High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/6249/2018dismissed

Meena And ORS v. Nishan Singh And ORS

2019-03-29Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan4 pages

# !

"#$# %&'&() '&*++(+,-./+)& %)*&+00&11+()' $%%!&'&()*'+ , *& 23 &, )2 43(% /*31-%&( +(- 4)*&% +43% 5*+( 6-&/&+'&-7+%&3(+00&+1+8+3('))*&+2+%--+)&-9: 0+''&-;<)*& )%//3-&()1+34'%3;=(+1,5+%(+16 %'*%),!)*&%3;=(+1!7'&&>3(8 &(*+(/&4&() /40&('+)3(+2+%-&-=(-&%#&/)3( )*&)% $&*3/1&'/), 6 %'*%),!)*&/)!7 *&%&'0(-&()'3()*&+00&+1+%&)*&-%3.&%,%&83')&%&-2(&% '=0&%-+% +()&% ;&+%3(8 %&83')%+)3( 9?

: 6*&%&3(+ )&% %& &%%&-)+'!)*&

&(-3(8.&*3/1&!7+(-)*&3('=%&%63&+)3(+1('=%+(/& 40+(<"343)&-7 )*&

&(-3(8.&*3/1&+)*&% -&/&+'&-*+';&&( +%%+<&-+'0% %4+%&'0(-&() *& +/)'(&/&''+%< %+-@=-3/+)3( )*&0%&'&()+00&+1+%& )*+)( ,+43%5*+(2+'%3-3(84)%/</1&;&+%3(8)&40%+%<

A"67?993' +)*&%2+')*&03113(%3-&%()*&2+<,)*& 4)%/</1&2+'')%=/>;<)*&

&(-3(8.&*3/1&,+'+%&'=1) )*&340+/), ;)*)*&%3-&%' &11-2(+43%5*+( &11()*&4&)+11&-%+-,'=')+3(&- 8%3&.='3(@=%3&'+(-*3'4=)*2+'/%='*&-&2+')+>&()5+10+(+ *+21+.&%(4&()&-3/+111&8&+(-'03)+1,5+%(+12*&%&*&2+' -&/1+%&--&+- -+)&-B 2+'%&83')&%&-+)13/& #)+)3(#+-+%5+%(+1 ()*&/1+340%/&&-3(8',3)2+'01&+-&-)*+))*&-&/&+'&-2+' +;=) B<&+%' +8&+))*&)34& +//3-&()+(-2+'&+%(3(8 ,

C?0&% 4()* *& %3;=(+1 +''&''&- )*& 4()*1< 3(/4& )*& -&/&+'&- +'

C?%&1<3(8=0(.+%3='3(/4&)+D%&)=%(',

E =)=%&0%'0&/)'

2&%&+2+%-&-,C )*-&-=/)3( %'&1 &D0&('&'2+'4+-&+')*&-&/&+'&- 2+''=%.3.&-;< 3.&-&0&(-+()'+(-4=1)3013&% !9!2+'+0013&-,+')*& +8& )*&-&/&+'&-2+')+>&(+' <&+%'+'0&%)*&0')4%)&4%&0%) *&%3;=(+1+2+%-&-+'=4 B,,

C?+1(823)*3()&%&')F9E0&% +((=4*&+4=()+2+%-&-3(/1=-&-

C? %1'' /('%)3=4, B,

C?&+/* %1'' &')+)&+(- % =(&%+1&D0&('&' *&%3;=(+1+ )&%/('3-&%3(8)*& +/)'+(-+00%&/3+)3(8)*& &.3-&(/&+--=/&- *&1-)*+) )*&+//3-&()2+'/+='&--=&) %+'* +(- (&8138&()-%3.3(8 )*&

&(-3(8.&*3/1&*&-%3.&%,2(&%+(-)*&3('=%&% )*&

&(-3(8.&*3/1&2&%&*&1-@3()1<+(-'&.&%+11<13+;1&)0+<)*& /40&('+)3( &+%-1&+%(&-/=('&1 %)*&+00&11+()'+(-0&%='&-)*&0+0&% ;> *& (1< /()&()3( %+3'&- ;< 1&+%(&- /=('&1 % )*& +00&11+()'3')*+)(+4=()*+';&&(+2+%-&- %1'' 1.&+(-+

&/)3(

: ))*&/*31-%&(+(-)*&+4=()

C?+2+%-&- %1'' /('%)3=4 3'()*&12&%'3-& *&/()&()3(%+3'&-;<1&+%(&-/=('&1 %)*&+00&11+()'3'

()2&11 =(-&- *&3''=&23)*%&8+%-))*&+4=());&+2+%-&-=(-&%)*& /(.&()3(+1*&+-'*+';&&(-&+1)23)*;< 3.&?=-8& &(/* )*&#=0%&4& =%)3( (- ./ 01/ 2 0! *(# 3!.443 '0&%)*&'+3--&/3'3(,)*&+4=()');&+2+%-&-=(-&%)*& /(.&()3(+1 *&+-' *+.&;&&( 3D&- 3& B,

C?&+/*);&0+3- %

=(&%+1&D0&('&'+(- %1'' &')+)&+(-

C? %1'' /('%)3=4 ))*&23-2)*+' =%)*&%;&&(*&1-;<)*&#=0%&4&=%))*+)23)*)*& /*+(8& 0%3/&3(-&D,)*&'+3-+4=()2=1-;&&(*+(/&-;< E&.&%< )*%&&<&+%' ( .3&2 )*& +=)*%3)+)3.& -&/3'3(, ( +4=() /+( ;& +2+%-&- %1'' 1.&+(-+

&/)3(+(- 313+1/('%)3=4)*+' =%)*&% ;&&(*&1-;<)*&#=0%&4&=%)3(2 0! 5+-

,)*+))*& *&+-%&1+)3(8)1'' 1.&+(-+

&/)3( )*&43(%/*31-%&(-&'() &D3') (.3&2 )*&-&/3'3( 3.&?=-8& &(/* )*&#=0%&4& =%) 3( 2 0 ! 5 +-

,* +4=() ) ;& +2+%-&- =(-&% /(.&()3(+1*&+-'2=1-;& 9 ,

C?3& B,

C? %1'' &')+)&, B,

C? % =(&%+1&D0&('&'+(-

C? %1'' /('%)3=4 '(1<3''=&23)*%&8+%-)&(*+(/&4&() +4=()+2+%-&-

%1'' /('%)3=4, %8%+()3(8+4=() %1'' 1.&+(-+

&/)3(3'

%+3'&-,)*&%&3'('/0& %&(*+(/&4&()

*&+00&+13'+//%-3(81<-3'43''&-#3(/&)*&+00&+1*+';&&( -&/3-&-(4&%3)'3)'&1 ,)*&G=&')3( 1343)+)3(3'1& )0&( +$%%!&'&(), '6)%

4> H*&)*&%'0&+>3(8C%&+'(&-

&'C H*&)*&%%&0%)+;1&

&'C