← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1973/2013allowed

Lokesh And ORS v. Rameshwar Tyagi

2017-12-11Dr. Justice S. Muralidhar18 pages

     

!"#$!$%& 

'(!)*+%$,*!-)  ..!//+%,) 0!-)1) +2!)*3+-4+5# !).%$!%, -+2& 6 ' 

7

-!)!%,&  

  

      

  +89#-!*-+3+,: -+/  

    

 

 

!  





" #!#    

 $% %% %%%&' 

# #       

    (    #   



 # 

 )      

  





#

" ! %*%+)%%,



 

)-       . 

 

 



/

 0     

     $1 1% %%%&'2 $% %% %%%&' 

  3 # 3

)4%5)%%,6 # 

#



#  2#



    # #    '                





 3      7

   )4%5)%%,  3 

 

.7"8  





 ' 



9  

 

!3

 

 9



9        /  :#

 ;/:< 

   

              

  2#       

$% %% %%%&'  

/:   

      

    9 92

 %4%,)%%, 

    2#

      5%,)%%, 9

 8 

8 8

 

  3

 # 

# 

 $% %% %%%&'

    

  -=

 2#  8 

   



  4%,)%%, # 

 

(#





   %+%1)%%,

6  

 #

    #

8   

 

 

  

 

  9

6 #   



# 

    

! #3



 #



   

  

#  

/: 

# '# #    

   3

6 #  #

  

 

 8 

/:   *%1)%%, # 







#

     >   

# 9 



.  "   ;.7"<  

 6 # 

   

    

 /:.7"      

 2 #

9



     

  2#    

2 #  * ?

 #

 

6 # #

 

  # 

;

8 2#



# 



   # 

6 #

#  #

  6 # 



      

   

  /:    

    #

 !

3

6

#

 

 

 

     

#

  #   )4%5)%%,      .7"  8                2      #  3      %5%,)%%,   

 .7"

#     3 2#  3 6

 #     # +        

 3 :@ A  B "

9//>> > > >    :@')  0# !:@'* : 

!:@'+  "  :@'5 $ 0 

#       

3 0@'    !

0@')  !0@'*   !0@'+ 

2$" 0@'5 $  0 

C30D C30D+#   5  

       

     "    

&



@   



<

     "   

  

          #          $ !    

 

             

           %*%)%%5  )4)%%5   %%*)%%, # 



#

 6

#    "

# 

#

    

 

#  3      

 

 

 

 



       $  6 # 

              3       

&



#  



  

6  #  #   "

  

    !  #

# 

 2#           

 

   !   , 

  

   "





&

      #

" 2#  



#  

 #

" #

@   

 





 #

" 



  %*%)%%5 )4)%%5 %%*)%%, 

3

 

=

  

#

 

 

   

  3    

 #

"

   

 3    

   

  6  #          #  

  "

        

>

# 

   

    #

 

8

     

 



3  "

 

 6 #   #   



     !               !  # 

9

      

 !   6 #   #

" !

   !#  9

    

 

! 

      +;<   $ 

4,* 1 E    



#



 2  3    )4%,)%%,

   3  





9 

 





 





     



    

0

  # 

  3   # #   #

 

  

  

           







  # 

 

9

   

#  

/:   

 

2 #

    #



/:  6 # 

  

 /:  !   

   !



    

    

&





 /:  !  

   



    # 



   

  

 

    

6 # 

    



 



 # 8 

      2 # 

   # #  



 2 

 " #



   

( 



          

  

    

  

> 



#

C

  



  



   3  3     

  

    



 

  9



 #





  

# !

 

 





   

  !8  9

    

 

 8  

  



  3      

#

 

 2 #

  - 7                    

&



 !  

!#        

 

 

 3  # 3  

%5%,)%%,

  

       

    

  

 /:8

8 !  

.7" 

 # 

E   

 

 

# # #

6       

.7"#

# 

 



.7"

 # 

 

!

# #  6   



      # 

 # # #

6 #    

.7"

 #  

!    0           

&

        

3   

      #

                          

   

    

   

      

2

  "    







     

2

 "  

  



 !

