High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/206/2013dismissed

Dhan Kaur @Dhanno v. Om Parkash And ORS

2019-08-01Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan15 pages

!"#$

%%&& '#"

(#) #"* &*&#%#+ #

% #*",- # .+/"%0+ # %%&&

#0#+2

# 3#0+ ##%3

5#&- # %& !"#$ 2 %&"* #& 6 &&" ,#"* " # &#0 %# ." #+#-* 7

(#) 03 &* 0"%! 03$3 06 0 5 #* 83#0 ##&,# #&

##-* ## *#+ / + $ 3+%##

%# +# %& 6 &&"

# %# 2 2# *#"&"#& & "#*9)&#&022&&* ""#*99 :"#-# ;:"#-##%+&-+%& "#*:"#-#< && %#%#2#& :"#%#%# 6 &&"< 6 &&"

=&+*, %# &*&#%#+0 2-# 0 +&+"% %& 2&&&& :"& #< 2+# %,#00 %&)2 3 92#*%# #%#%#02 %& ) # # # # ," # # *#"&"#&& &#-,%# ,23 9 #2,*+ # 3

< %&"# #)2 *#"&"#&& ,*###,-3 9# 6 &&" #"* &&*#

% 6+& " 3 0 2 2 "

#* %&0 %#* " 2#&0&&"+," #-2 " "#-#& )

%& "2#2 "#-"< #,,-3 9# 6 &&" &&"+0#""&%+&9= *#2&&* %#+%0 ## #:",&+:" #* 0 & # %&0 " &,& , #>02 "* #* " %& "%#%#- 0 %&0 %& "# # )2 *#"&"#&& ,:"#,-/+#?#-+

"#= 1:" 1:"6&&# %2#3

2#*%$ ;&%##< %&2&*7 # %0 2+#03 9# %&," # #0# # -#%# &+ &- # 6 &&" #+ " 007 % &&* ;0;=07

0 - &##,#&##8"* 2 "%&* %#%&%#-< ## 2""& %2

97%# :"#-# %## # "%##""# 2 +&" &) < :"&-

= 3 9 #+ " ;;0;=0;7 %

=< 3 9 && %%&,#?* 6"#+."*%@ 7

0 % 2 #

97%#:"#-# ;7%#:"#-#0" 3 9#+" 0; 0 7 &&* =;0907= < ## 3 9 &%&1+( %>6"# % &&%* #* %&03 9 #""&&- #+ & % 009 0;7 %%#%# #%&0* 090 ;70 2-0 %&& # # % >#3 9&##.&- +#&&-&,&%- %&2 #

03 09 %%# & . 2# #+#* #& # %&* %& & #"#&# "#< +-&" ,#* "< "2,##< 6+& 6"#&)."##-# "< " 2,&< %&2%%,- #2 "#&* " "2,##"# 1:" #0 2#*

; %#%#- " 2 #& %##- %#%#- 6 &&"&-&##+ 8"0 9;0 6 &&" #&:" %##-# *#"&"#&& #+,&%#%#-#, "& 3 9 ,* %## , >&"+ 2# # A 2#* " & , :"# ,- /+# ?#- % 2 %

#*" 0 %& +-#* # #2 "&0" 2&*- # %0# #2# %#* 2#* 2#"&-# #+"##2 #% :"#& "* #*&&* %&0 " %#-#& "

B %#2#&,-3 ;0 " ",* #& %#%#- %#**#"&"#&&"#*9)&#&2 %# 8"0 9; #"* #& %# &- &,23 9< 3 9 &"#&#,#*3 79 6"# # ", 8"*0 /"#*0 2 2 # + ."*# < &* "0 2#* ) #*+

# %&2&&3

0 2+#0 - %-- <"# ##0 2#*2&&< #3 =09 3 ; * %& "< ,#

0 *#"&"#&&2+* 3 902 ##*%#%#- #22&&* " +*#99:"#-# ;:"#-# +%&"#*

9:"#-# +-, %# B 0" &%#-#& "

& %# 2# * %#%#-" #& %#%#- %# " 0 %& 3 9#% %#%#-" #*" 0 & ## .% " %#%#- %"*."*##,* 2#* > #%#%#-" 2#*&& # % "

3 = 2#%#*>%#

B"#2## A %#2## :"%%#"&+

# #* &#"&# %#0 #&

9 6"#"3 * %&0"3 = * ,*%#0"3 ;+"# 0"3 +"# 0"3 9 +"# 0"3

* ,*%# "&&-0 #&6"# " %& A 2+."*#

@&***#+,- ."*#0 %& &%%& 6"##8"*0/"#*0 2 2*&#8"*0/"#*02 + ."* # %%& 2

2 ."*#%,- 6"#,&20 %& )) # 6"# ,-2-&*#*"&#%%&%#-* , %0 %"*."*#%,- 6"# ,&2, "&,- #,# 3 %%&2*+ #% #%3 +%%# #"* "& B + #&#"&# %#,** #"* ##

A #&6"#&* #" 0+",- %# &2%%&,&

0 ,#+ %# 6 &&"2#&#2# "%#%#-< >%#3 9# 2 #%& &*2 3

###"* #6 &&"

<"# ####*%&2&C -# 902 #3

*## -# ;< 6 &&" >%#

= #* %& 6 &&"+&+"%&& &# + #"* #:"& # 7 # #* %&0 %#%# & , ,- 6 &&" "# & :"# %#%#0 2 # #* * "##& %##-%#%# ?2+#0 %&** # ##(D #> " %#%#2##&%##-%#%#- 6 &&" 6* &*&- +&- %"* ."

