← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/4237/2016disposed of

Harphool And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others

2016-11-17Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih8 pages

  

  !    "#$%#&

%'(  ()"*"#+   %,-./&()(%*(&'.,01.2*%#&'.(,* --(//%#'* 3(,*0* 4'%'( %,5%#%%#&'.(,* (*-#&(#'* +62

4  22  



 

  

  22 7 ,%/  

  !  " # " $  %"%        #        &    %     '"#   () !( *!(% +,-. /)(00 1

  2 3 '14 "

5, 4  #$   " # &     +          #  $     $*0!!!67 5   ( !8 *!(% +7 9 ,-. ( ( *!(13%"

 2 

     4$  7   &$$ ##  3 '14

            %        %

  :        # "#"   !

  # "$" #$ $ 

&; ,   "%  #$% +  #  * !0 *!( 9&

  " #& +  $ # $$ $  :  4%8"5%'.%/%#&'.(,* 3*4-()"%/ %.*"/&%,%#&'.(,**!(81*4,+,1+4//( <%# +;""=  # $#   %  %    ;         +    "      #  "  $$     %" # %&  :#5 14

<%#+#    14  (((! " ,"-

  1,-48/ % + - $        "         #  &    %  "  #    #   %     >          $%># " 7   #   :$% "  % <%+$   7  9:."/(;(%1,((;"'.4.,"%,(#&(,&% '.%'  '.(  %<(,8(#'*  )#'%"#(&  "#  '.(  %--/")%'"#  , )#&#%'"# &(/%5;(,((=',(8(/5<%10(%#&&"&#'

-,<"&(*%'"* %)',5(=-/%#%'"# ,'.(/#1&(/%5  &%5*7>0'"')%##'>("1#,(&'.%'"#"&(#'")%/8%''(,* %#'.(,  /(%,#(&  4"#1/(  0&1(  .%&  1,%#'(&  ,(/"(  '  '.( /%#&;#(,*>5(#.%#)"#1'.()8-(#*%'"#%#&'."* %)', *.0/& #' .%<( >((# <(,/?(& >5 '.( /(%,#(& 4"#1/(

0&1(;."/(&()"&"#1'.(%--/")%'"# ,)#&#%'"#

&(/%5  :()%#'%?(@0&")"%/#'")( '.( %)''.%'

<"//%1(,*"#0,)0#',5%,(>5%#&/%,1("//"'(,%'(%#&%,( #')#<(,*%#';"'.'.("#',")%)"(* /%;.(5%,(0*0%//5 10"&(&  >5  '.(",  )<"//%1(,*7  ;.  %,(  %8"/"%,  ;"'.  '.( -,)((&"#1*"#'.(0,'*,'.(%&<)%'(*;"'.;.8'.(5 1('"#'0). ,,(&,(**%/ '.(",1,"(<%#)(

"&%<"'* "/(& "#*0--,' '.(%--/")%'"#* ,)#&#%'"# &(/%5%,( 0*0%//5&,% '(&>5'.(%&<)%'(*#'.(>%*"* .%/ >%?(& "# ,8%'"#  8%&(  %<%"/%>/(  >5  '.(  %

()'(&  -(,*#* .(,( ,(7"#'.( %)A0"*"'"# 8%''(,*"#</<"#1)/%"8 , %;%,&    @0*'  )8-(#*%'"#7  '.(  0,'  *.0/&  %&-'  % /">(,%/%--,%).%#&("'.(,1,%#''"8(''.(-%,'5' "/( >(''(,  %

"&%<"'  '  (=-/%"#  &(/%5  ,    '%?(

 )1#"B%#)( '.( %)''.%'/%,1(#08>(, '.(,*"8"/%,/5 *"'0%'(&-(,*#*;.;(,(%

()'(&>5'.(&('(,8"#%'"#

)8-(#*%'"#  >5  '.( 2%#& )A0"*"'"# 

")(,  ,  '.( ( (,(#)(0,'.%<(>((#1,%#'(&,(/"( C#<"(; '.(%><(&"*)0**"#7'.(%--(%/ "*%//;(&7'.("8-01#(&,&(,"**('%*"&(%#&'.(&(/%5"#

"/"#1C

$ >5'.(--(//%#'*"*)#&#(&  :(%--,()"%'('.(*'%'(8(#'8%&(>5'.( /(%,#(&4(#",&&"'"#%/&<)%'((#(,%/%#&./&'.%' '.(--(//%#'**.%//>((#'"'/(&'(#.%#)(&)8-(#*%'"# %''.(,%'(   -(,*A5%,&;"'.'.(,*'%'0',5 >(#( "'*;(<(,7"'"*8%&()/(%,'.%''.(--(//%#'**.%// #'>((#'"'/(&'"#'(,(*' ,'.(-(,"& &(/%57"(7 &%5*D 5;$  .",%@4"#1. ,2*')3* %,5%#%  4'%'(  %#&  ,* ') *!(81*4  ,+,  1+4 8!?    <% #+  (* " 5 154% + %   $  "         #  &     5  9    #*!!67&  $% & + 7$  #  " 5

%% <%+ 7 E 9&0>'7'.(,("*%/#1&(/%5"# "/"#1'.( %--(%/*;(<(,7;( "#&'.%'"'"*%)%*( -%58(#'

)8-(#*%'"#  '  '.(*(  --(//%#'*  ;.  ;(,(  '.( /%#& ;#(,*%#&;."). /%#& ;%*'%?(#%;%5>5)8-0/*,5 %)A0"*"'"#;(<(,7/%#&;#(,*;.*(/%#&*;(,('%?(#

