Union Of India And ORS v. No Jc 2758383n Ex Nb Sub Nirmal Singh And Others




   
    

 

 !"#$# % %& '




   

 !
! "# $    %&  (&  )*(  +
+

+ ,

  )*(  +
* ,
 '&()* "+,,- '.+,.,/&-0, 1.%2
 ",-&% './&-0,,& " . .,3,/&-0, 1%&4 +

+ ,

-.

*/ 4 .'.  .  ,  6  %/  .  %  . %,)1.',&1.&&,&74484 9:;4< ,%,&().=,&3&0 (,=00&/6.() .0=,31%&41',1&,(=)%6, ,==6&  ,&  1.  %&    4  6,  ',&  .  (1  1 &'  11/  .  1  03%'  .  &,(=)  =3  -;,;- &,(=)%

"

1 "234 0%5 

%&46,==&3=,)-0,1 3&0,=0&87844>

'.01.-0/.

 0&.&,(=)1


   ,& 6,1,==)&0.,'&13-048484.31 -,=&&/.&,(=)6,,&,8?()"&0,=!,&1 =1 0=,31&,(=)%6,.6-@0&().

%&    .  '&  1  .  ,&  &,(=)  ('  A. (,(=/'',-,&()"=,) -0B

='  ,''-&/  %&    4  1=&  .,', (1.=,& (,=00& .,&,%%=0,6, ,==6&-&&&,&74484 9:;4< .%,- %,1.,&&:,0&.,1     

       

 

  

              

        

  

    !

  "

 #  $

  



 



%

   !    !

     &

  % 







'

  



 

          



 



!" ‟  

#

  $# 

 %  &# 
# 
! '

() *

+ , - '! " 



    "     

- . 



 

 



"

"  "

   

 (

)%

*   %      !        

+,- 

  C ='  ,''-&  13 .  ,1  &/  .  %;
1&,.,1=&.,',.,6% +067#$$# %$ ! 81 4%5" 0%$1! 4 89 # # %4$

./.=,&0=1.%;
 1&,1.&9<1-,@&'3(). D(= %:/6.()/  



  

   



1.(3.,-61 .:%=,1=,63,&./.=,& (,=00& .=&.,-0&.',1,,.%&1. ), 7 ,==)/,10E&(3,&%,,',%.  ,&71.-&0&&(). D(=%:0, =&,
! ' /0    

 ( 1'

#

&2 1
3 /0

(  (

 (   *

+  4  ,0 5 &

/&0&&48 88  .,&%,,',%. ,&7 (03:,0&.,1 .

   

 

!

'

    

#!     !

$ #!   

  /

  $ )

 

 

 !

0  



   

 !    



   

1 !  



 ! 

 ! 

 



! 



   ' 2

 

           

          

    ! 



     3

!

 





!



4

  



 

 3  

  





  

 

 

2    



  

    !

 

  

 

 !     

5

              

     

     

 !

!  / 

5

%

!

 

5

      

 

   

 !

     76 ! 

5

     

   %  !  '

     



  76  ! 



 



      

   

!

 

  

 !

!  ! 

   



 

,&'1%,,',%. 1.-&09%,<0=,=) &0.1,0.,0,,)0=,3.().-01&=,) ,&=,0./.=3,=),110'.,%%-&&1,(= '.E,.,3)%=/(=,'=)%,)3;1:, 1  %,)    %/  .()/  .  ,&  &=,)&  0=,3/  ,.  ., (03','.6,)@0&/./E&(,==6&/(6. ,1.,.,,1%('0&%,%&1. ),%.&,11='1.6%



.,&0,%,,',%.7.1/.%: &0=,&.,. '.6,@1&&0.=,1 ,,1%0-',%&147),,&.,6.  > .,&-6,=,%%,.,-(,00%&, @&'3(,'
! ' /0 

  1'

#

&2 1
!3 /0 ((

 3   & !

6 ,0 *

+  4 7 " 

(0 0 0 .=-,%,,',%.6.1, :,0&.,1

 

    



 

!

 

  1  

 !

   

+

 

          
# .# $"    "  

.

"

"# 

   

#   0 % 



!

  





  

! 

 !       



    !  



!

  

7:

 

!

 



%   !

  

    

 

!

!  #   !

  

 8"

  

 



 . 00 1 

!



     

!

   

&         

  

  



   %



! 

!

  !    

+067#$$# %$ ! 81 4%5" 0%$1! 4 84$9 %5% 48 ...,&/.=,&0=1.%& (3.,.,1,&@&'3,,%%=0,(=., 0,/  ,  .  33(  1  .  &10  03(,,  ,(=.3  6, ,=,&)0%1.&,(=)%,&.,.&631 .,%%(1.0.'.3,F'1&'9<11/. 6=&=)=,@1,(=0,% 44 %%1.,'3/.%=,0&=,0,. &'  !0.  @&'3  %,&  ()  .  D(=  %:  /   88>847/0,=&, :#%54+#%38;$ %# % !
%5# %5

84$/6.0. #:#199 1 <<  !' ,'& . =-,%,,',%.1.,&-&0,:,0&.,1   

  ) 

:;

<:77

 / 4

( 2

 %  !  ) / = 7<,9 <:77 

!

