High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1637/2013allowed

Huda Panchkula v. Braham Bhushan

2018-05-02Mrs. Justice Anita Chaudhry12 pages

!"# $"% &'() *+"#,- +.*' (('' /"

0"+)0+* + +"

")+ ,& "+(('' "-1 2*)","&1+ "%+) #*0",& "+"

4+ (('' + 5*'" (('

+6*5) (

%#+7"

((''8*""&"

5+ 6*5) (

%#+'"

"'8*" +

"( + 8*", ''1 5 *% '

'1" +(" ;++" +% # 5,+"1+" (&'

+(" (' *"'6* "+) "#("*"' 1 +"+*' ,+6*" +8&'8*" <) +&'# +"" " *)( &1 +%"

" * " + !"# $"% &'() *+"# , =

" +" >+ =

? +''

<'*@%""A

;++" ""(

%#+*+"#* " + =

":*"%+'' 5%#+55"&("

1+ (" +"#"

")+ +""A 4+ (('' &5 "'(*%'("(

+* +))"' 9 +&" ) ,+) ")

+* 1"5& ,1++"<" * "

! "

# $ %&

& % ' (#

) $

$ *&

&, +

$ -. / $

! & 2

2 $ &$ & $ 2 2 # & & & - $

& & 4 4+ ('

" 1" '" +5+ %" ,

,@1+" (+("("#0+ ,", - +.*' (*%'* +' = 4+('

( *)

, @% 5B +' '

+ )#4+

")%#+('

+(*%'* 1

( '') '"1

*+('

= 4+('

1"":*" *"+"( C=, @

"")('+(#) B +(" +('1+ # 4+)* ''5+&% ( 1+ + " ) ("+'') '",+('

" +1 (

,+"( +%' (" '*)( *)1+* # " "( +") 5)* +'

#"'#

'') ' 51+ " ("+'') '",++'

#"'#

'') 1"* (#%' +)%" +D* ,&"##"4+"'& ("

+'') '" <" * "

$$& # 5# 6

& 7) "0 !

.&-)

! 4 4+* ,+ "

'') ''* =

'') ''* = = +* )'"'# + *% :* #"

4+('

( ''1 5)*

= =

, @ == ,@

== ,@ 4+ +1" ) 1+" (&"*

(("* 5& +('

* "

& -(89

:##("

& &;;;

# #%-)

2 &

& & & & <%* #-) *;; & 2

& 2 2

& -(8==9&

:%%(;

& & "";;"<"

"% #0-) &2 2

&$ 2

7) 9 : - (8"9 &

:,%*, & & "#;;"<"

%% ",-) 9 : - (8%9 &

:(0 & & "0*;;"<"

,, ,#0-) 9 : - (809 &

:0%#" & & "#;;;"<"

##;-)

:(;;*& &";;"

$ & 2

& 2

2 2 2 -( 809

& &#;;% & &

& 5

$ &

& & &";;% &

& :";"

& & ";;% & & & <# #-)

& &

4 4+('

+'' 5+"" " *)( (

%#+

" ((' 4+ ((' 1 )

& "" C == 4+('

'+(" * = . '" ++!"# $"% &'() *+"# +"5 '# B )(' " +"" == 5

'14+ ('

+'' 5 = 4+ "" == (

%#+E

" 'F"

+ ++"((("* +&% 5& +('

(#+)* ,+1&",+)* + % ( 4+E

" + '

+ + ('

+& '# % *'5 5

"" %* ( + )* , '+*5+, &"*

(("* 1"5& & %&4+('

+'' 5+))* = + *4+ " ))* '# '' 5 *( + ('

+ &" +

+%+

:* *( +" *)( +0+ F"

"'8*" ((" +& &'%'

+ ', )

+ * '%#+('

)" 1'' + :* ++6*" +8&'8*" %""* "

+ =

4+('

' "

(('' 51+ ((' "

'# 4+ ((' " '# 1

)

5*'" (('1 ' +!5+8*"0# ") "",+!5+8*"(")+('

( +)* " 5'#, ,@1 ( 1+!"# $"% &'() *+"# C 4+" ",(('1 ''1'# ' 5+ (('1 + 1 ")%.+7"

(('' 8*" " )" F"

((''8*" " 5++)* + % ( +!"# $"% &'() *+"#*'

+"5)"+ B " 1+" B1 % 5) , (+(('

& & &&$

?? @

& $

& & .

;((8

;((49 & @& &- &A + =

," * "

# / & & 3& ? ? 89 .

$ @ & &

& && &

. B

& & &

& & +

& 2 8"9 :?? 3&

& 2

2 C

&& &

$ &

2 &

& 4 " *'" 5 + =

((" ++6*" + 8&'8*"+ % <'* <) +""

(

%#+*+"

** "+ *%, +8&'8*"1+'<) 5+& &'%' + ' ""& '* ++"+) "#("&

+* "

1+++""

1"(

+&% &'"+""

(

%#+ *+" ("& 5+'' ))&%'("("#+&%

(

1+* ''1 5+(" (' *"'6* "+""

" 1+*6*" ,+8&'8*"1*'% ' " + * (" = +8 8&'-"*",+8*"

+&6*" "#''8&'* * '

( ''#%"" =

<" * "

)

? 83

&9 3&

@ 2 $

2 C

@ & &

$ & 2 2 &

& + 2

& @ =$

& 4

!1&", '++%"+6*" +8&'

8*"

% "

" '# " "'#* '

+" ( ("& %"" 5+6*" +8&'8*"4+8&'8*" +''

+&6*" "#''&' * 9 +(" ,%++8*"

%'1 "" # *+ 59 +(' ,+('

+& &

"++(" (' *"'6* +& % ''1"

+"" &' +) "#("&

+!"# $"%

&'() *+"# , =

& + % ' %# + ('

' "+('

" + "'*( 6*5) (

%#+ 8*""(" "89!D<#((

2 ?

