← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-M/11/2017dismissed

Jaipal v. Surbhi

2018-04-05Mr. Justice Krishna Murari,Mrs. Justice Archana Puri10 pages



 

   

  

  ! " #  $% &%

$ ' (%)%

$ * +,  - "" .

 / 















  

 " /

%0# 1"+2#'  ++ ,,%

%3  "  2.  #' 4 

%.3, 2#'   "+ % 555555   

  % 6  ++ ,,"  "   ,    "  ++ ,  ',, 

  7     '  %

8+""  9 " '* 2':,4   +   ,  "+ 4   . '   

 

'2;((      "< " '' +   ' ,7 7  + "" +"" %

6 '" " + "+ 4  2  +   . '   ' ""  # ,+  " +4  ++ ,,4 " 4"

)=( "$%

) ++ ,,:  7+,

 

:4"' . #9 6 7+, 2':,4    >' 

,"% "#    + " + "4  + "  '  7  4"+ 7 ""'2  4"#,  7    ",4%6  "+  #       # , #    # "

,  "   '"77 " "  "

 4  + "+  #   $%

)%6  "+ 4  "+ '

',,"   +    '"     ++ ,,' '

%6  "+  "+ ,7  7 +""

 '  #' % &% 6 ++ ,,"  "4  " 7  " + ,  ' "

" " 7   , 2 "++ , '% :" + : 4 ' 7 ) "+  7   '

 7 "+      '" "" ++ ,, "  '" 4  "  "+  " %++ ,,"     7  "4 " " + "2 4 4 ,,'"   7  ", 7 ? "+ 

  " ',

  '  7"4 ,, "    '  7  "'    + " ' + "4  "" "% 7  4 "  ++ ,, "',"  7  7 ,  "+   , + ',,2+4 ' 7 , "+ 4      7    '" @ ' "  '

   + "     ,    ++, '     .+    , ' 21:" " :

+ ' % "#   ++, ' 4","7#    7!

" 77 ""

2 % 6 ++ ,,"   +,       " 4   " 7   

&

+ " "+ #   7 7 ,7   "+   @ "  ++ ,, "7 ,"  "+ 4  4  7"

 '' +  7  "

 "   "+ 7  7 + 7  '  7 + " '  7 ,2 "  , # "4 ' ++ ,,    "+ ''7+   + "   "   "+ ': 7 7 , 7 : ++"+  7  +  > 

 " +  2  "+ 4"+ "" ?     7 ,   "",#  7 % 6 ++ ,," 4 ,   ,, 7  ,# 7 " +  2"  4"#, 4 '  ,'"77 $%

) " , , # "" 4  7$%

)7 



)"+   "7 "", +  % )% 6 + "4  ++ ,,4 "" "/ % A   7  4  + " ", ,   "",#   ,, B%

A   +   "7  ,   + "  7B!% &% A   +   " ,'""  ,  "7 B!% )% A   +    " "++  4' ''7 ,  + " +  B!% (% ! , % (% 6  "+ 4  +7 " ," ++ 4  "">"A      #  ' '+7 '  ' "C>% #

)

* +,""C>% % 6'#   "  #  ' 2 ++ ,,"   7" ,  " ++       4  ""  >  "  !A%    #  !A  + .74"       #  ' 4"

>7   '   #  + "'"" >7  %6 ++ ,,","     #  '  # ". 4  "

C>%!! D

,7 '  ' "C>%!&D'  '+ '7+,    

)" C>%!)D '  '+9  ,  :"

 ' "C>%!(D'  '+ # , ' ' "C>%!8D'   '+7 '  ' "C>%!&=D'  '+++, ' .%% "  C>%!D  '    '+         

)  "  C>%!$   + +""C>%!;!$% 8% 6 ,  ,4  +'"

    #  ' ,  +    "  " "" 0% #  "+ 4  ,

  #,  + 7  4  + "%6  7 "" "  4    '

    "    ++ ,,"   '" @ ,   +    4"  '' +        '    ,7    7  ',  7 ,, 4"+"" % 6 ++ ,, "2

 # 4  "  7  ' 2',,   "7  ,  + " ++ ,% A #  ,  '" , + "# + "   '  '" %6 "+ '

" @ "  #,#   + " '"  "" 4  #, : +,' 7 " + "$%

)% A ,   "+ 4  "" +'"   ""  ,'  7 "      + 7 2    ++ ,,"  "  :     "    

(

'  7 "  , : 

 !



     "'      4   , + 7 ", 7 7  + "%7   7      "+ 4    +  7  "  # ,+   " +4  ++ ,,4 " 4"7  ,)=( "  ''  " +2++ ,,":      >'  ,"%  4 # 2" " '  ',, +"      '  7 4"   #   + 7 %      "  ' 2    ++"

    +# ". '  '24 ' "

,,4"/ <







!"

