High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/6000/2018disposed of

Suman And Others v. Narender And Another

2019-03-28Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan7 pages

! "

!"! #$%$&'

#()&*$#()% )*)+,*+-)'$ #'($)..$//)&'% #$$%&%'()&* + ($.#$%$&')..$)/()%0$$& 1/$*0$1&2)22#1$+$* '($)3)#* *)'$*45

.)%%$*06'($ '#--1*$&'/)17%#108&)/,()99)#:

# %(#','($#108&)/;,3($#$06'($-/)17.$'1'1& 1/$*06'($)..$//)&'% 8&*$#!$-'1& '($ '#"$(1-/$%-', =

#%(#','($-';

&)--8&' '($*$)'( !)&*$$.3)%*1%71%%$* ($#$%.&*$&'%1&'($)..$)/)#$'($3&$# 7'#-6-/$ 0$)#1&2 #$21%'#)'1& < 5<< :($#$1&) '$# #$ $##$* ' )% '($

$&*1&2+$(1-/$;)&*'($1&%8#$#:1$#1$&')/&%8#)&-$ '*; '($

$&*1&2+$(1-/$ ($ )-'%1&0#1$ )#$'()'& >=

,!)&*$$.3)%*#1+1&2 '($

$&*1&2+$(1-/$&(1%3)6,)*20)#?$*)'(17)&*%')#'$*-()%1&2 (17@(1/$!)&*$$.3)%-#%%1&2'($%.$$*<0#$)?$#,*8$' $)#($/%'

-&'#/)&*'($01?$ %/1..$*,)%)#$%8/',($%8%')1&$*1&98#1$%$3)% %(1 '$*'$&$#)/%.1')/,()99)# #73($#$($3)%#$ $##$*' !,

(')? )&* '($& %(1 '$* ' 22)#%)1& %.1')/, $/(1 /'17)'$/6 ($ %8--870$*'1&98#1$%& =

4*)'$* 4=

3)% /*2$*)'/1-$!')'1&,()99)# -/)17.$'1'1&8&*$#!$-'1& '($-'3)% 1/$*($ #108&)/*1%71%%$* '($-/)17.$'1'1&#$/61&2 8.&'($*$-1%1& '($ !8.#$7$8#'1& ,

#-'' ./)* + ..0 (/*1&2'()''($*$-$)%$*3)%'($0##3$#

'($

$&*1&2+$(1-/$)&*'($-/)17.$'1'1&8&*$#!$-'1& '($-'

1%&'7)1&')1&)0/$ $)#*/$)#&$*-8&%$/ #'($)..$//)&'%)&*.$#8%$*'($.).$# 0? $)#&$*-8&%$/ #'($)..$//)&'%-&'$&*%'()''($*$-$)%$* 3)%0##3$# '($

$&*1&2+$(1-/$,'(8%,%'$..$*1&''($%($% '($ 3&$#,($&-$'($-/)17)&'%3$#$$&'1'/$*' )78&''0$21+$&8&*$# $#%&)/--1*$&'+$#:

#%(#',; &,

1* +,'($!8.#$7$8#'($/*'()') 0##3$#%'$.%1&''($%($% 3&$# '($+$(1-/$($1%%8$3(1-()#%$ 0$ #$'($.$A8#'3)% <

!"#!

5 ($1%%8$3)%*$-1*$*)&*1'3)%($/*)%8&*$# < ( )

! "#!

+ *

! "#! !

! "#!' '3)%($/*'()''($#$.#$%$&')'1+$% '($*$-$)%$*%'$.1&''($ %($% '($ 3&$# '($ 7'# +$(1-/$, ($&-$, -8/* &' -/)17 -7.$&%)'1&8&*$#!$-'1& '($-' ($1%%8$&3)#1%$1%'()'&-$1'1%($/*'()'0##3$#%'$.% 1&''($%($% 3&$#-)&)-&'#)#6%')&*0$')?$&'()'0##3$#31//&' 0$-+$#$*8&*$# ($)&%3$#1%6$%,($31//&'0$-+$#$*8&*$# '38/*0$)..#.#1)'$)''(1%%')2$'B8'$!$-'1&% > )&*

'($-')&*<5($%)7$)#$#$.#*8-$*0$/3

$%)

$/%-

* 0

$% $%

$1%! $%

$2%3 $/%

4 5

0! $%3 !

6* 0 7

* )+ 89 !(/ $/% $%

$%- 9 :

; :<

!" 5 ! $5!%9

" 5

67:- 9 #

# $ # %&'

9 5 ! 9

;

; =

()"-

5 !

A 5!

)

@ ($-&'$&'1&#)1%$*06/$)#&$*-8&%$/ #)..$//)&'%()%)

)//)-6($'$#73&$#<*#1+$#()%0$$&*$ 1&$*8&*$#<5'%')'$% D7.8/%#6$#%&)/--1*$&'+$#%()//0$)../1-)0/$8&*$#0'(-)%$% 1$ 1)01/1'6&/6)&*)-?)2$/1-1$%($3&$# 1&%8#$*+$(1-/$ (/*1&2)&$

$-'1+$*#1+1&2/1-$&-$1%'$#7$*)%3&$#<#1+$# #'($ .8#.%$% '(1%%$-'1&($*$ 1&1'1&-/$)#/6#$%'#1-'%'($7$)&1&2

3&$#<*#1+$#,1'&/61&-/8*$%3&$# '($1&%8#$*+$(1-/$($#$1%)

8#'($##1*$#'()' #-/)171&2-7.$&%)'1& #,3&$#%(8/*0$

4 (/*1&2)&$

$-'1+$*#1+1&2/1-$&-$ '$1&<5%')'$%'()'&/6'($#$21%'$#$*3&$#1&.$#%&1% $&'1'/$* #$#%&)/--1*$&'+$#1 ($(/*%)&$

$-'1+$*#1+1&2/1-$&-$ ($%)1*+$#1%&''0$2#)&'$*3($#$'($+$(1-/$1%3&$*06) -7.)&6, ) .)#'&$#%(1. 1#7 # ) %171/)# 0*6 -#.#)'$ (1% 8#'($# -/)#1 1$%'()'#$.#$%$&')'1+$ '($3&$#31//&' )//31'(1&'($)701'

($'$#73&$#<*#1+$#()%0$$&*$ 1&$*,($&-$,&3#*-)& 0$)**$*#*$/$'$* #7'($*$ 1&1'1&'$A'$&*'($0$&$ 1''-/)17)&'% '()''($'$#73&$#<*#1+$#-)&0$%'#$'-($*'7$)&3&$##*#1+$# #7.$#8%)/ !$-'1& '($-')&*'($*$-1%1&

'($!8.#$7$8#'1& ,

1 * +) &%()*3-)&0$-)%'

8.&'($ 1&*1&2%#$-#*$*06'($#108&)/8#'($#'($-)%$ -)&&'

0$1&'$&*$*'0##3$# +$(1-/$ 3$+$#,1'38/*0$)..#.#1)'$'1&+?$!$-'1& > '($ -'&*$#'($%)1*.#+1%1&,'($-/)17)&'%)#$$&'1'/$*'C , E< #&

)8/'/1)01/1'6)%.#+1*$*3(1-(1%'0$.)1*06'($1&%8#$# '($

$&*1&2 +$(1-/$ ($)..$)/1%*1%.%$* 1&'($) #$7$&'1&$*'$#7% *#$$%&%'(+ &-($

= 7?

@($'($#%.$)?1&2E#$)%&$*

$%E @($'($##$.#')0/$

$%E