← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/377/2016allowed

Shri Bhagwan v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2019-11-01Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari8 pages



     

 !" #

!&!"+!

 ,-.

" / #!

 , .

 



   

      ),  01)  22231



   !"!# "

$ 

"!# "

%&# "!# "

 

!"!#   $ "!# 

'

"!#  

  )

"*" 

 + ,

"*" 

 22

%5

6   , )  -    # ./

#0 #"12-34#45++

3+ 

6%7"-7"81-2819

6 %9.815

 3+ 

6%7777"777"7779"777

77.-8195



 7181. +

 #:"*

"

#0

+ 

  17181 #  # 8 , 0

 17181" +

(

82 #

#0 !( 

;

 ( #  #--11." *

 ,/

#0 :#! 

 % 71781

!

+

77

79 < # 7 ,  #: #

1# " # 

1 &!890 "5:5&

 !"&;&2  "<

 !"0

#( 1"7"-1"=>  # 

  + +

 

 8.1817   1 &!80

=

 !"&;&2 ! "<

 !"&03?@ 75

!

 ( "

   !



+ #0!

 (+# !( 

;

 (# #--11." *

 ,              #        (    891181198113?@ 8 5

?@ 

2 !

    +  @( B 7"1-"2"=> #

 

#..C"(    +  @  B 1"7"-1"=>    #  ,        89983?@ 15

#  ##  !

 +

8D  . :       

   !  +(     

 #:

) 

+ #<

 #"    +!

#

#

  

#

""

+ #< 



  A+(    !

  

77  

#(# !

  +

""



  !

 

     )  +  

 '    ,  +( 

( " 

 

*

#

#   9 :   

 

!

(!

 

 #( 

 +  (

 +  ## +

 (      #  +!

 +

 

"# # (+  (  

  ,#  #   >  % ?@ & /

 (  

#

!    1 ?@ .18 1-' 9"""=> 8"-."2."2-=>

+ 8 ?@ .18 8'1 9"1"89"9=> 8"."8."1=>

+ 7 ?@  1982 8'9 7.""=> 1"81"7"-17=>

+  ?@ .

8.881 '1 -"."=> 1".7"18"=>

+ . ?@ 8182 8' 1"17"=> 98"7"2=>

+ 9 ?@  8.881 '1 -"."=> 1".7"18"=>

+  ?@ 718 7'9. 1"2"2-"7.=> 8"98""=>

+ ?@ - 11882 19'

 -"1"9"=> "."72"=>

+ - ?@ 1 -.82 12' 1"".7"-.=> "."72"=>

'  1 ?@ 181182 '

 88"29"-"=> "."72"=>

'  ?@ 19982 1'1 8."9"=> 1"-.""91=>

'  ?@ 8182 8'1. 8".""=> .""7"2=>

'  ?@ 1 8182 1'19 1"7""=> ."""=>

'  2 ,   #  :     )#          

!

+    @#+  8 82  ?@ .

 @#     1(  

   #0

82 #, (  F>8

)  " 0



  #      !

  + 

     +  !

 & ("( "



&  + 6( ! # #( # ( " )  "'<

)   ) #  #  ( !



+ #0 (

 

 

(  - A   # !

 

79 < # #(  +/

#0 :#"

 !

<

"&

<":(

'<  )     +

 9   <    #  +    /

#0 :# 6!

 )  "( " ( <  + @B. < #"  &  +  + B. < # 1 A""    ( 

 



#

: 

#

#(   '

   !       #   #       @(   

+" +#! # ( "

:  

+ #<



!

 +##( #"

#

# +! #   @( ,

 +  

+ @:  )

>:/?

"( !"&;&2 !  "<

( !"&-'* '5+5%*-9



 #, !

  )    > G1. ,



)  #   +

   + 

#  # "

 !  # (+  + +       (# #      # #   0 

  ( ,# +







  # + #

(  

      

    # 

 (   )# 

(     !

 0    (       #     0 H 

" 

 (

#

#!  > <(

#(  ( <(   # /

+



( # !

+



  !

 19  ,  ! 

=)         #! #   #( ! 

#  ,  (       

  #!  +  ! ) =

0+!<

 #( !@( A # !

=)  +  @( " # (  ## +"

!

=) ##

+ + + 

#(  + )#  #   (  ( <     +     



#( "#

+    



#

+ #

=)

+ !

 1,

 ( 

   )    

      #0 +118 

#+

(  + + !

  # #( ! #       ##     !   $ 

77



       #   #   ,     (   (

#(  +   

+ # 

# +

#  # #

 !

  # "

! ## #

#   

 (  #, #   !   #  #

( #   

 "

# !

,"   "  ! ((

#(  12,+ (  #( 

!

=) "! ##   !) =



 ## + )#  (       +  #     "   "

=  )#( +# 

 A #  ( ( <

 + #(( ! 

=)       ( <

 #  #

=# ! # + #

+ ! #    #    #     

"  !

=) +

 > #

+ 



 (    # + > )#   #  #( ! @(    !  !

  #

# #+ # #  #

#  "( ( !

 I 11



":#>@   + # # +!?@ 1

 @#8D  " + # <

+ +   (! 

! (

(# 7-<

1(  A

!

    "

@# .18"  <8"7"."9=>

77  #" ##++  #@

(  ( "!  7183?@ 25

(

7 <

9.( 

B8"98""=> # 18 : 

 !B18C"

<

! 

 

0 5%

 /"

% &"$"

5

15?5!

;&

?!& @ 55+

@ 5

!%

 !"A-'8*2 89( #+    .18

  17181 17 :   

  

 # (#   #?@   ! + #   !" @ ( "  #

 82 # <

!8 #"(  <

B "."72"=> #," +  !

   

##

+  

++

 1 A  

 ##   8.182"

#01.(   <

&

<

,

&( 

+ % 

%2  !

'<&  *

 

       #!#  + 

#  #19 ,

!



  !

" 



  #(

(&

< ##  %  

7-7 1.  #  ##(

#"      +       1C #( !

#( 

 !

 # ?@ 1

8 8"7"."9=> # !

 ,( <     #(   7"7"7-".2-=>    #  3      7"7"7-"9=> #51C#  !+ +! "<

!  #  . #

"  

# + #0(

82 #

 #(   #0 "1C# # +   + ##

" (  @ 8"-"7."9=>

# 19



"  

   

           (  +  @

   ( <  !

  B 8"-"7."9=> # 

  +  1  

#!(#

 #    !+   

" ##

  '2231*  ;) 6.

    F <

=  

=% F  +

=%