Renu And ORS v. Anil Kumar Shukla And ORS

   
     

     



 ! ""## $ #%&!' (# !  "   ! "#" $%&%'(

$()* +,+-.,-/+(% $(0%+11%**+'(&  )**'+,+-./,!# 0%  +2+$,  ,+(%,  3 

  1+&&%,  45  (0%  ($  //6,%'( *+67&$64)'+*.)$)8$+79 $&0$(. (0%$64)'+* :0+&4%%'+&&+6*%,45 (0%*%8+*$%1$%&%'(+(6-%& +7+7%&09,%/%+&%,:.&%%;6'8%'0+'/%7%'(  /71%'&+(6'+2+$,%,)',%$"%/(6'<< (0% ($#%06/*%&/(.

= 9 $&0$(. (0%/( :  %&1',%'(&  +$%  (0%  ,$6-%$.  2'%$  +',  6'&)$%$  96%   !74+$,%'%$+*'&)$+'/%71+'5!(,: ($+/($4%+$6'8$%86&($+(6'

>3 >>?< 9 $&0$(. (0%

%',6'8-%06/*% : 0% +/(&+$%&)77+$6@%,4%*2 '  

<.+7+7%&0+*'826(006& $6%',#%,+$;+&0 2+&($+-%**6'86'+$4%+$6'8$%86&($+(6'> <>>= 3'(0%6$ 2+5.(0%/+$2+&&($)/;45(0%

%',6'8-%06/*%.,)%((0%671+/(.+7 +7%&0 &)&(+6'%,  6'A)$6%&  +',  '  (0% &+7% ,+5 0%  &)//)74%,  (  (0% 6'A)$6%&
 ,+(%, = 

<2+&$%86&(%$%,+(*6/%"(+(6'

   +';6.B+'1)$6(5 '(0%/*+671%(6(6'.6(2+&1*%+,%,(0+((0%,%/%+&%,2+&

5%+$&*,+',2+&$)''6'8+&016&%+$'6'82+&/*+67%,+&
? .

C>1%$ 7'(0'$,%$(1$-%(0%//)1+(6'+',%+$'6'8 (0%,%/%+&%,.'*5 (0%,%1&6(6' (0%26,22+&(0%$%+','%6'/7%>(+D$%()$' $(0% +&&%&&7%'(5%+$

> =2+&%D0646(%,0%/*+67+'(& +6*%,(1$-%(0% //)1+(6'+',%+$'6'8 (0%,%/%+&%,0%$64)'+*+&&%&&%,(0%7'(0*5 %+$'6'8+&
.

C>.

E )()$%1$&1%/(&2%$%+2+$,%,.C?$,,%,)/(6' $ &%* %D1%'&%&2+&7+,%+',7)*(61*6%$ 2+&+11*6%,0%$64)'+* +2+$,%,+&)7 
. .

< C>.206/02+&$)',%,

( 
. .

C> +*'826(06'(%$%&(F3E1%$+'')70%+7)'(+2+$,%,6'/*),%, .

C>)',%$(0%/'-%'(6'+*0%+,&+',
.

.

C> $*&& *-%+', +

%/(6' 0%  $64)'+*  /'&6,%$6'8  (0%  +/(&  +',  +11$%/6+(6'8  (0% %-6,%'/%  +,,)/%,  0%*,  (0+(  (0%  +//6,%'(  2+&  /+)&%,  ,)%  (  $+&0  +', '%8*68%'(,$6-6'8 (0%

%',6'8-%06/*%0%,$6-%$.2'%$+',(0%6'&)$%$ 2%$%0%*,A6'(*5+',&%-%$+**5*6+4*%(1+5(0%/71%'&+(6' %+$,  *%+$'%,  /)'&%*  $  (0%  +11%**+'(&  +',  1%$)&%,  (0% $%*%-+'(,/)7%'(&1$,)/%,45067 0%'*58$6%-+'/%$+6&%,45*%+$'%,/)'&%* $(0%+11%**+'(& 6&(0+((0%6'/7%+&&%&&%,45(0%$64)'+*6&'(0%*2%$&6,% (2+&/*+67%,(0+((0%,%/%+&%,2+&$)''6'8+&01+',2+& %+$'6'8
?

.

C>1%$7'(0.(0%/*+67+'(& +6*%,(+,,)/%+'5%-6,%'/%( &)11$((0%6$/*+67(06'82+&4$)80('$%/$,%-%'(&02(0+((0% &014%6'8$)'2+&2'%,45067$2+&'$%'( %6(0%$+'5+//)'( 4;&'$+'5(0%$6(+ %-6,%'/%2+&1$,)/%,(&)4&(+'(6+(%(0%

 ? 7'(0*56'/7% (0%,%/%+&%,0%6'/7%(+D$%()$'1$,)/%,2+& $ (0%  +&&%&&7%'(  5%+$ 

> =.  20%$%+&  (0%  +//6,%'(  (;  1*+/%   '

 

<%()$' 6*%,2+&%680(5%+$&*,
$7+1%$)&+* (0%$%()$'.6(6&%-6,%'((0+(6'(0%&+6,5%+$ (0%$%()$'2+& 6*%,/*+676'8(0+((0%$%2+&6'/7% $74)&6'%&&+', 1$ %&&6' $7206/0+'%(1$ 6(  
.

.

C>2+&%+$'%, !%+$'%, /)'&%* $(0%+11%**+'(&0+&'(4%%'+4*%(,6&1)(%(0+((0%$%+ (%$' $%()$'2+& 6*%,+(*%+&('(1$,)/%,
+6*)$% 6*6'8 (0%$%()$'/)1*%, 26(0(0% +/((0+('(06'82+&1$,)/%,(&02(0+(+((0%$%*%-+'((67%(0% ,%/%+&%,2+&&(6**/+$$56'8'(0%4)&6'%&&.(0%$%2+&'//+&6' $(0% $64)'+*(+//%1((0%&+7% $(0%1)$1&% +&&%&&6'8(0%%+$'6'8 (0% ,%/%+&%,G0%$%(0%7'(0*5%+$'6'8 (0%,%/%+&%,6&'(1$-%,.6'&)/0 /6$/)7&(+'/%&.'% (0%&+ %&(5+$,&(6/;6&($%*5)1'(0%76'67)7 2+8%&1$%-+*%'(6'(0%"(+(%+((0%(67% +//6,%'((8$+'(/71%'&+(6' '&6,%$6'8  (0%  76'67)7 2+8%&  1$%-+*%'(  6'  (0%  "(+(%  

+$5+'++((0%(67% +//6,%'(.'6'(%$ %$%'/%6&/+**%, $6'(0%6'/7% +&&%&&%,45(0%$64)'+* 0%+11%+*6&,6&76&&%, )**'+,+-. ,0.*  

= 7;

G0%(0%$&1%+;6'8C$%+&'%,

%&C G0%(0%$$%1$(+4*%

%&C