← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1731/2013dismissed

Surinder Dhingra v. Daya Chand Etc

2024-05-29Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal9 pages

    

  

 

  





  



 

    

    

  !

  " !  "

# $ !%&

  #   ! '&     ()  " # 

!$%&'

'()*+

%,*$-./)*%-, *       

 & 

          + + '' ,   ,    $      ,    

 ,-   )) )" &   %&.-&!* &/, *   &    +' ,  $ 

0   &

   

    0  1.*     2            !&  (3 4 5 ! 67    8

 9

9&,'

, 

  

9        ,       %  :,  

,   ,

  +  

* ,        &,  & +&;+ 

* + &

  ,+'       ,  $<    

 ,%    (&&="

,    ( 

&&=",   

&' +    >'&,+  % ' +&'    !  &

  %      +,  ' +  ,  > &  -*   '   ' '  &    9   &  '        &   ,    

   '          ) '      2 ?

        )   &2&="

  ,,,+

?&    %    &       &    ,     (&=" , &'    , &

, @  

  &+,    

  , 

&&=" (   & 9 &

&&=" ( 9

9& ;

 ,  , 

         A'    " "

'+$ &'    ?& ,

 6 !

$0/1&,*+ 2/* '-$*3 *3&

6&($,&.

)-/,+&6 $&2$&+&,*%,0 *3& 2($*%&+

>           '+    +% 0 

  &      

  '  +, '   "

 



  

 

  





       

  

 

 

  

     !"#$%$&'

    (&&)(&&*   

   + #   ,  -    

.%/0    !"#$%$1#'  

 2 

   !"#$%33#

 &)&*(&&*   

 4   5

' 

  

     

   

16(6. 

   

   



 

    

    

       

        

 

 -  /+   7  6 '     8   !       

         

 

   





    

  

(9&%1* 

   !"# $%$&6    !"#$%$16    !"#  $%336   



  

 

:

 



    

      5:/  813.  %  (&1&         





     

             

  3    

 

    

 





  

:



   

 

      5:/  8  13.  %  (&1&    

 

   

  16  .            

  3  -    

  3    %    



     

6      4;<:

=    5:/813.%(&1& 

  

 

     

 

 (9&%1*6

   4  

  

    :

    

  -  /+  7    !"#$ 

 



  

     !"#$%$&6   !"# $%$16  !"#$%336

   4;<:

=  (.&)(&1):

    

     

       

((&$(&(3:



  



    

  

4;<:

= (9&%1* <$93)# #(&(3 ((&$(&(3    

  

    93    -      

 

    

    ,         



1$ 2



   

   -    

  

/-'-  

    

   

   :



 

   

     /-' 

   

  

2

  6=% 



 (1

<6(&(3   

      0 

       

   0  

  

   <8$93)# #(&(3    >    ((&$(&(3 

  

 !"#$%$&6  !"#$%$16

  !"#  $%336            +  

    

   0

       -  /+  7  6'  8           ?  2

   2    &9&11))@       

           

(9&%1*      

   (.&)(&1)



   

 

 !"#$%$&6  !"$%$16  !"# $%33



    (&&* 

2 6/ $ 

   

8 ?  

     

       

 / 1& 

  !"# $%33



      

   

                

  

    

    



6

  

               

  

4      

+ 4 

  

+  

 

  

+

8 



  

 

     

   4

  

 

+     



- /+ 7  



 '

 '#1

 

        "!8 (3&3    (&1&    (1&9(&1&     

    /  $&6&&&%#  

 

 '

 /

6  #    - 6  =  



  

%



    

     (1&9(&1& 

  

  

 '

'#( 3  

1      

     +  #       ,  - 6245A 

6! #:B6= 



   

 

    



     

      

  

         

1 ( $  

1 



 



   

  , 0/0% 

.

   

  

 :% (13$@(&1.6       

  (.&1(&&*            (@&((&(&  

  

  

    :

     

 

  3     :

   

 

   

1

 

   +   

     

   2 % 

1

   

  

 

    6 4;:< =         (@&((&(&   

  

C

  

   

          

  1             ! 

      

     0

 (@&((&(&

    '

  '#.6     



  0

6C   

  

  

  

 !"$%$&6 

!"#$%$16  !"#$%33      



   

 /0%  

.

 6

 

  

            

     4  

     

(9&%1*      '

 

  



-/+  7  6'  8       

  



0

  

0

  

 +  

   +  2   %   

  1            + #      ,  - 6  245  A  

6  !   #:B6 =6       

  + 

  '    

D !

%+)/++%-,# ,(65+&+ (,.

&)%+%-, ?       &             ' +,  87: 7

?

 '      

8

& , 

  ,        

 '

' +, &

   ,     ,  ) 0 ,  &

      ,& ,  + ? , +  ,   %: &B!+    ,   

 ,  ,

   * , &  8

>'& ,     ,  + C+

  * &

 ,  B  +    " "

'    DC (( '+  +> ' 

  

 6'  , , ' +'

   '   9 ?  ,     +$       +      > &

      +  2  ;  &, 3 ?+,       

     '                   +

' + C,   +,   47 

%  +   +             ,      % : &

B!+ &  ,    ?  , ;+$+ ?,    ,   +%     8+,   47&,+     -*  '  +    

  

    



  &'&   

    

;

+  +;  &,  ,

 +

    ( 8+,   47&,+   

  , + A'      '+$  

   > & +,  %,  (( ?+,   47',  +     

+,   47 '     %: &' + C,  () +,   47  + +   

  8!"

 (&''   2

(  8 

' '  &  &   ,&  

    ?

     $,   ,    +  * & :"

 '        +  ;  '&    '

   

 

  

?+,  

%+ +

       ( ?  +,   47    '        ; & '& '

 +   (9 ?    +,     %  +   +      + ,  B!+ 

:

%:

?,  + C,  * +         ,+    ,          

      , ,,+  C  , 

+ 8

&   (2  ;  &   ,&

 , (3 

   ,

 

 & &   

  "  %

  8 % =  E=B 8 + 

E=B