"  ! # $ "

 



: " 

 %&'(  ") 

   *   +  ,6      

' 

3        

     4 2

       

 #  

   "           

6  





  

 !   

   

#  

#



  ( 



%*%)%%5!

#  3  #)%%)%%,

)4)%%5!#  3  #*%%5)%%,  

%%*)%%,!

#  3 #%%,)%%,

 



  3      

 



 

  #

  2#    

  

.  3

 



#

 3

 3   

C

#  

 

 " #

! 



!     "  





 

 "  3   

      

  #      

       #    

 

    

 #  

2# #

 





#



 2  3 

    







  

> "   #  #

   

   

  

!



7 

    



9

 

  

  

 !



/:    

     

 #8 

&  

!

  

 %7 #      9    



   

  

!   

#

 

#

 

#



     9

#

  

#

      

 # !  #  

 #        9





9

 

 



  

  9

 

  7 

  

  

%*%)%%5! 



$  

  # 

!  .  .   

2     

   

 # 

       

 #



  

  

    

!

%*%)%%5

          

       3     



   )4)%%5  

  *%%5)%%,   

 

   

#  > 9: !

  

#



#)4%5)%%,# 

)4)%%5

#*%%5)%%,

#

   

      3      3    %5%1)%%,2#  #   

 ! 

3   *%%5)%%,7 #      



#     C  



 # %%*)%%,            3          

 # %%,)%%, #  

 

  

  9

#

 

    

        4%,)%%,  

2# 

     #

!

#



!3   %%,)%%, 2   



# 

 

8   9

! 

#  

!   



#      

  8        9 

  

 

 

   

!  #  

   

   C  3  

  3 6

 9

  

  

/:  

  

 

# 

  

  

# 

#

   



   



 

  

 

 *   $  # 



 9

    

!   8 

!   2 " # #

#





 

   8 

 )

  

8  .7"

  # 

#  #  #  !

 3 

 #

   *5)%%,



 

.7"!  # 



  0&:"7      &



 

2#   

   

     

     2 # 

  

 :"7     

 



      

       

# 

;

     #

  

7 #  

  

  3     )4%5)%%, %5%,)%%,2#   

   2  3    3   



 *

       

 

! 

    $  3  3 ! #   #

  2#              

 3

 #

  ! 

    

#   #

       

  

 #   #      3   #   9

!# 

  

#  # 

  



!#   ' # 



  !   

 #

   9

 

 

   

 +  

                

! 

# #

!    # !  

  

      3    



   

$   

  

   #  #

   !  



< # 

##

                   6 

       3

  3 

 





!                     '

   8 3  

!#  &       #    

      '3 



   #

!

 

9  

     

#  2 

    

 5

#  #

!      

 3  

# )4%5)%%,   

  # 3  

  $     #3  %5%,)%%,2#

  3                 

  .  #

      3     3

6   



#  

    ! 

'

 .7" 

   

  

   3    %5%,)%%,6           3  

=   

8   #



9

  

#  



  

  /:        

 #   #         

     

 #   

  

 #   

 

    

   9



!  #  

       

#  #



#      

 ,

     

   

    !  

#

  

!   %+%1)%%1  

     

 8          3         

! 

  9

!    #  7 

   

 

    8  

  !

      C  1    $   

   7 

  #  

 

 

 

   

  8  



        

 " #   

" ##

   



# # !

           

8  

# 

    



 

   6   

 



        !

 # '

 ' 

                               2 

 " #    

    1        



     



 

     

 

                

&

    

    

 

 #   

         8 

      

2# 



# #

& ##  #

 ## 

!  

#

 2

  

   



    !



 

#  6

 

  



 

       

   

 

   !   

     



   

> 

   2

 "



    -   ../  !#

$.(.0.#

 1  

#



   

  

 8      !  #8   

9    

 

 7     

            

   (                  8  '         8  

  

  -. 

#  46  #  

  "

#      )%



  

# 

  #   ,*!"!29!-:

 ?

7@ )*+9*+

 @ 9

&  '

B @ 

'

B