Sudesh Rani & ANR v. Kulwant Singh & ORS

-1-



   


Reserved on:-17.09.2025



!



  

 





   



"  #$"

%  %
%  
% " 

   



  

 
  





   !"





 



#### %  
% "    $   

       "     

       $$%&'%$( ")   





* ! " +  " 

!

 


$,,



-



$.((/



0  " 12



!

!



!



$$ '% %%%34 





 5678

!

 

9   !59  

 

-

 





%$$%'%$6 '   

 !



  

:

!

!

  ")    "  

 



: 

"  

  ;

"

) % "
%%
% $  %$

 
% <  



 !

4 

  !

 ")    " 

   

"

-2-



  ) 

  "    !

!

"

     & 

 







  !

)       )"    !

!

  ")    "    )" 



  )

!

 

   7 =   



  

   





  " 

 %$$&  "

%
 , >

1" 
!  *

   

Sarla Verma Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another '(  )*%+,-.//0   

 !

!



  

 !   4 ?30
    

            

   

       

              

   

     

 

  
    

 

      

          

  

         !"#$            

  %#  !"&$

   

  &'   !"($       

 


31
)

       

       
*  

-3-         (+,                  







  

  


-  

    

 

     

      

 $         
.  /

 

         

                
*  

 

                     

  



         

     
32
 

                   (+,         

    (+,     
    

        



  

           

             

 

        

  
* * * * * * 42. )     

 

    &$          0

 1   $        !2    !(%+ %!

-4- %(

 $ 

    

  3!4 %'#+

 3!'#!#(

 3!(#'&+

 3 !&&!&(

  3!#&'(+

   



   

  3!!(!((

 35 (''+

 34'!'(

  3(''4+

 6 >

1"
!*



National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. '( 02)0*%*31   

  


$,, $,<4 $,(



-



$.((





4 /2 @

 

    

  A  

  !

!



B / 2


!

 



 

  B /*2 

  

" 

 )

!

 B /@2  

" 

 



    !)    



 

!  A  



/C2 +  

 

 









!

"B 4! ) 

A  ) 



!

    4 ?52. 6  conventional heads

    

   

 7/

8
*

    7
%(+++      

  7  !+++++  

   7 !+++++ 



  

   
     

       

   
7/

 0  9 

 





-5-

       



   

 

  



 

  
:    

       
6         
         

     



 



    


   

  

  

   


 ; 

       

          

     

        

   

     



   



          
    

  

*

     

            

  

 

  

     

 

!(+++  7
&++++     7
!(+++  


  

                    



 
 <              

  

 


)     

               

  

    

   

   !+,   


) 

 

 



  





 

-6- = = = = = 59.3
)    

  (+,    



 





 / 

   &+

   
 

 #+,  

  

&+ (+


* 

  

 (+'+

     !(,
6   

   


59.4
* 







 $ 

   &+,

 



 

    &+

 6  %(,

  

  &+(+

  !+,

  

 (+'+

    



 


 

    
59.5
.             

           #+#%0> ?  



    59.6. 

         

  0> @ &%/


59.7
  

       

-759.8
7   

        





 

    

 7

!(+++7 &++++ 7 !(+++


 

    

  !+,  


A ( >

1"
!*



".4,..5
/. ,+.6$7,7-8/ . .,.57./99 ., -9/'

03(03) %0:1





%.5.8,.(/+.) ..6%-97(%+.)  

   



!

  

 !     4 B21
6  <

  C  0 8        

      

 ;

   

      

  
 *    

D  D     



    D  D    D     D

 D
      

   

 

 

 

   

  
)

 

 

  

 

%!
!
Spousal consortium 

               

    



D       

       /  D

-8- %!
%
Parental consortium      



 

D 

 

 



 

   D
%!
#
Filial consortium   

 

 

   
6 

   

  

           


  

   

    

      

            
22
   



 

     

      
3  /  

  

 

   E 

 

   

   

  
3 /         

   

    
     

    

        

      

  

 
 23
 3> 

6  

    

      

  

 

 



 * 

                              

       
C 

     

    

    6 
6    

-9-

    
       

  

  

     

  24
  

          

 

   D

  D   C  0 8
*  



     

     7  &++++  

  

 .  

       

"

&< ) 

   

" 

<% %%%34!

")

   !



> 



!

) 

   :    !   " 

 "



 



 "

  ) 

!

)

! 6 7%%34*



 

!

!! 

!

 * !

  



 !



!

        

"

 !

!! 

 ;

 ;

$% %,734!

=  

  ! ")



!

)

!

     $$ %%%34!

 $% +  

     !

  

 A   



  

!

   

"



   : 





*  $ %
 $$ =  

   ") >

1"
!*

 "

 

!



        

-10- $$%&'%$(    !

 



)    

4 !

    

 

!

  

! 4 4 Sr.

No.

Heads Compensation Awarded $ 

)=

! $$ %%%34 '

+  

5'78 '

67%34/'78

$$ %%%2 < @

   

A

$3< & 7(<34/$< 67%D$3<2 & 

=

! .

$,6/$< 67%4& 7(<2 & 

  $&

 @ 

) $7 &% %7,34/.

$,6D$'D$&2 , 

C

$( $7%34 +  CA  $( $7%34 ( 

*

!

., (%%34
  &( &%%34A$  

&( &%%34A$ -.5,+/.-7

/ 0*;2:;0!*<

-7 !

 ")  "

/ 00;

;<

9..,-

/ !;!:;0!*< (0*;2:;0!* 00;

;) $'  

  

   ")>

1"
! *

Dara Singh @ Dhara Banjara Vs. Shyam Singh Varma 0 :02*

R.Valli and Others VS. Tamil Nandu State Transport Corporation (

)!

%+,-.//02;   

4 !

 

 5.8

!



 !

!  



!

  

 

$< = 

* ! )4



F &  





 !

!

 





 

  " 



!

 !  

)

!

 " 

-11- 

 " 

 !

!

 







!

3 

 



")     "  

   $$%&'%$( !

3 

  

  "

;





 "  $& 

 

/2

)   

  

!    (%  
% ") 0    G  ;

3

4 ;


 ;

  G  " H3F