← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2071/2013allowed

Gurdawinder Singh v. Balwinder Singh

2019-02-15Mrs. Justice Anita Chaudhry13 pages

        !"# $#%&'&() * 



,,#--!("

 

#',($#("



,,#--!("

 

#',($#("

 ..+

,,#--!("

 

#',($#("

/ /

,,#--!("

 

    

  #',($#("'

** *+

,,#--!("

 

    

  #',($#("'

) 0 1 12 1   

 !

"

# !

"

%%  

'()* +,*'

 %  

+,)* +,*'



 # -!

"

-  - !

"

%%  

*../!

*/)0 ('(/ +,*)

 -#!

" !

 !

"

 %  

*../ */)0 +,*)

 

#!

"

%%  

+,)* +,*'

 %  

'()* +,*'

11111 

    # !

+,)* +,*'!

'()* +,*'!

*../ +,*)!

*/)0 +,*)

('(/ +,*)  % 

%    

##

   "  3!

$

4       #

 $

  %         

7 $    #% 

7  "  %8#    %8 7 

 $

#

 9

 /+

:"  !

*;)+  7 %8   "  %"



  9 2  $   7  

 8     % 

 # # 8

3  



# "

<

= " !

7 

8 7 %   

 

    % 7  

   $#  %  7 6   

?

@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@2@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@  

%     

"

 

 

 

 

$ 8  

"

7

8  */;'

$ 

 

$ !

   

$

 7

# %

  " %%   

( #

$  

$

( # 4"  < +A

#

 6 

 

 ="    # 

%  %<

" 

#7

7 # #   

 %

#  #

$ %

%% 8

< +A

# 

%% 8  # 

$  $ 

$

%% 8

/

B %% !

  <

 7

7<  #  %8

 !

 $ !



%$$!

  4  

#

6 



 7 8 */ 8 

# 6 

 

 

3 !"# '!-#$##$ 1!($#!'43&(5 64("

,(C**C,* < #  0,!,,,C

,(C**C,* +.

< #  .!.+!(,,C

'

++C**C+,,* / < *.

#  +!0(!,,,C

     !

+.

#  

/ *.

# % 

$    $ # %  



2



%$$

8    6 

< # 

$

 $ 

  

%  





2

%  

"

$ "

D

!

%%  

+,)* '()* +,*'

"

?

%  8

 !

 " 

 % 7 !

# 8

      #     #

%  

   +( ,) +,,0

E$ 8!

$  #%#

" 

%% 

* = " !

$  #%# %

 

*/)0 *../ +,*)  7  

#

% 

#%# +( ,) +,,0!

  $  #

  #< 4 7

%%   7  

#

*+ ,;

+,,0

!

#% 

$    # 

" 

 " 

 % 7 

= " !

 



    

$    # !

"

"  7 

 

,+ ,;

+,,)  <

 

$$ 

  #

#

*+ ,;

+,,0    $!

 " 

#% 

#%#

& 6 % $ % $#

 #   

  #   

+0 ,) +,,'

 

  %  (.

/ #  





&     

+,)* '()* +,*'

7   

$  %%     #

$  #

%% 

      

  B %% 

.

%8  "  

 # 





++ +,,* "

=  !

4 ++ +,,*

# 

5  ,( +,,*

+.

#!

B %% 

  

$



%8#     .!.+!(,,C

%" 

  $ #





'

"  

 

    % $ 

  

#%



"

%" 

     

   7 



 #  % 

3 7 

  

 

 B %% 

     %% 

7# 

 # 

B %%   

++ +,,*  

"

#% 

   %  %  

 ,( +,,*

"

#% F 

   %  %

7# 

#% " 

%  " 



#     %

%  

  

6 



7# 

$8   %

 !

   $

"

%8 

7# 

$$ 

$# *,,G 78 7 

 $ #7

D



!

    

 % 



%%     %%  

+,)* +,*'!

7# 

      # 

   



%8#   

%"  < %

" 

    %  

 

   # 

"

%

7

6# 

7# 

$$ $#

$$

7   



6# 

7# 

%%   "  !

# 

#% 

         %  

 ++ +,,*!

 

$   !

%  %

  !

%    

"

% 

  

#<   

7



7  #<   

8

   B %% 

 8

 #  8 7 

%  %

6 

%   #% 

  !

