High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-M/128/2017allowed

Neetu Chauhan @ Sonakashi v. Sanjay Aswal

2023-01-05Ms. Justice Ritu Bahri,Mrs. Justice Manisha Batra22 pages

! ""## $ %

& '( # )" * + ,- -./0 #1 -%

(

-2"

# 1%

-- &/ -1%

-3#)

1 -%

(

- %/ -

-3 1%

5' ( ' #6

"- "" #1

( !6

6 & 63 -

- 0 61, !

# 1( -+'" #+'

- 787 87+8

* -- 6 197- - : 9:81-#

3 -- 6+ (

+' - %-

6- - ' - 1

+ ##( 5-

+#( -

3 -- 6 + (

( #3; 999 -6 * - -3

- -- 61

'#% 6

+ (

(#!1 (

- 3#' !

< % '

(- +-

9 -" %#'1( --6(

-3

- ( =

-"#

5>?<<5

( 6-

-+ -"# ##

- "-*

3 -

-#3;

3 -- 61

-3 & +#(

3 "

- =

(3 @ -3 66-%1 --6

- - # ! #

#% # A (3 +#%# 6 -#= -" ##6

%--" 3 "

- # 6- %- ' "

---"+# - #+

##'- 39 91(

3 #

%-"

-"#

3 -- 61 !

( 2 1 3+ - '31( -1 "

!6#B -- 3

! 3 ""6 3#B -1 + 3 ' # -%

* + 3 - -

--3 '3=

##6

(

+ % 6 -"

# 3 ( #!1(

-36 3 3#'33+-

( -

3 3 = -" "#

( ! 3 (

%- ( - 3#'33+- "

- 1+-

-1-3

-1

- ' 3= "#

' - 1

-(3 ;

"- +-

-1(

3 # "#

' -

6%-3 33

"---#'

-3"#' (

- 2"

#5 #

C!#3 -1+'# %6+ - 3

- -'6 (

-36 ' $ #

-" +-

-!"

- 6 -1

- -

- 3(

@ '1 3 + !

& 6 -6 " '1 #

+ ( ( '6

' - 1

, !

# *(%-1 -

- 3

3'-3 "

- 6

3 # (

-36 ' #+& - 6

6 # ## -

#- '

-"#

- %

(%- # 3

#3 -( ' #-"

-" 3#'33+-1

-'1 6 @ -3#'

' (

"- 3#'33+-1

% -

-= -3(:

(1( -' #

% 3

6 "#

( -

-"- -;

3 - + 1

- #1

%- ( -

-+ 3 3-6- %= -' -#

( -

:#!

, !

# 1

# 3# %6

-36 ' - 61 / #+

-!=

"- - !"

##'

- -6 3'1-" :"

- 0 "

C1* -1.

# -1

' - C1

-"#

' - 1

#6(

0 "

-*"

- "-% "

- #-

-3 - # ( - 3=

---; 3 ( #

- #+

##6

1 # - -"

3 # %6

- !

3 (

-36

- " =

#6(

-1- 3 #'#

3#'33+-# 6 # - "

-+' %6 -1+

' '

# 6' "#

-( '

-% 3 6

- -#

% 3#' =

/ 1 ,

3 61( 1 ##""# %

3 -+

% -1+

- ( -

% %-' 6-1 # - (

-= - -1 D1

(- #

-3

!1"-3 -"

- =

- "#

- -1

-3 # 3 +

# - " 3

3 31 !- 3 - -

-/3 !

= -" "#

3#B -@ %3

+ #1( 1 % - 3 #B -1+

3"-%6 -#1 @

# %

-((!

' - 1 @

- --#

% ,

-( ( #

%+-!

#6= @

( # #

3#'33+-

( #( # 3#'

( #-33+-

3-%-

-"#

3+-1 1

- (

-1 +

3)" "#

'6 ##

-1+

6 3

- #+

%"-"-#'(

-3-

-1 # +B #'1

-1

- !

' - 1+

1 1

# % #(

#" -

! ( '-+#'

-"#

1 #? (

-3"

#6(

-%- 3

- -"

C1*

+- ! #6 %#%

"" % 1 #

*#6

-"-

3 '

# -10 "

-A ##6

"@ -3#'

3#' ""- 6-

- #1 #

"-"- '=

-"#

9 9

+"#

(

+33"+#-

#% 6

3 -- 6

+33 6# +-!##

-3

#3 61

-+'1-

-- -% +#+- !( 1

" +'#6 -(-

3 3

3 -- 6

' # -

+ ( " 9 9

C1* -.