C <(,>5'.(*%8(#'"

")%'"#7.%<(>((#%>/('1(''.( )8-(#*%'"#  F 

$  -(,  *A0%,(  5%,&  ;.(,(%*  '.( )8-(#*%'"#1"<(#''.(%--(//%#'*"*F -(,*A0%,( 5%,& ,'.(",(#'",(/%#&  '"*%/*#'"#&"*-0'('.%''.(%--(//%#'*%,( %1,")0/'0,"*'*.(",%<(,8(#''.%''.(5)0/&#'-,( (, '.(2 *>()%0*( '.(", "#%#)"%/;(%?)#&"'"#.%*#'

>((#&"*-0'(&>5'.(,(*-#&(#'*:( "#&'.%'"#%*"8"/%, *"'0%'"#7'."*0,'.%&)#&#(&'.(&(/%5  &%5*"# '.()%*( %,?('88"''((7&%/<G,"*.%#0,%,"

%#&,*7EE +EE4 .(,(%,( 8%#5'.(,)%*(*)"'(&>5'.(%--(//%#'*)#&#"#1'.( &(/%5"#*"8"/%,)",)08*'%#)(*   # %)'7 "# % 8%''(, %,"*"#1  0'  '.(*%8( #'"

")%'"#7  "#  "<"/  --(%/  *   E    7  '."* 0,'.%&,(#&(,(&%@0&18(#'&%'(&   )#&#"#1 '.(&(/%5 &%5*%#&(#.%#)"#1'.()8-(#*%'"#'

$-(,*A0%,(5%,&-(,0*%/ '.()0#'(,%

"&%<"'

"/(&>5'.(,(*-#&(#'*8%?(*"')/(%,'.%''.(,%'( 

$-(,*A5%,& "=(&"#,%86*)%*(2 E

EE.%* >((# 0-.(/& >5 '."* 0,'>5 &"*8"**"#1 '.( *-()"%//(%<(-('"'"#%1%"#*''.(*%"&@0&18(#'-(,0*%/ '.(*%"&,&(,8%?(*"')/(%,'.%'"',(/"(&0-#&"*8"**%/ ,&(,*  -%**(&  "#  <%,"0*  '.(,  *-()"%/  /(%<(  -('"'"#* ;.(,(>5'.(% ,(*%"&,%'(.%&>((#0-.(/&  .0*7"#%/8*'%//)%*(*7'.(,%'( 

$-(, *A5%,&.%*>((#%--/"(&>5'.("1.0,'%#&'."*0,'  .(  --(//%#'*  %,(  "&(#'")%//5  *"'0%'(&  %#& '.(,("*#,(%*#'8(('0'%&"

(,(#'',(%'8(#'''.(8 :(%/*#'('.%'7;."/("#'.(*()%*(*7'.("1.0,'.%& ,( 0*(&')#&#('.(&(/%5%#&&"*8"**(&'.(2 * '.( %--(//%#'*7'.(,2 *;(,(%//;(&>5'.("1.0,'

 "'*(/ >5)#&#"#1'.(&(/%5 '.(*%8(8%1#"'0&("#'.( *%8()",)08*'%#)(* C A0"'"(*  )%#  >(  >%/%#)(&  >5  &(#5"#1  '.( %--(//%#'*6"#'(,(*' ,'.(-(,"& ,;.").'.(5&"&#'

%--,%).  '.(  0,'  .(  *0>*'%#'"<(  ,"1.'*    '.( %--(//%#'**.0/&#'>(%//;(&'>(&( (%'(&#'().#")%/ 1,0#&*  >5  '%?"#1  .5-(,  '().#")%/  <"(;    *(/ "8-*(& /"8"'%'"#*  #  '.(  8%''(,    )8-(#*%'"#  , /%#& %)A0"*"'"#7;(%,( '.(<"(;'.%'%--,%). '.(0,'

.%*'>(-,%18%'")%#&#'-(&%#'") H :(7%)),&"#1/57%//;'.(*(%--(%/*8-01#(& ,&(,* '.("1.0,'%,(*('%*"&( (/%5"# "/"#1'.( *"*)#&#(&'"*.(/&'.%''.(%--(//%#'**.%//>( (#'"'/(&'(#.%#)(&)8-(#*%'"#F 

$-(,*A0%,( 5%,&;(<(,7 ,'.(-(,"& &(/%5"#%--,%)."#1'.( "1.0,'>5;%5 2 *7"#%//'.(*()%*(*7#"#'(,(*'

*.0/&>(-%"&''.(88-(#*%'"#*.%//>(;,?(&0' %)),&"#1/5%#&-%"&''.(%--(//%#'*;"'."#%-(,"&

'.,((8#'.* ,8'&%5  " >" $ # @  &#"# $'#  %   "#  %>  #;"=   #"  #&  $$$ #  #

> $ % $# "%  % $" # &  "

" "%

   %  " $

#% #  

* 7 5&( 0/1 A B4 $;## $  %     +  $       #           #%  #" # & .$ "  6 6"

 (   #   "#

C>  $# #          $ $          #

+  " #& +'"#() !( *!(,-. /)(00 1   2 3 '14 "

5,  4 #   # *0!!!67

$%'   #$% + 7$ $ % &  %   #    !    "   : %   !  " # "  +

 C "#$%#&



H +  #& % % + 3 '14 "

 5, 14 #  $#  <%#+ :#5

'"

14  %    #     !   " 

(?

(( *!(    22



  

  ;"6 E6.  % E6.