 #<

6  

7$

 #    

 

%  % 

#%  < #%  7 

  !

$  8 %%8 



%    !

 $$

7  $$

6# 

$ 

7   8 "  %"

   ++ +,,*  

"

#% 

   %  %

     #% " 

6# !

  6#

#% "    8 %"

6  

#% "  8  

#% %% 

7 

5

++ +,,*!

#% %% 

%  

,/ +,,*

2  



7 8 *;

*/ 8 

#

 

"

$$  6%   6% $



,( +,,*

#



 #       

#     %

%   !

#  #%"



 !

 8   

%8# 

 

 8 %

#   % # 

%% 8

% 

%  

:"    !

7 

# 

% #%   

 !

< %

" 

  % 7  

# #7 

# $#8!

# 

#    

B !

   

  %8#      

%"  %8# 

 !

 7 # "

+ "  8



 " 

# %  

%8  #

%  

 $     #

 ((

>$  % 8 !

*;;+

 !

"  "

 $

" 

& 6                

2  %  %



#      

    8

7 $    # 

  6 #      

$8   %!

 

 #

%



7



7 8  

*;

8 

 

=  !

7  "  !



 #

% "F "F

$



$

8 +A 8  

& 6 #      

 $ #7       7 

78  $  $  

# !

  ,+ ,/ +,,(

$   $ 8 

$$   *,,G 78



 $ $  %  8  $#

 6 

 " 

"

# %7 #

8  +,,*

 !

 " 

#7  % % <



#8



 7  #< %  %7 

 !

$   $ 8 # 6  7 %% 

&     

 

" 

B %% 

 $

%"

 

 8  

$       

   

 

 

  '

" 

B %%    

7 

 $ !

#  8   

#% 

 $  !

 

%%   "  !

 8  %  #% 

7<   

2  

" 

 $  

 

#

$$

7  8 8   %% 

" 

$$

7  

B#

 

 # 

 %" 



%8  $

$

B %"

$!

 %$ " 8



4" 

 %$  4  %"



  #  

7 8  7 7

%    !

" 

%$$ %  <

&    

%% 

"8

,( +,,*

+.

#



 

 8

 

% $#

 

"

  7" !

 

$

< # %     ,) 

#% %%  6 

$    %   ,+ +,,*

6  %

+.

# ,( +,,* %     (;



!

$$   (* #  7  

%   7

D 7    $$   # C!

  

"

#  " 8  #

$ 

"

7  #% %%  %    ,+ +,,*

  

  

% 

  

%  % % C% 

%

  %"

6 

 !



 

 

6# 

  %8#   !

$$  

 8 #  $ !

   7

&     

 %% 



*../ +,*)!

#   $#



3

"

 8 $

%$$

      (.

< / #

 !

7

3

"

$

#%# +( ,) +,,0

%" 

=  !

 7





*/)0 +,*)   $#



   7!

*+ ,;

+,,0   #<  $  

#%# +( ,) +,,0!

 " !

3

"

   

#%#

  "  % #7  

 /+

:"  !

*;)+

%    !

 /+

:"   

"

 %%78

  #  

B #  #%# +( ,) +,,0 %"

 6 



< #

$ 7 

*+ ,;

+,,0 

 # 

 $ !

   $

6#

"  

#%#

 6# "    # 

 #

   8 # 

&     

('(/ +,*)

 !

%  8 % $ % $#

 #    +0 ,) +,,'



3

"

$

  #   

 % 

 

   #    %

 



 #    

"

 % 

% " 

   % !

+0 ,) +,,'

 8%  %% 

<  8 

  ,.

,;

+,,)!

 

,;

,0 +,,.

  $ 8



  $ 

  $

$ " 

3 7 

" 

$ !

%%  % 

$



,( +,,* 

+.

# ++ +,,*  / *.

# % !

 $ !

  # 

 8!

'()* +,*'

 #   

+,)* +,*'

  

2



      #  +( ,) +,,0 #%  $!



 #  % 

3 7 

*../   */)0 +,*) % 

*/)0 +,*)

%  $$    



  #%# 

#%#

% !

 $ !

*+ ,;

+,,0     $

('(/ +,*)  # 

'

4   $# 

 %

 #    

%% 



% 

#   %%!

%% !

 %  " 

7"

  # 

12 1

*    ?   % < C   H   %7 H