# -0 "

- "#

-1 " #

%+#=

- "- '1 ( -" #

' 3

-3 # 31( -

3 -- 6( # #'

+ #-

##6

& -

) &

= "#

-%- --

# #

3 # ##6

3 -

-1( -"

+#"- "#

###

3 -

#+#6

-;3 +'

+ 3#'33+-1

'3 - # ## "#

-6 %E

3 -3 -- 6+

3 -

-+'-" 3#'

33+-1

-( #"-%

3 '1 +

' - 6

-##6 #3 -3

3#'

- -"

' ##' (## 3

##'=

%- !

-% -#B --

-% - # ##6

##6

- )

-1"#

#-!- -

# #B - +# -# 3 #6 #- +# +

3 - "#

%-% -"

# 3 (

3#'

1- +#%- +# !7

-83 6= %- ""

(

3#'33+-1-%-

- ( -

-"#

-%- !

- - -%-+

-= 1-

-"#

' - 1 - "- '1

+'"-"6

'( #

F#-

2 * -/-

- +

! #

"- @ 3"

(

-6 -

- "#

' -

-" 1 (

- #- -"

( # #3

3 # 36

1 (6 ( - 6-3"# -

-- -3

"# 6

##(6 (- - 3- &

%--

9 $

1 -3 -- 6133

- '(

" - ##6

" G $

" - 9 9(

'- +#

G $

" - #- -

%-G C )#H .--

1 ""#

- C

* -- 6 ( "

#' ##(+'

- 0 61, !

# 1 ( -6C 1 F"-3

3 " # #6(

# 6

@")#

-3

""#

- C

-6

"' %- "-6 -6

" "

# -#'

#-1( -+'

- 3

""#

- D

( 31 +'6- 6

#+- '

3 -63

+#% A ""- 1

"" - ,$

- #' (- % >@,$F1 - -

" * #@ 3

& 6 ,$1,$ / #+

-7 +-

+ 81,$C0, ( #7

+ 8= # - %

##(6 3 >@, )" :* (-

>@, )" : #,--"

>@, )" :6)"-

6 -6 -+'" -(

# - "

- '8 >@,C ""## :* (-

- " - 3#'33+- >@, ""#

9 +'" - ,#

# -70 "

- '8-36

-7( 36-"- ( -"- +' 38 >@,D )" :* (-

"#6'<

D7= -, 68

>@,

* (-

)" :

" -

( '-3 3#' "

+ - # %

(

#6(

- !

>@, * (-

" - #%# ( % !!"#$

%-3" -

'+'

>@,9 * (-

)" :

" - + (" - "

- >@, )" :"#

= 6

" -+'(- 6

6 -33

6 >@, )6

(

3"5 ! (6

-( '"

5 !

% #1( ( #

-# - >@, @ #,--"

)" ( -6 # -#'+6

! -+'

" -+' # 6

"# - >@, -,

#6')"- )" :1 (6

( -6 # -#'+6

! -+'

" - >@,C 7) :)( # 8@

+ ( " -

# #-

0 "

-1

!- +'

" -

( #% "

#'-3

" -"

- # ( >@, , '3 )"

" - "

>@,D ,- -%-)"-

0 "

-- >@,

D )" : +3

3#' 10 "

- (6 -0 "

>@,

3 F,

- (6

0 <!-" -

5 !5!

- 0 "

-1( +6"-

-#6

"- %-, +'

" -

+ >@,9 )"

,#)"-

#6+' " - )" :

3 #3

- + 61

6 3

" - >@,

# 3"#

#6+'" -

)" :

3 #3-

+ 61

6 3

" - >@,

-% # #,--"

D , - >@, 5# ! 6+ 6)" 7

6) #

I #" - , "-(

" -8 >@, )-6

>@,C )-6

9 -"

>@, +! ,-

8 (6

- 33

- # "

- # >@,D )A)"-

D C C

- #-- " - >@,

- "'""#

!6 33 , J- -, #

- . & '( #K1"6=A *E)A J)= 1 ><*A >@,

- "'3 ""#

F, J- -, #

-. & ' ( #K1"6=A *E)A J)= 1 ><*A >@,9

- "'-6 #, 75- !6 33 8J- -, #

-. & '( #K1"6=A *E)A J)= 1 ><*A >@,

- "', J- 9* # K

. & '( #1"6=A *E)A

J)= 1 ><*A >@,

- "'=- -, D J- , # K

. & '( #K1 #+-*:+# "-3 A

>@, ># - '5###

1,# 1.'

