!6"."!D & 7%! !"#=8!6"+, %'!%E ++",, '!="." /.! , D+.%.!!6"%,%'7!6"%4%,/%!%'!6"8" .>/!D6%$6!6" %'&! '! "7/, ."$'#++" , .%&"&

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

A?? $$.#%'7,85 %' !6" ,%76! !6" +&%!%' '!"# =4"5 ' 9",8 !6" +,! 6 4%'7 =""' ,,!!"# ! !6" +, %'!%E ++",, '! %' !6" 8" . AF5 & ," #""# 6 4%'7=""'"H"$/!"#%' 4/.!6"+, %'!%E ++",, '!%'!6"8" .A?5 ,,!9"'! +,! &/=&"J/"'!,8 6 4%'7 =""' 9 #" =8 !6" #""'# '!&E."&+'#"'!& ! !6". "9+,8""& %' /'%$%+ , /'$%, ,'8 5 %.& %' !6" 8" . A?? '# ' 7.%"4 '$" 6 4%'7 =""' 9 #" =8 !

;F< +, %'!%E ++",, '!="." /.!, DD%!6%'!6"+".%#,%9%! !%'5!6" $%4%, &/%! %,"# =8 !6" +, %'!%E ++",, '! /. 8" .& !". 6%& ."!%."9"'!5 %' 4"9=".5 > %&6%76,8 =", !"# '# 6%! =8 ,%9%! !%' $$.#%'7,85 ' 7./'# D6 !&"4". %& 9 #" /! . %'!".".%'7 D%!6 !6" D",,@." &'"# 3/#79"'! '##"$.""+ &&"#=8!6"/.!&=",D ;< &/=&! '!% ,J/"&!%', D9/$6,"&&J/"&!%', D .%&"& .$'&%#". !%'%'!6%& ++" ,6"%'&! '! "7/, ."$'#++" ,%&="."! 9".%! '#%&5 $$.#%'7,85#%&9%&&"#

2) $% & ' ( )

* + , *- + , *-