Saranjit Kaur And ORS v. Surjit Singh And ORS
!
"#$$%&'&()"(*"+,-. "+"(/�"*+ #1$+'
22$33"(#'
4$+'*'
*+/&#&(51 #1$+'
$'2(6$(#'
! "
#$%&' () *+!' +*,&-()./'
71$#1$+ $2+#$+'3%"32"2$+'8",9$"33:$6#'$$#1$/*658$(#; 9$+$$++$6##1$ $2+#$+'+(#;
71$#1$+#1$/*658$(#'1*369$+$2+#$6&(#1$&5$'#;
+$'$(#) + "51*<&(6$+&(51.6<%"#$.
+#1$"22$33"(#' ===== +*,&-( 1&' &' " $5*3"+ $%(6 22$"3 "# #1$ &('#"(%$ #1$ "22$33"(#>23"&(#&' #?"5"&('##1$/*658$(#'"(66$%+$$'#1$ *+#'9$3:.:1$+$9,#1$&+%3"&8'+6$%3"+"#&(#1"##1$,"+$:($+'&( /&(#2''$''&(##1$$@#$(#?A-'1"+$*##1$2+2$+#,9$"+&(5 B1$:"#?.B1"#"*(& .B1"'+"?AAAA
>C!.?A C>!.A
>!.A C>!.CA
>!. AAA
> !. A ?>!.-A
>!.-A
>!.CA
>!. > !. C-
>!.
> !. "69"'#-. '&#*"#$6"#4&33"5$ "('*+:"3 (". $1'&3 "(6 &'#+&%# 0"2*+#1"3". "' 6$#"&3$6 &( #1$ /"8"9"(6&"(63"(6'&#*"#$6"#<&33"5$":"(B1"("5&+.$1'&3"(6&'#+&%# 0"2*+#1"3"9$"+&(5B1$:"#C.B1"#"*(&.B1"'+"- A-
>-!.
-AA
>!"(6"3':($+'&(/&(#2''$''&(##1$$@#$(#?A- '1"+$*##1$2+2$+#,'1:(+$6&(#1$'&#$23"(.'&#*"#$6:&(#1$D"3 D"B&+ 4&33"5$ "('*+:"3 (" "(6 2+2$+#, '&#*"#$6 &( 4&33"5$
":"(B1"("(6*+#1$+%1"33$(5$##1$8*#"#&(&(+$'2$%##1$ $'#"#$ 3$#9,,"3&(51 '&(%$ 6$%$"'$6! 9$&(5(*33 <&6"(6 + 2$+8"($(# &(/*(%#&(. :1$+$9, #1$ 6$$(6"(#' 1"<$ 9$$( '*51# # 9$ +$'#+"&($6+8"3&$("#&(5"(6%+$"#&(5%1"+5$<$+#1$2+2$+#,.1"'9$$( 6&'8&''$69,#1$#+&"3*+#<&6$/*658$(#"(66$%+$$6"#$6
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
#1$7&33%"((#9$+$(6$+$6"'" 5$(*&($"(69#1#1$*+#'9$3:1"<$$++($*'3,6&'%"+6$6#1$+$2+# %*8$(#'"(6"(6:+&#&(5@2$+#:1&3$136&(5#1"##1$%82"+&'( "(6:+&#&(5&'":$"B#,2$$<&6$(%$"(6%"((#9$#"B$(<$+*2(#1$ 6&+$%##$'#&8(,7> "3B&"#&(51."##$'#&(5:&#($''#1$7&33"(6 7>1"8"(D"3.
$@$%*#$6 9, ,"3 &(51 :"' 3"#$+ ( %"(%$33$6 #1+*51 " +$5&'#$+$6 %"(%$33"#&(6$$66"#$6C-- "(6#1$'&5("#*+$',"3&(51.& %82"+$6(@'"(6.#1$'"8$6(##"33,:$"%1#1$+1$ $"+3&$+7&33:"'$@$%*#$6&("<*+1&':&$6*+&(51&'3&$#&8$#9$
:($+"(6"#$+1$+6$"#1&(#$(6$6#9$6$<3<$6*2(#1$'('"(6($ 1*'$#"8"++&$66"*51#$+.("8$3,."+/�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
9$$(2+<$6#1+*51#1$#$'#&8(,7> "3B&"#&(51"(67> 1"8"(D"3.$$67+&#$+"(69#1#1$:&#($''$'1"<$6$2'$6&(#$+8' #1$2+<&'&('$%#&(?
