Madanlal v. State Of Punjab And Others





   




     







 !   #$ 
%#&  '%()*+ # ,-./
+ #& / '&(0+# ,'&1
'/+2 ,-./
+ '%()*+ # ,-./
+ #&,/ '&#&   
" 1 

&3 1 4"

  0   41 &3 1    . & 41 &3 1

 3 " 51 &  &3  6 1   !1

 (       41 

&3 1 4"

  ( 0 "1 &3 1

7 8 8 8


 
  
 #$9 !9 49

3

"  


 : 3 1   . ::1  "1  

  9 !"

 (     $ :  ! 5

  ." $  " !  !9 " $ 9;

< ";

 = = $ !9   > $$ 

9 

 

 $ !9   > 

91 4" !9 "  

 " !   34

; 1 4" 

    ;

 ; ."  " $  "  9

< ";  9; "

"

 < 9  

 1   !9 "

 1

 

 $ !9 "

 B ." !



 ;  ;

" $    " "  4  7 $$

;

";



0"
  1 $

   3 :  7    !9 "

  ." $ 4

  !  

 ! 1 4" " !

7 4   #$ 71 !; ;;

3 !9 "  

" !1   $$  !

!

!

 "  $$ 

9 ."

 $$ 

91 3 :$ ;

 = =

  ;

" 

" 4

0"
 

   "1 4" "

; "  71 !

 " $

4 <    4     ! 4  "   ." 1 !; ;;

3 !9 "

$ !9 "  $$

91     $$ !

 " 

91 4""

" ! : 3 " :$ ;

 

  /   !: !9 " 

" 3 !

 $;

 

 !9 "   $$

91   :$ 4" "      !9 "  $$

91 "

     3 : ;

 

"    

  $

0"
   " /   " "

 3  :

 C

 "

B 9 " 

 ; $

   " :4" " $ : " $    D  " 4

5 7

!: " " $

4 "  

 !   :

" 4

5  4  "; !9 7 !

 "  $$ 

91  $

4"" "  $$ 

9   " 4

5    !9

;  ; " " 5;

 

3 ;3 !9 4    

 4"


 /   !: " "

;" " $$

9 

5  

 " " $ "  9 D  7

" 4

5  " :



 $$  " " .

:: "   $ " 5;

 

3 ;3 !9 " !9  ;   !  

 4"


 !

!

 "  ;1 "

43  $

;  1 " :$ ;

" ! $ C

!: " 3 41  ! ;

 :5   " " 5; ;3 !9 " $   

 4" " 
   " ;  " 

 !9

  $ 3  

 $$

7  !: "

7 "   $$ ; "  

"  '

43 1 

; " $9

 $$1  ( 7  3  " " $ " ;3   5;

; ; "

3! 4" ":  "

1  $$

$;

 : &D

 &B  &D

 & "

4;  !:

;

3 !9 " $ 

"

4 " " " ! !: !9 " $ 4   3

 7 ?+@ ?(  @    7?+@

1 4

 !

 "  $$ 

9 /   !: " " $$ 

9 5; " 

 $       

;  $$

9 

  " :  ;

$

: "   . :: 

5    !9

; 

 

 " " 

  !: !9 " $ 4   4" "

  !: !9 "

 # : 1 4"

" ! 4   
      1 $

" 4 ;

"     /   !: " "

    9 !" !9 " 

 1

1 

  !

 4" "

$ !9 "  $$

9 =

 $$

7  !: " " 

9 " 

: "

 !9 " $$ 

91 4""    <  9 

 !9 "



/   !: !9 

7 " " " ! $ :  D  " 4

5 !9 "

9 

 : !; : 

 " 7 " 3 "; " 4 ;

   $

4""

 $$ 

9 "   " :1 4""   9 

1   3

: " $



 /  !: "   "  :1  



  :



7  &  &3  6 1   !1 $$ !"

 (   1  !: " 4

 > " $$ 

9  "   $$ 

9 "3

  



 ; " $ 1 4""     

:

9 ;9

$ 3 9 1 "

1   ! 

 4" !9 "

  $

; &  C

"
 

/ /  !: " "

 !9 " 

 

 " "

5; ;3 !9 " $ 4  9 

 ! !

A
 ;  9   !  

      



 !9 "

   "3 "  " 

" $   ;" 

:  $



1   3 " "     $$ 

 "3  " 4

5   

 " ;

 " " 5;

 

3 ;3 !9 "   9   7 ?+@1 (  

 
  7 ?+@1 (  

   "

 4;  :  F(    .

 : 



" !

1 " 

:

 ;3  5;  9 4

 !

 " +D 3 ;  "  

;  

!; 4   9   4"   "  !

 " 

"  

; " : 

5 G!

4"

 :

5 G!

  " 

$  !9 ":1 "  " ! !  !   <  H B & ! ;

" 


  :5   " 

C  : 



1 "  :

 ;3  5; 

 "      4   9   4"   "  !

 " 

"   <  1  " 

 

  ! :

4"   : 4" " 

$  !9 "  1 "  " ! !  !   <    ."

1  " !

1 "3

  ; 

 " " 

 ;3 !9 " $  " ;3 !9 "

 # 0 :    ;

 D 1 "

1 "  "   1    " 

  ;

"  ; 7 ."  " " 

    !4 "  "

 # 0 :   9 !

: "

 !9 !

" " $$ 

 ." $ 1  1 "  !:  

3

  !

 ; " "   !

  "   !: !9 " $  "

 # 0 : "3     " "9 "   ;3 " :  "

 # 0 :



$ ;

" 

!; "    "9 " 9   

 '

43 1 "  " " !

 4         1 "  !

   4

5;

"

 # 0 :   9 !

: " 

1  ; "  ;  $9:

+2 !9 "

 # 0 : 

$

" !

    C  

 $$

" $ 1  " ;1 !: " " $ "    :$ 4" " < :



1  " ;3  5; 

 " " 

  !: !9 ":

     4" 9   !: !9 ":  9 

;     

 " "  

;"  ! : !9 "  !  9 : 3 & ! ;

"
  :5   " "
  " !   4"  34   : 



  " " 5;

<   ! ;3 !9 "  

 " " 

5 G!

 ;3 !9 ":    

: 4" "

9  1 4"

" ! 4  4

5  9

  4"   "  !

 " 

" 4

5 

"   &$$ 91 " 5;  <   ! ;3 

 " " 

  !: !9 "      4" 9 $ 1 4"

"  9 ! 4   

  ; = / "  :1  " ;

 !9 "   

   !  

1 4 

"    $  " "    $ 3 9

;9  "

$ !9 "

1  " :  4

 

1  !

" " 

 "3 ;"9

 

 " " 5;

    

 4"

 7 ?+@

 ! !

;  1 

 

  !

 4" "

 $ !9 "   



= ." $  !9 " $ !; 3 

:   : ? 
  
  
 :! 1    
     "" $5;G   IG(

"" #$

! IG(