  #

$

7 7 ", 7 ?  ''' 4  '"7  "'  7 "

 +  %  A  "'  "'  7 " ',  "++  "2 :

" # " +"   7    ,   "'   2 7  '7 "'7+,    4  " # " + ": %E $% 6 ++ ,,2  '  '' #,

  "+ 2"4    " + +"

C>%!;!$"4  + "  >'

,"%  + +"," + '""   + 7   '  7% 6 ++ ,,"  "'"" >7  "7  + +"

 ', ':  +.7"7  ', ':  '"

 : "%  4 # "  : " "   >7   ++ ,,%"+  # C>%!A =!A  +.72 "  + +"4  ', ':  " 4  ""% 4 # 2      # 4" " >7   ' 2  #  + "'""

8

>7  " "" 7  7   '7+,  % "4 ,," ,  " 7   '"" >7   " '7+,  " 7  '    #  ' %6  "+ 4   #  ++  '"" >7    " 4  "" +.7""',,   # '

 "" 7  "  "'

 ' #  '  ", "   " + +"    + +"% " '

'7"' "2

4 ,, "  ,+ " + +"%6 2 + "2  7 7# '7+,    7!

" 77 ""

2



)" :

+ ' + ", # C>%!

"4"",    % % 8%

)  "+ 4   ,    ,    #        "   77 ""

  4    "   +"   "

,,4"/ <% %FF%%

% 6 ' 7  "   +   ,   + 2. 3 , * +,2 " #  '  ',,   + * +,", 7 ?  7 $%

) '   . #  9   6 7+, 2  ':,       '    7  4"

", 7 ? %6 '7+, 0% 2* +,''   

      @ "     "    4     "4       # ", 7 ?  7 " ', , ++'     + ' % &% 6  "+   7      +  ", ""; "

 '7+, 0% "7 &  "%  ' 2  4" ''"

", 7 ? 7 4  '7+, 0% * +,% 6  + 2'7+, 0%2',,4"7 4  '7  ''   + % 7 2  "7 ,:++ ""

 7  + %  #      + " 4, + , %

,7     + D   ""' '  +7+  4 ",,", 7 ?  7 4,, # "

"4  %FF%%%E



;% 6  "+ 4  ""+ '

',,"  "  # "  #   "',, 7 "  ", # ++ ,4  + "% 6  "  #  " 4  4 :7 '" "   '"  ++ ,," " # 7 #,     '' %   6 2    ++ ,,  ,"   , "  +    7

'  '  $%

)C>%!&   '7 :  +,'  4  + "' . #9 6 7+, 2':, $%

) '  7 " ''  !      " , 7 "7     " '  ' %   + "4+ 7  '  7 "7 "   >7   ++ ,,% # 4  "  "'""

24   ++ ,,"  ,  ", "+ 7' '  7 " 7  "+ '

,, '  7       0      + +"   ,   +     ++ ,,"+# 2   " " 7  "4 ,, ,+ 7 '  7 " 7 %6   !

" 

 ' 4, '" @ ' 4  ++ ,," ,  ", "  ""  ,'  7 " 7 % A '7 7 " "+ 2 

" 7   

 

' .+ '

,  '''"  +#, 

 G, .+ 7

4 , "  "

  7 

 2 "  7  7 7 ,  ',  7 ,,  "7 4   ', '

'7"' "4  7 '  '  +' "

$

#, ',  ", " %6  , # >'7 "  7  "",,4"/ <(%  ,

,, # '"2'

'7"' "+ , "2  ,  9 " '* 4"" " 4"+,     "+       ++ ,,        "   7



"  2   2  " '"  ',  7 #  . '  (

  .+ '

,  '% 6 

      ++ ,  4"  , '   7      , #  ' ,   "+  '  7+'

  , 7+ , "   "+ G"'" %A # ,        " '"    # % 6      '"77     7     + "2    " '     '  7' ' ' 4  7 2 '   # , #   ""4  +  $ 7"  "

  ++ ,,  4  "  #     ",,    + " , # " ++ ,,G"4  ++"  7 %  6   "+   4"    4+  + "  4 ,   ++ ,,4"   >+  ' ',, " ;

 "%   7+,2 4"  +"

 '  ++ ,,%++ ""  "+ 7# :  #   ' ' 2  >+  '     ++ ,,   "

 "    '  7"7:

, 7 " + "   %

;

 '

'7"' "24   ',   , #  ++ ,,G"'"

 "

 "4    '  7"4 ,, ++   ' "%"2 4""77 %,,  4  "" " >7    "+  ' ' 4  7"

'"',   "+ G"" 2    4% 6   ,  #  '   "    "+   '  '    "%  6 '

'7"' "7   # "4 4"7 , 7 %  C>' +    7  '  '  ""       

 ' 2   "'  7 %,, "+ , " " # "

 ++ ,,  "+ %E %          !"#$%"  #&'  (  #)  !%%" 4     "24 , ++"

+   #' 4" , + 

!

"   ' 2 "  ,  " ' +  '  '   "" ++' + +"  +7 ''7 ""

 >7   '

, 7 ' !

"  ""4  ""+'  

 ' !

" 2 '  ' ',  , 7 ""

,  #  ' % 6 ++ ,, "'' "",  ", "  '7", 7 ?  7 4  "+ 4" @  "4  ""  ,'  7 7 4

" ',   '  7" , + 7 %6   ,': #  '  "7  ,"+ '2 "   "  "       " ,4    '              #,   7   4     + "%

 

" @ , "   "    7 %6   7    ++ ,2 "7  "   "7 "" % &% 9 ' "  + + % "  4'""% 

!

&

"'

! 

#( )) &

"!#

"!#  * ) +, -+./ 7 A  "+ :

= "  H "=0 A   +, H "=0