High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/27562/2019allowed

Jagmohan Motors Ltd. v. Sonia Tagra And Another

2024-12-03Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj13 pages

!"#$%"&'('#)*+,,-

* ./

, 01 0, 22222 ! "#$%#&'(# )% *++#&'(# )

, #*#$&'(#)

----- 1 0, 3, 4 5 .%#$$/%0 %0##1,

23 % 4# * #$# 5+2$( $3'( 6& %#*23 0%(%%($#4)

,!#

$(#)# +4)

1,789!%# 2 #$$0 # % %# 2 ( #3 % #2' # #4+ #.+ $#

#/2%#$))% !/(3 ( %# ##+%:#$)#++:+* %#* # #$ '/ +#(;*/ '( +%#4)<#+

+#(;*/'= %

,!#

$(#&2/0

-2- )#.#$

;

>>> 2#// #

,!!1??&%# +(%# % +#( $(3)4% ##$

+#( .4 #3 ) % )4 ,,,8 % 4 /% ) ,8,, + $(3 ?,7@,,8,,?1?1A7@ ) % # 4 (# % 4+4#4+)

,&@9!0# #23%

$(#%+/%(%B+2#/ A8@)C ;#*)%#$

)

7&7&9! % #(#&%0'&40%##((% D##2# #& ++/#4 ?,, 0%#) 0# 2+/% ) # % !#$ % # (%#/ 0 4# 23 %

,!($#4#)4% +#(.4 #3&242+ & %0'&% #40# ($23#/# 0%(%% ##

$(# +(5.6)%/#$'( +% (&,8A0# )$ 2)%4#*#$#5+2$($3'( 6& %#* */#

#3%

/# +#(($#4)% # #% (%#/ # % +#( $(3##$ #3(4 #)4#$ #/3#$/#C @

+#(.4 #3#

##(2) % 4# * #$# # )$ 0 #4

()(#$$3

/+%#0%%(%B+ A8@#0C ;#*&

+ 23%

,!#

$(#0# #34) 4+4#/# %

# $(3 0# % ;#*& % #4 0# % 4##2+% %)(%B+#(#($$#)% $(3' 4 ,11?@#,,,,80# %+/%/

,!#

$(# +#( 4+4

-30# %#) 23%

$(#&%(&% +#( $(30# 4)(#2$C (# #+#3&,0% %(#40%%#(( 0# #'%#% $(3#% (%+$ %#'2#/%(#(#(% 4+4#4+%# 2 #&%4)(#)%#(($

&+%(#(& (#2 +/%) ?

% #/4%# #$ )$ % $3 % ##

$(##0#

()(#$$3 #%#0# $3##+%: #/2%#$))%(4 #3#%# $%'%($ %# #3 (#( (' 4+4 ) 4)3/ #3 $

9#4#/ %#4#32(#+ %'%($#((+)##((## +(%% ($#40# 4###2$#/# %/(3 1

% (($# (/ )#$ (+$4# #

$40%+ ##E+(#+(5.6586)%/#$ '( +% (& ,8A 0# +#* 23 % 4# * #$# 7 0# # 1,& % 4# * #$# 2 '%#% #/&2/%2*(4 #3&0# +# 2$/# ##/ ) % 4+4 #4+ (# % )4 %

$(#!

, 23 (#(/ %4 #$$3 $ %(#$$3 )4##//0$$)%(4 #3## )#$ &%) 0# $#2$ #3%#4+0# ###4#/ )%'%($ % + )

1,&789! % #' # ) % 0#

23 % 4#*#$## %+ !

-4-

! "

#$# % $ & $ '

()

* ! +

! ! ,

$ -$ ./

0* %1 -$

$ 2 3 -$ "

4* 5

) -$ '

(

-$ +

-$ ,

$ 2 3 !

$ ! 677 -$ 8

"$'$9 :

3 -$ :

$"$9 :

3$ -$ ./

; :$ 9$9 : 4* 5

2 %

& -$ . /6

$9 : 2 %

-$ . /

)

5 <

)$ -$

./=

; $

;

$ 4* 5

; )

-5-

(

)

;

6 )

)

$ 3

)

( 6 )

2 %

( %

"$9 $9 >

; )

$ 5

2 $ 9>999 +,'9/99/999999/9 98$9"$9 >

9:$9"$9 >

98$9"$99

)

$ 5

$ 3

) 5

-6- <

)

/ #

-$ 8

) #

$ 3

)

;

-$ > -$ 9

$ >">+?":+ @ + ,:9/ $ 3 ./=

$9 :

