High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1685/2013dismissed

Punjab State Power Corp Ltd & ANR v. Harpreet Singh

2016-02-05Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain5 pages

!"#$ !"#$ !"#$ !"#$

# #%& &'()(*&+,-,.

#%& &'()(*&+,-,.

#%& &'()(*&+,-,. / / / /

-0+%%& 1&, ,2,%(3(4(%& %(5 %6&,) 22&55%) 7&,)-) ,2,&&%(86 &)2&% ,2,&&%(86 22&55% 7&,)-) -0+%%& 1&, ,2,%(3(4(%& %(5 %6&,) &)2&%)

* 9"3!

" 9"3!

" ,&)&%* ,&)&%* ,&)&%* ,&)&%* ,-:-588,15/;'%&

,%6&22&55%)(

,&)2&%( ,.:%6-,/;'%&

,%6&22&55%( ,&)2&%(

<<<<< <<<<< <<<<< <<<<< "/!

"/!

"/! 7(& %6() ,&,/ +;&=4&%(& %1 22&5) 1-5+&()2)& )%6&)4&6;&,()&-% )4& )-(% ,2,&&% (86= 5(%(

6 (5& )-(% , &'5,%(%6%%6&,&,16&,&+./2&)(,.+&& (%) &425.4&%'42))(%&8,-)1&,&&'5(&% 6(4/1)(55&85 6&')&

/(+,(& /1)%6%0(+

(861)1,:(8)3(&41(%6%6&& &%) 6(& >> 16(5&()&,;('& 0(+(861) -4,,(&62%&%6&25(%(

)6()) 5(%(

6 (5&)-(% %&>??

)&&:(8&'5,%( %6%6&1)5&855.2%&) 0(+(86%6&)( )-(%/ 0(+ (866 22&,& 6 (5&6() 1,(%%& )%%&4&%6&)-(%1)&',&& ??? %&,%6& &%6 0(+(86/25(%(

6(6&,(%&%6&2,2&,%.

0(+(86+&(86()2%&) -+&1&55'&'%( ()%55&(%6&5 0(+(861)5)%,) &,,&+.

%6&& &%= ,2,%((%6&4&

%&, %6& &%6 0(+ (86/ 25(%(

6 22,'6& %6& &%= ,2,%( ,,&5&)& ,&%(,5+&& (%) 0(+ (86 % 6(4 , 2,;((8 6(4 &425.4&% '42))(%&8,-)1&;&,/%6&)(,&@-&)% %6& 25(%(

1)&'5(&+.%6&& &%);(&,&,%& > &'&/%6&)-(%1) (5&+.%6&25(%(

#& &%)(%6&(,1,(%%&)%%&4&%&(&%6%

1)%6&2%&) 0(+(86&'&/(% 1)2,.&%6%%6&25(%(

1)%&%(%5&%%6&,&5(&

'5(4&+.6(4 %6&25&(8) %6&2,%(&)/ 551(8())-&) 1&,& ,4&+.%6&%,(5 -,%*= A B6&%6&, %6& 25(%(

() &%(%5& , %6& &'5,%()2,.& ,C

())-& ()&'(&(6() ;-,/16&%6&,

()&%(%5& ,%6&2.4&% ,,&,) 581(%6(%&,&)%C B6&%6&, %6& )-(% %6& 25(%(

() % 4(%(+5&(%6&2,&)&% ,4C # = B6&%6&,&',&&%&D???2))&+.

(;(5 !-8& !-(, #(;()(/ +6 () ,&)-5%

,-'55-)(()(55&85/-55;(/ 1(%6-% 0-,()('%( % +((8 %6& &%C # D &5(& E ,%(&) 5& %6&(, &;(&'& ( )-22,% %6&(, ,&)2&'%(;&25&) ,(5 -,% ;(& 0-84&%F&',&& %& &',&& %6& )-(% %6& 25(%(

6& ,&5(&

'5-)& %6&0-84&%%& ,&))-&,*= A %6& %%5(%. %6& '%) '(,'-4)%'&) ()'-))& (

,&=8(8 2,8,26)/%6&)-(%()&',&& ,&'5,%(% %6&&

&'%%6%%6&25(%(

+&(82%&)

&'&)& 0(+ (86 () &%(%5& % 4:& ,&2,&)&%%( ,'42))(%&&425.4&%% %6&& &%)6&& &%))655&'(&%6& )4&('','&1(%6%6&&2,%4&%5,-5&) +. 2))(81&55 ,&)& )2&:(8,&, 6& 25(%(

()5)&%(%5& ,&%6='-4=,&%(,&4&% +&& (%)'',-& %&,&%6 0(+(86+&(8 2%& ) )-+0&'% % ,-5&) )-''&))( 225('+5& % %6& 2,%(&) 6& & &%) ,& 8(;& )(G 4%6) %(4& ,4 %6& %&

2,&2,%( '2. %6()0-84&%%&'(&%6&

'5(4 25(%(

('','&1(%6%6&51 &2,%4&% ,-5&) #&',&& )6&&% +& ,1 '',(85. (5& +& ')(8& % %6& ,&', ,4E 88,(&;& 8()% %6& )( 0-84&%F&',&&/ &%= ,2,%( 2,& &,,& 22&5 6& (,)% 22&55%& -,% ;(& 0-84&%F&',&& %& 2,%5.551&%6&22&56&5%6%%6&25(%(

1) &%(%5&%,&'&(;&%6&,&%(,5+&& (%)'',-(8''-% &%6 0(+(86/+-%1)%&%(%5& ,22(%4&% '42))(%&8,-)&'&/%6&2,&)&%22&5)+.

)1&55)& &%) 6;&6&,5&,&'-)&5 ,%6&2,%(&) 6;&8&%6,-86%6&,&',;(5+5&%6& (5&',& -55. 4(%%&5./0(+(861)1,:(8)3(&4 1(%6%6&& &%)6(& >> 16(5&( )&,;('&6& -,%)+&51,(86%5.6&5%6%%6&25(%(

1) %6& 2%& ) 0(+(86 (;(&1 &',&& %& D???2))&(%6(),&8,( ;-,

('&%6&25(%(

1)%6&2%&) 0(+(86/%6&

-,%)+&51,(86%5.6&5%6%%6&,&%(,5+&& (%)'',-(8 ''-% &%6 0(+ (86 1&,& 5(+5& % +& ()+-,)&%%6&25(%(

6&&G%@-&)%(%6%,&@-(,&)')(&,%(() ) % 16&%6&, 25(%(

1) &%(%5& , 22(%4&% '42))(%&+)()%6(),&8,/(%6)+&&%('&+.

%6&(,)%22&55%& -,%%6%%6&25(%(

1)6;(85& 2,2&,%.(;(558&56,#& &%)65)25'& ,&','-4&%)%%6&&

&'%%6%%6&25(%(

65) (6&,(%&2,2&,%. ,46()%-,5 %6&,%()%6&')&

6(4)&5 5)%6%6&6(6&,(%&2,2&,%.

0(+ (86 %6&)& '(,'-4)%'&)/ %6& 5&,& (,)% 22&55%& -,% ,(86%5. 6&5 %6% %6& 25(%(

1) % &%(%5& ,&425.4&%'42))(%&8,-) )-+)%%(5 @-&)%( 51 ,()&) ( %6&)& ')&)1,,%(8(%&, &,&'&+.%6() -,% 22&5))%()4())& " " " " !

# !

# &+,-,. / &+,-,. / &+,-,. / &+,-,. / 46;(,