← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5788/2018allowed

Pankaj v. Dharambir And ORS

2026-03-19Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma12 pages



             



 !"" # $% &'()*'

 + ,'%

!% , +!

#% #!

,- !%!'.!/ #!

,- ', ,2 3!(!

#/ 4  ",+!+ , /    

         5/  67 58 8  8

85  

       

  



   !   " # $  

    " % &&&&& 8

85

#

 

'  ( )  *% +# *+#,  '!

   -

'

 - .

  

 '( " /% *+#/0*+#1 

  #22  3   #4,, 5  6

'

78    (   

 */+++09 ( )  :

1;



  < !

 '!



 3      #2 +4 *+#/

 

*          = 

) '!



'

        .

  . '!

85    7   878    8 $

   0    ) '!



'

 )   '  



!    ' ) ) 0  '    ) %      

)  !

(   )    '!



'



( !

' ( 0 



!      /

>



      )    )  '  87 79 

5 8 



 ) (( ( )  '!

?





:2('

$% ;

:2('

 + ,#&!'

= 82 '!(!

,2'# %!% 0>0



9   

       

     

             !  "  #  $"         "! %#"& ! !'" &       !

#$  !(!

( (! "!  " (!    & !    # !

'" # 

"#"     !

(#$& !%"! !  &"   & "(  $"    " ! #& !'" # &

0

#  !  & $"&#"    "!  "" $"&

    #  !  #& ! "  #&$&      "! $&!#" $" !  #&   "   "! "!

 !

)* + )"#  ,&

+" " - ,.

/0)" *"1/2.

4  ( ! *,!

5!

  )**

 !6  7"( #&/0*82/

  !"!     !!  $"&    (9 

  



   :%   (         ;   !   " (! !  "%!"  5 ( ! (    $"! "! 

! ! #$"! (9  5 (!"( !  < # 5"" ( " ! #&   =""  !   %  ->" &  !

(  ?  (  3 ( "( ! "

  '" $"  5  !@  (

 5%  ( (&

," $"&    # !!& "!  !    !

,&" $"&

  ! !# ( !        #( !"! &

 ! #    !  ("" ( " ! #&"" ! %

   !@           (  !     %  %%% %%% %%% %%% !"

#    

  $%  $" ! # ( $" ! " (  & 

 ( ! #&  

#!&  # "

!#  (  (  & "!&  (  (  &     (  ! #&%      #"  #  !"!  ( (  &   ( ! #&



!  ! $"!>   % !

 "#'"&  %  ! #&  (!&( ! % ! #&

 (  & (   # !#&  #"    !& 

        ! #&  &  "    !  (         (    &    !  

>

!!("  "" $# ( !"  !   &'"(     )

$ # #  #  *  +,+ 9

$"!     (!10&  !

 (. 1000@>      ! 3 !  ! #&  #  '" $"& 20A ! '"  ! #&     '" !    10A

       (    &  

  !#&  #"   A # ! # "   "! & #"   ( ! * "    #  9 "  #  !9. 12000@> # 5"" ( "

 A  "  9 . 800@>  "  #   (9/ !

5"" (9 800%/ 9 . 00@> *  +-+9

$"!  ! (!10&  (.

1000@>    

 4  !    " !  !      ! #& ! 20A 4   ! $#  "!(! 4 (( &  &  #  ! ( &$#   & &#  

 #"   ! "" (   & / * "    #  9

"    !9. 12000@> # 5"" ( "

/ A  "  9. B/000@>  "  #   (9/ !

5"" (9B/000%/ 9. 8 000@> *    +.+ 9 

  $"!    B  &   !      &  :(("!  "  !        (  !  " ! !  !

 ! #   ! /0A  $"!     !""    !  '"!     "( "  "" (   &   ! /0A

 "    #  9

 "

 "    "!

( !# &!   :( 9. 20000@> # 5"" ( "

/0A %! "  9. 8B000@>  "  #B &   9 !

5"" (98B000% 9. / 2000@>



C-  9 

  ("  !!    "     !  6  

&  

("," *   # ! "    !!+"

  "

 

  * .

/"0"

 12"?< = 1 8 1 @

 )

  #22 #2$9 #2,  3   #4,, )( 9 58    ( ?  

@ 5A8 

 ( ( @ 5-8 (  '  !(

@ 5 8

' (  

  !    

 ? ) @ 5B8     (    ( )  <'@ 9 !  ? !

  (  

9

   &%  #"

,  "   #("   !  & "

 !" % "!#.  000. 80000 !.  000&

(  !  !   #   6"        "!    #   >   '" "

> 7   "!#!( 

"         '" !   "!  #   !    (# & &  !    "!#   0A   &  7  !! !# "  #(&    ! ,

 

3



0"  3) ( ". "/"&'&',.4& 5!6



9 F/

      '"!#% !#&"9



 

+ 7+  + 8+<

  !  ""(  #  (    B1& &( $"!( -   ," *  &5 !   &)  !G B0/*H B/00)*

,  82  !$"!(  *"6 &  !  " !#"!  !  #  )   )  !G  3 

 *  ! B00*HB)* ,  ( ("     >B  &      "      #    (    ( %! #&

1

  ! &!"!#& !"  !) *  ! "   "        "    #  !               #   ! /

$  /        

    

  #       $

9 " : ,          !            !