;

/ / ;

$ %

6 )

$$ #(

(

;

$ 5

;

6 )

)

6 )

-7-

$ 5 #(

(

& $

$ + ,:9/

$ %

$ #(

(

& $

$C A //' %)& % 0 %# 2 )$23 %#+%:#$ 8 # .+ $ #

#/ 2%#$) ) % %# '%4$3 #/+ %# % 0#

23 % 4# * #$#

+)) )4/

4 !#

(#)% #+3 ' #%# )#$ #*( #%#% !#+%:#/(30# 0% $#2$4)3)#4#/%'%($ %0# %#3 '3 )(#(#3 *%#2+#*23% /(3

+24 %#%%3 % # 23%4#*#$#5+2$( $3'( 6%$/%#4###/0$$& %+$ %#'($$(%#4+(# %)4% +#4% #4 % +#(.4 #3& 2# + #3+3%#%#2(# + % +#3#/4 %#2 ()#3+32$/# (# + % #/(3 %#' ($$( % + 4+4 #((+) %)%(%B+&%$#2$30# %$

+))

-8- #((+ ) #4#/ % '%($ # #(( (+$ %#' 2 )# #/# % !/(3 .+ $ ) %

+#( .4 #3 % %%#%# )%0 #4)$2)% .+# %# #/+ %# % (%B+ # ,8,,8 50/$3 0 # ,8,,6 % #4 ) % +#( (4 #3 0# + %+9+(# % ((/$3& % +#( .4 #3 (#($$%

$(3 ' 4 ,11?@ ,,,,8 # # 4#%+/%%/ 0%#B+ +%/#$ +#( $(3( 3)% #40# #$ % !/(3 0$$#%

0% #/%

#(%)%(44+(# #2+ (#($$# # % # ) % #4& % 4+4 0# 23 %

,!#

$(# # # +(%& % (#(+#$ $# % )% +#% +#((4 #3(# C 0# %+ 4 $#2$ 4)3 ) % #4#/ +)) 23

, #$ 4#* #)(%#(*/ )%4#$ 23 % #4 # ( %# % #4 0# (' 23 <3= ,,,,8 , .+ $ ) %

,!#

$(# ) % $3 #( %#%(%B+B+ 0#

+,8,,8#%# %

/+$ +#(&0#

()(#$$3 # %#%4#C4+4 ) (

/)% #$#(44+(# ) % ( ($+/ B+49

+#( ) $(39(#($$# %#$$ 2,1#3 0%# %(%B+B+ %#2+(,,,,8

-9- #)# )4%#,1#3 )+% +24 %#%4# $0%(%0# 23%

+#(.4 #30# ('23 <3=2+% #40# '$'% #%&0# % (

)%$'30% 4 #$ ('%2#/ (#/%(44+(##% #40# 0#3((%

(&% 4#+)4#2+% %) % (%B+ # #$ % (#($$# ) % +#( $(3 (& % 0#%#2/%$3

23%4#*#$#5+2$($3 '( 6& %#* ,, 4 %#( $#( %# 2 $#( + % %# 2* 4 +#(

+ 23 % +#( /+$#3 # '$ 4 +%3) # ,

%#/+4%# 2#'#(#3E+/4( ,@

%#' %# $# .+ $ #

#/ 2%#$) ) %

(' # #%#'/%+/%%(+4 #

#$/0% % 0 ,? .#)#( 4#+

+0%(%## + ! 6

%# % '%($ B+ 0# $ 23 % & 0% 0# ##+%:#/)%#++:+* #' 6

0# $3 # 2* #/ # %# % +#( $(3 B+ %# 2

+ 23 %

##$

+#(.4 #3 % 4+4#4+0# #23%

$(#'(%B+2#/ A8@#0

-10- C ;#*%+)

,&@9! 6

%# % # (%B+ 0# %+ 23 % ;#*

# # 0# + %

+#( .4 #3,,,,8 '6

%#((B+ * $#(?,, ,1 F%$ %

$(# %# 2 E+ )3/ % $4%4)(#%/+%#%0# ( ) (44+(## /# % %)%(%B+#%( B+#$ (#($$#)% $(3&%B+ 0%(% 4#$3# 2)% .+ # 0%% % #+%: #/& )4 0%4 % '%($ %# 2 +(%# # 0% 0# % 2* ) % +#( 2##%4) #$)%'%($&(+$2%$$#2$ #3% #4#/ +))#((+)##((%#* $#(#%40% %'%($%#'# +2 / +#( $(3 ,7