-1 "

+'" - >@,5 5-

< % '

( #

75- 9 85-

0 "

>@,

, '3 -"

)" "

+'" - >@, +#5## -! , "' -#

B 5! & '( #1

) "

0 "

-7, 68 -! , "'5 !, +! & '( #1 (6

) "

0 "

-7, 68 -! , "'

3 & '( #1 (6

) "

0 "

-7, 68 -!C , "', '--6 "-"

-+' & '( #- " 6 #

- -! < 3

C 9 C -!D , "', 75- !633 8J- -, #

& '( #K1"6=A *E)A J)= 1 ><*A -! , "', J- 9* # K

. & '( #K1"6=A *E)A

J)= 1 ><*A -! , "', J- 3 .# # K

. & '( #K1"6=A *E)A

J)= 1 ><*A -!9 , "'=- -, CC CJ- , # K

. & '( #K1# +-*:+# "-3 A

-! , "' #)"

7 , 68 -!D -! )"

( # -! )+',

- #2- 3

- % - !

( # -!9 5 !

3 !

-2

- ",

- # 2- 3

- -!,CF5, 6- "

>% -!,CF5, 6- "

5# ! 6>6' ( -!L <

--3 #

9 3 6-

-" -

0 "

- -1

#%1%--

D D

-1 @ 3 -# )$

--- - #'(- % >@)$F - -

%-1

3#'33+- -

- -

( - +'

' - %-33

- ' ( : #%(

3 3' -"

- 6 %

3%- # 3 ##6

"--3 3 -- 6 A ""- 1 # @ 3

3 ! )$1) &/ -

(8 )$1

/ -)!

)$C1)

) )

( '

---

##(6 3 >@)$F55 . 6 - >@ L

3 !

"'#

"' ##

9 D -!C

"' #-- -! -!5 , 6- "

- -1# - #-

#%1 %--

D -"

##(6

6- %- ' " 31

-+'3 !63"+#- 3#%

'3-

(

! " # !

% "!

! ! ! !

& !

(

) ! !

! * !

+ !

3#' -66

%#+'

1 !+

-- &

= 3#' A % -

+ +#

- ' "

-" A

+ #

3 -- 6

+-! ( -- -% +#'+

- ' "

- (

##"

3 .# 1 ##66%- # %#

3#'33+-= "#6'#

D7>@,D8 (-

+ #'"-%1

3= #

-7>@, ,D8 --6 # #

- + -6

%@ 3

(- 6@"- '

- - (-

+' -= 3

-6

- #

D# %6

-3 # (

# 6 #

-B

## -(

- (

C 3

! -+ ! # 3

-% -

'3 # 3

# -3-

- -'6 (

= >@,D ##'

" 1 ( -+'

- # -

3 3

3 3#'

33+- 3# -#'1>@,C1, 1, >@,9 ##

(- 6

( - -

3 !

#%(

-- ( ## % 3=

"-% --

#- '3

3 3#'33+-+'

( $

-" A 1

- !

( -- +

-" 1 !

3 --+-

0 6

9 D1(

(

-= ( #(##6

#= ( # +-"+#-

3 1

(##+6 (# -

# #6 66-%

6 & 63 1

( "---

"- "" #=

6& 63 -6

"" #= - -1 9 1

##(6-- ""#

D9 !!

% .

0 1'' !

0 !!

! !"' !!

% .

/ 0 1''

3 3

3' 4 %3 333*"!

3 3

! 2 4 5 ,(') 3' 2 31

! !

4 %3 333*" 4 (3 333*" !!

! 6

4 ' !

! !

! !! ! !

& !!

08 , 3

31 9

! ! !

! 8 91

- ( ---

*(%-1

- "

*(%-1 1 "

(-- "" -

#6(

#- C 1

-( ----

- 1 %

( ""

- = "

##(6-- :

! 2 ;

/ < 0 !! / !

/ !

2 !

! = !

< !48 ! "

! 4

3 ! !

; !!

! 4 ' # ! 2

D 4 ' !

! 4

' !

6+4 ! "

! + > 0 !

. 2 +

/ !

