High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/410/2016disposed of

Moji Ram And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2026-04-16Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja7 pages

!"# $#%

!"# $#% &'( &'( &'( &'( "'

! "'

) 1 1 1 1 '

1 1 1 1 '. '. '. '.

% % % % + + + + (*

'* '* '* '* 2233 2233 2233 2233

#! ",, "

- "

- H '* H '* H '* H '* 2 2 2 2 ". ". ". ". $1. 1

1 /&, %#*

" 0 * /&, %#*

" 0 * #% #% #% #% *$" 1-= 4 % -'!- DDDD #%-%1 3 #%-%1 3 #%-%1 3 #%-%1 3 0 * 0 * 0 * 0 * 7 + 8811-21 34 1A

9:;);

; ; );<;

14A 33

3 = 1 > 88 ?> =3=

?> 1 @ 41=5-

14A @ 18

7 &5 5 21 3- 33A 4 3 1

<2 453 13'

1%>A- 11

1 B 1">1 1">1 1">1 1">1E 41 11 697 &1 35 A- 21

- 3 3 8 >1A ;) )C9

1 > 1=> =3 A %

- !@ 32>1 0>84 0 332>1- 3 ' 1 1- ?>1 = =

>>1* , ?> - ;) 11B ;)

;)

;) ) E ) E ) E ) E12=35- 12>4 43 2>12- 835 5-F 11>AG

2" 3 180 < <9

;

@ @A 1809 9

I, 18%, ,"

3J 1>1*

;) 2 45 , ?> "331 1 1 B B ,"

,"E C

1 !@ 32>1 0>84 %

;

1 1 0 332>1- 145 8 1@ 3>

IN 21 1 4 A1 A 33 1 >15 4 >1 ;) 6 7 ' 1 45 ,"-

121 1114L 18 * ; ;) 1 1 113 1 1 ">1- 842

135

<-3 31N A8 3> K9)- <IN21 1 6<7 AA A1=1 -21 2 3 121 11

3 1 33 * "

& , & , & , & , 67

*. *. *. *. $$ ,, $$ ,, $$ ,, $$ ,, *N,' ,' ,' ,' H * H * H * H *....N 2>AA

1- 3 1 >3

1>48 3 1 1">11123 A 13 >2 3

; G$N =

>8 9-9

IN 4 21 ;-9-99IN 21

1, 1 >3 32> @ A >3

2 = - 221 K <M 4 A1 = 1 4 21 21 1 1 = 18

; G G$N 1 1- 8 1@ = 3> 1?>14

=>1

1>-21 5 4 8 1 311-8

3> 1?>141N

3 21 11

3 1 1 4 33 1 2 321 1145* 1 148 & , & , & , & , *$' * *$' * *$' * *$' *N*

.N 6C7 $1 11 -3 1* >3 >48 3 1 1 ">1 88 111 =A 1 21> 45 12I* 21 8 1=> =33 A % %

2121 11 3A1 1 A4C3 @

@ , 1 * >3 ," 31 5 3>K K

@21 1 223 11>

35 82 >- >11 8

1?>1 4 1 45 3 1 1 ">1 6C ,

1 * >3 >11 33 21> 45 12I* 1 3 21G85

- 1

; G$N 21> 45

1 2 1 =33

-> 8 83 1 >1 2 >21 5 82>A

<2 453 1 1">1 3 434

12 45," 4 411 '

*"#** '

*"#** ' * !. ' * !. ' * !. ' * !.N 6;7

= 1 3 1 >3 2 1 A 1>A 33 11 214@ 6)7

11> 1N N 8 8

- 3 13 >2 45 N 1 33 12N* >11 1 3 8

1 13= > >- 8 1121>1> >1.N

321> 321> 321> 321> >45 >45 >45 >45 1 1 1 1 G4 G4 G4 G4 '

G> G> G> G> G$N 9

1 0 0 0 0N 1 1 1 1

)

N;< ; ?5 1 21 1 21 1 21 1 21 1 => => => => I=33

I=33

IN <- ;CIN !@ 32>1 0>84

IN !@ 32>1 0>84

-9< IN !@ 32>1 0>84

IN ;-9-99IN 1A35 1

C-

C-99-

G$N

N ; < ?5 1 -

G$N9

N C < <?5 1 -9;-

G$N

9< ?5 1 9-9

G$N<

;

*?5 1

IN -

IN %

IN <-9 -

IN > @

IN 99-9)- IN 12>1 G$N

C G$NC

) 9 N ;

N9 )<?5 1 -;-<

1 G$N;

C C

)

?5 1 -<<-

IN -;

