← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1674/2013dismissed

Jagan Nath Goyal v. Municipal Council Sangrur Thrg E.O

2018-05-07Mr. Justice Arun Monga4 pages

 

     

    !

"#$$%&'&() "* + , "-"("#.*"/ 00$//"(# 1$2'3'

3(&%&0"/3(%&/+"(-232  $'0(4$(#'

! "

#$%&' () *+!' +*,&

2$'$(#) 2'.5."246"7+48%"#$+ 2#.$"00$//"(# 2 $."24$$0&(-.+48%"#$+ 2#.$2$'0(4$(# 99999  +*,&-(

00$//"(#:0/"&(#&&'&( $-3/"2$%(400$"/"-"&('##.$ %(%322$(#&(4&(-'"%#+6.$2$;*#.$'3&#&/$4;*.&<%/"&<&(-4"<"-$' # #.$#3($ +

+

=:+ ."' ;$$( 4&'<&''$4 ;*#.$#2&"/ 32#  "(4 2$&#$2"#$4;*#.$>6$200$//"#$32# .$  "2$<$(#&($4  '3&#  6"'  &/$4  (  #.$  02$<&'$  #."#  ( ?

"#";3#,

 +#.$"00$//"(#:0/"&(#&6"'0"''&(-#.23-.#.$ '#2$$#($"2 "#" "(&"/&+.32&"#$"(-232(";&%*%/$6.$(.$$// &(##.$'$6$2"-$./$43-;*#.$4$$(4"(#: 3(&%&0"/3(%&/+"(-232 '"2$'3/##.$"2$<$(#&($4&(%&4$(#+.$'3$2$4"2"%#32$(#.$ 2&-.#."(4"(4&(732&$'(62&'#+"2<7&(#"(44&'/%"#&(.$2$6"'"/'" %2"%5&(($;($ ($ "5$'.@3<"2A "003+6.6"'0"''&(-2< #."#0/"%$+42"--$4.&<3#2<#.$'$6$2"-$4&#%."(4.&'%*%/$ ( .$"2&(-#.$(&'$+ "7&8@3<"2'(2&"(."(4@"('"/%"<$3#

 2< .&'  .3'$  "(4  #5  #.$  "00$//"(#:0/"&(#&  #  #.$  &8&/  '0&#"/+ "(-232$6"' "##$(4$4;*2"/&&( #.$<$2-$(%*B&(-"(4 '3--$'#$4#-$#&#C:2"*$4"(4%$2#"&(#.$2($%$''"2*#$'#'.$'$6$2"-$ ./$4&#%.6"''<3%.4"(-$23'"(4&(8&$6#.$"2$<$(#&($4"%#+ .$2$<"&($4%(&($4#;$42 4"*'"(4+#.3'+%/"&<$44"<"-$'

0(  (#&%$+  #.$  4$$(4"(#'  %(#$'#$4  #.$  '3&#  ;*  2"&'&(- ;7$%#&(#."##.$2$6"'(3(%8$2$4'$6$2"-$./$&(#.$ "#" "(&"/& "'('3%.%<0/"&(#."4;$$(2$%$&8$42<#.$&(.";&#"(#'#.$"2$" .$"00$//"(#:0/"&(#&&'.";&#3"/&/&(-"/'$'3&#' 2$8&3'/*"/'+.$ &/$4"'3&#"-"&('##.$4$$(4"(#+6.&%.&'0$(4&(- (#.$;"'&'#.$0/$"4&(-'#.$0"2#&$'##.$/&'+#.$#2&"/ 32#2"<$4#.$//6&(-&''3$'):

D    

           

      

                

          



 

       

    

  !

"# (  '3002#    .&'  %"'$+  #.$  "00$//"(#:0/"&(#&  $E"<&($4 1$$2&(4$2 "/"' B:+2"/& B:+ "7&8"('"/ B:+0/"&(#& .&<'$/"00$"2$4"' B:?"(4'.5@3<"2 "."7"( B: (#.$#.$2 ."(4+#.$4$$(4"(#$E"<&($4"';&2&(-."(&#"2*('0$%#2B:"(4"& &(-./$25B: (  #.$  ;"'&'    #.$  $8&4$(%$  (  2$%24+  #.$  #2&"/  32# 4&'<&''$4#.$'3&#"(4#.$"00$"//"&4;$2$#.$>6$200$//"#$32#"/' <$#6&#.#.$'"<$"#$ 2'.5."246"7+/$"2($4%3('$/2#.$"00$//"(#:0/"&(#& '3;<&##$4#."##.$32#';$/6."8$(#"48$2#$4##.$'#"#$<$(# B:

 2"/&+6.$E"<&($4#.$"00$//"(#:0/"&(#&.$"00$//"(#'3$2$4 #.$ &(732&$'  (  .&'  2&-.#  62&'#  "(4  "48&'$4  C:2"*  $  6"'  2$$22$4 # 2#.0$4&%32-$( B:'#"#$4#."#.$6"'($<$2-$(%*43#*"(4#.$ "00$//"(#'3'#"&($4(3<$23'&(732&$' .#-2"0.'E #E ?028$4 #.$'$6$2"-$./$+;3#4$'0&#$#."##.$$8&4$(%$"2$<$(#&($4."4(# ;$$( "48$2#$4 #+2$'3/#&(- &(# 4&'<&''"/ #.$'3&#+6.&%. &'  -2'' &//$-"/&#*"(40$28$2'&#*

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

4"%#3"//*'3'#"&($4#.$&(732&$' ("%%3(##.$"//&(#.$4&#%..$0.#-2"0.'4(#4$0&%##."##.$2$ 6"'"4&#%.$8&4$(%$."';$$(;23-.#(2$%24#$'#";/&'.#."#'<$ 2$0"&26256"'-&(-(&(#.$'#2$$#6.$2$#.$"00$//"(#"//$-$4/*$// $'#0&$%$$8&4$(%$+&$+2#.0$"4&%2$%24."';$$(6&#..$/4+<3%. /$'' <$4&%"/ $8&4$(%$# 6"' " "//"%&3' /&#&-"#&( ( ;$."/ #.$ "00$//"(#+6.&%./"%5$4#.$4&2$%#"(4%-$(#$8&4$(%$.$"2-3<$(# 2."246"7&'(#";/$#%3#&%$#;2&(-#.$%"'$6&#.&(#.

 &//$-"/&#*20$28$2'&#*#$(";/$<$#2<"4&$2$(#0&(&(#."(#.$($ "22&8$4"#

2#.$2$"'(''#"#$4";8$+4(#&(4"(*&//$-"/&#*2 0$28$2'&#*&(#.$%(%322$(#&(4&(-'+<3%./$''(F3$'#&(/"6"2&'$'2 4$#$2<&("#&( $'3/#"(#/*+#.$"00$"/&'4&'<&''$4

.-/    +*,&

012 ()34'

,252167 81

 918

,252 5:"

918