High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/837/2017dismissed

Sapna And ORS v. Jodha Singh And ORS

2018-10-29Mrs. Justice Lisa Gill3 pages

!" #"$%&%'( )

* +' '#!,"-& ++".. '!& /"-&0&

#, *%'1, '#!,"-& "&+'#"'!&

-"&"'!( - '2 3",! 4#5$ !" -!," ++".. '!&

,%& ++" . , & 6""' %."# 67 !," $. %8 '!& &""2%'1 "', '$"8"'! $8+"'& !%' 9 -#"# ! !,"8 67 !," ." -'"# !- $$%#"'! . %8& -%60' .4 %& - :-%60' .; - &,-! 5%#" 9 -# # !"#

= ' $$0'! #" !, , ' .% & -% , ' %' 8!- 5",%$." $$%#"'!'

> ,"$. %8 '!&49, -"!,"9% " '#$,%.#-"' !,"#"$" &"#4

%."# +"!%!%' 0'#"- *"$!%' == !," !- /",%$."& $! &""2%'1 $8+"'& !%'' $$0'! #" !, , ' .% & -%, '#0"!%'30-%"& -"$"%5"# %' 8!- 5",%$." $$%#"'! 9,%$, !2 +. $" '

> <# !"#

>9 &-"1%&!"-"#0'#"-*"$!%'&

)4 >? '# !.%$"*! !%'* # -

0. ' 1 %'&!-"&+'#"'!!9 &+." #"# !, !!,"#"$" &"# !!,"!%8" ,%&#" !,9 &9-2%'1 & &2%.."# ."@6 -# +-%'!"-4" -'%'1& <4

A?+"-8'!,"9 & 7" -&.# !!,"!%8" $$%#"'!8+"'& !%'9 &!,0&+- 7"# -

,"." -'"#-%60' .'$'&%#"- !%' !," $!& '#"5%#"'$" '-"$-#,".#!, !!," $$%#"'!%'B0"&!%'!2+. $"#0"!!,"- &, '# '"1.%1"'! #-%5%'1 !,"

"'#%'1 5",%$." 67 %!& #-%5"- ,"-" %& ' #%&+0!" -"1 -#%'1!," 65"& %# %'#%'1 !,"." -'"#-%60' .'!,%&%&&0"49,%$, , & !! %'"# %' .%!7 C" -'"#-%60' .$'$.0#"#!,"#"$" &"#!6" 7" -&.# ! !," !%8" ,%& #" !, '# &&"&&"# ,%& 8'!,.7 %'$8" & &<<> A? +"- 8'!, < D %'$-"8"'! %' %'$8" 9 &

-#"# ' $$0'! 0!0-" +-&+"$!&,0&4!! .%'$8" !,"#"$" &"#9 & &&"&&"# &&

A? +"-8'!, "#0$!%' A<!, 9 &"

"$!"#!9 -#&!,"+"-&' ."@+"'&"& 2""+%'1%'5%"9!,"'086"- #"+"'#"'!& !"- ++.7%'1 80.!%+.%"- 4 !! . #"+"'#"'$7 9 & &&"&&"# ! & 4< 4)

A? &08 &4

A? 9 & 9 -#"#!$. %8 '!?9% "!9 -#&.&& $'&-!%08'!,"-&08 &4

A?" $,9 & 9 -#"#!$. %8 '!& '# !9 -#&.&& .5" '#

"$!%' &08 &<

A? " $, 9 & 9 -#"# ! +- -8 -"&+'#"'!&A+ -"'!& !9 -#& .&& .5" '#

"$!%' '!,"- &08 & <4

A?9 & 9 -#"#' $$0'! "@+"'&"&%'$0--"#'!- '&+-! !%' #" # 6#7 '# ' !," . &! -%!"& !," #"$" &"# ,0&4 $. %8 '!& 9"-" ,".# "'!%!."# - !! . $8+"'& !%' & 4 4)

A? .'1 9%!, %'!"-"&! E

<D+"- ''08 -8!,"# !" %.%'1 $. %8+"!%!%'!%..-" .%& !%' " -#." -'"#$0'&". -!," ++".. '!& ,"-"%&'"5%#"'$"'-"$-#!%'#%$ !"!,"#"$" &"#!6" " -'%'1 ' %'$8" 5"- '# 65" !," %'$8" &&"&&"# 67 !," ." -'"# -%60' .,"#"$" &"#9 &$. %8"#!6"9-2%'1 & ."@6 -#+-%'!"-60! %!%& %-.7&! !"#67." -'"#$0'&". -!," ++".. '!&!, !!,"-"%&'&+"$% %$

"5%#"'$" ! +-5" !," & 8" "%!,"- %& !,"-" '7 %'#%$ !%' !," "@ $! %'$8"" -'"#67!,"#"$" &"# C" -'"# $0'&". - !," ++".. '!& %& 0' 6." ! +%'! 0! '7 1-0'# - '7"', '$"8"'! !,"$8+"'& !%' 9 -#"#!!," ++".. '!& "&+"$% ..7 2""+%'1 %' 5%"9 !," 30#18"'!& ';6." !," *0+-"8" 0-! %' !%' .'&0- '$"8+ '7C!#/&- ' 7*"!,% '#!,"-&4

> %5%.

) '# 18 "'"- . '&0- '$" 8+ '7 C!# /& '0 8 .% &,0,-0 8 '#!,"-&4%'%5%.++" .)<

#"$%#"#' )

F""+%'1%'5%"9!," $!& '#$%-$08&! '$"& &' -- !"# 65"4 #'! %'# '71-0'#9, !&"5"-!%'!"- "-"%'!,"%8+01'"# 9 -## !"#

=%'!,%& ++" .+-"

"--"#67!,"$. %8 '!& !,"- -108"'!, &6""'- %&"# ++" .%& $$-#%'1.7#%&8%&&"#9%!,'-#"- &!$&!&

$!6"- )4

&,9 - G,"!,"-&+" 2%'1A-" &'"#(?"&A G,"!,"--"+-! 6."(?"&A