IN !@ 32>1 0>84

C<IN C-

IN > @

IN <)-);- 9IN > @

IN 9 -9C-) IN > @

IN > @

IN 9 - 9-999IN '@

IN <-

IN !3

IN 9-

IN !3

IN <

IN !3 <-

IN 0 332>1

1 1 1 1 G$N)

G$N

)

G$N

9 G$N

G$N 9 9 G$N < 9 G$N ;

G$N C C G$N ;

C G$N )

321> 321> 321> 321> 9N) ;-;)-9C

N9 -)- ;-

N <-<

NC< -

N 9 9-

;N;

N; <

N <-

IN >45 >45 >45 >4512 12 12 12I* * * * G4 G4 G4 G4 '

G G G G GH I

GH I&

GH9I"

GH I' GH<I

GHI

> > > > 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0N 31

31 31

21 1 21 1 21 1 21 1 => => => => I=33 A I=33 A I=33 A I=33 IN C-

IN %

IN )-

-C IN %

IN C-< 9IN %

IN )-

IN %

IN C-

IN %

;

)

NC )- -

I ;

9N -<

) N -<-

I C

N 9-; -<

) N -<

) ;N

C- ;-

21 -

> > 1 *

;) 1 ?> 3 21 A11= > 835!

!@ 32>10>84 -%

* 0 332>1 12>4 43 2>12 835 11>AG 2" 3 180 <9

;

@A A 18 0 9 9

I, 18 % %, "

3J + 1 2

12 4 45,"-13 A 4= =811=>

- > 188 1@

IN21

=>1

1$1 35-21 321 1 11

1 33 12I* 3513 3 18A 1 1=> =33

1 8 43G1 4=- 41 35

; G$N ;

G$N< 21 1=> =33 A %

=1-

;

G $N<21 212 >1*

;) -> 413>2 A 3> 21 3

; G$ $N 21 A

3 1 9-9

IN 21 21

1 ;-9-99IN

3 8 11 3

13 18A2 1 3 G $N 3 321G85 5

: 4A 8 135 1 1 18 > > 1>8 - 3 2 13 18A 2 1

; G$N 4A 88 =5 41 13 43 3G 823 1 12>12 A8 3>

1 -12 I* 21>G 3 21 A 1=> =33 A%

* 32121 1 1 3 3 1 A4 C3 @

@-1 1 ,"= C C

8 3>K

@ 21 13> >A- 1A>453 1 * >3 3

; G$N 21 23 18A2 1 =33

* - 111 31 13 -1 51=> 4 A > 18>841 >118 1>8 - 321 A 5 523 18A2 1

5 1=> 35 2 4> 1 - =1- 3

; G G$N 2 @ >841- 1 A3 >841

@33 >841 >-1 3 3 2 13 18A2 11 1 1=> 4 =33 A% %

* 97 >1 11- 21> 3 12 45," 8 1@ 3> K K

@21 1 4 188 8 45 '= ,=3 G "88 8 45 1 "881 '=- >1 1 4 2 21=45 '1"331- 1 > >1>8 -A 1=>IG>= =

318 83= = 18A2

1 1=> =33 A%

* 4

@ 21 1-

21> 45 1 2I* 1 3A 21 1 A C3

@ 221G8

35 M31- 4 14 4 31 1

3A121 = 321 3 8 ?> > - 84 1

= > 8 1 4=-

; G $N 21 A 81= > =33 A%

* - =

3 3 K 9-9

IN 4 21 ;-9-99IN 21 1- 4 13 > >2 4A 4 > 43 G823 1 1 2>12 18 8 3>

14A 8A 2 1>

5 1

84 G$N > >1* ;)

-> 43 221 4 1

=>1 1

1>- 221 K

M21 >8

MA1 =14 21 ;-9 9-99IN21 11= 18

; G$N 8 <-

IN21 1 <7 1=1-1A

3 2 13>1 3

; G$N 8 >1

18 1=> > =33 A %

221G8 35 C 1 - >K9

M=14 2121 1 1= 18 3

; G $N - 18 33 1 >3>

1A35-

>1* 8 9) )- C-

CIN 21 1

1 A 35 18 3> K9)- <IN45 3 1 1">1=

< 7

= = 4=-18 8 3>453 1 1 ">1 1 21 A

> > 1 *

;) - 4 4>L> 1 >

1 3 1 1">1-> =A A2 14 21 21

221

1 3 = 3 43 11- 1 1- 33 1 1 21 3- > 33 3 12 3 >23A8 82>A

< < C7 33 2A 223 - 5- 33 3 2 0 * 0 * 0 * 0 *#% #% #% #% %#'!

%#'!

%#'! 213 213 213 213

----

@ 12 @AI1 (I 1121 43 (I H H