   

 





  !

 :7 :7  !

 





  '

'



      

  

      

     !

     



 !   

   

       

 

     



    >   &      

                       

!

 :7 :7 7996! 

+,-

'

'

 

      0  



 



   

  !

 :7 :7 7996 :7 :?

<::9 

 !  

  

 

  =

%!4%"$ ! 8#$ 04 4 .'./-(=)0,,)&=,)&3,&(). ,''-&6.(),0.,=='0,&,&0='&%,& ().00&/.%/.,'1,&=,)&3(3,F .,3(.().-01&=,),&=,0. 6-/. :0%.,(-%0%=/,=&.'.-&00&&() .%:0,=&,*

+  4  ,0 5 &

1#3 ,&0,=&,& !

6 ,0 *

+  4  1#37 .,/).&10%=00&/(03' =&;1:,1%-;,;-.3/(6.,1.& .,.,&(0&=)1,%&1.),13. &,11='1.% 4 !.,,3,)/,1.:0%-.%, :,0&%,,',%./,00.-&09%,<&&(). %:/.:/.,0,,&1,(='.(03 -&.,''-&/.%/.,&-31,&1,(= '..,''-&/.6=&1=,0',0

( 0,  1  ,0  -;,;-  .  ,''-&  =,=)/  .()  . &=,)&,'1,0=,3/.6=&,,0.,..(, 1=3,.(),)%%&-01&=,),&=,0. 6=&110-=)10,,3(='(=0F,',.','1 .1===1.,''-& 4C &3'6...0,1,06.0.,00& -;,;-.%%&.6,,0',0 0,1,0(&1&3'6..,.-)0%/ ,&1,(='.-&.%%&/.()/ 0,)(,3&.1,03.,/.=-,0,1,0 ,00&.%%&/%/.3,F'1,-&0().

D(=%:0,=&,) %# % !
%5# ;$

7:

4D/ %&'

+ %1#%''/&0&&48484C/6./ ,&0=,,3,&.:/.,.(11&'11/ ,.  .,    (03  &6&    .  00&  .  =-, %,,',%.,00.-&09%,<,:,0&.,1 ;

2  

  

# $

5

!

  !

 

 

   

 



    

   !

 



   

  

   3  



# $

!  

          %  =

7#<$9?#

3%$  

     @

     

 A

      

  B7 :7 <::7   

 

               /   4

! 

       

    /   4



  



.

0   



  



9 0 

   

'

# $  # $    ! 



 3   





!    

?

 





! 1



%

!

   

  

 

   !



   

 .1/0.,&&1,(='.(0,3-& .%%&/%/.3,F'1.-&0().%: /0,=&, ) %# % !
%5# ;$

7:

4.$094 /  E=/.&0=,,1=,63,&.-&09%,</6.& ,110-'.(03&6&-;,;-.00&/. (-& =,=)/.&631.,&'./-;,;-. 00&/  .  (03  .  0  1  .  .13 &3'/  6..    %3%  E=  .  ,.  .  % %&,&,0=,3/,&/,&3.6. 47

0  .  -&0  9%,<  (0,3  %0&   48484C,&.%&,&31.,&-&0/., 3(1. (,=00&/.),84  .'./. %&31.-&09%,<&&,,%3%3 %,0./(,&,3=),1,&=,)1,( G   ),  ,F'  %=,0  6-/  6.  .   &63  3,& .&-;,;-.%%&/(,,==)01&, &1,(=  '.  E,  .3  .1/  6.  .  &1,(=  '. -&.%%&,..'.-&09%,<( 003,=) ,=  01&  ,  0  ,&  0'  0,  1 ,0 E, . % %&  =,=) ,= .& ,

&1,(='.(0,3-&. %%&1 . F'E,.,%%&'11('3,&.1,- 

-  .6  0  .  &0=,,  1  =,6  3,&   -&09%,<3,F.,&&0=,,(,:%=,1=,6 3/.()/.:%=,1=,63/,3,&-&0 9%,<,=3,F..&01&(1-;,;-. &10  %=  00&/  /     /  ,=  =  . 00&/.,,)3F.','1.&63, 3,&.&/,&.,/.1==03%=3/,%= .&/(&%0-1.(,1&=,),&=,0.

#% 1 454 ! 8#$ 04  ,13,./.1&3.6% ,&  6.  .  (-,  ,1,&/  .  ,3    &3&  . 3%'&&3,,&,&,113& 4>

0.3,0,=1.,(&0&&/./,==. %&',%%=0,9</1,)/,=,&9<&%&1     .+

+ ,

/  .* ,
/ '

 F,-'.

8 84$9 2#%3=4 $ %5 & $= 8 8449 4

& $=