High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/5286/2023dismissed

Monika Dalal v. Subhash Chander Kapur And Another

2023-09-18Mrs. Justice Amarjot Bhatti12 pages

!"! # $$

%&'(( ( ) *+&)

, )!

! , -./01 %!

23%451 ,, 24 /,445 # $$ %&&'&'! ! ((((( ,, 24 /,4456 2!

) ! $ %& &'&' )& *'" ) !

+,'

, +'-*) * "&* .&"&''

) "&"/0/1

3!&"45'&

" ,' ". 1 , 36 &7 ,' 8 - * / '" &

9) 45 ) !! 5 *' 9 &7 )& 4 &''5 & "

"'4 &'5"+' " &+ 7! 7&

45)'&

" "

**+ 6 4'&& ,'& * "&"//0/!&"45)

:;:<*/1

3 . 7 &",& +"45'&

"+ '* )! $

&%)& 6 ",+& & " $ , $&'% & " $ &=& $ ",+&* ! 9 )& " "&' )'&"&*)& . )&",+&& &4& .* 79 %"&59, 6)! ! >&

"+ '* )! & . ")&)!

)&"&!!

&+)")

:;:<*/ 9)+) "&"

//0/1

39&!&"45)+ ,"9)+)45&% &' ,9 **+,!! 59&.

")! $$ %&&'&'*'9 &7 ) 2"&*)& *2"4* ) &' 6 4=+)!&57 *+* /6///?6 4!&") ! ?!'& **)+' %*)+ '* ) ! &!!'"* + *"+!5*) )&7"&5& " 9&!

!& " @/0/) 2"&*2"4* ) &' 9& /0/ ) + ' * ) ! &!!& " 4* ) '&

" &' & "&!!

"&4 )& *

:;:<*/ 9)+)9&&''9"," "&"//0/& ") 9& !'&"" )**+&'94*).) )'&

" &' , *")*&+& "&"=

")+&/0/)+!5*

/0/6 .'5)'&

"+ '*

! ?!'& ** !

" ) ' +!5 * ) "&"

//0/4* )'&

" &' &/#;$& "*''9 .

9&!&"#

! "

"" # $ $

% & %

"" " ( ( "$ ''

$ $

% )'&

" " . **+ 9&)&, .)'4)&,

+ +," 9)+)+& 4.&) "* 7)&* &"

.'5)*'9&&% !)

"'5&"** ,&'/#;

$6 #// $ & " #/ $ >&

" + ' * ) ! ?

! &!!& " & " .) ! 7 *' 9

&7 & "&!!'+&

- ' &' A "

) ! ?!'& **&++!)+ +&)4 9& * " ) * 6 ) ! 9& +7!''" "!) 7 5 ) &++ * ) ! ) &* 6 '&

" + ' * ) ! ?"* "& +&7% 9)&)'&

" &' )&"!&"

) &#// &)&57&

9)+) !

" +"& # ) " " '

"" "

+ '

* , -.

"" "

% # " $"

% " ""

# " "

"" #

(

% "" '

" 1#2,23#

1 '

4# " "

" " "

% "

" " $ #

)

( /" "

"" % ''

( "

5 "

6 78 1 , -

: " "

"" & * )"!*+ )&++ * ! 9)

! &!!

&+)")'&

" &' 6)+&7% 9 &4 ) !&"&#// 9& &''9"*') &7 & "&!!'+&

- ' ) +!

.& " ."!*+

: !5*&!!'+&

8+ ;

;6+!5*9 &7

@& "+!5*&!!'+&

- '

- )&&'!'&+" + " &!!'+& &""

" + ".6

&7.

*&.* 01

03& ") +!5*+& '"&"/0/

< >&

"+ '* )! ! " )&)'&

" . **+ 7&54!

7!& " !

.) "+&' **+ 4 ))& + " +")!

+" . &+&,&' 67+)& +&'7&

6&& ') *)! )&4 &", '5&**+"* ) ! "

)&) ,) .)7,&!!

&&!!'+& * ) * *)!

* 7)&"+ !

&5")&) 7! .

" "&"/0/1

3!&"45)'&

,' ".1 , 3 &7 )&* &"+,' 9) 45 !! 59&.

") *') 9 &7 )&4

&''5& ""'4 &'5"+' " &+ 7! 7&

45) '&

" " . **+ 67&5% "'54&"& " &4'" +

4., )&" &) "7*& "&!!

& ) !+ '& *&+& "+ + 7& +*)+& : )'&

"+ '* ) ! )&"&'

&"5*'"&

;

&,& :<*/! & . "&"/0/ >&

"+ '* ) ! & . ")&&'')*&+"&'" ) +,' , & *&'& "9) & 54&)! &'* "&"

/0/!&"45'&

" ,' ".1 , 3 &7 1

39''+'& )*&+ &'! *&+) 2"&*2"

)+&9&/0/& ")+&9&&"=

"/0/*

&9& . *) B4'.)

/0/6)!

! 9& &"5+7!'5)" + ., 45) B4' .) &! "&"//0/1

3)+&9&

!&"'5 +&''" * 7 7 7 , ) ) ) + 9& "!" )+ )9 &7 9&*'" ) * 6 '7&'5)*'9&&.& &% !&#// & "&* !& "&'" )+&9&&"=

":/</!., &7!' !! 5"!)+&' .9)9 &7 69&) ! 9) *&'" +7!'5 ) ) * 6 ) !

