Mohinder Pal Garg v. Murli Manohar @ Manohar Lal & ANR



   

      




!"#$"% # $'( %()!*!"+,,
 -!"%(.$/ 11(//$"'

 2(.*3* 3./!$"-$.$/!$*$"-$.4$/$"%'-(.* (*1"%("'*

+

54 &

64&

.(*("'+

.$*7!.$''$"$"%.2!8(9$''$":%8)$'(*:

.'-($11(//$"'
 ;-('-(.'-((1.'(.* /)$/"(<*1$1(.=$>7($//<(%'*(( '-(?3%0=("'@  7(.( (..(%''-((1.'(.."'  ;-('-(.'-(?3%0=("'*-3/%7(.(1.'(%!"'-(%!0(*'@





64& : 4




-(.(!*%(/$> 
,%$>*!".(

!/!"0'-(1.(*("'$11($/ .'-(.($*"*=("'!"(%!"'-($11/!)$'!":<-!)-!* *311.'(%7>'-($

!%$8!' '-($11(//$"':'-(%(/$> 
,%$>*!".(

!/!"0'-(1.(*("'$11($/!*)"%"(% 11/!)$'!"!*$)).%!"0/>%!*1*(%  $!")$*( =130"(%  !"  '-(  1.(*("'  .(03/$.  *()"%  $11($/  !* ?3%0=("'$"%%().((%$'(%


:1$**(%7>'-(/($."(%

%%!'!"$/  !*'.!)'  3%0(:  &$"0.3.:  $

!.=!"0  '-(  ?3%0=("'  $"% %().((  %$'(% 
A,:  1$**(%  7>  '-(  /($."(% %%!'!"$/  !8!/ 3%0(  &("!.  !8!*!":  &$"0.3.:  8!%(  <-!)-  '-(  *3!'    '-( 1/$!"'!

#$11(//$"'-(.(!":<$*%!*=!**(% -(7.!( $)'* '-()$*($.('-$''-(1/$!"'!

#$11(//$"'

-$%!"!'!$//> !/(%$*3!' .1(.=$"("'!"?3")'!":<-!)-<$*/$'(."

)"8(.'(%!"'*3!' .1**(**!"$ '(..()(!1' .(1.' '-(/)$/ )==!**!"(. '<$**'$'(%!"'-(.!0!"$/*3!''-$'.!0!"$//>(' $=<$*'-(<"(. '-(-3*($"%'-$'!"$1$.'!'!":<-!)-'9 1/$)(*(8(">($.*($./!(.:-(%!8!%(%-!*1.1(.'!(*$="0*'-!* '-.((*"*:"$=(/>:-!"%(.$/ $.01/$!"'!

#$11(//$"':

3./!$"-$.$"%6$"'!6.!*-$"%( ("%$"'*-(%!*13'(%-3*( <$*0!8("'-!"%(.$/ $.01/$!"'!

:<-(.($*'-('-(.'< *"*<(.(0!8("%!

(.("'1.1(.'!(*'$/*)=(*3''-$'%3.!"0 '-(1("%(")> '-(*3!':('$=%!(%$"%-((B()3'(%$;!// .(0$.%!"0  '-(  %!*13'(%  -3*(  !"  $83.    -!"%(.  $/  1/$!"'!



"'-('-(.-$"%:'-(*'$"% '-(%( ("%$"'*<$*'-$'

"( -$=7$$=<$*'-(.!0!"$/<"(. '-(%!*13'(%-3*( 3./! $"-$.  %( ("%$"'  <$*  /!8!"0  <!'-  -!=  $"%  *(.8!"0 -!= %3.!"0-!*/!

