High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1680/2013dismissed

Pritpal Singh v. Mohinder Singh And ANR

2015-01-12Mr. Justice Arun Monga5 pages

!"##$%&%'(!')!*+,-

*%".!/%'01 ..#//!'"

2#*&)& 1%'3#*%'01 !'"1#* #&.'3#'"& !

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%,'(-.&

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

"1#*#&.'3#'"7./!%'"%& @#!*'#3 $)'&#/ !..#!*%'0 ' 9#1!/ "1# !..#//!'"7 3##'3!'",%'&)..*"1%&&)98%&&%',&)98%"&"1!"'A ==,"1#*# :!& ! &#""/#8#'" 9#":##' "1# !..#//!'"73##'3!'" !'3 "1# *#&.'3#'"7 ./!%'"%&!'3"1#&!%3&#""/#8#'":!&!38%""#39+"1#*#&.'3#'"7./!%'"%& 3)*%'0"1#$*&&7#>!8%'!"%''&)..*",/#!*'#3$)'&#/*"1#!..#//!'"7 3##'3!'"*#/%#&).'"1#.*5%&%'& *3#*2, )/#7 *"1# &!;#9*#5%"+,"1#.*5%&%'& *3#*2 )/#7 !*##>"*!$"#3 1#*#%'9#/:(7 BCD , 7

@E D*%""#'&"!"#8#'"71#3##'3!'"&1!//,:%"1%'"1%*"+3!+&*8 "1# 3!"# &#*5%$# &)88'& '1%8, .*#&#'" ! :*%""#' &"!"#8#'"1%&3##'$#(

*5%3#3 "1!" :1#*# "1# 3##'3!'" !%/& " %/# "1# :*%""#' &"!"#8#'":%"1%'"1#&!%3.#*%3"1%*"+3!+&,1#&1!//9# !//:#3"%/#"1#&!8#'&)$1"1#*3!+,!&8!+9#&.#$%%#3 9+"1#)*",**#!&'&"9#*#$*3#3%':*%"%'0,9)":1%$1 &1!//'"9#/!"#*"1!''%'#"+3!+&*8"1#3!"#&#*5%$# &)88'&E )"+3##'3!'"".*3)$#3$)8#'"&).':1%$1 *#/%# %& $/!%8#3 * *#/%#3 ).' 9+ 1%87 D1#*# "1# 3##'3!'"9!&#&1%&3##'$#).'!3$)8#'"**#/%#&).' !'+3$)8#'"%'1%&.&&#&&%'*.:#*,%'&)..*"1%& 3##'$#*$/!%8*&#"7*$)'"#*7$/!%8,1#&1!//#'"#*

&)$13$)8#'"%'!/%&",!'3&1!//.*3)$#%"%')*":1#'"1# :*%""#'&"!"#8#'"%&.*#&#'"#39+1%8!'3&1!//,!""1#&!8# "%8#,3#/%5#*"1#3$)8#'"!'3!$.+"1#*#,"9#%/#3:%"1 "1#:*%""#'&"!"#8#'"

D1#*#!'+&)$13$)8#'"%&'"%'"1#.&&#&&%'* .:#*"1#3##'3!'",1#&1!//, :1#*#5#* .&&%9/#,&"!"#%' :1&#.&&#&&%'*.:#*%"%& 3$)8#'":1%$1)01""9#.*3)$#3%')*"9+"1# 3##'3!'")'3#*"1%&*)/#,9)",%&'"&.*3)$#3&1!//'", :%"1)""1#/#!5#"1#)*",9#*#$#%5#3%'#5%3#'$#'1%& 9#1!/!""1#1#!*%'0"1#&)%"E

< "1%'0%'"1%&*)/#&1!//!../+"3$)8#'"&7

.*3)$#3 * "1# $*&&7#>!8%'!"%' "1# ./!%'"%F& :%"'#&&#&,*

1!'3#35#*"!:%"'#&&8#*#/+"*#*#&11%&8#8*+EG '.#*)&!/"1#.*5%&%'& *3#*2, )/#7 < ,%"%& #5%3#'""1!""1#!..#//!'"73##'3!'"1!3'"*#/%#3).'"1#3$)8#'"& 5#'!&&)8%'0*"1#!*0)8#'"&!;#"1!""1#!..#//!'"73##'3!'"1!3'" *#/%#3).'"1%&3$)8#'"!&8!'3!"*%/+*#H)%*#39+ *3#*2 )/#7, #5#'"1#'"1#.*%'$%./#&)97*)/# < )/#7 *3#*2:)/3'"

$8#""1#!%3"1#!..#//!'"73##'3!'"%'5%#:"1#!$""1!""1# !..#//!'"73##'3!'"1!3'"&.#$%%$!//+3#'%#3"1#$!)&#!$"%'!$$*)#3 ""1#*#&.'3#'"7./!%'"%& 1#!..#//!'"73##'3!'"1!3'""!;#'"1#./#!&#""/#8#'"%' "1#:*%""#'&"!"#8#'"D1%/#%/%'0"1#&)%","1#*#&.'3#'"7./!%'"%&%'.!*!

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

0 *#0%&"*!"%'"1#&!/#3##3#>#$)"#39+1%&!"1#*!;1!'%'01"1"1# )*"&9#/:1!5#*#'3#*#3!%'3%'0!$"!'3/!:9!&#3'"1#*!/!'3 3$)8#'"!*+#5%3#'$# &)9&"!'"%!/H)#&"%'/!:!*%&#&*3#"#*8%'!"%'"1%& )*" $$*3%'0/+,"1#!..#!/%&3%&8%&&#3 ' 1,0 *)+%

234 '(-.&