← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1722/2013dismissed

Divij Manchanda And ANR v. Rattan Dei And ORS

2015-09-22Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih7 pages



      

  

 !""#$%$&'() 



!



 





 ' *+

 

 ++ ,-"!-". "/.!".%0# 0/ /".%1 23" 004"5!%""!-"6758"1"&!9  3"."".."5!!-" "/.!".%.&!9

 ,-"!-".!-"67581"&!%-7053"."/.!"5$&!-"$8"%!9 #

$  %



&'  

(   

#")'

*** 

 ++:

+';

" ) +,

(  - +,

) ."

' "& 



0

   

)

&  

''(  - "& 

 

'

 ."

   &")   )#

) '



'(")

+, &)     1    " )   +, 

'  ,  ,   ) ,(

2(

32 



+  .

3

 

'' " '

5

+,-

 +"  &),'

+ "

 ")

, )  

6 )

  ( ))

 (.' &

& 

) " 

)

)

+,- 7

#5  - 

1

  % ( ))

 (.) 

)"

)

+,-7

#5 

  . ( "

"

8 9":-), "  (

&

 )

 

; <<  << 1 ( - 

"

   9" -),

 # &

+) 

   " $ (. = # - = >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> = = ."?) -?) >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> = =  @

5 #)

 #)

  

 # -'

 +  & 

 

 

 

- ),  ."  ?)           (,  

A<<  6" ' 



 )

 

'  

   +      ))"   

 

A< '& (.'



.)"  < 

< 'B"

, 

  

") '-"

;0 ( )  

?5 (



;<<0( &),



<<0'(  "

+, & 

'





& &  % 6" '+ 



)) &)    +&   

  :"

'    . ( "

+"

"

8 9":-), " 6

)

&



.' (  5

 '' " '  1

' ( )  '

)' &

+) ( ( 

 

 

 

" $2 (. = = = # - ?- 

  ;



 = >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> ."?)-?)85 

       "&

"&

"&

  

 

A<<  = = ?- =  = = >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> -   @  #"-   (("&

"&

 ,   = = = >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> = =  @

5 )

 )

 

/  1 (  



 9" -),  ,

1

( -   9" -),  & (.       # -      ?-    

&

   

    - ' 

 ' 

)&  

& '"

& )

- (.  

&  9" -),')) 

)&

), 

"

 +" 

   "

&

-),

(

(.  (  - ), # -?- '(.) 

 

& ") )) ) 

9"

;/' ( .),'#)()'    # -?- '

   

 

0< '  '      

,

- 

(

(.+    6

)

 

,

 "

-

   

-

  "

'      

'  +    ."

 + )( "

),)"  

&

,3 -  . '-

), ( "

+,

 # -' (

 )

 

; <<C473  << C473%  &( "& 

') ,& 

+) 

 

,( 

"

"

 9" -),

" 

"- C47 3 C47 3.

)

),."?))

+"  

, < /'

  ))) -

,&  

;

-" ' ) 



&





& ") ))) 1"

  

 

 '

+

 "& -+ & )

2#)

#7;-

 

( ?

D. , < /''  +



&: +  ( )  (





 9":-),( 

),."?) 

),- ?)6 & ' ( )"

, 

 . (  B"

,

' " ' 

, "

 -



)5  

&  

(

 & ") ))-  

 )"

%

'    (  )"  ) "&  )

 )-

& ") ))( ))

&

& 

(. ) " 

)

,)

+,-7

#5  )5 (  %( ))

(.) " 

)"

( )

+,-

 #5 ' 

-   "2 "+  

   

'   )5  

&  &( + "& 

 ( ( .

 ),

#5 



) 



),' "   

 ), ),"

( ,   &  1   '

)) ) 

 '

(.' ( +

-+ , <; 2;A C4# 

)  (  .   &

 & 

 

)

'(  ( + (

 ) )  "-  

< <;/   5     

&;/'( ) "

+,(.

( )  ) )     % (  ))

  ( .  ) "   

)

)

+, -7

#5 6 "& 



A< C4 C4 '

 ),'

)

(  )

+ (



%  6 )



A<  ;<<0(

)+) +

  (

&

'( ) 



' ' - ( 

 "

'

), ."?)'( ) '' " ' ))' ( && +,



' ")B"

"

& )

- %"



 '  , << 1 ( +



)-  )  

 ""

"

& )

-

."?)#

( 

 <

 



  &



A< 

 ,



;<<01, ')

),

" 

  

+"

) & 

 (

 

          

  (

 

  +    -),

  ?

 " ) )) ") 

"

  ( & 

"

),

+,+

."



,   

  "

-,-

))) &) ,

1 (5    

"

+ '

 ),

4 ,& "') )" +)  )(' B"

& )

)B"

)('-")

,  "+  )  B"

    )('     

   

  ) 6 & 

  &),'

 - )-  ()



 ++