* # #"& %# ,2 6 &&" 0 "& && # A 2,- 6 &&" +&" &,-* #*#0:"&-."

&:"& #

A %& ,,&,#*-* +*+& 2 6 &&" %%# 6"# &2#* & 02 2#%& "# * ## 6"#* & %& B "& %%,#&%##- %#%#-0 6 &&" #%-%## %#>* #* " & &- &7%#7##* #*# "& , +&&- ##+,2 6 &&" , #,2 # :"##* & # #02 * +#:"#%"&#-#*# # @"# ##0+# )#*"0 ) #2%* #0 "& +, &&*2 %# #-## 2 2% %&& )2&#0 "2+#- +-"% #,& 22#%* ##&#)2 ,"."

0 2+#0 2 & 9 A "* #*%&0 )2," %* #%,#0&-0," ,&+,&

6 &&" +*>%#

=" +* ,+"#3 9 , %"*#0%&",&+* %&2"2# ##" &* B+#- -"%2 %& %&22# # #&#)2,"&-,#&* " B" -%#,&+02 " %& ,#**"* *+*+ 2 0 %#+12"&#"# - # -#-;-##+#)&# * 22#%*##&# "# %&""&%#+*,-,#**"* +*+## )2&* %"*."

*##&# &,- #0 &,"# )2&*," 2 " )2 ",& * %&** )2&* ." ,# &* " ,- ,#** "* "%%#*+ ?

##&*# &* E++###:"#, &&* * 2 %# &0 #2 # > %&- , 2 2- A %& 2 + ", - ,. 1:"6&&#&* # % + - %%& ,# 1 :"A#,"&#-6"#&2&* # % A #&6"# #* &-,#+ %"* ."*#,&#"&&+ , +* , &&* " ,# %# &

#*# #%#-#,-%& ."-,%+"# %&* 3 9##*" #%#* #* %#%#- 2",&#-2&&* ""#*99 :"# -# ; :"# -# ,#* 3

0 #%+&- +%&"#*

9 :"#-# 2 " *+* # %&0 " #& 2 & & ,#+* "#-+&" " %& +,%&##,- %&%& &%#+ " "%&2#&:"#%#%#- 6 &&""# ##"#%#2 #*#

"#%&%*,#-6"# A A#&6"# ,#+ -%# "#%&)%&0 %& &&* 0 2 %#,".""&,*# # 3"&, "2 " ,#+,- #&6"#& #&%#." %& %& ,""&** %"*#&#"&& +0 ##0 #&7 # % "2#02&#."&,"2 " %%# #&6"# A #&6"#"# #,#+ %& &%&"#&#2 ")*# -:"&#&0 ##0 "2,&

1# & # 8"*0 /"#* 2 *#2 #&6"#&& * "% & ."*#%,- #&6"#

1#"&# %%&& %&7%%&& #22&&* "+%& &, ,- 6 &&"#& ?"",-0;

B"%%# 0 ###."*

##* %%&&7%& 2&&* "+%& ,,& &- "#* #&0 %%&&7%&-&"%#

#*#02 ,%,- 6"## 2 &2

1#"&# %%&& "# #### ."* !

"# $ #%"

,-*&5 6"#02 #2,#+ %#%#-" &,#& #%7%& *#,-,# #* %##-%#%#- & , #& %#%#- %%&&70 "&%

"* #&2,-"#*#," %#>*#* #+"# B2"# # ,#+ -#*%#+ *# A##(#%#-,", &+

A #,-%"2 " %#%&2 ," #+2&",+0 ,,#+ %#%#- 6 &&" 2 #& %##-%#%#-02 :"##,- ,# 0 - %#>*#* #02 2 %&-#*C,-2-%"*# A ##0 #:"##*#,,+& %#+*#A##(#%#-

# ."* ,- &# "&

& '& ($

& ($

= % 0 & & (* + ,

" $ "- 0 &(

") .,#0 %%& %# "##" >2 " ,#+ , @"# ##02 %%&2&0 6"# > #2," - , "% 1#"&# #% #*" 2 &"* = =0 &#"&# %%&&2## %%&&6"#"# ),& ?""0 ; &&",*2 #%#+ &#-,#%&,- ; ## "* # #* )%# 2&&*"- B 6"#,&2 #. & %&+2 &&*&"&%# # %& +&")%#

A ."*#%,- 6"#,&2 #2&&#0,"%%#%#%%#&%%# +###%#&2 A #&&*&-# #- # 3",&:"&2# %%&

A ##0B-# %#%%&

; - # "#, &*&0 +& 2&& #."*#%,- 6"#,&2

A %%&#*&-

5#.

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#