! '"& 5 '*& ")+,' , " , "7&' ; )&,+ " ")& . 7 & ")&,. ) .)) "+ 7 + " +& * ''5 ) *&+ &' ! "! "

.& " .)*&+)&)!

! $ %&&'&')&"*'"

:;:</&.& ) ! * .&") "&"

@/;/!&"45'&

" ,' ".1 , 3 &7 9) 45)"* +*)!

! 9& +%** ,'8 -*/'"&

)&"+,' , 9&&''9"45) 45!& .

"&"//0/9) 45&% .&' ,9 **+,!! 5

@ 9&.

")! *'9 &7 ) 2"&*2"

4* )'&

" &' 4=+!&57 *+* /6///? 4!&") ! ?!'& **)+!5* "&"//0/

)&* &" 9&!&" )!

+* '&

"+ '* 4))!& & "9& !'&"" ) 2"&5 /0/&@#$) 2"&*2"4* )'&

" &'

9&/0/8 +6) 9& +,"45)'&

&' ) " . **+ .)'5 &"=

" ) +& * 7 /0//0/>&

"+ '* )!

! 9& * ''5&9& )&)9 &7 9&4*'" 4=+!&57 * +&! ) "&"//0/1

3 )'&

+ '* )! )&!'&+" + "+!5*+& '*) +&*2" /0/1

<36&++ " .9)+))!

+&9&'"& &')+&9&&% !* )* 7& /#;$& "*''9 . 9&!&"# % $

" '

" 1#2,23#

*', !

! "

" # % ( "" " " $ $

% " 1 '

4# " " 4"

! " "" # " 1 '

4# +

# " '

$ $ ''

! " "" # $

- $

% & %

"" " ( ( "$ ''

$ $

% & 9

6 78 1 , - # "

" "

+ ( "

''*

) &* 6)+&9&&% !&#//$)*''9 9&!&"# C) " " ''*

"" + ''*', !

" ""

6 78 1 , - ( " ''*

)+&9&&.& &% !&#:/$& "*''9 .

9&!&"# ) " " ''*2 !

# "" # "

% "" ( " "

# %

" :

$ # " " ''

: #

(

0 78 1 , -

+ ""

) ""

" $"

# "

"" %

" """

) # " "" # " 1 '

4# " " 4"

& %

) "" $

# "

" "

;

" " #

2* -.

+ "" " '

(

( # $ $

% & # % " % ( " '

& )*'9&&.& &% !&#// & "*''9 .

9&!&"# ) " " '

"" "

+ '

* , -.

"" "

% # " $"

% " ""

# " "

"" #

(

% "" '

" 1#2,23#

1 '

4# " "

" " "

% "

" " $

)

( /" "

"" % ''

( "

5 "

6 78 1 , - " "

! "

! " "

" " 6

" "

< " 78 , - : "4 "

( + "

$ 1

4# " "" " % "

" "

/ " + ! = 8 +:

> 6

?2@ 1 1 ,2,

& & " 6 ', 1 , - ) " 6 78 , -

1 "

" = 5 8 9 A B ?-> @

?2@ 1 1 2,;

% ""

6 78 , -

( " 1 ,

4# C 3D - " '2

% ( " '

(

" < " '2

) &* 6 *' 9& &.& &% ! & #// $ ) &!!'+& *'" 8+ ; 9)+)& # ! ""

-. 5 ',' - " "

% "

# "

6 78 , -

-" "

% "

" 1#2,23#

" # % ( "" " " $ $

% " 1 '

4# " " 4"

% 1 '

4# " " "

% " " " " ""

% " "

" " % :

" "

E " "

$ #

% " "

# " ""

F "

" $

% ''

% ""

!!& .*&* &" * 777) ! "" *')9 &7 "+4 !&")!'& ** ) 9& " + "!)+ ) &++ *)!'& **&" 45)!

! )

) . + ")9)&'&

" ,' ".1 ,

&7 * "&++!)+ )9 &7 &! ) " + *) ," "&"//0/1

/0/ )&4 +*+!5* !&"45) ) &'

9 '")&, 4 &! &++!)9 &7

)+) * 6)* "&* *' .*)9 &7 & "

!&57 *+ 9& /0/) &* &"

+'& '5 "+&)&)+ '* )!

! 9& .*

) "&* *' .*9 &7 9)+))'&

" ,' ". 1 , 3 &7 .)'5 "+' " & ! ) "&"

//0/1

3& '5 **+,!! 59&4 " ) !

! *' 9 &7 4=+ !&57 *+ ) * 6)'&

" ,' ".1 ,

&7 * ".,& ) "&* *' .*9 &7

*&+9&)! 9))&*&'"+7!'5) *) 9)+)9&!&" )!

+*) + ', & ' )"* + *!

! 9& +%** &++ * *' .)9

&7 "** "&& ""!., !! 545)

6)!

! *&'"+7!'5) *) ) " . **+ " 54 "9&+)) *4))!& 4"5+& 4! 7"&%)57* .

) + + 7& +6 " * " & 5 & * ) "&"/0/1

3!&"45'&

,' ".1 , 3 &7"

.)+ *)"&5* 7 77& ")&7&++ " .'5 !)'" ++ " .'56)!

+,' , & ""+' " 0/</ ,, 24 /,445 5 /

2371 D)) !&% .?

& "# ? D)) ! &4'# ?