('!=( -$=7$$=<$*!**3(/(** '(.'-(%($'-

-$=7$$=:<-!)-'91/$)(=.('-$">($.*7$)9:3./! $"-$.%( ("%$"'<$*!")"'!"33*1**(**!" '-(%!*13'(%

1.1(.'>$*<"(.-(%!*13'(%1.1(.'>!**!'3$'(%!"'-(


  '-(8!//$0($"%'-(.(!*".().% -!*<"(.*-!1 -$8(-($.%'-(/($."(%)3"*(/ .'-($11(//$"'$"% -$8($/*)$.( 3//>0"('-.30-'-( !/( -(='1!"':<-!)-0(*''-(.' '-()$*(!*$* '<-('-(.'-(<"(.*-!1 ('$=8(.'-(%!*13'(%-3*(!* 1.8(%'!*"/>'-(.($ '(.'-$''-(C3(*'!" 1$.'!'!"7>('$= $"%'-(;!//(B()3'(%7>('$=!" $83. -!"%(.$/ 1/$!"'!

<!//$.!*(&!")('-(1.1(.'>!**!'3$'(%!"


 '-( 8!//$0(:'-(.(!*"%)3=("'$.>1. !'*<"(.*-!1!"'-( .=

%)3=("' '!'/(-(.( .(:"/>'-(.$/(8!%(")(!"'-!*.(0$.%!* '7((B$=!"(% -(/<(. 3.':<-!/(%!*)3**!"0'-((8!%(")(:

3"%'-$''-(.(!*"1. <"(.*-!1 ('$='-$*$/* .(/!(%31"'-(*'$'(=("'=$%(!").**(B$=!"$'!"7>$.*-$" &!"0-;:"(!0-73. '-(1/$!"'!

:<-$%=!''(%'-$'1.(8!3*/>

-$=7$  $=  3*(%  '  .(*!%(  !"  '-!*  -3*(  $"%  3./!  $"-$. %( ("%$"'<$*$/*/!8!"0<!'- -$=7$$=$/"0<!'--!* $=!/> 3./!$"-$.%( ("%$"'3*(%'/9$ '(.'-(*$!%  -$=7$ $='0(*'*-<'-$' -$=7$$=<$*!"1**(**!" '-!* -3*($"%'-$'3./!$"-$.%( ("%$"'<$*/!8!"0!"'-(*$!% -3*((8("%3.!"0'-(/!

('!=( -$=7$$=$"%$)C3!.(%'-( 1**(**!"$ '(.'-(%($'- -$=7$$= ;-("'-(.(!*" %)3=("' '!'/(:'-(1**(**!"!*'-(7(*'1. <"(.*-!1



.(0$.%!"0'-(1.1(.'>*!'3$'(%<!'-!"'-(


 '-(8!//$0( 4($."(%)3"*(/ .'-($11(//$"'-$*$.03(%'-$'!"'-( .(1.' '-(/)$/)==!**!"(.:!'-$*)=(3''-$'"/>/*( (/()'.!)  <!.!"0  <$*  3"%  $"%  '-$'  '-(  =('(.  <$*  -$8!"0  " )""()'!":<-!)-*-<*'-$''-(=('(.<$*!"*'$//(%?3*'')"))' $*'.> 1**(**!" <(8(.:'-(/)$/)==!**!"(.$/* 3"% *=(7B(*:7(%%!"0*$"%)<!"'-(-3*(-(%.<$*1("(% 7>*" '-(%( ("%$"'$"%'-(/)9* '-(51(''!*57B(*<(.( $/*1("(%7>'-(*" '-(%( ("%$"'.(8(.:'-($%=!**!"

 $.*-$"&!"0-;:"(!0-73. 1/$!"'!

:$/*1.8(%'-()$*(  '-(%( ("%$"' B)(1''-(.$/(8!%(")(!"'-( .= *'$'(=("'

 *"

!"

/$<* ('$=:'-(.(!*"(8!%(")('-$'('$=(8(. $)C3!.(%'-(1**(**!" '-!*-3*(.-(<$*'-(<"(. '-!* -3*(-( !"%!"0* $)'*-$8(7((".().%(%7>7'-'-( 3.'* 7(/<-(.(!*"0.3"%'!"'(.

(.(!"'-(*$=(C3(*'!"

/$<=3)-/(**'-(*37*'$"'!$/C3(*'!" /$<$.!*(*  (")(:'-( 1.(*("'$11($/!*%!*=!**(%  64&  

,,
 *?9*