← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1932/2013disposed of

Kuldeep Singh Mengi v. Food Corporation Of India & ORS

2016-08-19Mr. Justice P.B. Bajanthri6 pages

 

    

   



  !"#$%$ ##!! &'  (")'#' *""%' #"       ++++ ,' '-'"'%'./"0 '%##!! 1"'2 '/"0 '%'#" ++++

  

  !"#$%&'(!

) '#!$''"#3 %'"'"" 4 

 5 '

!!6" '%'"%##!6!! 

"0

( #&%&'(#  *%##!/%##!!%!"%'"'""



" 

#"73%8'!) '"##!!) '/ '#0!3##!! !"  '"!''$'"$!.

'0 #3"9 !7 " '%'$'''

$' 3"%'''!7 :%%8'!) '"##!!) ' "!"$'3'! %##!!-/%#'##!

8%  ##!!  6%!  6';$    8%!   *   ('";  '  6   72"    "#!'3  #'"$  6%%  6

  ! "".#$#!3 ".! '.'0< 

 %##!!6"." '.'0/6%%'%!" '

$' 3'%9  '"'8%##!!!" =' 3 "')!  %(")'#' *"%  .

'.  =' 3  $ !/   >/    %  ##!!  %"  7 "." '.'0 7 ,3. =' 3 / > '! "'6%' .'.".#!3 !" '$' 3''9 '"7"""73%).#  %'3?.#!3'   8%  5'     7      <   '#'" "%'



 



"#!  $   !  %"    !&'(!!$  !

!%) !  )!  #!!

 !%& !

%      $  ( "( & % ( ! "

 & !%($ % !%"  $'%'!%#!(

!!&'(!%$ ((#! !!

!!*!

& !%( "!

+ #! %"'#(! !&'(!!

,&#!((%'%(( !!

-  !!%) ! " !&'(!!)!

#!!

!%& !

%%"% % !%( 

"  % !%  )(!

! '%$%  !!%) ! " !&'(!!)!

#!!

 !%& !

%            "!  

! )()

&%("%'"

!$'%) " 

!    &!

 #  &    !  "%!     !&'(&!

.

@'" ! '%##!! 7."%6%!#$ %'"' ".! '.'0 '!. $' 3 '"/!/%' '/##!!!" '$' 3. 

  6%%    "     %.   ( '%'    6   7."  %  %'  6   "'.6%%'%##!!!" '$' 3.  "'

 7 %,3. * ##'  %  !./  !'"   !  '  %  ##!!  '!"    "  

!!%7"-$%) ''#'"    

  

  !"#$ %  & 8%!!%7"-$%) '6%' '% " %#5) '#"'!('"   )*!$+,-. ++  '+,-/ ++ *%"2 "$.  7 "7 %,3.

%7'#'",'> %2 "$.'#'" "%' / !'%!!

 !!%! )!%&!

  !*'%!% !%'!

#!!&'(!%

!

 '! !%0  %     %! !)!  %" /

!&

 

/

1 )2!3%4&!

 /  5 67 8   66  $!"'%!&!6"%  !%!

 !  9"(

 '!% %  '&!

  

%"$

!  !9"!

! '&!

%" !!%&  !%) ! %& 

" / !(    %"    '    !

"%!    

"  %"

"  !  '!%    !  %4&  !%)!   !&'(!%  !'!

'%' 2! ("! & 

"  )!%!  &)% %!!

%)$ "%!

&'   '( !

!

%4

!  !% ((!! & %!"(

( '#(!#!

 ( "(!

 !%& & ! 2!%!&#!    & % !

(!

!  %4& %&  %!

   !&'(&!

  

:"

   &(  /  ''!%     !%   '% "

!&!

$  !       &!

    '%) & !"

7# % !"%!

7 %"!!%((%'%((2!  %!

)!

!!&'(!%&"#!#!

"' !&!%( 

!%! %! % $ !%!%)

'% '(!

"%(:" !

!! 

 '"(! % !%   #!  '!