& &

EF &: , ++8&'8*"+ +6*" 7") " *'" 5 + " 6*5) , '"++ 8*"+

"'*( +6*5) "(" ;;089<

< 0;, BG >& & .

2 G 8!9 D & E

" *'<) +6*5) + G ;" *(", ((" + + ,+8*"+ , )"

, * ++) "#("&

+!$ ,=

+&% &'! ,+ " 6*5) 1*' )+" * +" ('

'+ *"+""'*( +6*5) "(" " 809 ! 3 D$ < ((0 &

E <? B 9 + 6*5) , +"

= *

+ =

+("&(" + 6*5) F"

'+ *"+""'*( +6*5) (

%# + 8*" "(" "* 89 !D< %; &

. & G 2, ++8&'8*"+ +6*" " *'" 5 + " 6*5) , * ++8*", )" , * ++ (" (' *"'6* +&% &' ++"+ ,'"

' "+(('' + "' *( +6*5) (

%#+8" 0 + = C

&)%" , , 1+" 8" 0 + '*++6*" +8&'8*" %"", ,

%' +++ *"#("&

+&% )('1+ + "" " *)( + % (

" ''1 5+(" (' *"'

6* &1 + " ,:*

1" &*"

+(('' " >

& &

& .

(

;(( + &

22 & $ &

& A 4+ * '%#+('

1 %""%#') 4+ ""(

%#+*+"#" *) 5+('1 (

== 4+ *)% ' = 9 + +'"

' "+" +& +((' '%#+('

+" *)( ""(

%#+E

",1 )

C == E& . 5+* +'' 5+""+& " C == , ''+ * '%#+('

1*'%%""%# ) (""' +F) ,+') %5

"* 1+ +"5+ * "

"* +') " ' 5+ *

+"#"

E<) 5+(" +% "' ,

* ++ * %""%#) '+*5+,'"

' "+('

) "* )( & + 8*"+ +('

+'' 5+ ))* = , +1&", %&, + ))* = '#

") 5+('

+ &"+(

4+'" *)( ""1 (

+#"

== (('1 '

)

+#"== 4+('

+'' 5+"" " *)( 1+ +)(" "%* "+'1 4+))* = 1 '#

:* ' *" ! ,:* '

1" &*" +(('' F"

' "+" ('

*%) ++) !"# $"% &'() *+"#1 ''5' +

"( + 8*",+ :* 1*' " "6* +('

+& '("&++('

&") )(")

"(#+)* ' 51+ " (*' +'') '"4+('

+& &" # (#) %#1# " "+:*+!"# $"% &'() *+"# (" ") 1+ + % %& 4+ %+ 1

(*"+ +#"= %* %&, "(#) B

+)* ,+('

(#+)* "5*'"'# F"

' "+" + '

*%)++ )* ":*"+ % ( %#+('

+#" (*"

* + ")""(

%#+!5+8*"*" 5+( # + (('! *%)+ +)* + % ( * "+"" +8*",+0+ 1%

%(") %" *) +5"* (#) +

"( + 8*",+"5*) +

" +""(

%#+ 8*"1 '# ")""1+' " 5 + 5*'" ((' *+ "" (

*)''#" *' 5 +"" +" *)( F"

' "+('

+ *"+" *%)++ " *)( +))&%'("("# +*' % ")''#" "%# +(*%'*+" 9 '#%" " ' " "! *%) ++"" " *)( 1 (

1+* "

)( 5( '# "

'(#) " "

*" +)* " *' <) + ', ("& + + ('

1"5& "

===4+" ",5 1

5& == 5 * " 1 5&

== 4+" " * " 1 5& C == +" " * " C1 5& === E&

+" ",('

1"5" (("* ( +)* & ))* == E& *"+" +('

5" 5+) '(("* #&))* == 1

("&! ,

% ++('

1" "1"

4+*+" * "+ =

5& *

(("* + ('

% ". 5 &1 + " ,+5*'" ((' '%# + (('' ( 4+ 6*5) (

%# + '"

((''8*" +6*5) (

%#+'"

8*" " "!1&",. 5 + + +#" , * "+ ")""," )* + % ( ,+!"# &'() *+"# +''. ( " * + )' 51+ # +")* * " * %'+('

''+( 5) '' * (('

, #," , &1 +%& 6*5) (('''1

$ !$ %&'%&()*&+,-./0(&+)1.&2

&)01 %&'%&((&*1('+34&

&)01