+%#% #/(3 +#3 (#(+#$ #/4 0% %

$(# 4)3 %4 ) #3$

#%0# '3)(#(+0/)#3 * $

%'%($ %$#2$3%# 2)# % !/(3

$$3 #%3 % %#2/# 2*& +/% %#'4# %

$(# #2+ % % ) % (%B+ # %+$ %#' 4# )) ($$(% 4+4 (# % # %#)& )0# %

#4 % +#( .4 #3 0'& % 2# ) +(% %3 % #)# /)#$#2$3 (+$B+#$$3#$ 2

%# % 0# # ##$$$

2$3 + % + * # #(* #

-110%%% +#( 4+4 # '%#

0#*23%

$(#(%(*)4% 2#*# 0%% % 4+4#4+%# 2($##2$3#/# # (# 2 )( # ' 2#(% ) # +3 #2$3 (# 2 %$

+))( #))C # $#2$3 % #2 ( ) #3 +3 (# 4++#$ $# % &/'/ #)(#2$2$/#&#4 #2$3) (+( # #(+$# 4# +))( %$# $#2$ 4)3)%$

((# $

4%##((+

#4 0+$ %#' #$ 2 /# +/ % # # %

$(#0+$#$ %#'2)423%;#*#2+% %)%(%B+%#%#2

+23%4'%

$(# %# #* #3

* %4 $) + #/# #3 *9#4#/ 0+$ 2 #

# %+ %$ # 2* $#2$ 4)30%%%##$4$ ,A )# # $#( $#( + % /+$

+ 23 %

#2+ # ) ,1 #3 (2 ) #*/ # ( # 0%%% $(3 2#'#$ ((&% ##/+4 2# + )#$$#(+ #/)% ' % #44$3/' # 4)#4%

(' # +3% $(3(+4(#)+$$3 # %#)& #* # ( (+ ( # 0%% 0# (+0%%(#(+#$$# % % #4(#2%$ ( + %# ' ) % 4+4 #& % '%($ 0+$ 2 42+$3 +C 3)# ),1#3 %2$/# 4)3)%$

#((+ #34) 4+4#/# # +#(

-12- ('#/#%#%

$(#(#($#4#343)4

#34)% 4+4#)#C 3) ),1#3 D+%&%

$(##$ (#($#4%# % %+$2%$)#+$

$$3)%# %#'%+/%%(%B+B+ 0#

+ ,8,,82+% #40# %+ '42&,8#)4 %## )4% % #4(+$%#'2##/+49)( #'#$#2$%

! +(# %#((B+ 0+$ %#' #* $#( % ) % (%B+ 23 %

+#( .4 #3 0% % ;#* +(% # ((+4 #( %

$(#4#3%#''#$$3#/+%#%(#2%$2# )#+$ ( % $#3 # ) % (%B+ $#3 % # ) %

+#(.4 #3 $) % %(# %# $3))#%')($#4 #)% %)%(%B+

0#'/%

+# /# %$'3)% (#($$/ % $(3 # (#$$/ + %

! + + % $(3 (+4#,,,,8'%#/+4)% #2+% #(*/ %# 2 %(C%## )4 ,,,,8&%(+40# ('23<3=&% #42/%

(

)## &% +2 B+#(*/ %#'/2 +!)% 0+$#30#3)#%)#(+#$#

(%#%(44+(##2+ E( ) $(3 0# %+/% / ( A ) % #$ .$#+ (& ,8A +4 ))(/ ) '( ( (44+(# %+/% # / % # #+3

+4 %# 2 2+ 23 %

$(# #3

-134# ,8

(& #*/ % )#( ) % (# 23 #3 ) %

('($+/%#%0# (4 $$#(*) '3)(#(& )%#%4#*#$#5+2$($3'( 6& %#*)$$ 0%$)# /%$#2$3+ %#+%: '((9#/(3 4)3)%$

%#%#((# # # +$)#(((#+ #+#3&, , D%)//# & )%#%4#*#$# 5+2$( $3 '( 6& %#* (44 # #

(#/ % )#(+#$ # 0$$ # $/#$ #

( '$' % (# # %+ (44# %4 +/0##1, +)) )4# $$/#$3&4 3#)#$+#

(#%)#( #((+4 #( )% (# +

('& ( ##

$(# % 0 #((/$3#$$0#%0##1,

23%4#*#$#5+2$($3'( 6& %#*

$ #

!"#$% # $$ % / 4 ($$#+ #

$(#5 6& ) #3& # #$

)

1 0, +3- 4 !

F%%

#*/9# * G F%% #2$ G