 #  !  !&'(!%  2!  !%& 

!%) !  !&'(!! %"

  !&'(!

"

7

#$#!( ! !

(!

!!&'(!% ! %"'#(! !&'(!! 2!%   !&'(!%!%& !!!%) ! 

!&'(!!  "

!%  !  6!% !

 

 % !%$  % !%) !6

   "   )!

 !  7 

#$ !   5 $ % "& %#!



%!% !

(

:"

% &! !

9"% !%)

 '% '(!   "%(  :" !$    & #!

!*& 

:" !

 

"%( :"

  $

   !  '%'% (    '"

&!

  &  #!

!*& "

 !/

"%(;'"!  $ 752!/

"%( :"

 "%!&

!

&! !

9"%

'"

&!

#!:"$ %

'%'!%$#"!!

#!&!()!  !%)!

!  %!9"%!&!

   !   7 

 #    !

<&!

=%" $ 5 2!% %! !)!

%""%% / "#!%)!

!

&& (%  !!&'(!%!%& !!

!%) !  !&'(!!/ % !% !!"% %  %"$9"( !

#!*'%! 0!!*!

 & !%( "!

0 "#!  #$!

9" "& !"%!#! !!%& $

" %!9"%!    % !%$      (  #!  '!

!%

)

 ''%"

    !  !&'(!!  3!

 !

!"%!$!)!

 # !*'%!

%! % !% ((!

#!

%!!6 %((

"%"

!%!

 $  !  !&'(!%  &"     !  "%  

'% !!

"

!% !  57  ! $!

:"   !"%!.

> < *  06    %  #'#! !" "6  73%   #'. ) ' .$  "    *"  @."A     #'    %  7  

"'.  6%%'  %  #'    !"    $' 3  '  /  % ##!!!"$' 3. %%'%"/!'" !

'%'#"'"% %##!!"'!" " %) ''#'"  / 0123/(  4  "  8%) ''#'"%#!3 '"'#"0"'$%A #'%%#'%" " !%)'#'%5# %.%76'""/.!3/ '0'3    !  %  7  "'."  "   $%    7  '0'" 8%' '/5'$#6' "' 7 <7

%,3. "' 4 -'"!'" ! '%#'

,' ! %".!'"'%#'/0" %%'"'.6%%'##!!!" '$' 3 . '8%'# "'.! "% )'#'"0'0'3%7'"'"*%'6'"/ % ##!!% "!%)'#'/%)'#'!" '0'%. B%%7'"'"!3".! % %'  %"/  '#" )'#'    %        :% !!'  0" 5 '

# !!3/'"'%7#"/.!3/;&(

%&  !  !%) !    !  6%'%

 (

   %" #!

"

7$"#!   !<&!

=%" $  5 "' %?"((%$@6 2/&&!

!!

! .* %"73!'" ! '%'#"/0"'$% &(")'#' *""%'/# %.!

'0'3 

 #' !'"'.". /%' '/  0"'$%A  #'6!!:% !!'A5 '

'"$ %7! '

%'%%##!!A6%%7'"'"!3 ".! '.'0*%'6'"/%'";73% '#" )'#' '!. $' 3 8%$' 3      $0'"  73  6       '3  #'0       (" )'#' *"%  .

'.=' 3$ !/ > ",3. 8%,3.

6 !"#'0!0'%(")'#' *"%  .

'. =' 3$ !/ > 8%' '/%'#" )'#'' 7 "73%,3.  ( '%'%'#"

)'#'3%##!!!'"3"." '.'0"

%!" '$' 3. 8%'#" )'#'%0 "'.6%%'%##!!!" '$' 3' "' 7

%,3.  > *  06    %    "  ' ./  %  '#"

)'#''"'""'.6%%'%##!!!" '

$' 3. ' "' 7 %,3.

=' 3/ > 8%##!""#" 8%'#"' "'"5.6%%'##!!!" '$' 3' "'

 7 %,3. 6% #'" %'.% '."3   

    )*)+,( &'(!     B%%'#;$?'"

C? B%%'#'7!

C?