   !# !" H (!   IG B0*H0)*  !) ! + "$  "3 !I B0/*H/)*

7%  #  " H (! "   9 J  ,  (          & #     !

!## !

 "    &! #& !#&  !   !       !      

  !     " (   ( 9 

 "( ! "

"(   !<  5 "!("" < 

 #&   !  (    < 

! %"!(    &# '"!"! ""< ! 

5%  J C "!D

  !  # ;!   $"!(   ) !+ "$  " ( 

" ! ( &"! !( &  # ! '" &               "    !       ! #&"!  ! ,  " "   %  ! #&             !

@  ;       ""

#! &K&  "(" B0H " &B01

 "$" !#"  "!9 J   9 

"! "  "

" 

 "# #  

"! "# #(   

 "1!8 I    (  ! 

"#  "(  " 

 "  " 

 "# #( 7  "!  (   %!   ( " &      "(  !#& !" !)  *     !  "

6   &      !

 "$"   % ="  #!  1) !+ "$  " 



  &(     "  !  ""     !      !       #      !  7  ""'" &    

     !   !

  ( !"" " # !

      (  ! #&  1 A

'"     #  $"!( -  ," * 5!

 "    &  2 !(  (    "!# 0A  "   &  

(        

  &: ,   !     !

!   !"( "  (A   $"! " "!( H (! L  "

G   (   " !" !#&  !" !    !A     !#& *"

.2./;

*2 

"   ! &( !

  "   #&     "    & "! # !!   9 <  ,#  5     (    . 828%B%1 @00 . /@> ="" 0 !!

. 80@> !   %  "!(    ( "



. 8228@> 5    .

00000@> 5         

 !   (& .  0000@>   !"( . B00000@>

  . 821@>

   "! "#!    . 821@>   ! (       A "

  !    !  & 



 )   0  )  ' !    

  <      

'



( 



*/+++09 ) !

(     <   '!

 0 #+   )    0     >

.

 '    < 



E     

  (  



'



 = !

= !



  (

 ?  

(  )      < !

 ##  '!

 5B?

28    

 #+;

'!

B  '!

   '!     ( !

!99!

  0  ' (



'

   (   '!

 ( !

= !

 <  #* >   

 ' D<   'F 

!

!

'

)    !

'< ' (

  3   #$

         $

  0"- $ $

  $

 $  1,A

8 

(!

 

   )     '!

     ' =  ) 9 (  

!

'    )  (( ( 

4

!

  

      



 D  F

 '

. '!

(  !





)( '  . ).

      )      #%

 ( (  '



)( . ).           0 %1A

B #/  

 #,  '  ( ( 0   ) #2

?

 G= >

 ?

$$ @     &'&A  * .  88B

( (  (' '

( =   (

    

9

D

+(   #>!$"!(  $" "! M  !"(  "! ! >(  " ! #& !"   >   !    3 !"! # !

'"   >  #$"! !  "   !  .  00000@>  "!      !  M   !

"( "&"     &   >       #& "

. 000000@> !   #$"   !  #   " !!

#1

 ) ' (  

      (

 

?"5'6'''CD       

  ( #,    0  '  

 

#2 +4 *+#/ *$ +4 *+#/  ( - 5B?

/8 )     )  

 ? ) )  



 $++++09 (   #4   ) )   '

   )( !



 G

( 7    '( !

!    

(

  '





'

    

 < !

 '!

!    <!

 

  

    ?

 

?



$   * .

6&'&9 9?.? .

57A = !

  (E   9 !

 ( 

 '!

 ( 

(   

  (  

9 F/> 

  % B0 -   # !!"!  #  !

*!(  "$"!"& ! !!    "!#!  "!

 ( ( &(" $"!(   *"  * " " & "   !

%!  . 1 "!  !  !

,   # *" $" !(

0000  "!         !    N     ( 



*+

  ) '  ( (    

     )

 $++++09



 

(  *#   )    ( '!



'





  

 ) =   (  ?3/*3E ** > ) '   ) )  *% +# *+#,

 (!   )  ) '!



 ' 9 

      ')9 8'

, !+% ,( !

%#*,

C'+!+ # >

 2+++09 * H   5%+;8

 *%++09 5%+;

 2+++098 $   >

 #++,++09  ,%++09 I #*8 % H  (  #+;

'!

 #++,+09  #++,++09 I #+;8 /  #,

 #,#%%+09  #++,+09I #,8  B?

 $++++09  (

 /++++09 , H

( 

 $++++09  

 $++++09 #+ ,#"

3,( !

%#*,

C'+!+/ %0A A>> B ## !+23#*, / ) '!

'

 % A

B #*  & 3!+ (,2 # ,- 3,( !

%#*,

% A41A>>

B <0A A>>  A

=

 

*$    

 '!





G  -   0"



0 

&' !,.49 7B ?"0

20 "(   (  .    &'&&5

..

 '7

   (  :

4;



  

 ( 

    E *%

 %9>  !

    ( )  )

'

 )  )

 

  !

(

'

  '

   ( )    0

 0  

'.

 

'

 */ (   !    <8

85=



4    J   .(09.(  .(

J   '

 K0"