← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1845/2013dismissed

Sukhdev Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2025-07-31Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil6 pages

  

      

  ! "# $%&''

"%&%(&) $%&'*'   



    

 

   +  ,-. '  . ..

 - ****       !     "  !   # 

  $  /&$ 0 %($1234 ' %&'

(   !  

  !*+ && ,*&,

" -

 !#     .  !&, */ ,*&&

" 0  0

 #  %

 -

'    

  !  " %,'

1 "    

 .  .

0 !

  ! .

   

    )

  !

 ) ."  "

( !. 

 .



"  !

 "

   

)   )

    .  

 )

   */ ,**5  6     

   

  "    .  

   &5 *7 ,**/ 

 "  !"  (

 -)      0



- 2 - %5'

(   ! ,& *5 ,**8

    */ ,**5 

 "  - !   (

     0

   . !    

 .

  &5 *7 ,**/

"!" (

 -)      0

  

      2 





*/ ,**5 

    



 0

 %

 ' &48*%

9&48* 9'

%7'

(   ! )  .

     



2 &

:  -

   */ *5   &5 *7 */     

 



 

; ,

:

 ! "; 

:

! !   ;-

:

0 !   

!  

" ;- /

  %/'

< .   !    

     ! . )   

! !  

 "!

. .

!    

) . ! +%&+'&48*

%='

(   !      

   

  

      " !

 

- 3 -

!  !  !

 )> )   "    )!      !

 . ! !



 !?.



" 

,8 *+ ,**5 .   . ) 

"  !  /%  '&48* 

. .

!  !2)" 

 .

 )   

  !  ! !     

   " !

 "   "

  (   !        

    ) "

)  %8'

      " @  !"  (

 -)   

 "



)

  

 "- ! (

 <.    "   !  ! !

!

   "  > .

! !

!! !.



&48*

 

  

!   0   

"     !   

!" ! ! 

   "

 %+'

<   !

      !

   "  

   





  !   



)

- ! (

  !  

 "  $  .

!      

   % '    0

 <<<  &488  (  0  !   "

$

- 4 -



!

 "

)

  "

 !!  )   ! !!  ! 

  ! . "$   -   - ! (

   !

"!

     !  

 " 

!)   " .    !

  (  0  !

)  !    " ! ! 



!) !.

 ! .



   ! 

"

 )

 !

" !  %4'

A   !

        ! %&*'

B  !  .     

 !   " .  !

. .

! !

   ) " !  .

   

   

" . !  (

"  !   

"   !   

  )    "      */ ,**5   

 .  

 )  (    "  

 

 %&&'

1  !  .     "  

       !

  !   



)

- ! (

   !  

 "  $

)! 

- 5 - )     % '   ! 0

 <<< &488 

) "

- !  (

  < )"  )     $



  " 

  )

  "    - !  

   



) "  .  

"  

  

   $ 

    

    !

   "  

 )

  " 

 !   ! 

)!       !    ! 

 +    0

  %

   '  &48*    . 

  )       

  " )



 "

 ! 



! 

. "$       - !  (

     0

  !

" !

C) 



! . )   !   

!   "  !   !!   

  !! 

" $



0

" 

  ! 

"

!)  ".   !

%&,'

(

 

 "

"!

 !! !) .   ) 

" !.   < 

   )") . 

! 2

 

 . 







!

- 6 -  !)     .

 

" 

  "    2 

 

 "3 

!)  )

 ! !) .    

    .  

  

 

   

!!2. %&5'

(! .

"    

 "!



 )  2 

   +%&+'     0

   %

  '  &48*     ! .       !

!"

!    

! ,/ ,***   

   

     

  !  



 .  ) %&7'

<   )  !

!  

"  !   

 

!) ! .

    !  

           .

 <    !

!)

 

"! .!

)

     %&/'

< . 

!



"

 )



"! .

0

" 





!!

"

 5& *8 ,*,/ 

/&$ 0 %($123

($1 

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No