>#1$(6&"(*%%$''&(%##(3,#1&'. 6$%$"'$6,"3&(51%3$"+3,8$(#&($6&(#1$7&33#1"#1&':&$ 1&(6$+ 0"*+:&33(#1"<$"(,+&51##"3&$("#$#1$'*+2$+#,3$#9,1&8 1$+$+$.+"33&(#$(#'"(62*+2'$'.'1$%*36(#1"<$9$%8$"9'3*#$ :($+&(<&$:#1$2+<&'&('$%#&( !#1$&(6**%%$''&( %#.-? $+$3,9$%"*'$#1"#8"++&$66"*51#$+'1"<$9$$($@%3*6$6+8 #1$2+2$+#,:*36(#9$'*&%&$(##6*9##1$6*$$@$%*#&(#1$7&33 "'#1$7&33&'"3:",'$@$%*#$6#6$<3<$*2(#1$'&93&(5'.&$.#1$("#*+"3 %*+'$'*%%$''&((#1$7&336"#$6 --C @!.,"3&(511"6
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
:1&%1:"'"33:$6"(6#1$%$+#&&$6%2,#1$7&33 :"'$@1&9&#$61$+6$+5+"(#&(5#1$2$+8&''&(#2+<$#1$7&339,:", '$%(6"+,$<&6$(%$1"6(#9$$(%1"33$(5$6#&'"3''$##3$63":#1"##1$ "(6:+&#&(5@2$+#"3:",'#$##1$3&($##1$2"+#,:1&%11"'$(5"5$6 1&8"(6.#1$+$+$.
#1$"(6:+&#&(5@2$+#1$7&33:"'+$5&'#$+$69$+$#1$ $5&'#+"+"(6 &#:"'+$"6<$+"(6$@23"&($6#6$%$"'$6,"3&(51"(6.:1"#$+ "68&##&(5#1$%(#$(#'"'%++$%#.'&5($6#1$$(6+'$8$(#(#1$9"%B#1$ 7&33&(#1$2+$'$(%$7> "3B&"#&(51"(60"+("&3&(51D"89"+6"+ 1$3$"+($6%*('$3"22$"+&(5+#1$"22$33"(#'.&('*22+# 1&' "+5*8$(#. 1"' +$3&$6 *2( #1$/*658$(# #1&' *+# +$(6$+$6&( ( 0
0 12332 45 -6 7&(#%(#$(6#1"##1$ "%#'#1$%"'$"+$&6$(#&%"3##1$"%#'#1$2+$'$(#%"'$"(6#1$*+# 1"6*(6#1"##1$7&33:"''*++*(6$69,'*'2&%&*'%&+%*8'#"(%$'"(6 $<$(&(#1$%&#$6%"'$"3'.#1$+$:"'"2+$<&*'7&33.:1&%1:"'%"(%$33$6 1"<$5($#1+*51#1$/*658$(#&( 5&(6$+&(51F'%"'$
'*2+"!1$"%#'"(6#1$+"#&6$%&6$(6$/*658$(#"+$(#"223&%"93$ ##1$"%#'"(6%&+%*8'#"(%$'#1$2+$'$(#%"'$+#1$+$"'(#1"#&(#1$ %&#$6%"'$.#1$+$5&'#$+$6%"(%$33"#&(6$$6:"'(#2+<$6&("%%+6"(%$ :
":$+$&(#1&'%"'$.&#&'"68&##$69$#:$$(#1$2"+#&$'#1"##1$7&33 :"'%"(%$33$61$+$+$.#1$"%#'#1$%&#$6%"'$"+$(#'&8&3"+##1$ "%#'#1$2+$'$(#%"'$1$/*658$(#&'9"'$6(#1$"%#'.&$.#1$ /*658$(#&( $+'("8"(6(# $8#1#1$*+#'9$3:1"<$+$(6$+$6"
&(6&(5"%#"(63":.9"'$6(#1$"22+$%&"#&(+"3"(66%*8$(#"+, $<&6$(%$'*9'#"(#&"3E*$'#&(3":"+&'$'+6$#$+8&("#&(#1&' *+# %%+6&(53,.#1$"22$"3&'6&'8&''$6 ( 89- +*,&
431 ()./'