08 '

9 1 -"- ( -%-3

C ( "# --(

')1 1 F

" )-

--+- =

(## -5*/#

7 "#@8 ##' - 51

-)'=(-1 *- -1 1 3-) 1 "

-3

+%1 (##"

' # 3" 3) 1 1 F

) 1 1 F1

6%3 - )1 1 F ) 1 1 F

' # - -1 1# - #

-3

( 6

(

= (## -

- ) # !

+ -%+' "-

#3 6-3 9 1

" 3) #

= - -1

+% 3 " 6%6# ""-

'+'

= "" # ( -- +3- 9 1

-( --% # -- #-

- ' -

- (## #" )#

" :-

< -- #-

--3

""#

,- $3 -3

3 .# 1 # +'

( ( # 3 - "-

9 C +' =* 1 = 3"# (

(

' - -"

6' - #-

# ' -= --

9 C

!-- @ - * -# - #-

3#'33+-5-

3#' (##1

+# --

( +-

(##1- #'1

3"-3

) #

- -1( 6 %

(

- +'

+% 3 ) # 1( ( +' ##

1-" ##- ' ++'

-3

3"-3F

#3 1 #' 6 +' +

= -" %# 36%

-6

1 6- +' 3#'

/"6%(" # -

61 (## +"+# ##

- 6=

""#'(

= +

% -

(

-"+#"-" ##'!"6%(

" 31

- " 31

( 6

(

% 3 "" #1 3

- '= %

!6 +

- (

-= 3 -- 6 #-- -% +#'+-!(

'6 "

#' 9 9

# %+-

3#' (

( --"+#( ( - # ( - 3 3#'33+- )-

6 +3 & 63 *:+#

"-3 A

( -*:+#

"-3 ( # -6 ( -3 -- 6( -- -% +#'+-!( #

-%- +6- ( -+

%#%## ##6

3 -- 6

"" - +"- ##'

#% 6

- )-

6 +3 & 63

- 6 5 *:+#

"-3 A

! ( - *:+#

"-3

+ - ' # 6 3

# - ' $ # @ 36

"# 6 %+-

--1

;

##6

- '

-( - 3"

3 -- 6 "+#1

(%-1 ---6 % - 1

+-%

-- -% +#+- !6(3 -- 6

-'6- ( - #

3 -- 61+

(

%( 3"# & -

6 6 #6- (#6 #+

#1-

3 -- 6A "

++-% - )

! 9

9 ! !

? 9

! .

! 8

8 !

& !

-0 65 *:+#

"-3 "#$ #$ %!"

6- 3

#- '+

-- -% +#+- !( -- 6

#---6

-"-

< (

33A

*:+#

"-3

' !((

+-%

-- -% +# +- !( 3 -- 6 6- - %- -

-- 6 1 (%-13 -- 6( - ##"

-"1 + -%%+' :%- 1"

- (##6 (-!

- - -- 6%#%

3 3

%- "1

-#' '

-"-66+ ! #

#- -

+' -

--- +3 & 63

*A) C7,?*89( -

+ #

( -

(# #-3 #3"#

+ 3#'33+- - C DFC9A, 1( - #

(

3 3

#- '

+ ( #+ # -%- - 787 8

9 *:+#

"-3

$ +

*$ 1 D7C8

# (

( -

(( #%6"

#'-#6+

( %-+'3

# #'

3 !#

+ 3- +#=

-%-( 6- +6 - # -

3 +'

(( #

-- 6

+-!-- -% +#'A"

D1D 1D D91

+ +-% - (

@ !!

6 !!

& !!

2 !

&&& &&& &&& ()

! !!

!! 9

;

2 8

2 9!

2 #

! 8

! .

/ 0 1''

9 & " !

' 33 333*"4!

4 ' 33 333*"

2 !!

3 33 333*"4!

! !

9 !

"- 1

3 -- 6+ (

+-! (-- -% +#'

-36 6

-1-#%6

-1 6- -%-( #+ - -

= # ""#

,- $3 -3 3 .# 1 1 ( ( 3- ""

( #6-

# 6

""#'6

+%3 & 63

"- !"6%(

@ - -' - 3

"" #3*(%-1(-

+ "

' 3 )#

3 -

(

-5*/#

7 "#@8 ##' - 51

-)'=(-1*- -1 1&3-) 10 "

-= @-

##+3"# (

-3

-- & '

& '

2--

A !

* BMF A !

BMF